Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Hirdey Narain And Another (Opposite Parties) v. Mrs. M.J Powell And Another (Objectors).

Allahabad High Court
Oct 30, 1912
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.

Karamat Husain and Chamier, JJ.:— This is an appeal against an order or decree of the District Judge of Saharanpur, awarding to the appellants and to the respondent Mrs. Powell of the sum of Rs. 7,768-8-0, awarded by the Superintendent of Dehra Dun as compensation for certain land taken up under the Land Acquisition Act for public purposes. It is not now disputed that Rs. 7,768-8-0 represent the fair value of the property taken up, and the only question for decision now is how this sum should be divided between the appellants and the respondent Mrs. Powell. The Superintendent proposed to award to the appellants the whole of the above sum except Rs. 144 which he considered to be the value of Mrs. Powell's interests in the land. She objected to this, and the Superintendent referred the matter to the District Judge. Mrs. Powell's case was that she was virtually the zamindar of the land and that the appellants were only nominally zamindars and were entitled at best to compensation calculated on the amount of rent paid to them. The rent was Rs. 12 per annum, and her suggestion was that the zamindars should be awarded Rs. 144 only. The reference by the Superintendent was made to the District Judge early in 1910. A date was fixed for the hearing of the case in June 1910, and it was decided that the case should be taken up at Dehra Dun. On some day in June, the exact date is not clear, it seems to have occurred to some one that the appellants were interested in the case, as of course they were, and on June, the 13th, notice was issued to the appellant, Hirde Narain, that the case would be taken up on the following day. Notice was served upon Hirde Narain on the 13th of June, at 9 p.m He appeared before the court on the following day, and, as the Judge observes, very reasonably asked for time. On that day two witnesses only were examined for Mrs. Powell and the case was adjourned to June 22nd. It was taken up on June 25th. Witnesses were examined on that day and on the 26th, one witness only being produced by Hirde Narain. Here we may mention that although Maharaj Narain seems to have a share in the property, no notice was issued to him. But this is not made a ground of complaint here, and for present purposes Maharaj Narain may be disregarded. The object of Mrs. Powell seems to have been to prove that occupancy tenants, like herself, were entitled to build upon their land also to transfer it to whomsoever they pleased. An extract from the wajib-ul-arz of the village was put in, and several witnesses were called and questioned as to the rights of occupancy tenants in the village in question and in the adjoining villages. It is unnecessary for us to examine this evidence in detail. The wajib-ul-arz does not lay down that occupancy tenants can transfer their rights. It says only that certain kashtkars can build houses without the permission of the landlord. The oral evidence on the point is quite worthless. The District Judge has arrived at the conclusion, as we understand his judgement, that occupancy tenants in the suburbs of the town of Dehra Dun which include the village in question are practically sub-proprietors who are entitled to transfer their rights and need only pay a quit rent to the zamindars. In arriving at this conclusion he made use of some remarks made by Mr. Dampier in a rent rate report for the Dehra suburban circle. It is not contended here that these remarks are admissible in evidence. They ought to have been excluded, and, even if they are admitted, we consider that they are not sufficient to show that Mrs. Powell is entitled to transfer her rights in the land. She is recorded, or rather the person through whom she claims, is recorded, as occupancy tenant of the land. According to the present law she is not entitled to transfer her rights. No issues were fixed in the case. The point which the District Judge had to decide was how the sum awarded by the Collector as compensation for the land was to be divided between the claimants, and a definite issue should have been struck on this question. The sum awarded by the Collector should be apportioned between the appellants and Mrs. Powell in proportion to their interests in the land. On the one hand we have the zamindars entitled to receive Rs. 12 per annum as rent; on the other hand we have Mrs. Powell, an occupancy tenant of the land, receiving according to the evidence Rs. 40 from her sub-tenants, so that at first sight it would appear that the respective values of the interest of the zamindars and Mrs. Powell are in the proportion of 12 to 28, and it is in this proportion that the sum awarded by the Collector has been divided between them by the District Judge. The appellants take objection to this on the ground that the learned Judge has not taken into consideration the fact that whereas the rents received by Mrs. Powell were fixed quite recently, the rent payable by Mrs. Powell to the appellants was fixed as long ago as 1890. They point out that a land-holder may sue an occupancy tenant for enhancement of the rent on the ground stated in section 43 of the Tenancy Act, and they contend that inquiry should be made as to whether Mrs. Powell was not at the date of the acquisition of the land paying rent at a rate below the prevailing rate paid by occupancy tenants for lands of similar quality and with similar advantages, and also that there has been a rise in the average local prices of staple food crops during the currency of the present rent. Owing to the fact that no issue was struck in this case the necessity for making a proper inquiry into the respective values of the interests of the parties has been overlooked. It has been held in more than one case in the Calcutta High Court that where a sum is to be apportioned between a landholder and a subordinate tenure-holder, the respective values of the interests of the two should be ascertained, and, if possible, something should be awarded to the land-holder on account of the possibility that he may be able to have the rent of the subordinate tenure-holder enhanced. Mutatis mutandis what was said in those cases applies to the present case. If it can be shown that the land-holder was at the time of the acquisition of the land entitled to have the rent enhanced, there would be no difficulty in ascertaining to what extent the rent might have been enhanced had the land not been acquired by the Government. There is some evidence that the land-holder took steps to have the rent enhanced, but abandoned them. Considering that notice of the case was given at the last moment to the appellant, and considering that no attempt has been made to ascertain the respective values of the interests of the parties in the land, we think that a further inquiry should be held. Under order XLI, rule 25, we remit to the court of the District Judge the following issue:—What are the respective values of the interests of the appellants and Mrs. Powell in the land in question? Further evidence may be admitted on both sides. On return of the finding ten days will be allowed for filing objections.

