Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Paras Nath Pandey v. Asstt. Director (Adm...

Allahabad High Court
Apr 8, 1997
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Structured Summary of the Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner was employed as Instructor in Discipline of Welding at the Government Industrial Training Institute, Naini. He petitioned under Article 226 of the Constitution of India challenging an order dated 19-12-1994 by the Assistant Director (Administrator) removing him from service and the appellate order dated 13-12-1995 by the Director, Industrial Training & Employment, U.P., which dismissed his appeal.

Procedurally, the matter was heard initially on 02-04-1996 and the petition was dismissed; the petitioner applied to recall that order and to be permitted to address the Court. That application was allowed, the case was reheard and judgment was reserved on 06-03-1997.

On the substantive facts, on 20-06-1992 the petitioner's wife, Smt. Kesari Devi, filed a complaint alleging that the petitioner had an illicit relationship with Smt. Urmila Devi and was keeping her as his mistress. A preliminary enquiry found the allegations correct. Disciplinary proceedings were initiated; a charge-sheet alleged (1) keeping a mistress during the lifetime of his wife, (2) showing Km. Rita as his daughter in the G.P.F. pass book and taking a loan for her marriage though she was not his daughter, and (3) showing Smt. Urmila as his wife and nominating her though he was never married to her.

The petitioner filed an explanation on 14-12-1993. After enquiry he was found guilty, issued a show-cause notice on 19-06-1994, replied on 16-07-1994, but the Assistant Director (Administrator) held him guilty of misconduct and violation of Rules 3(2), 18 and 29 of the U.P. Government Servants Conduct Rules and removed him from service by order dated 19-12-1994. The appeal was dismissed on 13-12-1995. Those orders were challenged in the present writ petition.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the orders of removal dated 19-12-1994 and the appellate dismissal dated 13-12-1995 were valid and sustainable under Article 226 of the Constitution of India.
  2. Whether the petitioner’s alleged second marriage (or long cohabitation and procreation with Smt. Urmila Devi) was proved as required for misconduct under Rule 29 of the U.P. Government Servants Conduct Rules, i.e., whether strict proof of "Saptapadi" was essential.
  3. Whether merely keeping a mistress during the life-time of the first wife constitutes misconduct within the meaning of Rule 29.
  4. Whether showing Km. Rita as the petitioner's daughter in the G.P.F. pass book and taking a loan for her marriage violated Rule 18 (guardianship of minor) and amounted to misconduct.
  5. Whether the punishment imposed (removal from service) was disproportionate to the proved misconduct and therefore vitiated by the principles of judicial review (including proportionality and reasonableness).

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The second marriage with Smt. Urmila Devi was not proved; strict proof of marriage (Saptapadi) is an essential ingredient for finding misconduct under Rule 29.
  • Mere keeping of a mistress during the lifetime of the wife does not necessarily constitute misconduct within the meaning of Rule 29.
  • The punishment of removal was harsh and disproportionate to the charges proved; it was excessive relative to his conduct and circumstances.
  • The petitioner described difficult domestic circumstances (early marriage, problems with first wife, compulsion to keep Smt. Urmila) and asserted that Smt. Urmila's presence did not interfere with his official duties; his performance remained dedicated and sincere.

