- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Punjab State Industrial Development Corporation Ltd. v. Triveni Engineering Industries Ltd.
Factual and Procedural Background
The present appeal arises under Section 37 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996, challenging the judgment and order dated 20th January 2006. The Single Judge had dismissed objections to the Arbitration Award dated 30th September 1996 and made the Award rule of the Court. The dispute concerns the validity of the arbitration agreement between the Appellant and Respondent No. 1, specifically whether such an agreement existed given that the original arbitration agreement was between Respondent No. 1 and Respondent No. 2, and whether it was properly assigned to the Appellant.
The Appellant contends there was no arbitration agreement between itself and Respondent No. 1, relying on the initial agreement dated 27th April 1991 between Respondent No. 2 and Respondent No. 1, which contained the arbitration clause but was not assigned to the Appellant. The Appellant also referred to a subsequent agreement dated 24th June 1993 involving Respondent No. 2, the Appellant, and the Punjab State Federation of Cooperative Sugar Mills, highlighting contractual limitations on the Appellant’s rights.
The Respondents argued that Respondent No. 2's successors and assignees, including the Appellant, were bound by the arbitration clause. They relied on the 24th June 1993 tripartite agreement which established the Appellant as an assignee of Respondent No. 2, and on letters from the Appellant invoking bank guarantees as evidence of the Appellant’s recognition as assignee. The Respondents further pointed to prior court orders appointing an arbitrator and submitted that the Appellant was estopped from denying the arbitration agreement.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether there existed a valid arbitration agreement between the Appellant and Respondent No. 1, given the original arbitration agreement was between Respondent No. 1 and Respondent No. 2.
- Whether the arbitration clause in the initial agreement was effectively assigned to the Appellant, binding it to arbitration proceedings.
- Whether the Appellant is estopped from denying the existence of an arbitration agreement due to participation in arbitration and prior court orders.
Arguments of the Parties
Appellant's Arguments
- The arbitration award and impugned judgment should be set aside as there was no arbitration agreement between the Appellant and Respondent No. 1.
- The original arbitration agreement was between Respondent No. 1 and Respondent No. 2 and was not assigned to the Appellant.
- The agreement dated 24th June 1993 restricted the Appellant’s rights to continue work only through existing contracts and limited the rights of contractors like Respondent No. 1 to remove unpaid materials.
Respondents' Arguments
- The initial agreement explicitly defined Respondent No. 2 to include its successors and assignees, binding the Appellant as an assignee.
- The tripartite agreement dated 24th June 1993 confirms the Appellant’s status as assignee of Respondent No. 2.
- Letters from the Appellant invoking the bank guarantee demonstrate acknowledgment of its status as assignee entitled to enforce the agreement.
- The appointment of an arbitrator by the Court under Section 20 of the Arbitration Act, 1940, estops the Appellant from denying the arbitration agreement.
- Legal precedents establish that arbitration clauses bind valid assignees unless based on personal qualifications.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Union of India v. L.K Ahuja & Company, AIR 1988 SC 1172 | Estoppel arising from prior court reference to arbitration proceedings. | Supported the finding that the Appellant was estopped from denying the arbitration agreement after court-appointed arbitration. |
| Hindustan Steel Works Construction Ltd. v. Bharat Spun Pipe Co., AIR 1975 Calcutta 8 | Arbitration clause binds valid assignees of contracts. | Reinforced that the arbitration clause in the initial contract binds the Appellant as a valid assignee. |
| Shri Patanjal v. Rawalpindi Theaters Private Ltd., AIR 1970 Delhi 19 | Binding effect of arbitration clauses on successors and assignees. | Applied to confirm that arbitration clauses extend to assignees. |
| Me Kenzies, Ltd. v. Sulleman and Co., AIR 1933 Sindh 75 | Principles relating to arbitration agreements and assignments. | Used to support the binding nature of arbitration clauses on assignees. |
| M.R Desa v. Giridharilal Ghanshamdas, AIR 1932 Sindh 128 | Legal effect of assignments on arbitration agreements. | Confirmed that arbitration clauses bind assignees under valid assignment. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court analyzed the initial agreement dated 27th April 1991, which explicitly defined Respondent No. 2 to include successors and assignees. The subsequent tripartite agreement dated 24th June 1993 unequivocally established the Appellant as an assignee of Respondent No. 2. The Court placed significant weight on the Appellant's own conduct, particularly letters invoking the bank guarantee as an assignee, which estopped the Appellant from denying the arbitration agreement.
