Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Committee Of Management, Lakhori Inter College v. District Inspector Of Schools, Moradabad

Allahabad High Court
Aug 2, 2001
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioners filed a writ petition seeking a mandamus directing the District Inspector of Schools (DIOS), Moradabad, to attest the signature of petitioner No. 2 as Manager of the committee of management based on elections held on 14.9.1997. They also sought to quash a letter dated 11.9.1997 issued by the DIOS. The respondents contended that the petition had become infructuous because the committee's term was three years, and the election in question was from 1997, implying the term had expired.

The last committee election was on 12.3.1994, with the term expiring on 11.3.1997. Since fresh elections were not held within one month of expiry, the DIOS appointed an Authorised Controller on 6.5.1997 to manage the institution and hold elections within six months. The Authorised Controller held elections on 14.9.1997 but the DIOS did not attest the signature of petitioner No. 2, citing a letter dated 11.9.1997 allegedly staying the election, which the Election Officer did not receive. The petitioners challenged the DIOS's inaction and the validity of the stay letter.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the writ petition had become infructuous due to the lapse of time since the committee's election was in 1997 and the term was three years plus one month.
  2. Whether the term of the committee of management elected on 14.9.1997 commenced on the date of election or upon taking charge after recognition by the DIOS.
  3. The legal effect of the DIOS's failure to recognize the newly elected committee or pass any order regarding the election held on 14.9.1997.

Arguments of the Parties

Respondents' Arguments

  • The writ petition is infructuous as the committee's term of three years plus one month has expired since the election was held in 1997.
  • Reliance was placed on Clause 8 of the Scheme of Administration which provides for automatic expiration of the committee's term after three years plus one month if a new committee does not take charge.

Petitioners' Arguments

  • The term of the committee never commenced as the newly elected committee was never recognized or handed over charge by the DIOS.
  • Clause 9(4) of the Scheme of Administration requires DIOS approval for the committee to take charge, and until such recognition, the term does not start running.
  • The DIOS's failure to pass any order on the election report or the stay letter means the committee's term cannot be said to have expired.
  • The petitioners should not be penalized for the failure of the Authorised Controller or DIOS in not handing over charge or passing any order.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Committee of Management v. Dy. Director of Education, 1991 2 UPLBEC 1183 Determination of the commencement date of the committee's term; term may start from date of valid election or date of taking charge. The Court relied on this precedent to establish that the term of the committee may begin either from the election date or from the date the committee takes charge, depending on facts.
Committee of Management v. Dy. Director of Education, 1995 1 UPLBEC 149 Clarification that the term begins immediately after expiry of outgoing committee's term and is not dependent on DIOS recognition; taking charge is independent of recognition. The Court distinguished this precedent, noting it applies where the committee has taken charge, unlike the present case where the committee never took charge due to lack of DIOS order.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court analyzed the Scheme of Administration under Section 16-A(1) of the U.P. Intermediate Education Act, 1921, focusing on Clauses 8 and 9(4). Clause 8 prescribes a three-year term and a one-month extension for the outgoing committee, but does not specify when the term of a newly elected committee commences. Clause 9(4) requires DIOS approval before the newly elected committee takes charge.

The Court observed that the term of the committee must logically commence from the date it takes charge after recognition, not merely on the election date, especially where the Authorised Controller manages the institution and the committee has not assumed control. The Court rejected the respondents' contention that the term expired by efflux of time despite the committee never having taken charge.

Relying on precedents, the Court distinguished cases where the committee had taken charge and the term began immediately after the previous committee's term expired. Here, the DIOS neither recognized the election nor passed any order approving or disapproving it. The Court found that the petitioners should not be penalized for the DIOS's or Authorised Controller's failure to act.

The Court emphasized that an interpretation leading to absurdity or injustice must be avoided, and a just, reasonable, and sensible construction should be adopted, whereby the term does not expire if it never commenced due to administrative inaction.

