Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Khushboo Shrivastava v. Union Of India

Patna High Court
Feb 6, 2009
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Structured Summary of the Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

The writ petitioner (first petitioner) appeared in the All India PMT/DPT Entrance Examination held on 1 April 2007, conducted by the Central Board of Secondary Education (CBSE). The results were published on 5 June 2007. After finding herself unsuccessful, the petitioner sought revaluation of her answer sheets from CBSE; when that request was refused she filed a writ petition (C.W.J.C. No. 7631 of 2007). When the writ petition was taken up, this Court directed the petitioner to deposit Rs. 25,000 and indicated that, if her paper were found correctly evaluated, the deposit would be paid to the CBSE as costs; upon deposit, the CBSE produced her answer sheets. The Single Judge examined materials and found the petitioner was entitled to two additional marks because two answers (in Botany and Chemistry) were correctly given in different language though subjective answers differed from the model answers. Despite this finding, the Single Judge declined to grant the relief of admission, citing that seats had already been allotted, successful candidates had undertaken one year of study, the next year's examination had been conducted, admissions granted, and no interim order had reserved a seat for the petitioner.

The petitioner appealed under Clause 10 of the letters patent. The Division Bench heard the appeal and considered (a) whether the Court could in exercise of writ jurisdiction examine/evaluate answer sheets despite rules against re-evaluation, (b) the correctness of the Single Judge's finding that the petitioner merited two additional marks, and (c) whether the petitioner should be granted admission despite the lapse of time and allocation of seats. The Division Bench ultimately allowed the appeal, held the petitioner entitled to two marks, and directed her admission to MBBS in the next academic session (2009-10), modifying the Single Judge's order to that extent. No order as to costs was made.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether a High Court, in exercise of its writ jurisdiction under Articles 226 and 227 of the Constitution, may examine and effectively re-evaluate answer sheets despite rules or regulations (of the examining body) that prohibit re-evaluation by candidates.
  2. Whether, having found the petitioner entitled to two additional marks, the Court should direct admission to the MBBS course despite admissions having been made and a year of study already undertaken by successful candidates, particularly where the petitioner filed the writ within days of result publication.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments (as presented in the opinion)

  • Counsel for the appellant (Mr. Sanjay Singh) submitted that, given the Single Judge's own finding that the petitioner's answer sheets were not correctly evaluated and that she was entitled to two additional marks, the Single Judge ought to have granted the relief of admission in the next session.
  • The appellant emphasized prompt action: the result was published on 5 June 2007 and the writ petition was presented within eight days (filed on 13 June 2007 and processed and listed thereafter), implying the delay in hearing was systemic and not attributable to the petitioner.

Respondent(s)' Arguments (as presented in the opinion)

  • Counsel for respondent Nos. 3 to 5 (Mr. Binay Krishan Tripathy) argued that the Court exceeded its jurisdiction in evaluating answer sheets, pointing to CBSE regulations that prohibit re-evaluation, and submitted the Court ought not to re-evaluate or substitute its judgment for the assessing experts. He relied on Division Bench and Supreme Court authorities to support the submission that candidates have no right to re-evaluation and that courts should not re-evaluate answer-books as if on appeal.
  • It was further submitted that expert opinion (from Professors) concluded the petitioner's answers were incorrect; thus, the Single Judge’s finding that the petitioner deserved two marks was assailable and should not have been made.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Ganesh Prasad Yadav v. The State of Bihar (Division Bench judgment; reported 1995 (2) PLJR 170) Illustrates that mistakes in model/alternative answers committed by experts do not necessarily warrant quashing the examination or that there was unfair treatment — all candidates faced the same errors. The respondents relied on this case to contend the Court should not re-evaluate answer-sheets. The Division Bench in the present opinion distinguished Ganesh Prasad Yadav, holding that its facts differed and that the present issue related to the Court's jurisdiction to examine correctness of answer sheets under writ powers.
Pramod Kumar Srivastava v. Chairman, Bihar Public Service Commission, Patna [(2004) 6 SCC 714; 2004 (4) PLJR (SC) 88] Holds that where rules provide only for scrutiny (checking marks totalling) and not re-evaluation, a candidate has no right to claim re-evaluation of answer-books from the Commission. Respondents relied on it to assert that no re-evaluation right exists and the Court should not re-evaluate. The Division Bench distinguished this precedent, observing that the cited authorities addressed entitlement to re-evaluation by candidates from the examining body, whereas the present question was whether the High Court in exercise of Articles 226/227 could examine answer-sheets in the course of judicial review.
Rajbir Singh Dala (Dr.) v. Chaudhari Devi Lal University, Sirsa [(2008) 9 SCC 284; 2008 (4) PLJR (SC) 168] Implies that it is generally inappropriate for a court to substitute its view for the considered opinion of experts on academic/technical matters (i.e., courts should not sit in appeal over experts' opinions). Respondents relied on this to argue against substituting judicial opinion for experts. The Division Bench accepted the general proposition but held that the court is not foreclosed in all circumstances from differing with experts; the Court may examine and, in limited circumstances, reach an independent conclusion.
The Bihar Combined Entrance Co. v. Vishakha Gupta (2008 (1) PUR 847 — Division Bench of the Court) Demonstrates that, in certain factual situations, a court can direct admission (even by raising an additional seat) where a candidate is found entitled and it would be unjust to dislodge someone already proceeding in the course. The Division Bench cited this decision to support the remedy of directing admission (by raising a seat if necessary) where an isolated successful claim is established and the delay was not the candidate's fault.
Aman Deep Jaswal v. State of Punjab [(2006) 9 SCC 597] Shows that the Supreme Court has ordered admission in a subsequent academic year within sanctioned intake in similar peculiar facts where a candidate was found entitled. The Division Bench relied on this precedent to justify directing admission of the petitioner in the next academic session (2009-10) within appropriate intake arrangements.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Division Bench proceeded through a sequence of analytical steps, constrained to the materials and arguments set out in the opinion:

  1. Jurisdiction to examine answer-sheets: The Bench considered respondents' reliance on regulations and authorities that deny a candidate the right to seek re-evaluation from the examining body. It held that while rules may deny statutory entitlement to re-evaluation, those rules cannot curtail the High Court's power under Articles 226 and 227 to exercise its high prerogative writ jurisdiction. Where a glaring mistake is pointed out, the Court cannot shut its eyes; judicial review to advance justice remains available.
  2. Review of Single Judge's process: The Bench noted that the Single Judge required a deposit of Rs. 25,000 before directing production of answer sheets and that, on production, the Single Judge determined the petitioner merited two additional marks. The Division Bench reviewed the materials that had led to that conclusion (including the comparative chart and reference to NCERT/model answers) and agreed with the Single Judge's finding that two marks were due because subjective answers, though not in the same language as model answers, were correct in substance.
  3. Expert opinions: Respondents produced expert opinions (dated 10 and 15 February 2008) concluding the petitioner's answers were incorrect. The Division Bench observed those opinions were not before the Single Judge and, after considering them, found it difficult to infer conclusively that the petitioner's answers were wrong. The Bench reiterated that while courts ordinarily should not substitute their view for that of experts, that proposition is not absolute; the court may, in proper circumstances, differ from experts.
  4. Remedy despite elapsed time: On the issue of delay and the fact that seats had been allotted and a year of study undertaken by successful candidates, the Bench examined the petitioner's promptness in filing (within eight days of result publication) and acknowledged systemic court delays beyond the petitioner's control. The Court concluded it would be unjust to deny relief merely because time had elapsed when the petition had been filed promptly and the petitioner otherwise was entitled to relief.
  5. Reliance on precedents for remedy: The Bench referred to prior decisions (including a Division Bench decision of this Court and a Supreme Court decision) where similar factual situations warranted directing admission (including raising an additional seat or admitting in the next academic year). On that basis, and to avoid ridiculing the system and causing injustice to the petitioner, the Bench decided to direct admission in the next academic session.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The appeal is allowed. The Division Bench concurred with the Single Judge that the petitioner's answer sheets were not correctly evaluated and that she was entitled to two additional marks. The court directed that the petitioner be admitted to the MBBS course in the next academic session 2009-10. The Single Judge's order is modified to that extent. No order as to costs.

Implications:

  • Direct effect on the parties: The petitioner is to be admitted to the MBBS course in the 2009-10 academic session; the Single Judge's refusal to grant immediate admission is modified accordingly. No costs were awarded.
  • On legal principle: The Division Bench affirmed that the High Court's writ jurisdiction under Articles 226 and 227 enables it, in appropriate cases, to examine the correctness of answer-sheets and reach conclusions on marks where a clear mistake is pointed out, notwithstanding rules that deny a candidate a statutory right to re-evaluation from the examining body. The Bench also reiterated that courts ordinarily should not substitute their views for expert opinion, but that this is not an absolute bar; courts may differ with experts in suitable circumstances.
  • No new detailed rule of law was formulated beyond the application of established principles: the opinion applied existing constitutional writ powers, distinguished reliance authorities in their factual contexts, and directed an equitable remedy on the particular facts. The decision modifies the remedy in this case but does not purport to overrule the precedents cited.
Show all summary ...

