- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Dr. Bajrang Bahadur Singh And Another v. The State Of U.P And Others
Court Opinion Summary — D. P. Mohapatra, C.J.I.
Factual and Procedural Background
The appellants, Dr. Bajrang Bahadur Singh and Dr. Arun Kumar Misra, were appointed as Demonstrators in Lal Bahadur Shastri State Homeopathic Medical College, Allahabad, an institution owned, controlled and managed by the State Government since 1981. The appellants claimed that, because the posts of Lecturers were vacant, they had been teaching students since 11-12-1981 and performed functions such as teaching, occasionally acting as paper-setters and external examiners. They relied on several documents annexed to their writ petition (including correspondence in which they were described as Lecturers) and sought salary as Lecturers from 11-12-1981 on the basis of the principle of "equal pay for equal work".
The learned Single Judge rejected their claim by judgment dated 27-9-1991 in Civil Misc. Writ Petition No. 13343 of 1989. The appellants appealed against that judgment. The respondents did not dispute that the appellants taught students but maintained that they were Demonstrators entrusted with teaching duties, not Lecturers; that the post of Lecturer is a gazetted post requiring consultation with the Public Service Commission (PSC) for appointment; that the appellants had not appeared before the PSC for recruitment to Lecturer posts; and that the principle of "equal pay for equal work" did not extend to the appellants' case. During the pendency of the appeal, Dr. Arun Kumar Misra was subsequently appointed as Lecturer on the recommendation of the PSC.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the principle "equal pay for equal work" is applicable to the appellants' claim for salary at the Lecturer rate for work performed since 11-12-1981.
- Whether the constitutional principle of equal pay (noted as a directive under Article 39(d) and as potentially arising under Articles 14 and 16 where discrimination in service is alleged) supports the appellants' claim in the circumstances of this case.
Arguments of the Parties
Appellants' Arguments
- The appellants asserted that they had been teaching students since 11-12-1981, performing the teaching duties associated with Lecturers because the Lecturer posts were vacant, and therefore they were entitled to receive the salary differential payable to Lecturers from that date.
- At the commencement of argument, senior counsel for the appellants clarified that they were not claiming an appointment to the post of Lecturer, were not claiming the full pay scale or formal equivalence of the two posts, but sought the differential amount in salary on the ground that they had been doing the job of a Lecturer.
Respondents' Arguments
- The respondents did not dispute that the appellants taught students, but maintained that the appellants were Demonstrators who were assigned teaching duties as an internal arrangement by the Principal, and were not demonstrably holding the post or cadre of Lecturer.
- They contended that the post of Lecturer is a gazetted post requiring appointment in consultation with the Public Service Commission, and the appellants had not appeared before the PSC for recruitment to that post. One appellant was later appointed on PSC recommendation during the proceedings.
- The respondents argued that the principle of "equal pay for equal work" did not extend to the appellants' case.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Chandigarh Administration v. Anita Sood (Smt.) and others, 1995 Supp. (3) SCC 613 | Teaching Assistants who teach the same subjects as Lecturers cannot automatically claim the pay scale of Lecturers; qualitative differences in teaching roles and permissible classifications based on academic qualifications, experience and standard of teaching. | The court relied on this decision to show that merely teaching the same subject does not entitle one to a higher pay scale; classification in teaching posts is permissible and supports rejection of an equal-pay claim absent full equivalence. |
| State of West Bengal & others v. Monirujjaman Mullick & others, 1996(2) LBESR 968 (SC) | Non-formal educational instructors cannot be equated with primary school teachers; institutional, qualitative and functional differences (recruitment, method of teaching, hours, mode of payment) justify different pay. | Used to illustrate that material and institutional differences can preclude application of "equal pay for equal work" where the nature and context of duties differ significantly. |
| State of West Bengal & others v. Deb Kumar Mukherjee & others, 1995(2) LBESR 379 (SC) | Selection grades and super time-scales based on seniority or seniority-cum-merit are permissible; classification in a cadre for pay purposes is permissible even if duties may appear similar. | The court cited this authority to support the proposition that permissible classifications in pay structures will not be struck down merely because duties are similar across different classified posts. |