Respondents' Arguments

  • The findings of fact recorded by the punishing authority were based on relevant evidence on the record and therefore not open to interference under Article 226.
  • The petitioner had himself admitted having married Smt. Urmila Devi, and that admission estopped him from denying misconduct under Rule 29 (second marriage during the life-time of the first wife being misconduct).
  • The petitioner admitted that Km. Rita was not his daughter and that he had taken a loan for her marriage, amounting to violation of Rules 3(2) and 18.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Ranjit Thakur v. Union of India, (1987) 4 SCC 611 : AIR 1987 SC 2386 (quoted) Doctrine of proportionality within judicial review; sentence/punishment must suit the offence and offender and not be so disproportionate as to "shock the conscience". Irrationality and perversity are recognised grounds of review. The court relied on the principle that judicial review can examine the proportionality of punishment and used it to assess whether removal was disproportionate to the proved misconduct. This authority supported interference with punishment that is outrageously disproportionate.
Council of Civil Service Union v. Minister for the Civil Service, (1984) 3 WLR 1174 (HL) (quoted within Ranjit Thakur) Classification of grounds of judicial review as illegality, irrationality and procedural impropriety; mention of proportionality as an evolving principle. The court invoked this articulation to reinforce that proportionality/irrationality are valid grounds to review administrative disciplinary decisions concerning punishment.
Bhagat Ram v. State of Himachal Pradesh, (1983) 2 SCC 442 : AIR 1983 SC 454 The penalty imposed must be commensurate with the gravity of the misconduct; a disproportionate penalty violates Article 14 of the Constitution. The court applied this principle to conclude that a penalty (removal) disproportionate to the misconduct proved would be impermissible and justified interference with the punishment imposed in the present case.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court undertook a fact-specific analysis and applied the relevant conduct rules reproduced in the opinion (Rule 3(2); Rule 29 sub-rules (1)–(3); and Rule 18). The key steps in the Court's reasoning were:

  1. Admission in the petitioner's own reply: The Court relied on the petitioner's written admissions (filed 14-12-1993) that Smt. Urmila was living with him as his mistress, that they had children, that he entered her name as nominee in the G.P.F. pass book, and that Km. Rita was not his daughter though she was shown as such and a loan was taken for her marriage. The Court described admissions as "the best evidence" and treated those admissions as supporting the findings of the authorities below on the marriage/cohabitation issues.
  2. Presumption of marriage from conduct: The Court observed that strict proof of ritualistic marriage (Saptapadi) may be absent, but long cohabitation as husband and wife and procreation supported a presumption of marriage for the purpose of preventing immorality in the State services. The Court reasoned that otherwise persons might evade Rule 29 by merely avoiding formal proof while keeping mistresses.
  3. Findings of authorities below: Because the authorities' findings on the question of marriage/cohabitation were based on the petitioner's admission and other relevant evidence on the record, those findings could not be characterized as illegal or erroneous.
  4. Rule 18 and the question about Km. Rita: The Court examined Rule 18 (guardianship of a minor) and its Explanation, which includes certain relatives (including brother's and sister's children residing with and wholly dependent on the Government servant) within the definition of "dependent." The Court found that Km. Rita was the petitioner's niece, resided with him and was wholly dependent, so showing her as a daughter in the G.P.F. pass book and taking a loan for her marriage did not constitute misconduct or breach of Rule 18.
  5. Proportionality of punishment: The Court applied the doctrine of proportionality and precedent (Ranjit Thakur; Bhagat Ram) to examine whether removal from service was commensurate with the misconduct proved. The Court emphasized that punishment must match the gravity of proven misconduct and that irrational or perversely disproportionate punishment can be interfered with under judicial review.
  6. Application of proportionality to facts: The Court noted that the misconduct imputed (cohabitation/nomination admission) had not been shown to affect the discharge of the petitioner's official duties — the authorities below recorded no finding that official performance was impaired. Given that absence of adverse impact on duty and the petitioner’s admissions, the Court concluded the sentence of removal was strikingly disproportionate and therefore liable to be quashed.
  7. Relief fashioned with guidance to the disciplinary authority: While quashing the removal, the Court allowed reinstatement and observed that the disciplinary authority could impose minor punishment (citing Rule 29(3), which prescribes withholding increments for three years as a minor punishment for contravention of sub-rules (1) or (2)). The Court limited back wages to one year because the petitioner had not admittedly rendered service after 19-12-1994.

Holding and Implications

Core Ruling: The writ petition was allowed; the orders of removal dated 19-12-1994 and the appellate dismissal dated 13-12-1995 were quashed.

