Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Husaini Begam v. Khwaja Muhammad Khan And Anr.

Allahabad High Court
Nov 27, 1906
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

This appeal arises from a suit filed by Nawab Husaini Begam against the decree of the Subordinate Judge of Agra dated 16th August 1904, which dismissed her claim for arrears of an annuity. The annuity of Rs. 500 per month, described as "pandan," was agreed upon by Nawab Khwaja Muhammad Khan, father of the plaintiff’s husband, Rustam Ali Khan, at the time of the marriage arrangement. The annuity was to be paid in perpetuity from the income of certain properties. Although the annuity was paid for some time, it was later stopped by the plaintiff’s father-in-law on the ground that the plaintiff had ceased to live with her husband. The suit sought recovery of arrears due up to October 1903.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the plaintiff’s cessation of living with her husband forfeited her right to receive the annuity under the agreement.
  2. Whether the agreement for the payment of the annuity was illegal, opposed to public policy, or without consideration.
  3. Whether the plaintiff, being a minor at the time of execution, could enforce the agreement made for her benefit.

Arguments of the Parties

Respondent's Arguments

  • The plaintiff was not a party to the agreement executed on 25th October 1877.
  • At the time of execution, the plaintiff was a minor and thus could not enforce the agreement.
  • The plaintiff ceased to live with her husband due to quarrels, thereby forfeiting her right to the annuity.
  • The plaintiff had become unchaste, which would also forfeit her rights to the annuity.
  • The agreement was illegal, opposed to public policy, and lacked consideration.

Appellant's Arguments

  • The agreement was executed as a result of an arrangement between the plaintiff’s father and the defendant, expressly for the benefit of the plaintiff.
  • The plaintiff was named in the document and empowered to recover the annuity from the specified properties.
  • There was no condition in the agreement that the payment of the annuity was contingent upon the plaintiff living with her husband or maintaining chastity.
  • The plaintiff’s refusal to live with her husband was due to his misconduct, including entertaining a prostitute and other improper behavior.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court examined the terms of the agreement executed on 25th October 1877, which obligated the defendant to pay the plaintiff Rs. 500 monthly in perpetuity from specified properties. The court noted the absence of any condition in the agreement relating to the plaintiff’s chastity or cohabitation with her husband. It found the lower court’s conclusion—that cessation of living with the husband relieved the defendant from liability—was erroneous as it was unsupported by the agreement’s terms. The court rejected the respondent’s contention that the plaintiff could not enforce the agreement due to minority, holding that the document was executed for her benefit and she was entitled to enforce it. The plaintiff’s reason for leaving her husband, namely his misconduct, was noted but not examined in detail as the execution of the agreement and non-payment were admitted. Consequently, the court allowed the appeal and decreed recovery of the arrears with interest and costs.

Holding and Implications

The appeal was allowed, the decree of the Subordinate Judge was set aside, and a decree was granted to the plaintiff for Rs. 15,000 with interest and costs.

The court declared the annuity charge valid on the specified properties situated in British India and directed sale of sufficient property if payment was not made by 1st June 1907. The decision directly benefits the plaintiff by enforcing her right to the annuity and clarifies that no condition precedent existed for payment relating to cohabitation or chastity. This ruling does not establish new precedent but corrects the misapplication of the agreement’s terms by the lower court.

Show all summary ...

and William Burkitt, J.

1. This is an appeal by the plaintiff Nawab Husaini Begam, wife of Nawab Rustam Ali Khan, against the decree of the Subordinate Judge of Agra, dated the 16th of August 1904, dismissing her suit. On the occasion of the marriage of the plaintiff with her husband, Nawab Khwaja Muhammad Khan, the father of Rustam Ali Khan, agreed with the plaintiff's father that in consideration of the marriage he would pay to the plaintiff Rs. 500 a month as pin money, described in the document which was subsequently drawn up as "pandan." It appears that this annuity was paid for a considerable time, but, owing to the fact that the plaintiff refused to live with her husband, or ceased to live with him, her father-in-law thought it fit to stop the payment of the annuity. The amount claimed is for arrears due up to the end of October 1903.

