- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Chandra Prakash Gupta v. Additional District Magistrate
Structured Summary of the Provided Opinion
Factual and Procedural Background
The petitioner was appointed as a typist on daily wages in the Integrated Rural Development Programme (IRDP) w.e.f. 1-12-1986 by the A.D.M. (Project) through an order dated 5-12-1986. He worked intermittently with breaks up to 16-10-1989 and was paid daily wages during that period. On 17-10-1989 it is alleged his services were terminated orally by the A.D.M. (Project). The petitioner challenged the termination and sought a writ of mandamus directing respondents to treat him as a regular typist from 17-10-1989 and to pay salary.
This Court, by an interim order dated 23-11-1990, allowed the petitioner to join and continue in the post of typist and directed monthly payment of salary. Respondents filed counter-affidavits stating the petitioner had been appointed on daily wages for a fixed limited period and that the scheme had ceased; hence no regular appointment could follow.
Subsequent proceedings included an order dated 23-5-1996 directing respondents to show cause or pay salary if the petitioner had been allowed to join, a direction on 3-10-1996 to pay salary month-by-month (for lack of a counter-affidavit), a contempt petition, and an order by the Chief Development Officer dated 23-12-1995 purporting to give regular appointment w.e.f. 24-8-1996. The District Magistrate later cancelled the Chief Development Officer's order and stated the petitioner shall continue on daily wages. The petitioner produced a District Magistrate order dated 29-7-1997 (said to be in compliance with a contempt order) purporting to appoint the petitioner w.e.f. 24-8-1996 in a regular pay scale, which respondents contend was issued under threat in contempt proceedings and not through proper appointment procedure.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the petitioner, appointed on daily wages and working intermittently until 16-10-1989, has a right to be regularised as a typist from 17-10-1989.
- Whether interim orders of the Court (allowing petitioner to join and directing payment month-to-month) amount to an effective appointment conferring a right to continued service or regularisation.
- Whether orders purporting to give regular appointment (including the Chief Development Officer's order and the District Magistrate's later order in contempt compliance) can be treated as valid appointments made after due process.
- Whether the absence of an available permanent post or cessation of the scheme precludes any direction for regularisation and whether the petitioner is nevertheless entitled to salary for periods actually worked.
- Whether any alleged discrimination (vis-à-vis a junior, Ram Chandra Dohre) gives the petitioner a right to regularisation.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioner's Arguments (as presented in the opinion)
- The petitioner, though appointed on daily wages, worked repeatedly with artificial breaks and served more than 240 days in a calendar year.
- A junior employee, Ram Chandra Dohre, received an ad hoc appointment and continued in service; this raised an argument of discrimination.
- The petitioner relied on a District Magistrate order dated 29-7-1997 purporting to give him appointment on the post of typist in a regular pay-scale and claimed regular appointment w.e.f. 28-4-1996 (and that ideally he should have been appointed w.e.f. 17-10-1989).
- The petitioner relied on the Supreme Court decision in State of Haryana v. Piara Singh (1992) (as authority against prolonged ad hoc/temporary status where long service raises presumption of need for regular posts).
Respondents' Arguments (as presented in the opinion)
- The appointment on daily wages for a short period does not confer any right to regular appointment.
- The District Rural Development Agency is not an "industry" and if the petitioner seeks rights as a workman under the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947, he must approach the labour court.
- There is no permanent post of typist available; the scheme under which the petitioner was appointed has ceased, so continuation or regularisation is not possible.