Consequential directions and immediate implications:

  • Respondents were directed to reinstate the petitioner within one month upon production of a certified copy of the order.
  • The Court permitted the disciplinary authority (respondent No. 1) to impose only a minor punishment in view of Rule 29(3) (withholding of increments for three years) instead of removal; the Court observed the petitioner could not go unpunished for the admitted misconduct but that removal was disproportionate.
  • The petitioner was entitled to back wages for one year only, because he had not admittedly rendered any service after 19-12-1994.
  • There was no order as to costs.

No broader legal principle was declared as a novel precedent by this opinion; the Court applied established authorities on proportionality and the requirement that punishment be commensurate with proved misconduct to the facts of this case.

Show all summary ...

1. Petitioner, who was employed as Instructor in Discipline of Welding in Govt. Industrial Trailing Institute, Naini, filed the present petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India, challenging the validity of the order dated 19-12-1994 whereby he was removed from the service by the Asstt Director (Adfninistrator) and the order dated 13-12-95 passed by the Director, Industrial Training & Employment, U. Pj. Rozgar Bhawan, Lucknow dismissing his appeal filed against the order of removal noted above. This case was heard on 2-4-96, but disagreeing with the submissions made by the learned Counsel, it was dismissed and reasons for the order weredirected to follow. In the meanwhile, learned Counsel for the petitioner made an application for recalling the order dated 2-4-96 and to afford him an opportunity to address the Court. After hearing the counsel for the parties, the said application was allowed. Case was again heard and thereafter judgment was reserved on 6-3-97.

2. The relevant facts of the case, in brief, are that on 20-6-92, a complaint was made by Smt. Kesari Devi, wife of the petitioner that the petitioner had illicit connection with Smt. Urmila Devi and was keeping her as his mistress. On the said complaint, preliminary enquiry was made and the allegations were found to be correct. Thereafter, disciplinary proceedings were proposed to be initiated and the Joint Director of Education was appointed as Enquiry Officer. A charge-sheet was served upon the petitioner levelling three char-ges against him, that he was keeping a mistress during the life-time of his wife; he has shown Km. Rita as his daughter in G.P.F Pass Book, took loan for her marriage, although Km. Rita was not his daughter and that he shown Smt. Urmila as his wife and nominated her although he was never married with her. Petitioner in reply to the aforesaid charges filed his explanation on 14-12-93. Thereafter, enquiry was conducted and petitioner was found guilty of the charges levelled against him. A notice was issued against him on 19-6-94 to show cause as to why he be not dismissed from service. Petitioner submitted his explanation/reply of the said notice on 16-7-94 denying the charges levelled against him and requested for dropping the proceedings. The Punishing Authority, Asstt. Director (Administrator) held that the petitioner was guilty of misconduct and violation of Rules 3(2), 18 and 29 of the U.P Govt. Servants Conduct Rules. Having recorded the said findings, he removed the petitioner from service vide order dated — 19-12-94. Thereafter, petitioner filed an appeal before respondent No. 2, who also affirmed the findings recorded by the Punishing Authority and dismissed the appeal by his order dated 13-12-95 as stated above. The said orders of punishing and the appellate authority have been challenged by the petitioner in the present, petition.

3. Learned Counsel for the petitioner vehemently urged that from the evidence on the record, second marriage of the petitioner with Smt. Urmila Devi was not proved. He asserted that unless the factum of marriage with is essential ingredient i.e “Saptapadi”, is proved petitioner cannot be held guilty of misconduct under Rule 29 of the said Rules. He has further asserted that mere keeping a mistress in the life-time of a wife does not constitute misconduct within the meaning of Rule 29 of the said Rules. He has vehemently urged that in any view of the matter the punishment of removal awarded against the petitioner on the charges levelled against him, was quite harsh and not commensurate to the charges proved against him, therefore, was liable to be quashed.

