- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Shib Deo Misra v. Ram Prasad
Judgment Summary — Plaintiffs' Appeal (Sulaiman and Kanhaiya Lal, JJ.)
Factual and Procedural Background
This appeal arises from a suit for recovery of possession. Plaintiff No. 1, Shib Deo Misra, claimed to be the reversionary heir of Kallu Misra (deceased). Plaintiffs Nos. 2 and 3 were transferees from plaintiff No. 1. The plaintiffs alleged that on the death of Kallu Misra his widow Musammat Mohini entered into possession as a Hindu widow for life, that she made various unlawful transfers, and that she died on 15 December 1907. The suit was instituted shortly before the expiry of the limitation period, with courts closed on 15 and 16 December 1919.
Defendant No. 1 (Ram Prasad) claimed to be the adopted son of Kallu Misra. Other defendants were transferees from either Musammat Mohini or Ram Prasad and were in possession of most of the disputed property.
Defendants pleaded denial of the plaintiffs' pedigree, limitation, the validity of Ram Prasad's adoption, res judicata, and estoppel among other defenses. At a late stage, Ram Prasad produced a document purporting to be a will of Kallu Misra (dated 4 October 1887) that purported to exclude other brothers and leave the property to Shib Deo Misra after Musammat Mohini's death.
The Subordinate Judge found (inter alia) that the plaintiffs' pedigree was established, the adoption of Ram Prasad was not established, res judicata did not bar the claim, the plaintiffs failed to prove Musammat Mohini's death within 12 years, the will was a forgery, and the claim was barred by estoppel. The plaintiffs appealed; the respondents supported the decree on the findings below and on other pleas.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the plaintiffs' suit was barred by limitation — including (a) application of the six years' rule to the alleged adoption, (b) non-verification of the plaint at presentation, and (c) the exact date of Musammat Mohini's death.
- Whether the death-register entry relied upon by the plaintiffs (daily death register kept at the police station) was admissible and sufficed to prove the date of death.
- Whether Ram Prasad's adoption by Kallu Misra was valid and, if so, whether prior proceedings and decree/arbitration results operate as res judicata.
- Whether the will produced late in the proceedings was genuine or a forgery.
- Whether various defendants who are transferees are protected (estoppel / ostensible ownership / protection under section 41 of the Transfer of Property Act) and which transferees, if any, are not so protected.
- How costs should be apportioned between the parties in light of the outcome.
Arguments of the Parties
Plaintiffs' Arguments
- Plaintiffs alleged that Musammat Mohini died in December 1907 (initially pleaded as 15th; explanation was offered for the discrepancy with other dates) and that their suit was within 12 years.
- Plaintiffs relied on two death registers (village death register and daily death register) and a certified copy from the Superintendent of Police to establish the date of death.
- Plaintiffs treated the omission of verification in the original plaint as a curable irregularity and not a fatal defect that would render the suit barred by limitation.
- Plaintiffs contested the validity of the will produced late in the proceedings, arguing it was not disclosed earlier in the pleadings and was susceptible to challenge.
Defendants' Arguments
- Defendants denied the plaintiffs' pedigree and urged pleas of limitation, estoppel, res judicata and that Ram Prasad was the legitimate adopted son of Kallu Misra.
- Respondents' counsel argued that the daily death register entry was inadmissible because the chaukidar who made the entry was not produced and the plaintiffs did not prove the handwriting or identity of the register.
- Mr. Dar (for another set of respondents) contended that even if the register is an official book, it must be proved in evidence or shown to fall within section 81 of the Indian Evidence Act; he argued the register's format (separate pages per village expected) did not match the exhibit and thus plaintiffs should have proved identity by oral evidence.
- Defendants urged that prior arbitration and the decree arising from it were collusive or not the result of a fair trial and therefore should not operate as res judicata.