2. A number of defences were set up in the Court below, the most important being that the plaintiff had ceased to live with her husband on account of quarrels and therefore was not entitled to the annuity, and that she had become unchaste and therefore hud forfeited her rights in respect of it. It was also said that the agreement was illegal and opposed to public policy and was without consideration. Issues upon these defences were knit in the Court below, but all of them were determined in favour of the plaintiff, with the exception of the issue whether the plaintiff had ceased to live with her husband and so forfeited the annuity. The learned Subordinate Judge found that she had ceased to live with him, and on this ground that she had forfeited her right to the annuity. His words are: "I hold that if the plaintiff prove unchaste or refuse to live with her husband, there is no obligation on her father-in-law to pay her any allowance;" and further on: "In this present case unchastity has not been legally proved, but her refusal to live with her husband is most satisfactorily proved, and I therefore hold that she is not entitled to her allowance." How the agreement to pay the annuity was embodied in a document which has been adduced in evidence. It is dated the 25th of October 1877 and is very simple in its provisions. In it the defendant, Khwaja Muhammad Khan, after reciting that the marriage of his son Rustam Ali Khan, with the plaintiff had been fixed to take place on the 2nd of November 1877, declares that he will continue to pay Rs. 500 per month in perpetuity to the plaintiff for pin money (pandan) from the date of the marriage, that is, from the date of the plaintiff's arrival at her husband's house, out of the income of certain property in the Agra district and a jagir in the Dholpur State which is specified in the document. Then follows a provision, that neither the executant nor his heirs or representatives shall have power to object to the monthly payment and that the whole property shall be liable for the amount of it; and further that the plaintiff shall have power to recover the annuity from all the property in the Agra district and the property in Dholpur in whatever way she pleased. This is the substance of the document. Details of the property the subject of the charge are then given, and the signature of the executant is appended with that of several witnesses. The execution of the document is admitted and it is also admitted that arrears of the annuity are due in case there be any liability on foot of the agreement. It is to be observed that there is no condition whatever attached to the payment of the annuity. There is nothing said as to the chastity or unchastity of the plaintiff, nor is there any provision under which the executant can claim freedom from liability in case the plaintiff cease to live with her husband or by reason of any other act done by the plaintiff. We therefore fail to understand how the learned Subordinate Judge arrived at the conclusion that the fact that the plaintiff was not living with her husband relieved the defendant, Nawab Khwaja Muhammad Khan, from his obligation to satisfy his undertakings. He is in our opinion clearly wrong as to this.

3. We may point out that the reason assigned by the plaintiff for her refusal to live with her husband is that he has been in the habit of entertaining a prostitute in his house and otherwise misconducting himself, and that it was owing to his misconduct that she left his house. Our attention was not called by either the learned Counsel or the Advocate for the respective parties to the evidence upon the record, nor was it indeed necessary to do so in view of the fact that the execution of the agreement for the payment of the annuity is admitted and payment is not alleged.

4. Mr. Karamat Husain on behalf of the respondent contended that the plaintiff was no party to the agreement of the 25th of October 1877, and that at the time when it was executed she was a minor, and that therefore she could not take advantage of its provisions and sue upon it. "We do not think that there is any substance in this contention. The document was executed in pursuance of an agreement entered into between Khwaja Muhammad Khan, the father of the intended husband, and the father of the plaintiff, who was a child of tender years at the time. In consideration of the agreement the father and guardian of the plaintiff allowed the marriage to take place, and on the faith of it the marriage between the girl and Rustam Ali Khan was consummated. The document provides that the plaintiff shall have power to recover the amount of the annuity, and she is expressly named in the document as the person for whose benefit the agreement was executed. Under circumstances such as these it is idle, we think, to put forward the plea that the plaintiff cannot take advantage of a document which was executed solely for her benefit.

5. We therefore allow the appeal, set aside the decree of the Court below, and give a decree to the plaintiff for the sum of Rs. 15,000, with interest at the rate of 6 per cent, per annum from the 10th of November 1903 up to the date of payment, with costs. We also declare that the annuity is well charged upon the property mentioned in the plaint and specified in detail in the agreement so far as that property is situate in British India. If the amount of the decree with interest be not paid on or before the 1st of June 1907, we direct that the said property or a sufficient part thereof be sold for the satisfaction of the plaintiff's claim. The decree will be drawn up in accordance with the provisions of Section 88 of the Transfer of Property Act. The plaintiff appellant will have the costs of this appeal and also the costs in the Court below against all the defendants.