Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

State Of U.P v. Hari Shanker And Others

Allahabad High Court
Nov 17, 1987
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Structured Summary of the Opinion — B.L. Loomba, J.

Factual and Procedural Background

This appeal arises from a State appeal against the judgment and order dated 16.2.1978 of the then III Additional Sessions Judge, Barabanki, which had extended the benefit of doubt to the respondents and acquitted them of charges. One respondent (Respondent No. 19 Shiv Bux) had died by the time of this opinion.

The respondents were tried for offences under Sections 302, 326, 325, 323, 452 read with Section 149 of the Indian Penal Code. The prosecution's case (summarised in the first information report and evidence) alleged that on 15.6.1972, between about 7–8 a.m., several accused persons armed with country-made pistol, spears (kantas), lathis and other weapons suddenly arrived at the house of the deceased, Chandrika Prasad Misra (resident of village Chhoti Chandawal, P.S. Jaidpur, district Barabanki), assaulted him at the main door while he was said to be washing his hands after answering a call of nature, inflicted multiple severe injuries, and similarly assaulted his sons and wife. It was alleged that Krishna Kumar (a son) had acid thrown into his eyes and became blind, and that household goods were damaged and valuables looted. The deceased later died at Safdarganj crossing while being taken for treatment; the FIR was lodged by Virendra Kumar (another son) at 12:05 hours.

Investigation included inquest, post-mortem and medical examination of injured persons, and recovery of certain household articles from two wells and a talab, identified by the complainant as items looted from the house. The prosecution called family-members as witnesses; an independent witness examined did not support the prosecution. At trial the Sessions Judge acquitted the respondents on benefit of doubt, a decision the State appealed to the High Court, which recorded the present opinion dismissing the appeal.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the prosecution evidence, including oral testimony and medical evidence (post-mortem), sufficiently established the charge of murder and related offences as pleaded in the FIR.
  2. Whether inconsistencies between the prosecution's account (as recorded in the FIR and oral evidence) and medical findings, witness conduct and investigative omissions raised a reasonable doubt requiring acquittal.
  3. Whether the findings of the learned Sessions Judge (acquitting the accused and construing the occurrence as possibly dacoity committed at night rather than a daylight murder) were perverse such that the High Court should interfere and reverse the acquittal.

Arguments of the Parties

Prosecution's Arguments

  • The occurrence took place on 15.6.1972 between 7–8 a.m.; the culprits came armed and attacked the deceased at the main door while he had just returned after attending the call of nature and was washing his hands.
  • The accused caused multiple serious injuries to the deceased (five lacerated head wounds, punctured wound on left arm causing fracture of humerus, punctured wound on left leg, and multiple abrasions) and injured his sons and wife; acid was poured into Krishna Kumar's eyes resulting in blindness.
  • After the assault the accused entered the house, injured the wife and indulged in looting and damage to household goods; some of the looted articles were later recovered from two wells and a talab and identified by the complainant.
  • Prosecution offered an explanation for the post-mortem observation of intestines being full (i.e., that the deceased was constipated), to reconcile the medical report with the account that the deceased had gone out to answer nature's call.

Respondents' Arguments

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The High Court analysed the factual matrix and the trial court's findings, focusing on the following points (as stated in the opinion):