- Some defendants argued on caste grounds that an adoption across the named sub-castes (Kankubjya vs Sanadh) was invalid.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Rajit Ram v. Katesar Nath | Authority supporting that omission of plaint verification is a curable irregularity (following Privy Council authority). | The Court cited it to support the proposition that subsequent verification cures the defect and the plaint need not be treated as void. |
| Basdeo v. John Smidt | Same line as Rajit Ram; follows the Privy Council decision on verification. | Used to reinforce the view that omission of verification is merely irregular and curable. |
| Mohini Mohun Das v. Bungsi Bnddan Saha Das (Privy Council) | Principal authority on the effect of subsequent verification of a plaint. | Identified as the leading authority which the Court followed in holding that the omission to verify was not fatal. |
| Sampat v. Gauri Shankar | Cases concerning chaukidar's pocket book entries and their admissibility. | Distinguished by the Court as dealing with a pocket book, not a police station death register; thus not controlling here. |
| Habibullah v. King-Emperor | Cases on admissibility of chaukidar or similar pocket-book entries. | Distinguished for the same reason as Sampat (pocket book, not station register). |
| Bisheshar Dayal v. Hira Lal | As above: authorities on pocket-book entries. | Distinguished by the Court. |
| Mohammad Jafar v. Emperor | As above: authority on pocket-book entries and admissibility. | Distinguished by the Court. |
| Tamij-ud-din Sarkar v. Tazu | Authority that a death register kept at a police station is an official book and entries are admissible. | Relied upon to support admissibility of the daily death register entry as an official record under the Evidence Act. |
| Zaib-un-nissa v. Hasrat-un-nissa | Same principle as Tamij-ud-din regarding police station death registers being official records. | Relied upon alongside Tamij-ud-din to hold the daily death register admissible. |
| Ramalinga Reddi v. Kotayya | Similar view expressed about official registers and admissibility. | Cited to reinforce the admissibility of the police station death register. |
| Narain Singh v. Musammat Shiam Kali Kunwar | Held that for inheritance purposes primary caste limits adoption; adoption is valid if adoptive father and adopted son belong to sub-castes of the same primary caste. | Applied to reject the objection that adoption was invalid because the adoptive father and adopted son were of different named sub-castes. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court addressed each issue sequentially and applied statutory provisions and authorities cited in the record.
-
Limitation:
- The six years' rule (for setting aside an adoption) did not apply because reversioners were not required to sue to declare the adoption void; they could wait till the life-interest ended and sue for possession within 12 years of the widow's death. The present claim was for possession, not merely declaration.
- The omission of verification in the plaint when first presented (17 December 1919) was treated as an irregularity, not a voiding defect. The Court followed prior authorities (including the Privy Council decision referenced) and held that subsequent verification cured the defect; the plaint was not thereby barred by limitation.
- The decisive question was the actual date of Musammat Mohini's death. The plaintiffs produced two death registers; one (village register) was found suspicious and rejected; the other (daily death register kept at the police station) was a bound official book, its entry untampered with, and showed death on 18 December 1907 reported by the chaukidar on 19 December 1907. This date was corroborated by a plaint filed by Ram Prasad in 1908 that used the same date. In the absence of reliable contrary evidence, the Court accepted the daily register entry and held the plaintiffs proved the 18 December 1907 date, so the suit was within 12 years and not barred by limitation.
-
Admissibility of the daily death register:
- The Court held the daily register to be an official book under section 35 of the Indian Evidence Act because Police Regulations required head muharrirs to keep registers of births and deaths in prescribed forms. The register contained printed pages of the prescribed form and had been received from proper custody.
- Respondents argued that the register's identity was not proved orally and relied on section 81 (presumption) arguments; the Court noted that plaintiffs produced a certified copy endorsed by an authorized officer and that the correctness of that copy was to be presumed under section 79 of the Evidence Act. The certified copy, together with corroboration from the 1908 plaint, satisfied the Court.
