- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Ahmadi Begam v. Abdul Aziz
Dalal and Pullan, JJ.:β The learned Judge of the lower appellate court has not quoted any ruling in support of his view. The father himself was out of possession at the time of the gift and he did all that was possible for him to do in putting his daughter in the same position in which he was. He and his daughter subsequently only sued the other co-owners of the property and obtained a decree. Under these circumstances want of possession at the time of the gift would not render the gift invalid. In the case of Mohamed Buksh Khan v. Hosseini Bibi their Lordships observed at page, 702:
βIn this case it appears to their Lordships that the lady did all she could to perfect the contemplated gift and that nothing more was required from her. The gift was attended with the utmost publicity. The hibanama itself authorized the donees to take possession and it appears that in fact the did take possession. Their Lordships hold, under these circumstances, that there can be no objection to the gift on the ground that the donor had not been in possession and that she herself did not give possession at the time.β
This ruling fully supports the claim of the plaintiff that the gift cannot fail for want of possession at the time of the gift.
There is a single Judge ruling of this Court, Mohibullah v. Abdul Khalik, in which the principle enunciated by their Lordships of the Privy Council in the case of Sheikh Muhammad Mumtaz Ahmad v. Zubaida Jan was applied to a house. Possibly the case which was before their Lordships was one where the donor himself questioned the validity of the gift, and it may be argued that it could not be applied generally where no such question of equity arose. This is how Mr. Tyabji interprets the ruling in his book on Muhammadan Law at page 422. This Court, however, has gone further in the matter and held the gift to be valid even where it is not the donor himself who questions it. We are in agreement with that view. Mr. Ameer Ali in his Muhammadan Law has stated the principle to be that a hibabil-musha, i.e, gift of an undivided joint property is not void, but only, invalid, and possession-remedies the defect. Mr. Tyabji does not appear to accept that view but lie has suggested a device by which the operation of the doctrine may be condoned, and that device was adopted in the present case. At page 403 he quotes a Hanafi lawyer as laying down that a gift of a moiety of a house can validly be effected by the donor selling it first at a fixed price and then absolving the debtor of the debt which was the price. This was exactly what the plaintiff's father did, and on this ground also the doctrine of musha will not apply.
For these reasons we decree the appeal and declare the share of the plaintiff to be that which she claimed in her plaint. This is a preliminary decree for partition and this declaration will be sufficient. The plaintiff shall receive her costs of all courts.
Appeal allowed.
Alert