Holding and Implications

The writ petition is not infructuous and the claim of the petitioners is liable to be examined on merits.

The Court held that the term of the committee of management elected on 14.9.1997 did not commence due to the lack of DIOS recognition and handover of charge. Consequently, the petitioners are entitled to have their election and recognition considered substantively. The decision directly affects the parties by allowing the petition to proceed but does not establish any new legal precedent beyond clarifying the application of the Scheme of Administration in such factual circumstances.

Show all summary ...

S.K Singh, J.:— By means of this writ petition, the petitioners have prayed for issuance of a writ in the nature of mandamus commanding the respondent No. 1, the District Inspector of Schools, Moradabad to attest the signature of petitioner No. 2 as Manager of the committee of management on the basis of the election held on 14.9.1997 A further prayer has been made that the letter dated 11.9.1997 (Annexure 12 to the writ petition) as issued by the respondent No. 1 be also quashed.

2. When the matter was taken up, a preliminary objection was raised on behalf of the respondents that this writ petition, by lapse of time, has become infructuous as the term of the committee of management as provided under the Scheme of Administration is 3 years and thereafter, for 1 month the office bearers of the old committee can continue and therefore, according to the learned counsel for the respondents, the election in which the petitioners claim to have been elected being of the year 1997, no relief can be granted to the petitioners. Learned counsel for the petitioners has placed before the Court Clause (8) and sub-clause (4) of Clause-9 of the Scheme of Administration which was been annexed as Annexure 1 alongwith the impleadment application by Sri Daman Singh and others.

The aforesaid clause-8 and sub-clause (4) of Clause-9 for convenience is hereby reproduced as under:—

3. In view of the aforesaid preliminary objection, matter was heard on this issue. For deciding the aforesaid preliminary issue as to whether the writ petition has become infructuous as argued by learned counsel for the respondents, a reference to certain facts will be necessary which come out from the narration of the facts as have been pleaded in the writ petition.

4. The last election of the previous committee of management was held on 12.3.1994 The term being 3 years, it was to continue upto 11th March, 1997 and as fresh election to constitute the committee of management could not take place within 1 month of the expiry of the term of out-going committee of management, the DIOS, by order dated 6.5.1997 appointed the respondent No. 2 as Authorised Controller of the College as contemplated under the Scheme of Administration with a direction to hold elections of the new committee of management within a period of 6 months. The Authorised Controller took charge of the affairs of the College on 7th of March, 1997 and with a purpose to hold the elections, wrote a letter on 2.9.1997 to the DIOS for according permission to hold election. On that very day, 2 other letters were written by him to the DIOS by which, he gave information about the appointment of respondent No. 3 as Election Officer and requested that if the department wants to appoint an Observer, that may be made. The DIOS by his letter dated 3.9.1997 in reference to the letters of the Authorised Controller dated 2.9.1997 granted permission according approval to the nomination of the 3rd respondent as Election Officer with a further direction for the publication of notice of the elections in the daily news paper. It has been stated that after due publication, ultimately elections took place on 14.9.1997 upon which the Election Officer sent information about the proceedings of the elections to the DIOS on 14.9.1997 itself. It is said that the President of the Committee of Management so elected as per information of the Election Officer dated 14.9.1997 also wrote to the DIOS for attesting the signature of the petitioner No. 2. Enquiry was made from the office of DIOS upon which it was revealed that signature was not attested because of the reason that a letter was already sent from the office of the respondent No. 1 on 11.9.1997, although same was never received by the Election Officer, for staying the election which was to take place on 14.9.1997 It is by this action on the part of the DIOS i.e (i) of not taking any decision in respect to the election which was held on 14.9.1997 as informed by the Election Officer, and (ii) the letter dated 11.9.1997 for staying the election, petitioners feeling aggrieved, has filed this writ petition.