  1. Consistency between medical evidence and the prosecution's factual account:
    • The post-mortem report showed the deceased's large intestine was full, small intestine semi-full and bladder full while the stomach was empty. This condition was considered inconsistent with the prosecution's assertion that the deceased had just returned from answering the call of nature immediately prior to the attack.
    • The prosecution's explanation that the deceased might have been constipated could not be ruled out, but the court considered that ordinarily there would be at least partial evacuation and hence the post-mortem findings more plausibly suggested the deceased had not gone out as alleged.
    • Investigative omissions: the Investigating Officer could have seized the Lota (water vessel) allegedly being used by the deceased at the spot; absence of such seizure was treated as a circumstance creating doubt about the time and circumstances of the assault.
  2. Discrepancies between FIR and subsequent evidence regarding motive and conduct of culprits:
    • The FIR primarily set up a case of murder; it described damage to household goods but did not allege looting. The allegation of looting emerged in oral testimony at trial (complainant and wife stated ornaments and other articles were looted).
    • The court regarded the emergence of looting allegations only in oral evidence (and not in the FIR) as weakening the prosecution narrative that the culprits had specifically come to commit murder rather than to commit dacoity.
    • The court observed that if the assailants' objective had been murder they could have killed the deceased at the entrance (e.g., using the pistol allegedly in their possession) without entering and ransacking the house, making the prosecution's version less probable.
  3. Reliability and number of witnesses:
    • Most prosecution witnesses were family members of the deceased; the sole independent witness examined (Satendra Bahadur Singh) did not support the prosecution (was hostile) and stated he was not present.
    • The court found it significant that the alleged attack occurred in daylight and yet no independent villagers (allegedly drawn to the spot) were named or supported the prosecution. The absence of independent supporting witnesses for a “sensational” daylight occurrence undermined the prosecution case.
    • The conduct of the complainant (Virendra Kumar) was noted as problematic: he left the witness box citing illness, failed to return, required issuance of a bailable warrant for his arrest before being produced again, and his explanation about fearing a statement from a doctor after an alleged demand for money by the Assistant Public Prosecutor was regarded as unconvincing. His inaction at the scene was also described as "somewhat unnatural."
  4. Aggregate effect of contradictions and omissions:
    • The Sessions Judge had recorded additional contradictions in oral evidence (not all individually recited in the opinion), but the High Court accepted that these and the important factual circumstances (medical inconsistencies, differences between FIR and oral testimony, absence of independent corroboration, suspicious conduct of complainant and investigative slippages) cumulatively impaired the prosecution case.
    • The High Court agreed with the Sessions Judge that a reasonable doubt was raised about the time and nature of the occurrence and that the event may more plausibly have been a case of dacoity committed in the night rather than a premeditated daylight murder as set out in the FIR.
  5. Standard of appellate interference with trial court findings:
    • The court reiterated the established principle that findings of fact recorded by a trial court—particularly where the trial court has had the advantage of seeing and hearing witnesses—are entitled to great weight, and may be reversed on appeal only for substantial and compelling reasons (i.e., if the findings are perverse or nearing perversity).
    • The High Court concluded that the Sessions Judge's findings did not suffer from such a defect and were not perverse; therefore there was no basis to disturb the acquittal.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The State appeal is dismissed and the acquittal granted by the Sessions Judge is sustained.

Implications:

  • The direct consequence of this decision is that the respondents' acquittals for the offences under Sections 302, 326, 325, 323, 452 read with Section 149 IPC are affirmed and the prosecution's case fails on the basis of reasonable doubt arising from inconsistencies and evidentiary deficiencies.
  • The High Court emphasized deference to the trial court's factual findings where there is no perversity; the opinion does not purport to lay down a new legal precedent but applies established principles governing appellate review of acquittals.

This summary is derived exclusively from the provided opinion and does not add information beyond that text.

Show all summary ...

B.L Loomba, J.:— This is a state appeal against the judgment and order, dated 16.2.78 of the then III Additional Sessions Judge, Barabanki whereby benefit of doubt was extended in favour of the respondents and they were acquitted of the charges against them. One of the respondents, namely, Respondent No. 19 Shiv Bux has since died.

2. The respondents faced trial for the offences punishable under Sections 302, 326, 325, 323, 452, read with Section 149 of the Indian Penal Code. Prosecution case against the respondents briefly stated was that accused Chandrapal, Kanhaiya Lal, Ram Chandra and others had a long standing enmity with deceased Chandrika Prasad Misra resident of village Chhoti Chandawal, Police Station Jaidpur, district Barabanki and that on 15.6.72 sometime between 7-8 in the morning the accused-respondents suddenly arrived at the house of the deceased well armed with country made pistol, spears kantas and lathis and in a planned manner raided the house of the deceased. At that time the deceased had just returned after attending the call of the nature and was washing his hands near the main door of his house. The accused-respondents challenged the deceased and started assaulting him and caused serious injuries being five lacerated wounds on the head, punctured wound upon the left arm causing fracture of left humorous bone and another punctured wound on the left leg besides several abrasions on the chest, back knee, elbow and hand. Krishna Kumar, Nirmal Kumar and Ashok Kumar sons of the deceased tried to save their father but they too were subjected to attack by the accused persons and several injuries were caused to them. In so far as Krishna Kumar is concerned acid was poured in his eyes as result whereof he became 1 blind. The accused persons after causing injuries to the deceased and his three sons entered into the house and caused injuries to Smt. Dashrath Dei wife of the deceased. They then indulged in looting and damaging house hold goods. The alarm raised by the occurrence attracted several persons of the village and they reached at the spot but could not have the courage to intervene and save the victims. The accused persons thinking that Chandrika Prasad had died made good their escape.

