- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Roshan Lal v. Lallu
Factual and Procedural Background
This appeal arises from a suit for foreclosure based on a mortgage-deed dated 30th August 1907. The defendant held a simple money decree from suit No. 192 of 1898, under execution. On 30th July 1907, the disputed property was attached in execution of that decree. While this attachment was in force, the judgment-debtor executed the mortgage-deed on 30th August 1907. Subsequently, on 20th August 1908, the mortgagee applied to the execution court for notification of the mortgage, and on 14th November 1908, notification was ordered as no objections were raised. The property was put up for sale multiple times, with some sales set aside. On 20th August 1909, the property was sold to the attaching decree-holder for Rs. 1,800. The mortgagee then filed suit to enforce the mortgage, while the defendants argued the mortgage was invalid as it was executed during the subsistence of the attachment under the prior decree.
The court of first instance held that the attaching decree-holder was not prejudiced by the mortgage and that the attachment did not bar the mortgage's validity. On appeal, the District Judge ruled that the plaintiffs were not entitled to enforce their mortgage against defendants who had purchased the property in execution of the decree under which the property was attached when the mortgage was executed. The plaintiffs then filed this second appeal.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether a mortgage executed during the subsistence of an attachment under a prior money decree is valid and enforceable against the attaching decree-holder and subsequent purchaser.
- Whether notification of the mortgage under Order XXI, Rule 66 of the Code of Civil Procedure estops the attaching decree-holder or purchaser from disputing the mortgage's validity.
- Whether the mortgage is void or merely voidable under Section 64 of the Code of Civil Procedure if the attaching decree-holder is prejudiced.
- Whether the mortgage executed to pay off another attaching creditor without a decree for sale affects the mortgage's validity.
Arguments of the Parties
Appellants' Arguments
- The defendants had full notice of the mortgage, and thus are estopped from denying its validity.
- The notification of the mortgage under Order XXI, Rule 66 of the Code of Civil Procedure was sufficient to establish its validity.
- Under Section 64 of the Code of Civil Procedure, the mortgage is not absolutely void but valid unless the attaching decree-holder is prejudiced.
- The mortgage was executed to pay off money due to another attaching creditor, Sheo Mukh Rai, thereby validating it.
- Relied on the precedent of Dinobundhu Shaw Chowdhry v. Jogmaya Dasi to support the validity of subsequent mortgages during attachment.
Respondents' Arguments
- The mortgage was executed during the subsistence of an attachment and is therefore invalid and unenforceable against them.
- The notification under Order XXI, Rule 66 of the Code of Civil Procedure is not conclusive proof of the mortgage's validity.
- The property was sold free of the mortgage since the mortgage did not create a lien enforceable against the attaching decree-holder's sale.
- The mortgage executed to pay off Sheo Mukh Rai is irrelevant as he held only a simple money decree without a decree for sale.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Dinobundhu Shaw Chowdhry v. Jogmaya Dasi | Validity of subsequent mortgages executed during attachment and effect of Section 276 of the Code of Civil Procedure | Distinguished from the present case as the prior mortgages were kept alive by intention of parties; not applicable here as the current mortgage was executed during attachment without such intent. |
| Abdul Rashid v. Gappo Lal | Validity of subsequent mortgage only in respect of excess not saleable under prior decree | Distinguished because in that case the mortgage was valid only for non-saleable excess, unlike the present case. |
| Lala Bhagwan Das v. Ahmad Jan | Notification under Order 21, Rule 66 of the CPC is not conclusive as to mortgage validity | Supported the principle that notification of mortgage does not estop auction purchaser from questioning validity. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court analyzed the effect of a mortgage executed during the subsistence of an attachment under a prior money decree. It noted that the notification procedure under Order XXI, Rule 66 of the Code of Civil Procedure does not conclusively establish the validity of the mortgage. The Court emphasized that for estoppel to apply, the plaintiffs needed to prove that notice was actually issued to the decree-holder, which was not shown. The Court interpreted Section 64 of the Code to mean that a transfer or mortgage during attachment is void only to the extent it is contrary to the attachment and prejudices the decree-holder. Since the property was sold in execution of the decree, presumably free of encumbrances, the mortgage did not create a lien enforceable against the purchaser. The Court distinguished the cited precedents on their facts, noting that none mandated upholding the mortgage in the current circumstances. Regarding the contention that the mortgage was to pay off another attaching creditor, the Court found this irrelevant as that creditor had no decree for sale and the point was not raised earlier. Consequently, the Court upheld the District Judge’s view that the mortgage was unenforceable against the defendants.
Holding and Implications
The Court’s final decision was to dismiss the appeal with costs. The appeal is dismissed, affirming that a mortgage executed during the subsistence of an attachment under a prior money decree is not enforceable against a purchaser who acquires the property in execution of that decree.
This decision directly affects the parties by denying enforcement of the mortgage against the defendants who purchased the property in execution. The Court did not establish any new precedent beyond the application of existing principles concerning attachment, notification, and mortgage validity under the Code of Civil Procedure.