-
Res judicata and adoption:
- The Court reviewed earlier proceedings: Ram Prasad had executed a bond asserting adoption (20 Aug 1897); Musammat Mohini sued (26 Nov 1897) to declare the adoption invalid; parties agreed to refer disputes to arbitration; arbitrators (two locals among them) delivered an award (24 Feb 1898) finding Ram Prasad to be the son and proper heir, with directions on distribution; objections to the award were overruled and a decree dated 25 Mar 1898 was drawn up.
- The Subordinate Judge had treated that decree as non-binding for lack of a fair trial, but the High Court found no satisfactory evidence of collusion or unfair trial. The Court observed that the suit was contested, the award was made after court reference, objections were filed and disallowed, and in absence of strong contrary evidence the decree could not be lightly set aside as collusive.
- The Court regarded Musammat Mohini's suit as representative for reversioners (citing section 11, explanation VI of the Code of Civil Procedure) because she represented the whole estate for the time being and the reversioners had a common interest. Consequently, the award and decree operate as res judicata between Ram Prasad (and those claiming through him) and the reversioners represented by Musammat Mohini.
- After assessing other evidence, the Court held that the defendants had discharged the burden of proving that the adoption had in fact taken place.
-
Caste objection to adoption:
- The Court rejected the argument that adoption was invalid because Kallu Misra was a Kankubjya Brahmin and the adopted boy belonged to the Sanadh sub-caste. The Court relied on the cited authority (Narain Singh v. Musammat Shiam Kali Kunwar) and evidence in the record showing compatibility of caste groups, concluding the adoption was not invalid on this ground.
-
The will:
- A will was produced late by Ram Prasad purporting to exclude other brothers; after considering the evidence the Court held the will to be a forgery (the judgment states the will was held to be a forgery; details of the analysis are abbreviated in the provided text).
-
Estoppel and protection of transferees:
- Several defendants derived title through successive transfers reciting the award/decree. The Court found that certain transferees (e.g., Hardayal and Raj Narain; Badri Prasad and his successors) were bonafide transferees for value, after due inquiry, who relied on the award and were in possession of the property as ostensible owners. Such transferees were protected under section 41 of the Transfer of Property Act and by estoppel.
- By contrast, a transferee who took directly from Musammat Mohini during her lifetime (defendant No. 9, Khubi) could not claim the protection of section 41 because the widow possessed the property by her own right; her possession did not operate as ostensible ownership derived from consent, express or implied, of the reversioners. Therefore a transferee from a widow who acted in her lifetime could not successfully plead section 41 protection.
-
Costs:
- The Court noted that the suit failed substantially because the factum of adoption succeeded as a common ground for all defendants. The Court concluded it was appropriate that one set of costs only be allowed to the defendants (the learned Subordinate Judge had not allowed separate costs, though the prepared decree had given separate costs).
Holding and Implications
Holding: Appeal dismissed. The High Court dismissed the plaintiffs' appeal and ordered that the plaintiffs' suit stand dismissed as against all the defendants.
Direct consequences for the parties (as ordered by the Court):
- The plaintiffs shall bear their own costs.
- The plaintiffs shall pay the costs of all the defendants other than Ram Prasad in both courts.
- Ram Prasad shall bear his own costs throughout.
- The total legal fee allowed will be the maximum taxable fee both in this Court and in the court below.
Broader implications: The opinion does not purport to lay down a novel legal doctrine; it applies established principles on limitation, admissibility of official registers, res judicata, protection of bona fide transferees under section 41 of the Transfer of Property Act, and the consequences of representative suits under section 11 explanation VI of the Code of Civil Procedure. The decision's effect is primarily consequential as between the parties rather than to create a new precedent.
Disposition: Appeal dismissed.
Sulaiman and Kanhaiya Lal, JJ.:— This is a plaintiffs' appeal arising out of a suit for recovery of possession on the allegation that the plaintiff No. 1 is the reversionary heir of Kallu Misra, deceased, the last male owner of the property. Plaintiffs Nos. 2 and 3 are transferees from plaintiff No. 1. In the plaint it was alleged that on the death of Kallu Misra, his widow Musammat Mohini entered into possession as a Hindu widow for her life, that she unlawfully made various transfers and ultimately died on the 15th of December, 1907. The suit as brought was just within limitation of this date, as the courts were closed on the 15th and 16th of December, 1919. The defendant No. 1 claims to be the adopted son of Kallu Misra. The other defendants are transferees either from Musammat Mohini or from the defendant No. 1, who are now in possession of the bulk of the property in dispute.
