Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Emperor v. Ram Sewak

Allahabad High Court
Nov 12, 1946
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The application in revision was brought by Ram Sewak, convicted by the courts below for an offence under section 161 read with section 116 of the Indian Penal Code. At trial the Magistrate sentenced the applicant to one year rigorous imprisonment and a fine of Rs. 50; this conviction and sentence were affirmed by the Sessions Judge on appeal.

Facts found by the courts below: Ram Sewak, a resident of Cawnpore, obtained a ration card on the basis of an inquiry form for himself and family members including his father (Satti Prasad) and brother (Ram Nath). The father and brother were already employees of J.K Cotton Mills and had separate ration cards; consequently Ram Sewak was drawing a ration in excess of his lawful entitlement. An Inquiry Inspector of the Supply Department discovered the matter and reported it to Senior Inspector S.K. Hasnain on 7 August 1945. Hasnain later informed the Town Rationing Officer on 15 August 1945 that attempts were being made to bribe him to drop the case.

Acting on that information the Deputy Town Rationing Officer (Mr. David), also a Magistrate, concealed himself with two others in Hasnain's house. At about 8:30 p.m. on 15 August 1945 three men including the applicant came to Hasnain's house. When the applicant offered three currency notes to Hasnain (with the apparent intention of bribing him), Hasnain gave a prearranged signal; Mr. David and the witnesses then entered and arrested the applicant with the notes in his hand. A recovery list showing the numbers of the three notes was produced and Mr. David gave evidence describing his ability to see and hear events.

At trial the applicant admitted offering a bribe and pleaded guilty when the charge was read. On appeal he later contended procedural defects (that no charge had been prepared or read to him and that he was not permitted to cross-examine prosecution witnesses) and argued substantive law points (that Hasnain, having already reported the matter, had no power to accept a bribe and therefore no offence was committed). The Sessions Judge rejected these contentions and upheld conviction and sentence.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the applicant was guilty of the offence of abetment of bribery under section 161 read with section 116, Indian Penal Code, given the surrounding facts (offer of money to Hasnain to induce him to drop a report).
  2. Whether procedural objections (that no charge was prepared/read and the applicant was not allowed to cross‑examine prosecution witnesses) vitiated the conviction.
  3. Whether the sentence imposed by the trial court and upheld by the Sessions Judge was lawful under section 116 (i.e., whether the enhanced sentencing provision applied and, if not, what the correct maximum sentence was).

Arguments of the Parties

Applicant's Arguments

  • The applicant (through counsel) argued that because Mr. Hasnain had already made a report to the Town Rationing Officer on 15 August 1945, Hasnain had no power in the exercise of his official functions to show favour to the applicant; therefore, acceptance or offer of money could not constitute the offence of abetment of bribery. This argument was supported by reference to two cases: Shamsul Haq v. King Emperor and Venkatarama Naidu v. Emperor.
  • It was contended at trial/appeal that the trying Magistrate had not prepared or read a charge to the applicant and that the applicant was prejudiced by not being permitted to cross‑examine prosecution witnesses. The intended purpose of cross‑examination was said to be to show that somebody else was behind the offence.
  • In mitigation, counsel pointed out the timeline of proceedings: conviction by the trial court on 27 September 1945; revision application presented on 6 December 1945; release on bail by this Court on 29 April 1946; and that the applicant had already undergone about six months' rigorous imprisonment.

Prosecution / Court's Counsels' and Findings

  • The prosecution produced eyewitness evidence (Mr. David) and a written recovery list showing the three notes recovered from the applicant; the trial court found the offer of a bribe and recovery of notes established. The applicant admitted offering the bribe and pleaded guilty when the charge was read at trial.
  • The Sessions Judge rejected the procedural contentions (no charge/read and denial of cross‑examination) as false and scandalous, and found the prosecution evidence conclusive.
  • The court (in this opinion) reasoned that in the absence of any suggestion that the applicant knew of Hasnain's prior report, the two precedent cases relied on by the applicant were distinguishable; accordingly the acts here constituted an offence under sections 161 read with 116 IPC.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Shamsul Haq v. King Emperor Held that there was no abetment of bribery where the recipient had no power to show favour (because the matter had already been disposed of) and the offeror knew the recipient could no longer affect the result. The Court held this case distinguishable: in the present case there was no suggestion that the applicant knew Hasnain had already reported the matter; therefore Shamsul Haq did not support the applicant's contention that no offence was committed.
Venkatarama Naidu v. Emperor Held there was no offence of abetment of bribery where the public official was functus officio (i.e., had no further official power in respect of the matter) and the offender knew of that fact. The Court treated this authority as distinguishable for the same reason: the applicant here was not shown to have known that Hasnain had become functus officio, so Venkatarama Naidu did not apply to negate criminal liability.
Emperor v. Ajudhia Prasad (Dalal, J.) Applied in a similar factual context to support the conclusion that the conduct amounted to an offence under section 161 read with section 116 IPC. The opinion notes that Dalal, J. took the same view as the present court — supporting the conclusion that Ram Sewak was guilty under the cited provisions.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court's analysis proceeded in several discrete steps, grounded on the evidence and statutory sentencing limits:

  1. Fact‑finding: The courts below found beyond reasonable doubt that Ram Sewak offered money (three currency notes; the amount stated elsewhere as Rs. 25) to S.K. Hasnain with the apparent intention of inducing him to drop a report regarding unlawful ration drawing. The arrest was made contemporaneously and a recovery list documenting the seized notes was produced.
  2. Evidentiary credibility: The crucial evidence of Mr. David (the Deputy Town Rationing Officer and Magistrate who was concealed nearby) described his capacity to see and hear the events and corroborated the recovery. The applicant admitted offering the bribe and pleaded guilty at trial. The Sessions Judge rejected later procedural allegations (no charge read; denial of cross‑examination) as false.
  3. Distinguishing precedents: The applicant relied on Shamsul Haq and Venkatarama Naidu to argue no offence was committed because Hasnain had already reported the matter. The court distinguished those authorities on their facts: in both earlier cases the offerors knew that the official could no longer confer any favour or was functus officio. In the present case there was "absolutely no suggestion" the applicant knew of Hasnain's prior report; he offered the bribe intending to induce Hasnain not to make a report. The court observed that accepting the applicant's argument would yield absurd results (e.g., timing alone would determine criminality; or it would allow a public servant to accept bribes with impunity).
  4. Statutory sentencing analysis: The court examined section 116, which contains two parts limiting sentence when an offence under section 161 is abetted. Part I permits a sentence up to one‑fourth of the longest term for the offence; Part II permits up to one‑half of the longest term but applies only when the abettor or person abetted is a public servant "whose duty it is to prevent the commission of such offence." The court found Hasnain was not a public servant with a legal duty to prevent the offence of bribery (at most a moral duty), hence Part II does not apply.
  5. Mathematical consequence: The longest term for the offence under section 161 was three years; one‑fourth of that is nine months. Therefore any sentence beyond nine months was legally unauthorized under section 116 Part I.
  6. Relief in revision: The court noted the applicant had undergone approximately six months' rigorous imprisonment by the time of the hearing. Balancing the illegality of the one‑year sentence and the time already served, the court concluded that the period already undergone sufficed to meet the ends of justice.

Holding and Implications

Core Ruling: The Court dismissed the revision application, upheld the conviction of Ram Sewak for the offence under section 161 read with section 116 IPC, but reduced the term of imprisonment to the period already undergone by the applicant. The fine of Rs. 50 was maintained; in default of payment the applicant shall undergo two months' rigorous imprisonment.

Direct consequences:

  • The conviction stands.
  • The one‑year sentence imposed by the trial court (and affirmed below) was held to be illegal in excess of the statutory limit under section 116 Part I; the lawful maximum was one‑fourth of three years = nine months.
  • The Court reduced the sentence to time already served (about six months), thereby ordering the applicant's release from further imprisonment for the term of the sentence; the monetary fine remains effective with the stated default term.

Broader implications: The opinion distinguishes prior authorities that negatived liability only where the offeror knew the public official had no power to affect the matter. It emphasizes that absence of the offeror's knowledge is decisive in determining whether the offer constitutes an offence. The court did not purport to lay down a novel precedent beyond applying and distinguishing existing authorities.

Show all summary ...

Mulla, J.:— This is an application in revision by one Ram Sewak who has been convicted by the courts below of an offence under section 161 read with section 116, of the Indian Penal Code. The learned trying Magistrate imposed a sentence of one year's rigorous imprisonment plus a fine of Rs. 50, which has been maintained by the learned Sessions Judge in appeal.