Stuart and Sulaiman, JJ.:— This is a plaintiffs' appeal arising out of a suit for foreclosure on the basis of a mortgage-deed, dated the 30th of August, 1907. It appears that the defendant held a simple money decree, in suit No. 192 of 1898, which was in execution. On the 30th of July, 1907, the property in dispute in this case was attached in execution of the simple money decree; while this attachment was subsisting, the judgment-debtor, on the 30th of August, 1907, executed the mortgage-deed which is the subject-matter of dispute in this appeal. On the 20th of August, 1908, the subsequent mortgagee seems to have made an application, to the execution court, praying that his mortgage should be notified. An order of the 14th of November, 1908, passed by the execution court, shows that inasmuch as no objection was preferred, notification was ordered. The property was put up for sale on two occasions, but the ??? were set aside? On the 20th of August, 1909, the property was again put up for sale ami was ultimately sold to the attaching decree-holder himself for a sum of Rs. 1,800. The subsequent mortgagee has now brought a suit to enforce the mortgage of the 30th of August, 1907, and, on behalf of the defendants, it was contended that inasmuch as this mortgage-deed had been executed at a time when the attachment under the decree in suit No. 192 of 1898 was in force, the mortgage was invalid and unenforceable as against the defendants.
The court of first instance held that the attaching decree-holder had in no way been prejudiced by the execution of this mortgage-deed and that the attachment was no bar to the validity of this mortgage.
On appeal the learned District Judge was of opinion that the plaintiffs were not entitled to enforce their mortgage as against the defendants who have purchased this property in execution of a decree under which the property was under attachment at the time when the mortgage-deed was executed.
The plaintiffs have, come up to this Court in second appeal, and, on their behalf, it is argued that the finding of the learned District Judge is not correct. It is contended on their behalf that inasmuch as the defendants had full notice of the existence of the plaintiffs' mortgage, they are estopped now from saying that mortgage is not valid. In the first place, there is nothing on the record to show that any notice was actually issued to the decree-holder on the application of the 20th of August, 1908. In order to succeed on a plea of estoppel, it was obviously incumbent on the plaintiffs to prove this. In the second place, the proceeding relating to the notification of the mortgage-deed was merely a proceeding under order XXI, rule 66 of the Code of Civil Procedure, and the order passed in that proceeding can in no way be conclusive as to the validity of the, mortgage which was going to be announced.
It is next contended that under section 64 of the Code of Civil Procedure the mortgage is not absolutely void, but that it is valid so long as the attaching decree-holder was not prejudiced. It is true that under the new Act this section has been slightly altered. In the old section 276, the words “during the continuance of the attachment” were too tried and might have made all granters “during the pendency of the attachment” absolutely void. Under the new Code, however, that expression has been substituted by the expression “contrary to such attachment.” It is clear, therefore, that a transfer during the pendency of the attachment would be void only as against all claims enforceable under the attachment. It cannot be disputed that it was open to the attaching decree-holder to ignore the subsequent mortgage and to proceed to sell the whole property and not only the equity of redemption, and that if he did so, the auction-purchaser would get the whole property free from the encumbrance, the mortgage not creating any lien on the property sold. There is nothing to show that the property sold was anything less than the absolute interest in it, and there is nothing to show that it was only the equity of redemption, subject to the subsequent mortgage, which was put up for sale and purchased by the defendants.
The learned advocate for the appellants has strongly relied on the case of Dinobundhu Shaw Chowdhry v. Jogmaya Dasi . In that case there were, first of all, two previous mortgage-deeds and the equity of redemption was attached in execution of a money decree. While the property was in the course of being sold, a third mortgage was created by the mortgagor in lieu of the amount due under the previous mortgages. The auction-purchaser, in execution of the mortgage-decree, claimed that the provisions of section 276 of the Code, rendered the subsequent mortgage wholly old as against him. Their Lordships of the Privy Council, however, held that inasmuch as the intention of the parties was to keep alive the earlier mortgages, it was impossible to hold that fire effect of that, section was to give an execution creditor an unencumbered see simple, instead of an equity of redemption, against the intention of the parties. In our opinion that case is clearly distinguishable from the present case. The case of Abdul Rashid…(Plaintiff); v. Gappo Lal…(Defendant).* is also clearly distinguishable because in that case the subsequent mortgage was held to be valid only in respect of that excess shall which was not legally sale able in execution of a prior decree. The case of Lala Bhagwan Das v. Ahmad Jan was a case where ultimately the subsequent mortgage was not upheld. But it was clearly pointed out in that case that under order 21, rule 66 of the Civil Procedure Code, if a mortgage-deed is notified, that notification is in no way conclusive, as between the decree-holder or the purchaser on the one hand and the holder of the in cumbrance on the other, as to its validity, and it was pointed out that where a sale is not effected subject to a mortgage, but the mortgage is simply notified at the time of the sale, the auction-purchaser is not estopped from questioning the validity of the mortgage.
It is next contended that the mortgage-deed in dispute was executed in order to pay off the money due to another attaching creditor, namely, Sheo Mukh Rai, and that, therefore, this mortgage was valid. In the first place, this point was not taken before the learned District Judge, and we have no pronouncement of his opinion on this point. In the second place, Sheo Mukh Rai did not hold any decree for sale. He was a simple-money decree-holder, and as soon as his amount was paid out of court, the attachment ceased to exist, and we are of opinion that fact cannot in any way help the appellants. In our opinion the view taken by the learned District Judge on this point was correct. The appeal therefore fails and is dismissed with costs.
Appeal dismissed.
Alert