Chandramauli Kr. Prasad, ACJ and Shyam Kishore Sharma, J.:— Writ petitioner-appellant, aggrieved by the order dated 20th October, 2008 passed by the learned Single Judge in C.W.J.C No. 7631 of 2007, has preferred this appeal under Clause 10 of the letters patent.

2. Short facts, giving rise to the present appeal are that the writ petitioner no. 1-appellant herein appeared in the All India PMT/DPT Entrance Examination held on 1st April, 2007 conducted by the Central Board of Secondary Education (hereinafter referred to as CBSE). The result of the examination was published on 5th of June, 2007 and finding herself unsuccessful she made request for revaluation of the answer sheets. When the said request was not acceded to she preferred the writ application. When the writ application was taken up on 24th of August, 2007 this Court directed her to deposit a sum of Rs. 25,000/- (twenty five thousand) and while doing so it was observed that in the event it transpires that her paper was correctly evaluated, the amount deposited by her shall be treated as cost and be paid to the CBSE. It was further observed that on receipt of the amount the CBSE shall produce her answer sheets. She deposited the amount and her answer sheets were produced. The learned Single Judge on consideration of the materials placed before it came to the conclusion that her answer sheets were not correctly evaluated and she was entitled for two more marks. Finding of the learned Single Judge in this regard, reads as follows:—

“After thorough perusal of the answer sheets and model answers the result of the petitioner after scrutiny as per information of the petitioner no. 1 has been placed before this court through the supplementary affidavit which contains comparative chart of model answers given by petitioner no. 1 with reference to certain questions in the papers of Botany, Zoology and Chemistry. This court was also taken through the comparative chart of answers given by petitioner no. 1 and the model answers as well as the answers in the book of N.C.E.R.T which is also incorporated in the chart. The reply to question no. 3(e) in the paper of Botany and the reply of the petitioner to question no. 20(a)(iii) in chemistry shows that her answers were correct as per the prescribed text book for those subjects but since the answers were to be given in the subjective manner, it was not in the same language as in the model answers. Thus, this court is satisfied that petitioner's answer sheets were not correctly evaluated in the context of questions worth two marks.”

3. Despite the aforesaid finding the learned Single Judge declined to grant relief to the petitioner, inter alia, observing that the seats have already been allotted and one year of study has been undertaken by the successful candidates and in the face thereof it would be inexpedient to direct for her admission. The learned Single Judge also took into consideration that the examination of the next year had already been conducted and admission granted to the successful candidates. Absence of any interim order reserving any seat in case of success of the writ petition was also taken into account by the learned Single Judge while declining the relief. However, while doing so it observed as follows:—

“Model answers are suitable for objective tests only because two correct answers may be described by good students in two different languages and only an expert in the subject can evaluate the correctness of such answers. When the correct answer given by the petitioner, for two questions did not fetch her the required two marks, it reflects upon the correctness of the assessment system adopted by the C.B.S.E for evaluating subjective answers. The C.B.S.E in its own wisdom may adopt a better system to finalize model answers or it may adopt objective questions even for the final examination. These are suggestions which must be considered by the experts with a view to prevent same kind of injury to any other candidate in future.”

4. Mr. Sanjay Singh appearing on behalf of the appellant submits that learned Single Judge on its own finding ought to have granted relief to her for her admission in the next session. It is undisputed that if two marks are added in her marks, same shall entitle her admission in MBBS Course. Mr. Binay Krishan Tripathy appearing on behalf of the respondent Nos. 3 to 5 had gone into the root of the matter and assailed the findings of the learned Single Judge that the petitioner was entitled for two more marks. He submits that this Court, in the face of the regulation of the C.B.S.E prohibiting revaluation exceeded in its jurisdiction in evaluating her marks and coming to the finding that she was entitled for two more marks. He points out that in sum and substance this Court had evaluated the answer sheets which is not permissible in law. In support of his submission, he has placed reliance on a Division Bench judgment of this Court in the case of Ganesh Prasad Yadav v. The State of Bihar and analogous cases reported in 1995 (2) PLJR 170 and our attention has been drawn to paragraph 36 of the judgment which reads as follows:—

“No doubt, there are mistakes in the alternative answers or responses to the four questions, but on that basis it cannot be said that the Commission adopted any unfair means or acted in an unfair manner, on the other hand, the aforesaid mistakes appear to have been committed by the experts to whom the work of setting of questions and their suggestive answers was entrusted. It cannot be said that there was unfair treatment to the non-selectees in particular. All the candidates including the successful candidates including the successful candidates have answered the same set of questions and in that view of the matter either all the candidates have suffered equally or took advantages of wrong suggestive answers. In that view of the matter, in spite of the aforesaid errors, in my view, it would not be proper to quash the preliminary test for the aforesaid defects.”