| Sita Devi & others v. State of Haryana & others, 1996(2) LBESR 984 (SC) | Distinctions based on educational qualifications and modes of classification can be upheld under Articles 14 and 16 even if parties perform similar work; claimants must plead and prove similarity of qualifications, duties and functions to succeed. | Referenced to show that the petitioners' failure to plead and establish necessary similarities is fatal to an equal-pay claim; supports requirement to prove equivalence across multiple dimensions. |
| State of Mysore v. P. Narsinga Rao, AIR 1968 SC 349 | Earlier authority concerning classification of tracers (matriculate and non-matriculate) and permissible distinction based on qualifications. | Referred to by the court via Sita Devi to support the proposition that classification based on educational qualifications may be valid. |
| Jaipal, AIR 1988 S.C. 1504 | Referred to in Sita Devi by petitioners seeking parity; exact rule not detailed in the opinion text. | Cited within the Sita Devi discussion; the opinion notes petitioners had relied on it but did not elaborate further in this judgment. |
| Union Territory, Chandigarh v. Krishan Bhandri, J.T. 1996 (10) 396 | Refusal to equate Science Supervisors in Chandigarh with District Science Supervisors in Punjab for scale of pay. | Used as an additional example where the Supreme Court declined parity claims between supervisory posts in different services/territories. |
| Copal Krishna Sharma & others v. State of Rajasthan & others, AIR 1993 SC 81 | Research Associates (though not regular members of a cadre) could be granted a consolidated salary worked out by placing them on the basic of a lower time-scale when qualifications, recruitment method and job-charts were identical; however, they could not be placed on the time-scale or equated in status. | The court treated this authority as distinguishable: in Copal Krishna Sharma the incumbents had statutory/organizational recognition (and pleaded identity of qualifications, recruitment and duties) which justified a remedial salary order; in the present case appellants did not plead or establish such equivalence or statutory recognition. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court began by identifying the core question as whether the principle "equal pay for equal work" applied to the appellants. It observed that the principle is a constitutional goal under Article 39(d) and may arise where discrimination or denial of equal opportunity in service under Articles 14 and 16 is alleged, while noting that reasonable classification based on intelligible differentia is permissible.
The court recorded the appellants' clarification that they were not seeking appointment to the Lecturer post, were not claiming the Lecturer scale in full, nor seeking formal equivalence of the posts; rather, they sought the differential pay on account of having performed teaching functions. The court also noted the absence, in the writ petition and affidavits, of any pleading or attempt by the appellants to establish that Demonstrators in the institution discharge duties and bear responsibilities similar to Lecturers in all relevant respects.
The court surveyed several precedents in which the Supreme Court and other authorities declined to grant parity of pay merely because incumbents did similar or overlapping tasks; the cited cases emphasize that parity requires equivalence across multiple factors (mode of recruitment, eligibility qualifications, nature of duties/responsibilities, service rules, and other pertinent features), and that permissible classification may be upheld even when duties appear similar.
Applying those principles to the present record, the court found that:
- The appellants had not pleaded or established that Demonstrators and Lecturers were alike in the relevant dimensions required to invoke "equal pay for equal work".
- The teaching duties performed by the appellants were assigned by internal arrangement of the College Principal rather than arising from appointment to a Lecturer post or a statutory recognition that they belonged to the Lecturer cadre.
- Internal administrative arrangements (assignment of teaching duties within the college) did not create legally enforceable rights to Lecturer pay or a change in cadre or status.
- On the authority of the cited precedents, mere performance of duties similar to those of another post is insufficient; the appellants needed to demonstrate equivalence in recruitment, qualifications, duties, responsibilities and applicable service rules to succeed on an equal-pay claim.
Given these findings, the court concluded that the learned Single Judge correctly rejected the appellants' claim, and that the appeal was without merit.
Holding and Implications
Holding: The appeal is DISMISSED. (The court ordered that there shall be no order as to costs.)
Implications
- Direct effect: The appellants' claim for salary as admissible and paid to Lecturers on the principle of "equal pay for equal work" was rejected; they are not entitled to the Lecturer salary differential for the period claimed on the record presented.