- The Chief Development Officer's purported regular appointment (23-12-1995) was cancelled by the District Magistrate on the ground that the CDO had no authority to give a regular appointment without following proper appointment process; and the later District Magistrate order (29-7-1997) was passed under the threat of contempt compliance and cannot be treated as a proper appointing authority's order made after following procedure.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Daily Rated Casual Labour Employed under P. & T. Department v. Union of India, (1988) 1 SCC 122 : AIR 1987 SC 2342 | The rights of daily rated casual labour were considered; the Supreme Court directed submission of a scheme to extend permanent status of workmen in appropriate situations. | The Court noted this decision as part of the jurisprudence on daily-rated employees, but did not treat it as automatically entitling the petitioner to regularisation; it acknowledged earlier directions in that case to consider schemes for regularisation where appropriate. |
| State of Haryana v. Piara Singh, (1992) 4 SCC 118 : AIR 1992 SC 2130 | Where eligible and qualified persons continue in ad hoc/temporary service for a long period satisfactorily, a presumption arises as to the need for regular posts; the case dealt with validity of regularisation orders. | The petitioner relied on this authority to argue against prolonged ad hoc status. The Court referenced Piara Singh but distinguished the present facts (temporary daily-wage appointment, absence of regular selection and absence of available posts) and did not grant regularisation on that basis. |
| Ghaziabad Development Authority v. Vikram Chaudhary, (1995) 5 SCC 210 | Held that, in absence of availability of posts for regular appointment, regularisation cannot be directed; daily-rated employees should be given minimum or prevailing wages instead. | The Court relied on this precedent to support the proposition that where there are no permanent posts available, regularisation cannot be ordered and remedy is limited to payment of wages for actual service. |
| State of Himachal Pradesh v. Nodha Ram, 1998 SCC (L&S) 478 : AIR 1997 SC 1445 | Where a project is completed and closed for want of funds, temporary employees must go with closure; no vested right is created by temporary employment; directions to regularise where no vacancies exist are illegal. | The Court used this authority to support the view that temporary employment does not create a vested right to regularisation when the underlying scheme has ceased and no posts exist, and that earlier directions for regularisation may be illegal if they ignore these realities. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court proceeded by first recording the admitted facts: the petitioner was appointed on daily wages and served intermittently from 1-12-1986 to 16-10-1989, being paid daily wages. After these dates his services ceased. The Court observed that interim orders allowing the petitioner to join and directing salary month-to-month cannot be treated as an appointing instrument conferring a substantive right to continued service or regularisation.
The Court examined the validity of various purported appointment orders: the Chief Development Officer's order of 23-12-1995 (giving regular appointment w.e.f. 24-8-1996) was cancelled by the District Magistrate on the ground that the Chief Development Officer lacked authority and no appointment process was followed. The District Magistrate's later order of 29-7-1997 was characterized by respondents as produced under compulsion of contempt proceedings and therefore not an act of appointing authority following due process.
The Court reviewed relevant precedents on regularisation of temporary/daily-rated employees. It noted the evolution of law: earlier decisions contemplated regularisation in certain cases, but subsequent decisions stressed that regularisation cannot be ordered where no posts exist and that temporary employees have no vested right when a project/scheme has ended. Applying these principles (as set out in Ghaziabad Development Authority v. Vikram Chaudhary and State of Himachal Pradesh v. Nodha Ram), the Court concluded that regularisation cannot be directed in the absence of available posts or an existing establishment.
On the discrimination point, the Court noted that the junior employee Ram Chandra Dohre had ad hoc appointment and continued without break, but even he had not been regularised. The Court held that mere benefit of a fixed number of days of service does not itself provide a ground for regularisation.
The Court also expressed concern over appointments made without following recruitment procedure, warning that such practices generate litigation and public dissatisfaction and should be avoided; appointing authorities must follow recruitment rules and reservation policy when a scheme continues long-term.
On relief, the Court held that the petitioner was not entitled to be regularised but would be entitled only to salary for the period during which he had actually worked. The Court added that, if no regular selection is made in future for similar posts, the appointing authority may consider relaxation of age for future appointments for the period the petitioner actually served.
Holding and Implications
Final Disposition: The writ petition was dismissed. WRIT PETITION DISMISSED.
Implications and Direct Effects:
- The petitioner is not entitled to regularisation as a typist from 17-10-1989 or any other date on the basis of the facts and documents before the Court.
- The interim order allowing the petitioner to join and directing month-to-month salary does not amount to an appointing instrument conferring regular employment.
- The petitioner is entitled only to salary for the specific periods he actually worked; no broader right to continued service or regular appointment was recognized.
- Orders purportedly granting regular appointment that were issued without following the prescribed process (including orders obtained in the course of contempt compliance) cannot be treated as valid appointments made by the competent appointing authority after following proper procedure.
- The Court noted that appointing authorities must follow recruitment rules and reservation policy where schemes continue long-term; ad hoc/back-door entries into public service should be curbed.
- The Court suggested a limited remedial accommodation: if future appointments are made without regular selection, the appointing authority may consider age relaxation for the period the petitioner actually served (but no regularisation is directed now).