5. Reliance has also been placed on a decision in the case of Pramod Kumar Srivastava v. Chairman, Bihar Public Service Commission, Patna reported in [(2004) 6 SCC 714] : [2004 (4) PLJR (SC) 88] and our attention has been drawn to the following passage from paragraph 7 of the judgment which reads as follows:—

“We have heard the appellant (writ petitioner) in person and learned counsel for the respondents at considerable length. The main question which arises for consideration is whether the learned Single Judge was justified in directing the re-evaluation of the answer book of the appellant in General Science paper. Under the relevant rules of the Commission, there is no provision wherein a candidate may be entitled to ask for re-evaluation of his answer book. There is a provision for scrutiny only wherein the answer-books are seen for the purpose of checking whether all the answers given by a candidate have been examined and whether there has been any mistake in the totaling of marks of each question and noting them correctly on the first cover page of the answer-book. There is no dispute that after scrutiny no mistake was found in the marks awarded to the appellant in the General Science paper. In the absence of any provision for re-evaluation of answer-books in the relevant rules, no candidate in an examination has got any right whatsoever to claim or ask for re-evaluation of his marks.”

6. Submissions advanced do not commend us. In absence of any provision for re-evaluation of answer Sheets in the relevant rules, no candidate in an examination has got any right whatsoever to claim or ask for the evaluation of his/her marks, but this does not mean that this Court in exercise of its high prerogative writ denuded of the power to examine the correctness of the answer sheets when such a challenge is made. The power to issue high prerogative writ to the superior courts is given to advance justice and this Court cannot shut its eyes when glaring mistake is pointed out. Here, in the present case, as observed earlier while directing for production of the answer sheets the learned Single Judge had put the petitioner to terms, she was required to deposit a sum of Rs. 25,000/- (twenty five thousand) and only thereafter, the learned Single Judge directed for production of the answer sheets. This Court came to the conclusion that the petitioner was entitled for two more marks. This exercise has been done by this Court in exercise of its high prerogative writ and rules framed by the C.B.S.E would not preclude this Court from exercising this power. It is hallowed by time and sanctified by precedent that power of this Court under Articles 226 and 227 of the Constitution cannot be curtailed by any rules or regulations.

7. In view of what we have observed, the decision of this Court in the case of Ganesh Prasad Yadav (supra) and of the Supreme Court in the case of Pramod Kumar Srivastava (supra) shall have no bearing in the facts of the present case. In those cases, the issue was not the jurisdiction of this Court to re-evaluate the answer sheets in exercise of its power of judicial review but the entitlement of a candidate to ask for re-evaluation of the answer sheets from the Board/University conducting the examination.

8. Mr. Tripathi then, submits that in the facts of the present case the learned Single Judge ought not to have held that the petitioner was entitled for grant of two more marks. He points out that it is not the case of the petitioner that the questions were incorrect or for that matter the model answers. He further points out that the matter was examined by the Professors and it was found that answers given by the petitioners in regard to question nos. 3(e) and 20(a)(iii) are not correct. According to him, this Court in exercise of power of judicial review will not substitute the opinion of the expert on the subject. Reliance has been placed on a decision of the Supreme Court in the case of Rajbir Singh Dala (Dr.) v. Chaudhari Devi Lal University, Sirsa reported in (2008) 9 SCC 284 : [2008 (4) PLJR (SC) 168] and our attention has been drawn to paragraph 31 of the judgment, which reads as follows:—

“We agree with Mr. Patwalia, learned counsel, that it is not appropriate for this Court to sit in appeal over the opinion of the experts who are of the view that Political Science and Public Administration are interrelated and interchangeable subjects, and hence a candidate who possesses masters degree in Public Administration is eligible for the post of Lecturer in Political Science and vice versa. We are told that a large number of persons having qualifications in the interchangeable/interrelated subjects have been appointed Readers/Professors/Lecturers and are continuing as such in various Colleges and Universities in the State.”

9. We do not have the slightest hesitation in accepting the broad submission of Mr. Tripathi that this Court in exercise of its power of judicial review would not ordinarily differ with the opinion of the expert, but as a proposition of law it cannot be said that in no circumstance the Court can differ with the conclusion of the expert. It is well known that the Court is expert of the experts. Therefore, it cannot be said that the learned Single Judge erred in examining the merit of the two answer sheets.