- Legal standard reinforced: To succeed on an "equal pay for equal work" claim, a petitioner must plead and prove that they are equally placed in all relevant respects with the cadre or persons whose pay they seek—this includes mode of recruitment, prescribed eligibility qualifications, nature and responsibility of duties, work done and service rules (if any).
- Administrative assignments (internal arrangements by a principal/employer) do not, by themselves, create legally enforceable rights to a different pay scale or to membership of a different cadre.
- The opinion does not purport to establish a novel legal precedent beyond applying and following extant Supreme Court authorities; its practical consequence is the dismissal of the appellants' claim on the facts and pleadings before the court.
Appeal dismissed.
D. P. Mohapatra, C. J.I.-
The short question that arises for determination in this case is whether the principle 'equal pay for equal work' is applicable to the case of the appellants? Their claim having been rejected by the learned single Judge by judgment dated 27-9-1991 in Civil Misc. Writ Petition No. 13343 of 1989, they filed this appeal challenging the said judgment.
2. The relevant facts of the case, sans unnecessary details, may be stated thus:
Both the appellants, Dr. Bajrang Bahadur Singh and Dr. Arun Kumar Misra, were appointed as Demonstrators in Lal Bahadur Shastri State Homeopathic Medical College, Allahabad, which is an educational institution owned, controlled and managed by the State Government since 1981. The petitioner-appellants claimed salary as Lecturers on the sole ground that they have been teaching students since 11-12-1981 as the posts of lecturers in the institution were vacant. Several documents have been annexed to the writ petition to show that the appellants were teaching students regularly and occasionally they were appointed as paper setters and external examiners also. In some of the corropondence of the principal, they have been described as Lecturers (Annexures 2-C and 2-E). In the circumstances, according to the appellants, they are entitled to the salary of Lecturers since 11-12-1981. The claim is based on the principle of equal pay for equal work'.
3. The respondents, as is evident from the counter-affidavit; have not controverted, the case of the appellants that they have been teaching students in the institution. Their stand is that the appellants were entrusted teaching work as Demonstrators and not as Lecturers. It is the further case of the respondents that the post of lecturer being a Gazetted post, appointment has to be made in consultation with the Public Service Commission. The appellants have not appeared before the Public Service Commission for recruitment to the post of Lecturer. Indeed, subsequently during the pendency of the case in this Court, one of the petitioner-appellants, Dr. Arun Kumar Misra, has been appointed as Lecturer on the recommendation of the Public Service Commission. The respondents contend that the principle of 'equal pay for equal work' does not extent to the case of the appellants. On the case of the parties, as shortly discussed above, the question formulated earlier, arises for consideration.
4. Equal pay for equal work is, no doubt, a constitutional goal enshrined in Articles 39(d) of the Constitution as one of the directive principles or State Policy. The principle may also arise for consideration in a case in which discrimination or denial of equal opportunity in service under Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution is alleged. It is also to be borne in mind that while providing for equal protection of law and equal opportunity in State service, reasonable classification based on intelligible differentia is not prohibited.
5. At the commencement of his argument Sri S.P. Gupta, senior Advocate appearing for the appellants, made it clear that the appellants are neither claiming in this case appointment to the post of Lecturer, nor are they claiming the scale of pay of Lecturer, nor are they contending that the two posts (Demonstrator and lecturer) should be equated with each other. All that they claim, submitted Sri Gupta, is that since they have been doing teaching work since December 1981, which is the job of a Lecturer, they should be paid the differential amount in the salary of the two posts. It is relevant to note here that in the writ petition or in the affidavits filed in the case, the petitioner appellants have not made any attempt to show that the Demonstrators in the institution discharge similar duties and bear similar responsibilities as Lecturers.
6. The applicability of the principle 'equal pay for equal work' has been considered by the apex Court in several decisions. We may notice here a few such decisions which, we feel, are relevant for the present case.
