Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Emperor Complainant v. Mussammat Misri Accused.

Allahabad High Court
Jul 12, 1909
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.

1. Musammat Misri, aged about 25 years, Musainiani, has been convicted of the murder of a little girl aged about 7 years named Misria and sentenced to death. She has appealed from jail and the sentence has been referred to this Court for confirmation. The murdered child was the daughter of a man named Sulai. Sulai's brother is married to a sister of the wife of a brother of the accused and so there was some connection between the families. Sulai says that Musammat Misri, the accused, came to his house and claimed shelter on the ground of this family connection. He gave her shelter. He says that she stayed with him for one night. The next afternoon he saw the accused taking his little daughter's hand and going east towards the river. The accused at this time had her own child in her arms. Sulai asked why she was taking the little girl in the sun. She replied that she would return very soon and that she was going to the river. Sulai was satisfied with the answer and apparently had no suspicion that any evil would happen to his daughter. He never saw the girl alive again. Nihal, the Headman of the village deposes to the fact that he had seen the accused walking in an easterly direction followed by the deceased child. The accused had her own child in her arms. He had no thought that anything was strange or wrong until two gharis later when Sulai and his brother, Jiao came searching for the child. Bheja says that he saw the accused walking rapidly not very far from where the body was subsequently discovered and that she appeared agitated. She asked for a drink of water which he gave her. She had her own child but she was no longer accompanied by the deceased. She had a conversation with him. She concealed from him where she had come from and suppressed the information not only that she had come from the house of Sulai, but even that she had come from Keswara where Sulai lives. She said that she had come from Rajadiha, and was going to Banethu. Bheja asked if she had come from Rajadiha how was it that she was there. She said that she had lost her way. The information possessed by Bheja became known to Sulai by accident. He had been to a small feast given by one Danyar. Sulai came there weeping over the loss of his child. Everyone was speaking of the disappearance of the woman and the child and when Bheja heard the description of the woman, he at once remembered what he had seen. The body was found in a place where the cattle drink, something less than a mile from the house of Sulai. There was about a foot and a half of water and there was the same quantity of mud at the place. From the nostrils of the child was coming bloody foam and the windpipe contained blood and mud. There were no external marks of violence. The cause of death was drowning. Ornaments which the child was wearing when she left her father's house were missing. So far as stated, the evidence against the accused is the fact that the deceased left her father's house in the accused's company and was seen still in her company some distance away by Nihal, the village headman. Next that the accused was seen by Bhoja in an agitated condition not far from the place where the body was subsequently found when she gave a false account of how she came to be there and concealed facts which if she were innocent, she had no reason to conceal. Lastly that the body was discovered that very night stripped of the ornaments. This evidence although raising a very strong suspicion against the accused might perhaps not warrant her conviction. There is, however, very important additional evidence. Subsequent to the discovery of the body and after the accused had been caught by one of the villagers who went in search of her, she brought the police and a number of the villagers to a place some distance off and there produced from a dung heap the ornaments which the child wore. Khushal a witness has said that the day after the murder, he was in a grove with a number of villagers as well as the accused. The thanadar was also there. The accused persisted that she did not know where the ornaments were. The witness continued:— “After a little, prisoner said to me that she would tell me where the ornaments were if she was let off. The thanadar made this promise to her”. Having regard to this evidence and to the opinion of the learned Judge expressed towards the conclusion of his judgment, we thought it right that the question of the admissibility of evidence as to the discovery of the ornaments by the accused should be considered by a Full Bench. We accordingly referred a case which assumed in favour of the accused that the promise or inducement had been held out by the thanadar as deposed to by the witness Khushal and that the discovery of the property was the result. The Full Bench were unanimously of opinion that the fact of the discovery was admissible in evidence. This very evidence of Khushal shows, however, that the accused before any promise had been made to her had made a statement which clearly implied that she knew where the ornaments were for Khushal says that he told him that she would say where the ornaments were if she were let off. This promise Khushal says the thanadar gave though the latter denies it. We think that excluding every statement made by the accused and relying only upon the other evidence which we have set out coupled with the mere fact of the discovery of the murdered child's ornaments by the accused, the case is proved up to the hilt. Of course, in weighing evidence of this kind obtained under an inducement, consideration must always be given to the fact that the evidence was in all probability secured by the promise held out. There may be cases where the circumstances are such that the fact that the discovery was induced by a promise would raise a doubt as to the genuineness of the discovery and render the evidence almost worthless. In the present case, however, we think, there can be no doubt that the discovery was perfectly genuine. The learned Judge says that the evidence connected with the discovery of the ornaments was most convincing. The defence suggested by the accused is that Sulai maliciously invited her to stay in his house with the intention of injuring her, that after she left, it was pretended that certain ornaments which really belonged to the accused herself belonged to and were worn by the child and that the whole case is the result of a conspiracy. Her own brother says that there was no enmity of any kind between the families. It is impossible to think that Sulai invited her to his house and then had his own child done away with for the purpose of injuring the accused. By her own account, she was kindly treated by Sulai up to the time she left and it is absolutely certain that the child did not meet her death for a considerable time after the accused had left Sulai's house. She claims some of the ornaments which were found and which were proved to have been worn by the child. But the evidence is that when she left the house of Sulai and when she was seen by Nihal and Bheja, she was not wearing a hansli which is perhaps the most important ornament that was found. The Assessors were unanimous as to the guilt of the accused and the learned Judge who has fully dealt with all the circumstances seems to have been convinced that a treacherous and cruel murder had been committed by the accused. We dismiss the appeal, confirm the conviction and sentence and direct that the latter be carried into execution according to law.

2. Appeal dismissed.