4. On the other hand, learned Standing Counsel submitted that the findings recorded by the punishing authority on the charge levelled against the petitioner are findings of facts, which are based on the relevant evidence, which formed part of the record and the same cannot be interfered with under Article 226 of the Constitution of India. It was also urged by him that the petitioner himself having admitted the factum of marriage with Smt. Urmila Devi, was estopped from contending that he was not guilty of misconduct, inasmuch as under Rule 29 of the said Rules second marriage during the life-time of first wife was a misconduct. It was further urged that the petitioner himself admitted that Km. Rita was not his daughter and that he took loan for her marriage was guilty of violation of Rules 3(2) and 18 of the said Rules.

5. I have considered rival submissions made by the learned Counsel for the parties and also perused the record carefully.

6. Sub-rule (2) of Rule 3 and Rule 29 of U.P Govt. Servants Conduct Rules, are relevant for the purposes of the present case, which are reproduced below:—

“3(2). Every Govt. servant shall at all times conduct himself in accordance with specific or implied orders of the Govt. regarding behaviour and conduct, which may be in force.”

“29(1). No Government servant, who has wife living shall contract another marriage without first obtaining the permission of the Govt. notwithstanding, that such subsequent marriage is permissible under the personal law for the time being applicable to him.

(2) No female Govt. servant shall marry any person, who has a wife living, without first obtaining permission of the Govt.

(3) a minor punishment to be imposed in contravention of the sub-rule (1) or sub-rule (2). shall be withholding of the increments for three years.”

7. Petitioner in his reply to the show cause notice submitted an 14-12-93, staled as under:—

8. From a perusal of the aforesaid paragraph, it is revealed that the petitioner categorically admitted that Smt. Urmila was living with him as his mistress and he had illicit relation with her and that she gave birth to children. He has also admitted that he got entered the name of Smt. Urmila as his nominee in the. G.P.F pass book. He further admitted that Km. Rita was not his daughter, but she was also shown as his daughter in the G.P.F account and he also took loan for her marriage from the said account.

9. There may not be strict proof of performance of Saptapadi between petitioner and Smt. Urmila, but from their long living as husband and wife and procreation of children by them, their marriage may be presumed, otherwise it will give rise to immorality in the services of the State. As people shall start keeping mistresses to save their skin from the clutches of Rule 29 of the aforesaid Rules.

10. The findings recorded by the authorities below on the charges level led against the petitioner regarding their marriage are quite valid, they are based on the aforesaid admission and besides other relevant evidence on the record, the same, therefore, cannot be said to be illegal or erroneous. It is well settled law, that admission is the best evidence, which can be used against the party making it. The petitioner was thus rightly held to be guilty of ??? by the authorities below.

11. So far as the question of showingf Km. Rita as his daughter in the G.P.F pass book is concerned, Rule 18 of the U.P Govt. Servants Conduct Rules provided as under:—

“18. Guardianship of minor:

A Govt. servant may not without previous sanction of the appropriate authority act as a legal guardian of person or property of a minor other than dependent.

Explanation: (1) A dependent for the purposes of this Rule means a Govt. servant's wife, children and step-children and children's children and shall also include his parents sisters and brothers, brothers ‘children and sisters’ children, if residing with him and wholly dependent upon him.”

12. Explanation (1) referred to above, clearly shown that brother's and sister's children of a Govt. servant, if residing with him and are wholly dependent upon him come within the definition of his dependent. In the present case, Km. Rita was the daughter of the petitioner's brother (niece), who was living with him since very beginning and she was wholly dependent upon him as it is evident from the explanation submitted on 14-12-93. The petitioner, therefore, did not commit any act of misconduct or breach of aforesaid Rule in showing Km. Rita as his daughter in the G.P.F pass book and in taking loan therefrom for solemnizing her marriage.

13. So far as the question of punishment is concerned, learned Counsel for the petitioner has vehemently urged that the punishment of removal from service awarded to the petitioner was quite harsh and disproportionate to the charge proved against him. He submitted that the charge of misconduct, if not serious cannot entail major punishment of dimissal, removal from service or reduction in rank. It was further stressed that in the present case, the petitioner has stated, in detail, his domestic problems and the circumstances under which he was compelled to keep Smt. Urmila Devi as his mistress. It has been stated that petitioner was married when he was aged about 10 years only with Smt. Kesari Devi, who was about 7 years elder to him, his father developed illicit relationship with Smt. Kesari Devi and that both have been leading immoral life. He has also stated that circumstances under which Smt. Kesari Devi has left him and he was compelled to keep Smt. Urmila Devi as his mistress.