Further, the Court noted the settled legal position that arbitration clauses bind valid assignees unless based on personal qualifications. The prior appointment of an arbitrator by the Court under Section 20 of the Arbitration Act, 1940, and the Appellant's active participation in arbitration proceedings, including contesting claims and filing counter-claims, reinforced the conclusion that the Appellant cannot now contend the absence of an arbitration agreement.
The Court also relied on established precedents confirming that arbitration clauses extend to assignees of contracts, thereby binding the Appellant. The Single Judge's rejection of the Appellant's objections was therefore upheld as consistent with these principles.
Holding and Implications
The appeal is dismissed as devoid of merits.
The direct effect of this decision is the affirmation of the arbitration award and the order making it rule of the Court. The Appellant remains bound by the arbitration clause as an assignee and is estopped from denying its applicability. No new precedent was established; the ruling applies established legal principles concerning arbitration agreements, assignment, and estoppel to the facts of this case.
Manmohan, J.:— Present appeal has been filed under Section 37 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 against the judgment and order dated 20th January, 2006 passed in Civil Suit (OS) No. 2708/-A/1996 and I.A Nos. 5243, 5655 of 1997 whereby the Single Judge has dismissed the objections to the Arbitration Award dated 30th September, 1996 and made the said Award rule of the Court.
2. Mr. Mukesh Anand, learned Counsel for the Appellant submits that the Arbitration Award and the Impugned Judgment are liable to be set aside on the short ground that there was no arbitration agreement between the Appellant and Respondent No. 1, and the agreement executed between Respondent No. 1 and Respondent No. 2 containing an arbitration agreement was not assigned. In this connection Mr. Mukesh Anand relied upon the initial agreement dated 27th April, 1991 executed between Respondent No. 2 and Respondent No. 1. The relevant portions of the said agreement are reproduced hereinbelow for ready reference:—
“This AGREEMENT made at Chandigarh on the 27th Day of April One thousand nine hundred and ninety one between The Dasuya Cooperative Sugar Mills Ltd, Dasuya. Distt. Hoshiarpur Registered under the Punjab Co-operative Societies Act, 1961 (hereinafter referred to as the Purchaser which expression shall, unless repugnant to the subject or context, include its successors and assignees) represented by Shri S.C Sethi Managing Director of the ONE PART and M/s. The Triveni Engineering Works Ltd. a company registered under the Companies Act, having its registered office at Kailash Building, 2nd floor, 26, Kasturba Gandhi Marg, New Delhi—110001 (hereinafter referred to as the “Seller” which expression shall, unless repugnant to the subject or context, include its legal representative, administrators, successors or permitted assignees represented by Shri A. Bank, Manager (Marketing) of the Triveni Engineering Works Ltd. New Delhi of the other part…
17. BANK GUARANTEE
17.1 The Seller shall furnish to the Purchaser at its own cost, five guarantees as specified below in the form of the Purchasera.