3. The deceased, according to the prosecution case, was still surviving and the complainant namely, Virendra Kumar another son of the deceased along with other family members arranged to take the deceased for treatment to Barabanki but when they arrived at Safdarganj crossing effort was made to engage a Kharkhara (a cart driven by a horse) but the same could not become available and injured Chandrika Prasad Misra breathed his last at the Safdarganj crossing. Complainant Virendra Kumar left the body of the deceased and other injured family members there and went to the Police Station Jaidpur and lodged first information report at 12.05 hours.

4. Virendra Pratap Singh, P.W 10 Station Officer of the Police Station was present at the time when the first information report was lodged and the case was registered and along with the police force he is said to have immediately left for Safdarganj crossing. The inquest proceedings were duly, taken and the dead body was despatched to the District Hospital for post-mortem examination. After interrogation of the complainant and injured persons the Investigating Officer sent the injured Krishna Kumar, Nirmal Kumar and Ashok Kumar to the Distt. Hospital Barabanki for medical examination and treatment of their injuries. Smt. Dashrath Dei who was advised by the members of the family to go to her house was sent for medical examination on the next day.

5. During the course of investigation the Investigating Officer recovered certain articles from the two wells and Talab near the village Abadi which was allegedly looted away by the culprits and thrown in the wells and the Talab. The articles recovered from the two wells being buckets, Gagras and Lota etc. From the Talab some books and certain quantity of wheat, a piece of lathi and other Misc. small items were recovered. These articles were identified by the complainant to have been looted from their house. According to the statement of Virendra Kumar, vide para 60 thereof, one box was found in a shrub and one transistor and one old coat were found in the box while all the remaining articles kept therein were found to be missing.

6. The evidence on facts of the occurrence consists of the statements of complainant, Virendra Kumar P.W 2 his brother Krishna Kumar injured and his mother Smt. Dashrath Dei injured. These three witnesses belong to the family of the deceased. One independent witness Satendra Bahadur Singh, P.W 1 was also examined but he did not support the prosecution case. According to him he was not present at the time of occurrence. He did not see any part of the occurrence and according to the prosecution he turned hostile.

7. As would appear from the judgment of the learned Sessions Judge, the prosecution evidence was not accepted mainly because of being not consistent with the medical evidence and also because according to the finding of the learned Sessions Judge, the occurrence appeared to be one of dacoity having been committed sometime in the night rather than being a case of murder as set up by the prosecution on the basis of first information report lodged by the complainant being the own son of the deceased. According to the prosecution case the occurrence took place sometime between 7-8 in the morning. The date of occurrence being 15th June even at 7 a.m it was a time after about one and half an hour of the sun rise. The deceased was said to have just returned after attending the call of the nature and was washing his hands and the Lota near the main door of his house. The post-mortem examination report indicates that large intestine of the deceased was full, small intestine was semi-full bladder was also full and stomach was empty. The deceased did not succumb to his injuries just after the attack and according to the prosecution he breathed his last sometime at about 10 a.m The fact, however, remains that according to post-mortem examination report the deceased had not cleared his bowels and normally speaking this contradicts the prosecution case of the deceased having gone to attend the call of the nature and subjected to attack on return. An explanation appears to have been raised on behalf of the prosecution that the deceased was constipated and his bowels had not become clear even when he had gone out in response of the call of the nature, while the possibility of the submission being correct cannot be ruled out, normally speaking it would be taken that there would atleast have been partial evacuation and the position of the intestines would not have been as reflected in the post-mortem examination report. When the large intestine was found to be full and small intestine, semi-full, the probability of deceased having not gone out in response to the call of the nature would be more acceptable. The Investigating Officer could have found the Lota at the spot which was being cleaned by the deceased when he was subjected to attack and the fact that no such Lota was taken in possession also raises a doubt as to the correctness of the prosecution case as to the time of the occurrence.