7. In the case of Chandigarh Administration v. Anita Sood (Smt.) and others 1995 Supp. (3) SCC 613, the Court held that Teaching Assistants cannot be granted pay scale of Lecturers on the ground that they teach same subjects to same/similar student as was being done by the Lecturers. The relevant discussions in the judgment are quoted hereunder-
"We proceed on the assumption that a Teaching Assistant teaches the same subjects to the same students as were being taught by the Lecturers/Assistant Professors/Professors. It is common knowledge that in various departments of a university different subjects are taught to the same set of students by different teachers who may be Lecturers, Assistant Professors or Professors. A teacher who is a Lecturer, cannot claim that he be given the same salary as given to a Professor who teaches a different subject or the same subject to the students. The quality and standard of teaching by a Professor is bound to be of much higher standard than that of a Lecturer. Keeping in view the qualitative difference of standard of teaching between the two teachers with different designations it cannot be claimed that they are entitled to the same pay scales. A Teaching Assistant is entirely a different class of teacher than that of the Lecturer. In the teaching profession classification is permissible on the basis of academic qualifications, experience and the quality/standard of teaching of various classes of teachers."
8. In the case of State of West Bengal and others v. Monirujjaman Mullick and others. 1996(2) LBESR 968 (SC), the Apex Court rejected the contention raised on behalf of the Instructors in various non-formal educational centres in different districts of the State of West Bengal that they were entitled to the same scales of pay and allowances as were being paid to primary school teachers on the basis of principle of 'equal pay for equal work'. The Supreme Court took the view that the non-formal educational centres cannot be equated with the primary schools which are regularly run by the Education Department of the State Government that apart from the basic qualitative difference between the two institutions even the nature of work of the non- formal instructors and the primary school teachers is not identical; that the method of appointment, the source of recruitment, method of teaching, hours of teaching and the mode of payment are entirely different; and that in that facts and circumstances of the case the High Court fell into patent error in applying the principle of 'equal pay for equal work.
9. In the case of State of West Bengal and others v. Deb Kumar Mukherjee and others, 1995(2) LBESR 379 (SC), the Apex Court ruled that it is well-known in service jurisprudence that selection grade and super time-scale based on seniority or seniority-cum merit are permissible. In that case the court rejected the plea that the Inspectors in Housing Department should be equated with the Inspectors in the Animal Husbandry Department of the State Government and given the pay scales which are being drawn by Inspectors in the Animal Husbandry Department. Considering the point the Court observed-
"The duties performed by the Inspectors in the two grades may be the same, but no fault can be found with the classification. It is settled by a string of authorities of this Court that classification in the cadre on the ground of selection based on merit is permissible. It is well-known in service jurisprudence that selection grade and super time scale based on seniority or seniority-cum-merit are permissible. The High Court fell into patent error in setting aside the classification on the ground of discrimination."
10. In the case of Sita Devi and others v. State of Haryana and others, 1996(2) LBESR 984 (SC), the Supreme Court, referring with approval to a previous decision in State of Mysore v. P. Narsinga Rao, AIR 1968 SC 349, observed that indeed, in that case both the matriculate and non- matriculate tracers formed one single category with one single pay scale earlier. It was only at a later stage that a distinction was made between matriculates and non-matriculates, which led to the said proceedings. The Court proceeded on the assumption that both matriculate and non-matriculate tracers were doing the same kind of work, yet the classification made was upheld as permissible under Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution. Distinction on the basis of the educational qualifications was upheld as valid. On the ultimate analysis the Court observed-
"We arc, therefore, of the opinion that the grievance made by the petitioners is unacceptable. We may also mention that apart from relying upon the decision of this Court in Jaipal, AIR 1988 S.C. 1504 and claiming that the benefit given to matriculate teachers should also be given to them, no attempt has been made in the writ petition to allege and establish that their qualifications, duties and functions are similar to those of squad teachers."
A similar view was taken by the Supreme Court in the case of Union Territory, Chandigarh v. Krishan Bhandri, J. T. 1996 (10) 396, where the Supreme Court declined to accept the pleas that Science Supervisors in the Union territory of Chandigarh are entitled to the same scale of pay as admissible to the District Science Supervisors in the State of Punjab.