On receipt of the finding the following judgement was delivered:—

Griffin and Chamier, JJ.:— This case was remitted to the District Judge in order that he might ascertain the respective values of the interests of the appellants and Mrs. Powell in the land in question for which the Superintendent of Dehra Dun has awarded under the Land Acquisition Act a sum of Rs. 7,768-8-0. The learned Judge rightly, as we think, set himself to ascertain what were the respective rights of the appellants and Mrs. Powell in the land. He came to the conclusion that Mrs. Powell was what he calls an abadi tenant; having a right to build on the land and to transfer it, that the interest of the appellant in the land was worth no more than Rs. 1,060, and that the balance of the sum awarded by the Superintendent of Dehra Dun, namely, Rs. 6,708-8-0, should be given to Mrs. Powell. But in case this Court did not agree with the view that Mrs. Powell was an abadi tenant, he went on to ascertain the values of the respective rights of the parties in the case on the assumption that Mrs. Powell was an occupancy tenant of the land. He found that the annual value of Mrs. Powell's interest as an occupancy tenant was Rs. 22, and the annual value of the appellants' interests as landlords was Rs. 11. He then suggested that Mrs. Powell should be given a sum of Rs. 352, that is, sixteen years' purchase of the annual value of her interests and that the balance should be given to the appellants. We are unable to accept either of these conclusions in their entirety. Mrs. Powell, or rather the person through whom she claims, is recorded as an occupancy tenant of the land. There is really no evidence as to the circumstances in which, or even as to the time when, Mrs. Powell's prodecessors first obtained the land. Both sides have indulged in much speculation as to what their respective rights must be. One fact stands out clearly, namely, that for the last fifty or sixty years the land has been used for agricultural purposes, and in the absence of definite evidence as to the respective rights of the parties in the land, we think that the sum awarded should, be divided between them in proportion to the values of the interests hitherto enjoyed by them, after making due allowance for the possibility of the rent being enhanced. We accept the finding of the District Judge that the annual value of Mrs. Powell's interest in the land is Rs. 22, and that the annual value of the appellant's interests is Rs. 11. But it seems to us that the whole sum awarded by the Superintendent should be divided amongst them in proportion to the value of their interests, and that there is no justification for what the learned Judge has done, namely, give Mrs. Powell, sixteen times the value of her interest and give the appellants the whole of the balance. It would be as wrong in our opinion to give the appellants sixteen times the value of their interests in the land and to, give Mrs. Powell the whole of the balance. The result is that we hold that the sum in question should be divided in the proportions of ⅓rd and ⅔rds, ⅓rd going to the appellants and ⅔rds to Mrs. Powell, that is to say, Rs. 2,590 to the appellants and Rs. 5,178-8-0, to Mrs. Powell. The decree of the court below is modified accordingly.

Decree modified.