8. A perusal of the first information report would show that in substance the case set up was one of murder. The culprits having came armed with country made pistol, Kantas, Bhala and Lathis and attacked the deceased while he was at the main door of his house, when the two sons of the deceased tried to save the deceased they too were subjected to attack and acid was thrown in the eyes of Krishna Kumar. The culprits thereafter are said to have entered inside the house and started beating the wife of the deceased who somehow managed to escape and come out of the room. No doubt, it is alleged in the first information report that the culprits started damaging the house hold goods in the house but no allegation was made that the culprits looted away any house-hold goods from the house. On the other hand it was stated that the culprits managed to scope taking that the deceased had breathed his last at the spot. It is only in the oral evidence that the allegation has come that house-hold goods including the valuables had been looted away in this occurrence. Complainant Virendra Kumar in his statement, vide para 42, stated that in this occurrence of murder and looting the family was finished and ornaments and other articles of the house worth hundreds of rupees were looted away, Smt. Dashrat Dei, P.W 6 in her statement vide para 5 thereof, also stated that the culprits not only damaged the household goods but they looted away the same. She even went to the extent of saying that the culprits did not leave any house-hold goods in the house meaning thereby that all worth while household goods had been looted away. It is true that according to the first information report as also the statement of Virendra Kumar and Smt. Dashrath Dei the culprits had damaged the house-hold goods and further that some of the miscellaneous items including some quantity of wheat were found to have been thrown away in well and Talab, nevertheless the culprits are said to have indulged in dacoity and looted away the house hold goods including some oranaments. A reasonable doubt, thus, stands justifiably raised that it was not a case in which the culprits had come with the object of committing the murder of the deceased. If that were the basis intention there were hardly any necessity of the culprits having gone inside the house. The deceased having become available at the main entrance of the house and having been subjected to attack. It is also important that one of the accused having been armed with country made pistol could have easily killed the deceased by shooting him down.

9. If the occurrence took place sometime between 7-8 in the morning the cries of the witnesses would have attracted several persons from the village. In fact, according to the first information and the oral evidence of the prosecution witnesses several persons from the village reached at the spot and saw the occurrence but no one had come forward to save the victim for fear of their own lives. These persons were not named in the first information report. One independent person, namely, Satandra Bahadur Singh was examined but he did not support the prosecution case. It is true that independent witnesses hesitate to come forward to depose about the occurrence more, particularly, when the accused or some of them are residents of the same village, nevertheless it cannot be taken as an absolute rule and the fact that no independent witness has come forward to depose about such a sensational occurrence of day-light is a factor going against the prosecution.

10. Even the testimony of the three witnesses examined is not very inspiring. The conduct of the complainant was found by the learned Sessions Judge to be somewhat unexplainable. He entered the witness-box and just then stated that he was suffering from diarrhoea and pain in abdomen and that he may be allowed to go. This was permitted and he did not return and a bailable warrant of his arrest had to be issued against him and it is then that he was produced to be examined before the learned Sessions Judge. The explanation furnished by the complainant in this regard appears unconvincing. According to him the Assistant Public Prosecutor who was conducting the case on behalf of the State had demanded some money from him and he become somewhat apprehensive as regards the statement of the doctor and that he thought it expedient not to make a statement on that date. The conduct of the complainant in just standing out and in not making any effort to save his father also appears somewhat unnatural.

11. The learned Sessions Judge had made a mention of certain other contradiction also in the oral evidence of the prosecution witnesses. It is, however, not necessary to refer to the same. There exist important facts and circumstances which go to impair the truthfullness of the prosecution case and raise a serious doubt as to the time and nature of the occurrence. What appears more probable is that it was a case of dacoity having been committed during the course of the night. Once a reasonable doubt stands raised as to the nature and time of the occurrence, the prosecution case has necessarily to fall and the benefit of such doubt has naturally to go to the accused persons. The finding recorded and conclusion arrived at by the Learned Sessions Judge cannot in any way be said to be perverse.

12. The well accepted principle of law is that when an accused is acquitted the presumption of his innocence is reinforced by the order of acquittal passed by the trial court who has had the advantage of seeing the witnesses and hearing their evidence. The findings of fact recorded by the trial court can be traversed and the judgment reversed only when there are substantial and compelling reasons. Great weight has to be attached to the view taken by the trial court and the same cannot be reversed unless view adopted in the opinion of the High Court is such which may on the face of it appear to be perverse or nearing perversity. The findings of the learned Sessions Judge in this case cannot be said to suffer from any such defect and as such, there is no force in this State appeal and it is liable to be dismissed. Accordingly the appeal is dismissed.