14. Learned Counsel for petitioner further submits that presence of Smt. Urmila Devi in the house of the petitioner did not in any manner interfere with nor obstructed his official duties which he has performed with dedication and sincerity. In support of his submission, learned Counsel for petitioner placed reliance upon the decision in Ranjit Thakur v. Union of India, (1987) 4 SCC 611 : AIR 1987 SC 2386 : (1988 Cri LJ 158), wherein it was ruled as under by the Apex Court of the country (at page 2392 of AIR):

“Re: contention (d): Judicial Review generally speaking, is not directed against a decision but is directed against the “decision making process”. The question of the choice and quantum of punishment is within thejurisdiction and discretion of the Court-martial. But the sentence has to suit the offence and the offender. It should not be so disproportionate to the offence as to shock the conscience and amount in itself to conclusive evidence of bias. The doctrine of proportionality, as part of the concept of judicial review, would ensure that even on an aspect which is otherwise within the exclusive province of the Court-martial, if the decision of the Court even as to sentence is not outrageous defiance of logic then the sentence would not be immune from collection. Irrationality and perversity are recognised grounds of judicial review. In Council of Civil Service Union v. Minister for the Civil Service, (1984) 3 WLR 1174 (HL) Lords Deplock said:

“………Judicial review has, I think, developed a stage today when without reiterating any analysis of the steps by which the development has come about, one can conveniently classify under three heads the grounds upon which administrative action is subjected to control by judicial review. The first ground I would call ‘illegality’ the second ‘irrationality’ and the third ‘procedural impropriety’. That is not to say that further development on a case by case basis may not in course of time add further grounds. I have in mind particularly the possible adoption in future of the principle of ‘proportionality’ which is recognised in the administrative law of several of our fellow members of the European Economic Community.”

15. In Bhagat Ram v. State of Himachal Pradesh, (1983) 2 SCC 442 : AIR 1983 SC 454 : (1983 Lab IC 662) (at page 460) this Court held:

“It is equally true that the penalty imposed must be commensurate with the gravity of the misconduct and that any penalty disproportionate to the gravity of the misconduct would be violative of Art. 14 of the Constitution.”

16. The point to note and emphasise is that all powers have legal limits.

17. In the present case, the punishment is so strikingly disproportionate as to cal 1 for and justify interference. It cannot be allowed to remain uncorrected injudicial review.

18. In view of the aforesaid decision, the punishment should be proportionate to the charge proved against the employee. In the present case misconduct, which has been imputed to the petitioner has not in any manner affected the discharge of his official duties, as the authorities below did not record any finding to that effect. In my opinion, therefore, the punishment of removal from service awarded to the petitioner is harsh and not, commensurate to the gravity of the charge proved against him and same is liable to be quashed.

19. The writ petition succeeds and is allowed. The order of removal from service dated 19-12-1994 and the order dated 13-12-1995, passed by the Director, Industrial Training and Employment, dismissing the appeal filed by the petitioner, are quashed.

20. Respondents are directed to reinstate the petitioner in service within one month from the date a certified copy of this order is produced before respondent No. 1. It is, however, observed that it will be open to the respondent No. 1 to award only minor punishment as the petitioner cannot be allowed to go scot free for the admitted misconduct within the meaning of Rule 29 of the said Rules. Sub-rule (3) of Rule 29 of the said Rules itself provides for minor punishment of withholding of increment for 3 years only, for violation of sub-rules (1) and (2). Petitioner will be entitled to his back wages only for one year as he has pot admittedly after 19-12-94 rendered any service to the department. There shall be no order as to Costs.

21. Petition allowed.