On behalf of the defendants there were several pleas taken. There was a denial of the pedigree set up by the plaintiffs. There was a plea that the claim was barred by time, and there were pleas that Ram Prasad, defendant No. 1, was the adopted son of the deceased, that the claim was barred by the principle of res judicata and that it was also barred by estoppel.
In the pleadings, or at the time when the issues were settled, there was no suggestion that the deceased, Kallu Misra had left any will. On the other hand the plaintiffs' vakil admitted that Shib Deo Misra, plaintiff No. 1, had other brothers alive, and also stated that he would not amend his plaint. As matters stood on the pleadings, it is clear that in any event, Shib Deo Misra not being the sole ‘surviving reversioner at the time of the death of Musammat Mohini, the entire claim could not be decreed. At a late stage in the case Ram Prasad, defendant No. 1, filed a number of papers, among which there was a document purporting to be a will of Kallu Misra and bearing the date the 4th of October, 1887. Under it, with the exception of a temple and rights connected therewith which were to go to Ram Prasad himself, the rest of the property was on the death of Musammat Mohini to go to Shib Deo Misra, to the exclusion of his other brothers.
The learned Subordinate Judge came to the conclusion that the plaintiffs' pedigree was established, that Ram Prasad's adoption had not been established, and that, the claim was not barred by res judicata. He, however, found that the plaintiffs had failed to prove that Musammat Mohini died within 12 years of the suit, that the will produced by Ram Prasad was a forgery and that the claim was barred by the principle of estoppel.
The plaintiffs have come in appeal and challenge the findings arrived at against them. The learned advocate for the respondents has not only supported the decree on the findings in his favour but has also supported it on the other pleas raised. Thus all the important issues of fact and law have been re-argued before us and we propose to dispose of all of them.
The first question is one of limitation. This plea was based on three grounds: (1) that the alleged adoption of Ram Prasad not having been set aside within six years, the claim was barred by time; (2) that the plaint when originally filed was not verified at all and this defect was not cured till long after the expiry of the period of limitation; and (3) that Musammat Mohini had not died on the 15th of December, 1907, but died either on the 9th or 10th of December of that year and the claim was beyond time.
We agree with the learned Subordinate Judge that the six years' rule has no application to this case. The reversioners were not bound to bring a suit for a declaration that the alleged adoption had in fact not taken place. They were entitled to wait till the lady died and then bring a suit for recovery of possession. The present claim is not one for mere declaration but is for possession. If it is brought within 12 years of the death of Musammat Mohini, it cannot be held to be barred by the six years' rule.
We, however, do not agree with the view taken by the learned Subordinate Judge that the verification having been made after the expiry of 12 years, the suit itself was barred by time. It appears that the plaint was actually presented in court on the 17th of December, 1919, but though it bore the signatures of all the plaintiffs, it did not contain any verification by them. This defect was brought to the notice of the munsarim by one of the defendants and subsequently to that of the court. Under an order of the court the verification was ultimately made, but it was some months afterwards. We are, however, of opinion that the plaint was not a void plaint merely because it did not contain the verification clause as required by the Code of Civil Procedure. In our opinion the omission to verify it was a mere irregularity which could be cured even at a later stage. Merely on the ground of such a defect, the plaint cannot be treated as altogether invalid. The subsequent verification was not an amendment of it. This has been the view consistently followed in this Court, and we may refer to the cases of Rajit Ram v. Katesar Nath and Basdeo v. John Smidt , which follow the case of Mohini Mohun Das v. Bungsi Bnddan Saha Das decided by their Lordships of the Privy Council.