11. Sri S.P. Gupta placed strong reliance on the decision of the Supreme Court in the case of Copal Krishna Sharma and others v. State of Rajasthan and others, AIR 1993 SC 81. In that case the Court considered the claim of Research Assistants/Associates in the scale of Rs. 700-1600, which, on the recommendation of the University Grants Commission, was granted to other members of the teaching staff. The Research Assistants claimed that they belong to the teaching faculty and, therefore, are entitled to get salary in the pay scale of Rs. 700-1600 at the lowest scale of the teaching staff. The Supreme Court took note of the definition of 'teacher' in Section 2(j) of the Udaipur University Act, 1962 and the Statute 47 of the University, which provided the teacher means a person appointed or recognised by the University for the purpose of instruction or conducting and guiding research or extension programmes and includes a person who may be declared by the statute to be a teacher. The Court held that Research Associates cannot be treated at par with Research Assistants in the matter of grant of scale merely on the ground that the educational qualification for appointment in the two posts was identical. The Court further held that the educational qualification and method of recruitment of Research Associates was the same as for Research Assistants as was evident from Resolution 153 and their job-charts were identical; that like Research Assistants, Research Associates also conduct and guide research work. In such circumstances, the Supreme Court accepted the contention that on the principle of 'equal pay for equal work' the University could not be permitted to exploit the market condition of large scale unemployment of educated youth and availability of surplus qualified persons by offering them a paltry consolidated pay of Rs. 1100/- per month. At the same time the Court made it clear that they could not claim to be placed on a scale of pay since they were never on a time scale like their colleagues, i.e., Research Assistants. The Court ultimately took the view that ends of justice would be met if it was ordered that Research Associates be allowed a consolidated salary to be worked out by placing them on a basic salary of Rs. 700/- (which is the minimum of scale of Rs. 700- 1600 allowed to Research Assistants) and granted monetary benefits thereon in the form of such allowances allowed to a regular employee drawing a basic pay of Rs. 700/-per month. The Court made it clear that their appointment would however continue to be what it was and they would not belong to the cadre of Research Assistants merely because their consolidated salary was ordered to be worked out on the minimum of the time scale allowed to Research Assistant, i.e., Rs. 700-1600; similarly they would not be equated with Lecturers/Assistant Professors in status and salary and they would continue to carry out the same duties and functions which they were carrying out including assisting Assistant professors. Their demand for placement in the scale of Rs. 700-1600 was rejected.
12. This decision, in our opinion, is clearly distinguishable from the case in hand. As noted earlier, the petitioner- appellants have neither pleaded nor established any similarity between the posts of Demonstrators and Lecturers of the institution. Further, there is no statutory provision, as in the Supreme Court case, to the effect that Demonstrators are members of teaching faculty on are teachers. On the other hand, from the Supreme Court decision the principle is clear that unless a person is found to have held a post in a cadre he is not entitled to the benefit of the scale of pay admissible to the members of the said cadre and cannot base his claim for higher salary admissible to persons holding post in the cadre.
13. From the conspectus of views taken in the aforementioned decided cases, the position is clear that to substantiate a claim of higher scale of pay/salary on the basis of the principle 'equal pay for equal work" the petitioner-appellants will have to establish that they are equally placed in all respects with the person or persons whose scale of pay/salary they claim. They must allege and prove that the mode of recruitment, eligibility qualifications prescribed, the nature of duties/responsibilities discharged/shouldered, the work done and the service rules (if any) applicable to the two posts are similar. They cannot succeed in the case merely by showing that they have been discharging same duties which are being discharged by persons holding the other class of posts.
14. In the present case, as noted earlier, the petitioner- appellants based their claim of salary of Lecturer merely on the basis that they were teaching students which was also a duty to be discharged by a Lecturer. Further, as the materials on record reveal, the petitioners-appellants were assigned duty of teaching by the Principal as an internal arrangement in the College. In all probability the petitioners-appellants readily accepted the assignment of teaching duty by Principal with the hope to get weightage ont he basis of teaching experience at the time of recruitment to the post of Lecturer. By such internal arrangement in the institution no legally enforceable rights could be created in favour of the petitioner-appellants. It also does not render any assistance to them in application of the principle of 'equal pay for equal work' in the case.
15. On the analysis made and for the reasons stated in the foregoing paragraphs, we have no hesitation to hold that the learned single Judge was right in rejecting the claim of the petitioners for salary as admissible and paid to Lecturers on the principle of 'equal pay for equal work". Thus, the appeal being devoid of merit is dismissed, but in the circumstances of the case there shall be no order at to costs.
Appeal dismissed.
Alert