20. ARBITRATION
20.1 If at any time there should be any question, dispute or difference between the parties in respect of any matter arising out of or in relation to this Agreement, either-party may give to the other party notice in writing of the existence of such question, dispute or difference and the same shall be referred to the arbitration of a single arbitrator…”
3. Mr. Mukesh Anand then referred to an agreement dated 24th June, 1993 executed between Respondent No. 2, Appellant and Punjab State Federation of Cooperative Sugar Mills. He, in particular, referred to Clause 12 of the agreement to submit that the Appellant would be entitled only to continue the erection and construction work through the contracts already executed. However, in the event of contractors, like Respondent No. 1, not agreeing to execute the work or the Appellant not willing to get the work executed through them, the contractors, like Respondent No. 1, shall only be entitled to remove unpaid materials, operational materials etc. belonging to them and lying at site. The relevant Clause 12 is reproduced hereinbelow for ready reference:—
“12. That the PSIDC shall be entitled to continue the erection construction of work through the contracts already executed by accepting the liabilities thereon. However, in the event of contractor(s) not agreeing in work or the PSIDC not willing to get work executed through them the contractor(s) shall be entitled to remove unpaid materials, operational materials, tools and tackles belongs to them and lying at site…”
4. Mr. Sanjeev Anand, learned Counsel for the Respondent on the other hand contended that the initial agreement dated 27th April, 1991 executed between Respondent Nos. 1 & 2 clearly defined Respondent No. 2 to include its successors and assignees. Mr. Sanjeev Anand further contended that on a reading of the subsequent tripartite agreement dated 24th June, 1993 executed between Respondent No. 2 and Appellant, it would be apparent that Appellant was an assignee of Respondent No. 2. The relevant extracts of the agreement dated 24th June, 1993 are reproduced hereinbelow for ready reference:—
“This Agreement made at Chandigarh 24th day of the month of June One Thousand Nine Hundred Ninety Three, between the Dasuya Cooperative Sugar Mills Ltd. a society registered under the Punjab Cooperative Societies Act, 1961 having its registered office at Dasuya through its Managing Director (hereinafter referred to as ‘the sugar mill’ which expression shall unless repugnant to the context shall include its successors and assigns) of the one part and the Punjab State Industrial Development Corporation Ltd., a company registered under the Companies Act with its registered office at Udyog Bhawan, 18, Himalaya Marg, Sector 17, Chandigarh (hereinafter referred to as ‘the PSIDC which term shall include its successors and assigns) of the second part and the Punjab State Federation of Cooperative Sugar Mills Ltd. a society registered under the Punjab Cooperative Societies Act 1961 with its registered office at Bhogpur (hereinafter referred to as ‘the Sugarfed’, which term shall include its successors and assigns) of the third part.
Whereas the sugarfed had obtained letters of Intent to setting up three sugar mills at Ainloh, Patran and Dasuya in the cooperative sector and an amount of Rs. 39 crores was obtained from the State Government as share capital for setting of three sugar mills…
Whereas finding that the Financial Institutions are not likely to finance these projects, the matter was considered by the High Powered Committee under the Chairmanship of Hon'ble Chief Minister, Punjab, wherein it was decided to transfer the sugar mills along with the letters of intent to the PSIDC for setting up these sugar mills in the joint/assisted.
Whereas in pursuance to the decisions taken, the sugar mill by way of resolution dated 29.03.93 had passed a resolution in its general body meeting to transfer the letter of intent along with the assets and liabilities on “As is where is” basis on the date of transfer, including advances to the cane growers and other contingent liabilities of the sugar mills at book value to PSIDC…
NOW THEREFORE IT IS HEREBY AGREED BETWEEN THE PARTIES AS FOLLOWS:—
2. That in consideration of the payment by the PSIDC from the date of agreement, the PSIDC shall be entitled to the takeover/transfer of assets and liabilities along with its undertakings, rights, securities whatsoever and wherever situated and shall thence forward be entitled to complete the sugar mill, whether in joint or assisted sector in terms of the decisions taken in the meeting dt. 13.10.92 held under the chairmanship of Chief Minister, Punjab…
9. That the PSIDC shall be responsible for all the liabilities in connection with the implementation of the ‘project’, and would also meet any undisclosed liability like the enhancement of compensation towards acquisition of land etc. and the sugarfed and Sugar Mill shall be indemnified and kept indemnified by PSIDC…
14. That the Sugar Mill shall transfer all their licenses of whatsoever nature in favour of PSIDC including contracts pertaining to machinery supply and erection thereof by way of assignment or otherwise of contract agreements or documents relating to supply and erection of machinery entered into with M/s Triveni Engineering Works and M/s. Engg. And Technical Services Limited i.e the supplier of the machinery and erection contractor.