The main point to consider in connection with the plea of limitation is the exact date on which Musammat Mohini died. There can be no doubt that the burden lies on the plaintiffs to prove conclusively that her death took place within 12 years of the suit.
[After discussing some of the oral evidence the judgment proceeded.]
The plaintiffs also relied on two death registers of which certified copies were produced and the originals also were summoned from, the office of the Superintendent of Police. One of these registers is a bigger register and contains entries of deaths of villagers arranged according to the various villages. The other is a smaller register which contains reports of deaths, in chronological order and not by division of villages. For the sake of reference we shall call the first register as the village death register and the second the daily death register.
[As to one of the registers the Court held that the entry was suspicious and could not be taken in evidence].
The other register namely, the daily death register, on the face of it, is not suspicious. It is a bound book, the stitches of which do not appear to have been broken. The entry regarding the death of Musammat Mohini in this register has not; at all been tampered with. The original has come from proper custody and a certified copy of the entry has also been produced. Both the original and the copy say that the death of Musammat Mohini, as reported by the village chaukidar on the 19th of December, 1907, had taken place on the 18th of December, 1907. It is to be noted that this date fits in with the date given in Ram Prasad's plaint filed in the year 1908, These two pieces of evidence, therefore, corroborate each other. It is true that this date does not tally with the date given in the plaint, but for this the plaintiffs have an obvious explanation, namely, that they got this date from the certified copy which had been granted to them shortly before the suit was instituted. As the plaintiffs cannot have a personal knowledge of the exact date of her death, it seems impossible to pin them down to the date mentioned in the plaint.
The learned Subordinate Judge, however, has held that this register is not admissible in evidence at all and the learned advocate for the respondents has strongly supported that finding. The chaukidar who made the report of Musammat Mohini's death has not been traced and has not been produced. He is probably dead. No attempt has been made by the plaintiffs to produce any other evidence in order to prove the handwriting in this book. The learned advocate for the respondents has, therefore, argued that this register is not at all admissible and that even if it is admissible and relevant, it requires some proof.
He has relied on a number of cases decided by the Oudh Court in support of his contention. In all these reported cases, however, the book in question was the chaukidar's pocket book and not the death register kept at the police station. The cases of Sampat v. Gauri Shankar , Habibullah v. King-Emperor , Bisheshar Dayal v. Hira Lal and Mohammad Jafar v. Emperor are thus distinguishable. On the other hand, it has been laid down in the case of Tamij-ud-din Sarkar v. Tazu and in the case of Zaib-un-nissa v. Hasrat-un-nissa that the death register kept at the police station is an official book and the entries in it are legally admissible. A somewhat similar view has been expressed in the case of Ramalinga Reddi v. Kotayya .
Under the Police Act (No. V of 1861), section 12, the Inspector-General of Police is authorized to frame orders and rules relative to, amongst others, the collecting and communication by them of intelligence and information, etc. Under the Police Regulations, chapter 24, paragraph 274, sub-clause 4, the head muharrir of every police station has to keep registers of births and deaths and make entries therein as reported by the village chaukidars. There are prescribed form's, Nos. 1 and 5, which have to be used for that matter. The register in question contains printed pages of the form No. 5 and it was manifestly kept at the police station and later on forwarded to head-quarters. The mere fact that the entries in it are made in chronological order would not show that this document is not an official book. We are clearly of opinion that this register was an official book, register or record made by a public servant in the discharge of his official duty, within the meaning of section 35 of the Indian Evidence Act. An entry made therein would, therefore, be itself a relevant fact.
