Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Sheo Harakh Upadhya v. Jai Gobind Tewari

Allahabad High Court
May 12, 1927
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

This second appeal arises out of a suit filed by the plaintiff-respondent seeking demolition of a baithak (sitting room) constructed by the defendant first party (appellant) on joint vacant land. The trial court dismissed the suit, holding that the appellant had long been in exclusive possession of the land and that the plaintiff had acquiesced in the construction. On first appeal, the lower appellate court found that the appellant was in exclusive possession of the plot, although the land belonged jointly to both parties. It noted that the baithak was a recent construction on land previously used as a cattle trough by the defendants. The appellate court refused to grant the plaintiff joint possession but decreed demolition of the baithak. The appellant challenged this order in the present second appeal.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether a co-sharer in exclusive possession of joint property can erect a building without the consent of other joint owners.
  2. Whether the recent construction of a baithak on land hitherto used differently alters the nature of exclusive possession and justifies demolition.
  3. Whether the principle that one joint owner cannot build on joint property without consent requires modification when exclusive possession is established.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The lower appellate court erred in decreeing demolition despite finding the appellant in exclusive possession.
  • The appellant contended that the building should have been allowed to stand, leaving the plaintiff to seek remedy at the time of partition.
  • Reliance was placed on the decision in Lahaso Kunwar v. Mahabir Tewari to support this position.

Respondent's Arguments

  • The erection of the baithak without consent of the plaintiff, a co-sharer, was unauthorized.
  • The recent construction altered the character of exclusive possession, which had been limited to use as a cattle trough.
  • The plaintiff was entitled to object to this change as it could prejudice him in partition.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Lahaso Kunwar v. Mahabir Tewari Referenced by appellant to support the claim that demolition should not be decreed despite exclusive possession. The court found this precedent irrelevant to the present facts and did not rely on it.
Lachmi v. Ganga Din Established that one joint owner cannot erect a building on joint property without consent of other joint owners, even if no direct loss occurs. The court reaffirmed this principle, applying it to hold that a mandatory injunction (demolition) is justified if the building is unauthorized.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court analyzed whether the principle that a joint owner cannot build on joint property without consent should be modified when exclusive possession is established. It distinguished between buildings erected long ago, which may imply consent, and recent constructions, which do not. Since the baithak was recently built on land previously used as a cattle trough, the court held that this altered the character of the appellant’s exclusive possession. The plaintiff’s objection was valid as the new use could prejudice his rights upon partition. Therefore, the court found the lower appellate court justified in ordering demolition of the baithak.

Holding and Implications

DISMISSED the second appeal and upheld the decree for demolition of the baithak.

The decision directly affects the parties by affirming that exclusive possession by a co-sharer does not permit construction that changes the nature of possession without consent of other joint owners. No broader precedent beyond the facts was established.

Show all summary ...

1. This second appeal arises out of a suit brought by the plaintiff-respondent for demolition of a certain baithak by the defendant first party, who is appellant in this appeal, on joint parti (vacant) land. The first Court dismissed the suit on a finding that this piece of land had long been in the exclusive possession of the appellant, and that the plaintiff had acquiesced in the construction of the building in first appeal the lower appellate Court found that the appellant was established in exclusive possession of the plot although it belonged to both the parties. It found that the construction of the baithak was recent, the land hitherto being occupied by the cattle trough of the defendants. It refused to decree to the plaintiff joint possession of the plot but decreed demolition of the baithak.

2. In this appeal it is urged that the lower appellate Court, having found that the appellant was in established exclusive possession, should not have decreed demolition of the baithak but should have allowed the building to stand, leaving the plaintiff his remedy, if any, at the time of partition.

3. Reliance is placed upon a decision in Lahaso Kunwar v. Mahabir Tewari (1).

4. This ruling has nothing whatever to do with the present points it was held in Lachmi v. Ganga Din (2) that one of several joint owners is not entitled to make a building on the joint property without the consent of other joint owners notwithstanding that the erection of such building might cause no direct loss to the other joint owners, and that in such a case a mandatory injunction ought to be granted. The question arises whether the proposition just stated requires any modification where it is found that the land built on has been in the exclusive possession of the person erecting the building. Of course, if the building was erected long ago, it will be presumed that the co-sharer in exclusive possession, who erected the building, did so with the permission of the other co-sharers. No such presumption can be made in a case like this where the erection is of recent date and has been objected to from the beginning. The principle to be applied in this case is whether the erection of the building by the appellant is in keeping with the method of exclusive possession hitherto enjoyed by the appellant. If so, there should be no interference, the other co-sharers having allowed the appellant to occupy exclusively in a certain way must be deemed to have consented in advance to any use of the land consonant with the exclusive possession permitted. In the present case, however, the appellant is attempting to build a sitting room on land hitherto merely used for trough for cattle. This is to alter the character of the appellant's exclusive possession, and it might have a prejudicial result to the plaintiff in the event of partition. In any case the plaintiff is entitled to object to this use of the land as unauthorised by him either expressly or by implication. The lower appellate Court was, therefore, in my opinion, justified in passing a decree that it did and the appeal is dismissed with costs.

D.D

5. Appeal dismissed.