5. It has been submitted by learned counsel for the petitioners that in the fact situation of the case stated supra, term of the committee of management never commenced and therefore, this writ petition has not become infructuous. It has been submitted on the basis of the sub-clause (4) of clause 9 the the scheme of administration that handing over of charge by authorised controller to the newly elected committee is also dependent upon the fact that the report about the election has to be approved by the DIOS and it is to that committee as approved by the DIOS that the charge is to be handed over.

6. The question that calls for determination is as to whether term of committee of management elected on 14.9.1997 commenced on the date of election and expired automatically on expiry of prescribed period of 3 years and 1 month.

7. Section 16-A(1) of U.P Intermediate Education Act, 1921 provides that there shall be a Scheme of Administration for every institution. The Scheme of Administration as provided in Section 16-A(1) shall, amongst other matters, provides for constitution of a committee of management vested with the authority to manage and to conduct the affairs of the institution. The Act however, does not provide as to what would be the duration/term of the committee of management in accordance with the Scheme of Administration. The 3rd Schedule to the Act which contains principle on which the Scheme of Administration shall be accorded approval, visualises that every Scheme of Administration shall provide, inter-alia, for the procedure for constitution of the committee of management, the qualification and dis-qualification of the members, and office bearers of the committee of management and the term of their office. Clause-8 of the approved Scheme of Administration in the present case, provides that the term of the committee of management shall be 3 years and if a newly constituted committee of management does not take charge of the affairs of the institution within a month thereafter, the office bearers of the committee of management of which the term has expired will cease to function. Clause-8 of the Scheme of Administration, reliance on which has been placed by learned counsel for the respondents, is however silent about the date of commencement of the prescribed term of the committee of management. It visualises of a situation where there exists a recognised committee of management and its term expired with no new committee of management to take charge within 1 month after expiration of the term. It does not comprehend a situation where the affairs of the institution is conducted by the authorised controller who holds election but does not hand over charge to the newly constituted committee of management in the absence of order passed by the DIOS according recognition to the newly constituted committee of management. In such a situation 3 years term of the committee of management will commence w.e.f the date of taking over the charge within a reasonable time after recognition. The expression used in clause 9(4) is significant. A conjoint reading of clause 8 and 9 (4) of the Scheme of Administration also leads to the conclusion that it is the date of assumption of the office i.e relevant for the purpose of commencement of the term of the committee of management. It would be preposterous to hold, in the instant case that the term of the committee of management expired or lapsed by efflux of time even though it could not commence as yet.

8. In Committee of Management v. Dy. Director of Education . 1991 2 UPLBEC 1183., a question arose as what would be the date which can be said to be the date of commencement of term of committee of management. A Division Bench of this Court held as under:

“…………we find that there is nothing in the Act, Rules or under the Scheme of Administration. However, we feel after perusing the Scheme of Administration, the various provisions of the Act and the Rules that its period would start running either from the date of election validly held where the period of earlier committee of management has already come to an end prior to this date and there being no dispute or from the date the elected committee of management takes over the charge of the management.”

9. It would appear from the observation aforestated that the Division Bench was of the view that depending on fact/situation of each case, the term of the committee of management would start running either from the date of election validly held or from date the elected committee of management takes over charge of the management.

10. In Committee of Management v. Dy. Director of Education . 1995 1 UPLBEC 149., a Division Bench of this Court was seized of a similar matter. After referring the decision of the Division Bench in aforestated case (1991) 2 UPLBEC (supra), the Court held as under:

“……………It is true that it is mentioned in the Scheme of Administration of the College that papers of the election will be submitted before the DIOS who will recognise the Committee, if he is satisfied from the perusal of the record. But the Scheme further says that the Committee so elected shall take over charge after the expiry of the term of the outgoing Committee. Taking over charge of the College by the newly elected committee is not dependent on the recognition by the DIOS. The term of the newly elected Committee begins immediately on the expiry of the term of the outgoing Committee and if the Committee of management is not elected before the expiry of the term of the outgoing Committee.”