Mr. Dar, who argued the case on behalf of another set of respondents, has strongly contended that, even if the register is an official book within the meaning of section 35, and even if an entry in it is a relevant fact, the register must either be proved by some evidence or be shown to come within the scope of section 81 of the Indian Evidence Act. It cannot be denied that there is no oral evidence on the record that this was the identical register which was kept at the police station, Etmadpur, in which circle village Brijnath, where Musammat Mohini died, is situated. All that is known is that this was brought into court from the record room at head-quarters by a clerk named Abdul Ghani. Mr. Dar has, therefore, contended that the Court can presume its genuineness under section 81 of the Evidence. Ace only when it is shown that this is a document directed by any law to be kept by any person and if such document is kept substantially in the form required by law and is produced from proper custody. His argument is that the Police Regulation No. 274, sub-clause 5, enjoins the keeping of a register with separate pages assigned for each village and that, therefore, this register is not kept substantially in the form required by law, assuming that the law requires it to be kept. He has argued that it was, therefore, incumbent on the plaintiffs to lead evidence to prove the identity of this register and to show that it is this very register which has come from the record room and which was the register kept at the police station. The answer to this objection is that in addition to the original register, the plaintiffs have produced a certified copy of its entry, and a certificate is endorsed on it purporting to have been given by an authorized officer. The correctness of the Copy must, therefore, be presumed under section 79 of the Evidence Act. This copy removes all doubt as to any possible mistake in the identity. We have already said that the entry in the daily death register is corroborated by the statement contained in the plaint of 1908. These two pieces of evidence, even excluding the other register, are very strong evidence of the exact date of the death of Musammat Mohini. As against this we have no rebutting evidence whatever except the solitary statement of Jhamman Lal, the brother of Musammat Mohini. We have already said that Jhamman Lal, when sued in 1908 by Ram Prasad, did not specifically deny the correctness of the date. In the witness box he did not appear to be a man possessing a retentive memory.
There is, of course, always a possibility that the date given by Ram Prasad in his plaint might not have been the exact date, or that the date as reported by the chaukidar was not the, correct date. But in the absence of any other reliable evidence, there is no reasonable ground for doubting that the statements contained in these two independent documents, which corroborate each other, were accurate.
We accordingly hold that the plaintiffs have established that Musammat Mohini died on the 18th of December, 1907, and that, therefore, the present claim was in no way barred by time. The next point which we propose to consider is the question of Ram Prasad's adoption.
The plea of res judicata is raised in connection with this issue and is based on the following circumstances. Kallu Misra had admittedly brought up Ram Prasad in his house from his childhood. It is the defendants' case that he even performed Ram Prasad's janeo ceremony and marriage ceremony, but the evidence as to this consists of the solitary statement of Jhamman Lal and is, therefore, not necessarily strong. There can be no doubt, however, that Ram Prasad had been living in Kallu Misra's house when the latter died, and continued to live there for some time longer. On the 20th of August, 1897, he executed a bond in which he asserted that he was the adopted son of the deceased Kallu Misra. Musammat Mohini promptly instituted a suit on the 26th of November, 1897, for a declaration that Ram Prasad was not the adopted son of Kallu Misra and that the bond referred to above was altogether invalid and ineffectual. Ram Prasad filed a written statement on the 18th of December, 1897, in which he put forward his claim of a valid adoption. The parties, however, entered into an agreement to refer all their disputes to arbitration and the court referred the matter to the arbitration of three arbitrators. Two of these three arbitrators are proved in this case to have been residents of the same mohalla, Kachahri Ghat, where Kallu Misra used to live, and one of these two, namely, Ganga Prasad, used to live in a house which was in front of Kallu Misra's house, the two houses being separated only by a road. Ganga Prasad's son, Mahabir Prasad, proves this. On the 24th of February, 1898, the arbitrators delivered their award in which they stated that they; were empowered under the agreement to decide the dispute between the parties, without having regard for the issues and without taking any evidence. They expressed the opinion that “Ram Prasad is the son and the proper heir of Kallu Misra deceased.” Then they proceeded to direct that out of the entire estate left by him, one house was to remain in the possession of Musammat Mohini for life and to go to Ram Prasad after her death and that two houses were to vest absolutely in her with full power of alienation. Ram Prasad filed objections to this award on the 14th of March, 1898. The court, however, disallowed these objections on the 25th of March, 1898, and ordered that a decree be prepared in accordance with the award. A decree was accordingly prepared which bears the date 25th of March, 1898.