The facts of the case are quite simple. The applicant Ram Sewak is a resident of Cawnpore and he filled in an inquiry form and obtained a ration card on the basis of that form for himself and for other members of his family including his father Satti Prasad and his brother Ram Nath. It is admitted that his father Satti Prasad and his brother Ram Nath were employed in the, J.K Cotton Mills and had already obtained a separate ration card in their capacity as the employees of that mill. The applicant Ram Sewak was, therefore, clearly drawing a ration in excess of that to which he was entitled in law and had committed an offence. This matter was discovered by an Inquiry Inspector of the Supply Department who made a report to the Senior Inspector in the same department named Mr. S.K Hasnain. This happened sometime on the 7th of August, 1945. It appears that the applicant cant and other persons on his behalf then approached Mr. Hasnain in order to persuade him to drop the case and even tempted him by the offer of a bribe but he refused to accept any. On the 15th of August, 1945, Mr. Hasnain made a written report to the Town Rationing Officer and also told him at the same time that attempts were being made to bribe him in order to induce him to drop the same, and that some persons might be coming to his house that day with that object in view. Thereupon, the Town Rationing Officer directed the Deputy Town Rationing Officer Mr. David, who also happened to be a Magistrate, to try and catch the offender if possible. Accordingly Mr. David along with an Assistant Rationing Officer, and a witness named Mr. Sabir Husain who is a Mukhtar by profession, entered the house of Mr. Hasnain at about 8 p.m on the 15th of August, 1945, and concealed themselves in a small room. Next to that room was a larger room in which Mr. Hasnain was sitting with his brother who happened to be the Inquiry Inspector who had discovered the fraud committed by the applicant. Soon after 8.30 p.m three men including the appellant came to Hasnain's house. A servant of Mr. Hasnain brought that information to him and he was asked to show them up. The three men then came into the room in which Mr. Hasnain was sitting with his brother. One of those men, with whom we are not concerned in this case, spoke to Mr. Hasnain on behalf of the applicant Ram Sewak and when Mr. Hasnain said that he could not do anything in the matter the applicant Ram Sewak put out his hand with three currency notes in it, obviously with the intention of offering, a bribe to Mr. Hasnain in order to induce him to drop the matter. Thereupon Mr. Hasnain made a signal which had been previously arranged upon between him and Mr. David, namely he started scratching his head, whereupon Mr. David and the two witnesses immediately came into the larger room from the smaller one where they were concealed in the meantime, and Mr. David immediately proceeded to arrest the applicant Ram Sewak with the three currency notes in his hand. A recovery list was prepared by Mr. David in the ordinary course. That list is an exhibit on the record and it shows the numbers of the three notes recovered from the possession of Ram Sewak in the circumstances mentioned above. Mr. David has been examined by the prosecution to support its case, and he has stated in the clearest possible terms that he was able to see all that was taking place in the larger room occupied by Mr. Hasnain and his brother and also to hear the conversation that took place between Mr. Hasnain and the applicant as there was only a chick suspended at the door of communication between that room and the smaller room in which he and the two witnesses were concealed. From his evidence it is clear that a companion of the applicant first proposed to Mr. Hasnain that the case against the applicant should be dropped, and when Mr. Hasnain showed his reluctance to accept it the applicant Ram Sewak offered a bribe of Rs. 25 to him. These facts have been found by both the courts below to have been fully established upon the evidence in the case. At trial the applicant admitted the fact that he had offered a bribe to Mr. Hasnain and when, as the record shows, a charge sheet was prepared by the learned trying Magistrate and the charge was read out to the applicant he pleaded guilty. Later on in appeal, however, it was suggested on behalf of the applicant that the trying Magistrate had never prepared any charge and had never read it out to the applicant. It was strenuously contended that the applicant had been prejudiced by the fact that he was not asked to cross-examine the prosecution witnesses. Even at that stage it was admitted that all that was intended to be achieved by means of cross-examination was that the applicant would have shown that somebody else was really at the bottom of the whole affair. These contentions were rightly rejected by the learned Sessions Judge as utterly false and scandalous. The sentence imposed upon the applicant by the learned trying Magistrate, which has been referred to above, was upheld by the learned Sessions Judge.