- No new broad legal precedent or novel principle was proclaimed; the decision applies existing precedents to the facts and denies the petitioner's claim for regularisation in the circumstances described.
This summary is based exclusively on the content of the provided opinion and does not add or infer facts beyond the text.
1. The petitioner was appointed as a typist on daily wages in the integrated rural development programme w.e.f 1-12-1986 by A.D.M (Project) vide its order dated 5-12-1986. He was continued with breaks in between up to 16-10-1989. During the period he worked, he was paid daily wages. On 17-10-1989, it is alleged that his services were terminated on oral orders of A.D.M (Project). In the present petition, he has challenged termination of his services and is seeking a writ of mandamus directing the respondents to treat the petitioner in service since 17-10-1989 as a regular typist and to pay him salary.
2. This Court vide its order dated 23-11-1990, after giving opportunity to the respondents to file counter-affidavit, passed orders to the effect that the petitioner shall be allowed to join and continue on the post of typist, on which he was working within a period of one week, and that he shall be paid his salary from month to month. A counter-affidavit was filed on behalf of opposite party, in which it has been stated that petitioner was appointed on daily wages for fixed tenure of limited period.
3. The work for which he was appointed in the integrated rural development progamme has ceased as such he could not be appointed further. Replying to the question of discrimination, it has been stated in para 9 that Sheo Chandra is no more in service and Ram Chandra Dohre is still in service on the strength of his tenure fixed in his appointment, letter, but his services have not been regularised as there is no permanent post of typist under the programme. It appears that petitioner was not paid his salary and as such he filed an application on which an order was passed on 23-5-1996 directing the respondents that if petitioner has been allowed to join, he shall be paid his salary or the respondents shall show cause. The matter came up again on 3-10-1996 and this Court directed that since no counter-affidavit has been filed on the application for payment of salary, the respondents are directed to pay salary to the petitioner on the post of typist month by month. It appears thereafter a contempt petition was filed and in compliance with the orders passed in contempt petition, the Chief Development Officer vide its order dated 23-12-1995 gave regular appointment to the petitioner w.e.f 24-8-1996. In supplementary counter-affidavit of Ravi Kumar, Project Director, District Rural Development Agency, Hamirpur, it has been stated that the order dated 23-12-1995 passed by Chief Development Officer, Hamirpur was cancelled by the District Magistrate and it was made clear that petitioner Chandra Prakash Gupta shall continue on work on daily wages. Petitioner filed a listing application on 17-8-2000, with which he has annexed an order of District Magistrate, Hamirpur dated 29-7-1997 by which in compliance with the order dated 7-5-1997 in contempt petition No. 2093 of 1996, the District Magistrate has given appointment to the petitioner w.e.f 24-8-1996 in the pay scale of Rs. 950-1500. This order has been passed on the threat and in compliance of the contempt and cannot be treated to be passed by appointing authority, on his won, after following any procedure of appointment.
4. Heard Sri. A.A Khan, learned counsel appearing on behalf of the petitioner and the learned Standing Counsel for the respondents. It has been stated by counsel for the petitioner, that although petitioner was appointed on daily wages but his services were continued from time to time with artificial breaks and that he has worked, more than 240 days in a calendar year. He has further stated that one Ram Chandra Dohre was appointed for a period of one month, who was junior to the petitioner, but was given ad hoc appointment up to the period regular selection was made. Counsel for the petitioner has also relied upon order dated 29-7-1997 passed by District Magistrate by which the petitioner was given appointment on the post of typist in regular pay-scale and has claimed that by the said order he has been regularly appointed w.e.f 28-4-1996 where he should have been appointed w.e.f 17-10-1989. Petitioner has also relied upon the judgment reported in (1992) 4 SCC 118 : AIR 1992 SC 2130 : (1992 Lab IC 2168). State of Haryana v. Piara Singh and has submitted that the employees should not be kept temporary or ad hoc for a long time and that such long appointments presume that there is need for regular service. Lastly it has been submitted that there, are two posts of typist lying vacant since long and that petitioner has right to continue on the said post.
5. Learned Standing Counsel in his reply stated that the appointment for short period on daily wages does not give any right of appointment. The District Rural Development Agency is not an industry and that in any case if the petitioner claims rights under the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947 as a workman, he must seek his remedy before labour Court. He further stated that there is no permanent post of typist and there is no vacancy in the rural development agency and that the scheme under which the petitioner was appointed, has ceased and as such it is not possible for respondents to allow him to continue on the said post.