10. Mr. Tripathi has taken us to the opinion of the professor in this regard. As observed earlier, dispute is in regard to question no. 3(e) in Botany and question No. 20(a)(iii) in Chemistry. Question No. 3(e) reads as follows:—

“Write the type of inflorescence, Placentation and fruit in each of the following.

(e) Wheat

In the model answer of the C.B.S.E following answer has been indicated and petitioner's answers have been indicated in the right side:—

Question - Model Answer - Answer of Petitioner Infloures cence - Spike of Spikelets - Compound spike Placentation - Basal - Basal Fruit - Caryopsis - Caryopsis

11. The opinion of the retired Reader in the Department of Zoology is as follows:—

“Q. No. 3(e)—

The appropriate answer to the type of inflorescence in wheat is only “Spike of Spikelets”. This is the standard Taxonomic term. The other Term “compound spike” is being loosely used in several books.”

12. As regards question no. 20(a)(iii), the opinion of the Professor is as follows:—

“Q. No. 20(3)(iii):—

The answer written by the candidate shows that he/she lacks the complete understanding of the subject. Let the following be understood in this connection:—

(i) The presence of asymmetric carbon is not the 100% surety for the optical activity of a compound.

(ii) There could exist optically, active compounds having no asymmetric atoms of carbon.

(iii) The presence of Chiral carbon atom is a must for the optical activity of the compound.

Thus the answer given by the candidate is not totally correct and not acceptable.”

13. These opinions are dated 10th February and 15th February, 2008, but those opinions were not placed before the learned Single Judge. We have considered the opinion of the two experts but from that it is very difficult to infer that the answers given by the petitioner were wrong. The learned Single Judge had rightly observed that answers of those questions were to be given in the subjective manner. In his opinion the language may differ but that itself shall not render the answer of the petitioners wrong.

14. Accordingly, we concur with the finding of the learned Single Judge that the petitioner's answer sheets were not correctly evaluated and she was entitled for two more marks.

15. Mr. Singh, submits that the petitioners did what was possible for her to do. According to him, the result was published on 5th of June, 2007 and petitioner without waiting presented the writ petition before this Court on 13 of June, 2007 and after it was processed, filed on 3rd of July, 2007 and therefore learned Single Judge on its own finding ought to have directed for admission. Mr. Tripathi however, submits that at such a distance of time it would be inexpedienfto direct for her admission.

16. We have given our anxious consideration to this aspect of the matter. In case, we show door to the petitioner and decline her relief, the very system will be put to ridicule. The petitioner has approached this Court within 8 days of the publication of the result. It was not possible for her or for that matter any litigant to force the Court to hear the matter immediately. Systemic delay occurs and for that blame cannot be put on the petitioner. It is well settled that no citizen can be allowed to suffer for act of other. Had the writ petition heard within the reasonable time from the date it was filed, perhaps this argument would not have been available to the respondents. Taking into consideration-the aforesaid facts, we are not inclined to decline the relief to the petitioner only on the ground that much time has elapsed in the face of finding that she is otherwise entitled. A Division Bench of this Court when confronted with such a situation in the case of The Bihar Combined Entrance Co. v. Vishakha Gupta reported in 2008 (1) PUR 847 directed as follows:—

“In the circumstances, in our opinion, it will be just and proper to direct the respondents-appellants to grant admission of the writ petitioner-respondent, to the MBBS for the Session 2007-08, if necessary, by raising an additional seat for her. This is necessary because the respondents have admitted next candidate in order of merit to MBBS course, but since she has not been impleaded and has already gone some length in course, it will be unjust to dislodge her without hearing her. Moreover, it is not a case in which any irregularity of general Rules has taken place affecting a large number of candidates but is in the nature of one isolated case.”

17. Such a direction has been given by the Supreme Court in the case of Aman Deep Jaswal v. State of Punjab reported in (2006) 9 SCC 597 which would be evident from paragraph 4 of the judgment.

“On these peculiar facts, we are of the view that the appellant Aman Deep Jaswal is entitled to be admitted in MD Anaesthesia in Government Medical. College, Patiala in the next academic year 2006-07 within the sanctioned intake of the college. Ordered accordingly.”

18. In the facts of the present case, we are of the opinion that the petitioner deserves to be admitted in MBBS course in the next academic session 2009-10. We direct accordingly.

19. In the result the appeal is allowed with the direction aforesaid and the order of the learned Single Judge is modified to the extent indicated above. No order as to cost.