The learned Subordinate Judge has held this decree not to be binding on the ground that, in his opinion, it was not passed after a fair trial, but merely embodied a private settlement of the dispute, the arbitrators having been given power to decide the case without taking any evidence and without having regard to the issues framed. There is not much evidence on the record to indicate any peculiar circumstances under which the proceedings had been conducted. All that we know is that there was one sitting of the arbitrators. At least two of the arbitrators were residents of the same mohalla and there is nothing strange if they had been given power to decide the case on their own personal knowledge without taking any further evidence. The suit was a contested one and the award was made after the case had been referred to the arbitrators' under an order of the court. Objections were also filed to the award and they were disallowed. We are, therefore, entitled to presume, in the absence of any satisfactory evidence to the contrary, that the court at that time was satisfied that it was a bonâ fide litigation and not a collusive or fraudulent one. We find it impossible to fix upon any particular circumstance which would justify us in holding that there was not a fair trial at all. Decrees of courts are not to be lightly treated on a mere suspicion and on a mere supposition, based on no substantial evidence, that they are collusive. We are, therefore, unable to agree with the view which the learned Subordinate Judge has taken of the arbitration proceedings.
Musammat Mohini represented the whole estate for the time being. The reversioners had then no rights in præsenti. Her claim was to avoid the adoption set up by Ram Prasad. The suit was, therefore, brought not only in her own interest but in the interests of the whole body of reversioners who would be entitled to the property after her death. If the adoption were to be upheld, the line of the reversioners would be altogether cut off. The suit brought by Musammat Mohini must, therefore, be treated as a representative suit and all persons having a common interest must be deemed to have been represented through her under section 11, explanation VI, of the Code of Civil Procedure. The defendants Nos. 7 and 8 are claiming through Ram Prasad, whereas the plaintiff No. 1 must be deemed to have been then represented by Musammat Mohini. The award and decree, therefore, operate as res judicata between them.
Defendants Nos. 2 and 3 and defendant No. 9, as will be shown later, claim title under Musammat Mohini and, therefore, the plea of res judicata cannot be successfully urged on their behalf.
We now proceed to consider the question of adoption itself.
[After discussing the evidence the judgment proceeded.]
They have fully discharged the burden of proving that the adoption had in fact taken place.
In the court below there was an objection as to the validity of the adoption on the ground that Kallu Misra was a Kankubjya Brahmin and Bansi was a Sanadh Brahmin and it was suggested that an adoption of a Sanadh boy by a Kankubjya Brahmin was not valid. Two witnesses, namely, Shib Deo, plaintiff, and Suraj Prasad, stated that such an adoption could not take place. We are unable to accept this contention. A registered sale deed dated the 25th of January, 1906, shows that Jhamman Dal is of the caste of Sanadh Brahmin. Musammat Mohini, therefore, must have been of the same caste. She was duly married to Kallu Misra who was a Kankubjya Brahmin. There was obviously, therefore, no bar to a marriage between them. Nor can the adoption of a boy belonging to the same sub-caste be held to be invalid. In the case of Narain Singh v. Musammat Shiam Kali Kunwar the Oudh Bench, of which one of us was a member, held that for the purposes of inheritance each primary caste must adopt from within its own limits and that the adoption would not be invalid so long as the adoptive father and the adopted son belonged to a sub-caste of the same primary caste. We, therefore, think that there is no force in this objection.
We have already indicated that so far as the pleadings went, Shib Deo Misra and his transferees would in no case be entitled to the entire property left by Kallu Misra, as it is admitted that at the time of the death of Musammat Mohini, when succession opened to the reversioners, there were more than one person entitled to it. In cases of such collateral succession the property inherited is the separate property of all the reversioners and does not go to the head of the family only. In order to get over this difficulty, the appellants relied on a will which was produced by Sam Prasad at a very late stage in the case. In the plaint there was no suggestion that Kallu Misra had left any will. Even in the written statement which Ram Prasad filed there was no suggestion that Kallu Misra had not died intestate. The story told by Ram Prasad is that soon after the death of Musammat Mohini he obtained possession of a large number of papers left by her and kept them since.