6. I have considered the submissions of both the parties. It is admitted to the petitioner that he was appointed on daily wages and that he continued to work with breaks in between from 1-12-1986 to 16-10-1989, on daily wages, and thereafter his services were ceased. He was allowed to join by interim order passed by this Court. This interim order cannot be treated to be an appointment letter, which gives any right to the petitioner to continue in service. The scheme, according to the respondents, has come to an end. The regular appointment claimed by the petitioner vide order dated 23-12-1995 was cancelled by the District Magistrate on 24-8-1995 was cancelled by the District Magistrate on 24-8-1996, on the ground that the Chief Development Officer had no right to give regular appointment to a typist in District Rural Development Agency for which no process of appointment was followed. The order dated 29-7-1997 was passed, under the threat of compliance in contempt petition 2039 of 1996, which was filed for compliance of the order dated 23-11-1990. This order also cannot be treated as an order of appointment after following any process of appointment.
7. The question of regularisation of daily wages employees has been subject matter of judicial scrutiny for a long time, in a developing country various schemes are implemented. These schemes are supported by limited financial allocation. The employees appointed on daily wages in such schemes are fully aware of its temporary nature, and also the nature and term of their appointment. In Daily Rated Casual Labour Employed under P. & T. Department v. Union of India, (1988) 1 SCC 122 : (AIR 1987 SC 2342) the Supreme Court considered the rights of the daily rated casual labour and directed for submission of a scheme to extend permanent status of the workmen. State of Haryana v. Piara Singh, (1992) 4 SCC 118 : (AIR 1992 SC 2130) was a case of ad hoc temporary Government and consider the validity of the orders of regularisation made by State of Haryana, in which Supreme Court held that eligible and qualified continue in service satisfactorily for a long period raises presumption of need of regular posts. Later on there has been a marked changed in law relating to regularisation of daily rated employees. In Ghaziabad Development Authority v. Vikram Chaudhary, (1995) 5 SCC 210 : (1995 All LJ 1786) it was held that in the abence of availability of posts for regular appointment, regularisation cannot be directed and that the daily rated employees should be given minimum wages under the Statute, if any, or the prevailing wages in the locality. In State of Himachal Pradesh v. Nodha Ram, 1998 SCC (L&S) 478 : (AIR 1997 SC 1445) it has been held that where a project is completed, and closed due to non availability of funds, the employees have to go along with its closure. No vested right is created in temporary employments. Directions cannot be given to regularise their services in the absence of any existing vacancies, nor can directions be given to the State to create posts in a non existing establishment. In this case Supreme Court found that the directions issued by Hon'ble Court for regularisation were illegal warranting interference.
8. In the present case petitioner was not appointed by following any selection process. He was given appointment for a period of one month on daily wages, and it was continued up to 16-10-1989 with breaks. The period of his service in compliance with the directions of this Court cannot be treated to be regular service, which entitles him to be considered for regularisation. The project, according to the respondents, in para 5 of their supplementary affidavit has since ceased. There is no post available for regularising the services of the petitioner. So far as the discrimination with the junior employees Ram Chandra Dohre is concerned, it is to be noticed that Dohre was appointed on ad hoc basis and continued in service without any break. In any case he has also not been regularised. The benefit of a fixed number of days and service can not be a ground for reguiarisation.
9. It is distressing to note that employment in the scheme have been made without following any procedure. Thls attempt not only gives rise of litigation but causes dissatisfaction in public. The authorities competent to appoint must follow the recruitment procedure provided under the relevant rules. If the scheme has to be continued for long period, the appointment must be made after advertisement by a process of selection and after following reservation policy. Any back door entry in public services must be curbed, and should not be encouraged. The appointments dehors recruitment rules should not be permitted to continue for long periods. In the aforesaid facts and circumstances, the petitioner has no right to continue, and that his claim for regularisation is not established. The petitioner will be entitled for salary only for the period during which he had actually worked. In case, however, no regular selection is made under the recruitment rules, the appointing authority may consider relaxation of age in future appointment in any scheme for the period the petitioner had actually served.
10. The writ petition has no force and is accordingly dismissed.
11. Petition dismissed.
Alert