Learned counsel for the applicant contended that, in view of the fact that Mr. Hasnain had already made a report against the applicant to the Town Rationing Officer on the 15th of August, 1945, prior to the incident in question out of which the charge against the applicant arises, it must be held that Mr. Hasnain had no power in the exercise of his official functions to show any favour to the applicant and hence no offence was committed by the applicant. Learned counsel sought to support this contention by a reference to two cases; one reported (Shamsul Haq v. King Emperor)(1) and the other reported (Venkatarama Naidu v. Emperor)(2). In the former case Shamsul Haq a taxi driver had been prosecuted for some offence under the Motor Car Act by a police sergeant and the case against him was dismissed by the trying Magistrate on a certain date. Five days after that he gave a rupee to the same police sergeant in the hope that the charge against him would be withdrawn. It was clearly found in that case, and indeed it was alleged by Shamsul Haq himself in his defence, that he had knowledge of the fact that the case against him had already been discharged. In these circumstances, the learned Judges who heard the case held that there was no abetment of the offence of bribery, inasmuch as the police sergeant had no power to show any favour to Shamsul Haq. In the latter case a man offered himself for selection as a police constable and a Reserve Inspector who examined him rejected him of the ground that he was below the minimum height. It must again be emphasised that the person knew that he had been rejected when, later on, he offered a bribe to the Reserve Inspector. It was held by the learned Judges who decided the case that there was no offence of abetment of bribery, inasmuch as the Reserve Inspector was functus officio so far as the transaction in question was concerned.

I do not think that these two authorities can support the applicant's contention in the circumstances of the present case. There is absolutely no suggestion in the present case that the applicant Ram Sewak had any knowledge of the fact that Mr. Hasnain had already made a report against him to the Town Rationing Officer. He obviously offered the bribe with the intention of inducing Mr. Hasnain not to make any report against him. If the argument of learned counsel for the applicant is accepted certain absurd results will follow. In the first place, it is evident that the applicant Ram Sewak would have been clearly guilty under section 161 read with section 116 of the Indian Penal Code, if the incident in question had taken place at about 8.30 p.m on the night of the 14th of August, 1945, instead of the 15th of August, 1945. It is obviously unreasonable to suggest that the very act which would have clearly amounted to an offence if it had been committed on the 14th of August, 1945, was rendered innocuous not by anything done by the applicant himself or by any knowledge or intention on his part but by the fact that Mr. Hasnain had in the meantime made a report to the Town Rationing Officer of which the applicant did not have any knowledge at all. Again, it would appear upon the argument advanced on behalf of the applicant that no offence could be committed and so Mr. Hasnain could have accepted the money offered by the applicant with impunity. In my view the applicant was clearly guilty of an offence under section 161 read with section 116, of the Indian Penal Code, in the circumstances of the present case and the same view was taken by Dalal, J. in the case of Emperor v. Ajudhia Prasad.

I, therefore, see no reason to interfere with the conviction of the applicant, but I must point out that the sentence imposed upon, the applicant in the present case was illegal. Section 116, part I, provides only for a sentence which may extend to one-fourth part, of the longest term provided for that offence, which in the present case was three years for the offence under section 161, of the Indian Penal Code. The learned Sessions Judge seems to have been of the opinion that the case fell within the purview of the second part of section 116, of the Indian Penal Code, which provides for “imprisonment of any description provided for that offence for a term which may extend to one-half of the longest term provided for that offence”. It is, however, to be noted that the second part of section 116 applies only when the abettor or the person abetted is not merely a public servant but a public servant “whose duty it is to prevent the commission of such offence”. It can hardly be suggested that Mr. Hasnain was a public servant whose duty it was to prevent any offence or the offence of bribery with which we are concerned in this case. It may have been his moral duty not to accept the bribe and to prevent any bribe being offered to him, but he certainly was not enjoined by law to prevent any offence, and no duty was cast upon him by the law to prevent the offence of bribery. I am therefore clearly of the opinion that the applicant could not have been legally sentenced to a period of imprisonment extending beyond nine months, which is one-fourth of the longest term provided by section 161, of the Indian Penal Code. Learned counsel for the applicant has also pointed out to me that this application in revision was presented in this Court on the 6th of December, 1945, and the case was put up for hearing for the first time on the 16th of September, 1946. In the meantime the applicant was released on bail by an order of this Court on the 29th of April, 1946. He was convicted by the trial court on the 27th of September, 1945. It would appear therefore that he has undergone about six months' rigorous imprisonment. In all the circumstances of the case I think that period of imprisonment is sufficient to meet the ends of justice.

The result, therefore, is that I dismiss this application in revision and uphold the appellant's conviction but reduce the sentence of imprisonment imposed upon him to the period already undergone. The sentence of a fine of Rs. 50 is maintained. In default of payment he shall undergo two months' rigorous imprisonment.