15. That the Sugarfed/Sugar Mill shall get the benefit of bank guarantee executed in favour of the sugar Mill securing the advance payment given to Triveni Engineering Works by way of assignment or substitution in favour of PSIDC or is/shall also get the debt of Rs. 5,39,666.35 (Rupees Five Lacs Thirty Nine Thousand Six Hundred Sixty Six and paise thirty five only) acknowledged from the debtors with an assurance that the amount would repaid to the PSIDC by debtors……”
5. Mr. Sanjeev Anand also drew our attention to the Appellant's letter dated 28th September, 1993 written to the Manager, Union Bank of India invoking the bank guarantee issued by Respondent No. 1 to Respondent No. 2. In this letter Appellant submitted that the bank guarantee executed in favour of Respondent No. 2 could be encashed by Respondent No. 2's assignee also. In another letter dated 11th October, 1993 to the Manager, Union Bank of India, the Appellant claimed that as Respondent No. 1 had failed to supply the machinery as stipulated in the initial agreement, Appellant being an assignee of Respondent No. 2 was entitled to invoke the said bank guarantee. The relevant extract of Appellant's letter dated 11th October, 1993 is reproduced hereinbelow for ready reference:—
“…M/s. Trivani Engineering Works Ltd. have failed to supply the machinery as stipulated in the agreement and has thus committed breach of contract which entitles the undersigned as beneficiary being assignees of the Dasuya Coop. Sugar Mills Ltd., Dasuya to invoke guarantee executed in their favour by you. Therefore, in terms of the breach of guarantee we invoke the guarantee and request you to pay a sum of Rs. 82,50,000/- (Rs. eighty two lacs fifty thousand only) immediately on receipt of this letter unless the same is executed.
Thanking you,
Yours faithfully,
For PUNJAB STATE INDUSTRIAL DEVELOPMENT CORPORATION LTD.”
6. Mr. Sanjeev Anand also referred to two orders of this Court dated 12th December, 1994 and 9th July, 1997. By virtue of the first order under Section 20 of the Arbitration Act, 1940 an Arbitrator had been appointed to resolve the disputes between various parties including the Appellant and Respondent No. 1. Mr. Sanjeev Anand submitted that in view of reference order having been made by this court, the Appellant was estopped from urging that there was no arbitration agreement between the parties. In this connection he relied upon judgment of Supreme Court in Union of India v. L.K Ahuja & Company, AIR 1988 SC 1172. Mr. Sanjeev Anand further submitted that an arbitration Clause will bind a valid assignee of a contract unless and until it is based on a personal qualification. In this regard he relied upon the following judgments:—
(i) Hindustan Steel Works Construction Ltd. v. Bharat Spun Pipe Co., AIR 1975 Calcutta 8.
(ii) Shri Patanjal v. Rawalpindi Theaters Private Ltd. Delhi, AIR 1970 Delhi 19.
(iii) Me Kenzies, Ltd. v. Sulleman and Co., AIR 1933 Sindh 75
(iv) M.R Desa v. Giridharilal Ghanshamdas, AIR 1932 Sindh 128
7. In our view, the initial agreement dated 27th April, 1991 specifically defines Respondent No. 2 to include its successors and assignees. The subsequent tripartite agreement dated 24th June, 1993 leaves no doubt that the Appellant is an assignee of Respondent No. 2. The Appellant is also estopped from arguing to the contrary in view of the admissions contained in the letter dated 11th October, 1993 referred to hereinabove.
8. Moreover, in view of the settled legal position that if a contract is capable of being assigned and is actually assigned, then the arbitration clause in the initial agreement would also bind the assignee.
9. In fact in view of a reference order by this Court, we are of the view that it is too late in the day for the Appellant to contend that there was no arbitration clause between it and Respondent No. 1. It is also pertinent to mention that the Single Judge had rejected the Appellant's submission on the ground that Appellant had never raised this issue before the Arbitrator and further had not only willingly participated in the arbitration proceedings and contested the claim of the Respondent No. 1 but also had preferred its own counter-claim.
10. Consequently, the present appeal being devoid of merits is dismissed but with no order as to costs.
Alert