[On the evidence the Court held the will to be a forgery.]
We come now to the question of estoppel. Defendants Nos. 2 and 3 claim under a title derived from Musammat Mohini. On the 3rd of August, 1898, Musammat Mohini made a gift of the house in her possession to Jagdhar, her own brother. On the 20th of January, 1906, Jagdhar sold it to Santan Lal and Lakshmi Narain. On the 3rd of February, 1910, Santan Lal and Lakshmi Narain mortgaged it to Hardayal and Raj Narain. The mortgagees obtained a decree for sale on the basis of the mortgage deed and purchased the property at auction on the 9th of March, 1918. The previous deeds recited the award and the fact of Ram Prasad's adoption. The reversioners allowed the transferees, Santan Lal and Lakshmi Narain, who were the ostensible owners, to remain in possession even after the death of Musammat Mohini. We are satisfied that Har Dayal and Raj Narain were bonâ fide transferees for value after due inquiries. The claim as against them is barred by section 41 of the Transfer of Property Act.
Defendants Nos. 7 and 8 derive title from Kam Prasad. After the death of Musammat Mohini, Ram Prasad remained in possession of the house which is now in their possession. He mortgaged it on the 18th of May, 1910, to Bihari Lal and then on the 3rd of October, 1911, contracted to sell the equity of redemption to Badri Prasad. On the 16th of April, 1912, he sold the equity of redemption to Badri Prasad the mortgagee. Defendants Nos. 7 and 8 are the sons of Badri Prasad. We are satisfied that Badri Prasad was a bonâ fide transferee for value and he had made due inquiries and acted in good faith on the strength of the award of the arbitrators which was recited in the previous title-deed. The reversioners allowed Ram Prasad to remain in possession as ostensible owner and the transferees are protected.
Defendants Nos. 4, 5, 6 and 10 are also transferees, but they have compromised their disputes and we are not now concerned with their rights in this appeal.
The case of defendant No. 9, Khubi, stands on a slightly different footing. He took a mortgage from Musammat Mohini herself on the 17th of July, 1898, and then took a sale-deed of the equity of redemption from her on the 11th of March, 1899. He, therefore, derived title from Musammat Mohini herself and the deeds in his favour were executed in her life-time. We are of opinion that a transferee from a Hindu widow who takes the property from her before the reversioner's right has accrued cannot successfully plead the bar of section 41 of the Transfer of Property Act. Assuming that he was a bonâ fide transferee for value who has taken the property after due inquiry and believing in the validity of the award, it cannot be held that he has taken it from an ostensible owner who was in possession with the consent, express or implied, of the reversioners. A Hindu widow enters into possession of her husband's estate by right and not with any express or implied consent of the reversioners. While she is alive the reversioners have no voice in the matter and have no right to intervene. She can continue in possession in spite of their protest. A transferee from such a person, who is in possession by her own right and as to whose possession no consent of the reversioner can be implied by law, cannot claim the protection of section 41 of the Transfer of Property Act.
The only point that remains now is the question of costs. The suit is failing substantially on a ground common to all the defendants, namely, the factum of the adoption of Ram Prasad. We think, therefore, that it is a case in which one set of costs only should be allowed to the defendants against the plaintiffs. The learned Subordinate Judge has not allowed separate costs, though the decree that has been prepared gives the defendants separate costs on account of pleaders' fees.
We accordingly dismiss this appeal with this modification that the plaintiffs' suit shall stand dismissed as against all the defendants. The plaintiffs will bear their own cost's and pay the costs of all the defendants other than Ram Prasad in both courts. The defendant Ram Prasad shall bear his own costs throughout. The total legal fee allowed will be the maximum taxable fee both in this Court and in the court below.
Appeal dismissed.
Alert