11. In both the cases aforementioned, it was held that commencement of the term of the committee of management was not dependent on attestation of signature by the DIOS but at the same time, the Court did recognise that the term of the committee in a given case may begin to run from the date the elected committee of management takes over charge of the management. It would depend upon the facts of each case that whether term of committee of management will begin from the date of election of from the date of taking over charge. In a case where the affairs of the college are managed by the Committee which holds the elections in accordance with the scheme of administration, before expiry of its term, the newly elected committee of management will begin to run not from the date of election but from the date of taking over charge of the management after expiry of the term of the outgoing committee. In the present case, affairs of the College were being managed by the authorised controller and it was he who held election on 14.9.1997 but did not hand over the charge to the petitioners' committee in view of the fact that no express order was passed by the DIOS approving the petitioners, committee of management. The DIOS did not recall the Authorised Controller and rather allowed him to continue even after the election. A reading of para 9(4) of the Scheme of Administration suggests that newly elected committee of management will take over charge only after it is recognised by the DIOS. The arguments of Sri Ashok Khare, learned Senior advocate that the term of the committee elected on 14.9.1997 automatically expired on expiration of prescribed period of 3 years and 1 month is based on mis-construction of Scheme of Administration. In my considered opinion, para-8 of the Scheme of Administration provides for automatic expiration of term of existing committee of management in case newly elected committee does not take charge within extended period of 1 month after expiration of 3 years term of the committee of management. It does not apply to a case where, the elected committee of management is seeking its recognition and the affairs of the institution are conducted by Authorised Controller.

12. Learned counsel for the petitioners submits and in my opinion rightly that admittedly the DIOS has not passed any order either way in respect to the election, report about which was sent on 14.9.1997 by the Election Officer and therefore, the contention that the term of the committee has expired on completion of 3 years term cannot be accepted. The election was conducted by the authorised controller and it was for the DIOS to take a decision by passing a specific reasoned order, dis-approving the election in the event of there being any infirmity or even on the ground that he had stayed the election for the reasons stated in the letter dated 11.9.1997

13. In the decision cited by learned counsel for the respondents i.e Committee of Management v. Dy. Director of Education (supra) it has been said that taking over charge of the affairs of the college by the newly elected committee is not dependent on the recognition by the DIOS. To my mind that decision will apply in a situation where the committee has taken over charge of the affairs of the college on a particular date and in the meantime, for any intervention at the level of DIOS or otherwise, management was interrupted. In such situation, it will be deemed that after running out the period of 3 years, the term of that committee will cease. But so far as present case is concerned, the election was conducted by the authorised controller, and admittedly, petitioners could never come into the control of the affairs of the college for a single moment and it is the authorised controller who, under law, as well as fact has been continuing. It cannot therefore, be said that the term of the committee has run away, which admittedly never came into existence.

14. In my opinion, a distinction has to be drawn in the situation where the election was conducted by the authorised controller and in respect thereto no decision has been taken by the DIOS either way and the term of the committee never commenced due to the reason that charge was never given by Authorised Controller and therefore, the prescribed duration cannot be said to have expired. The authorised controller was appointed by the DIOS and the petitioners cannot be penalised for the fault of the authorised controller or for the fault of the DIOS in not passing any specific order. The construction, which leads to absurdity and injustice, should be avoided. The Court must adopt an interpretation i.e just, reasonable and sensible, rather than which leads to unjust and absurd results. It would never have been intended by the framers of the Scheme of Administration that the term of the committee of management would expire even though the same never commenced due to the fault of the either the authorised controller or the DIOS.

15. In view of the aforesaid premises, I feel persuaded to take the view that this writ petition cannot be held to have become infructuous and the claim of the petitioners is liable to be examined on merits.

16. List on 14th August, 2001 this matter for admission/final disposal.