Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Zonal Chief Engineer... v. Presiding Officer, L...

Allahabad High Court
Jun 12, 2001
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.

1. This petition under Art. 226 of the Constitution of India by the petitioner — Zonal Chief Engineer, Uttar Pradesh Jal Nigam Gorakhpur, challenges the award of the Labour Court, Gorakhpur, in Adjudication Case No. 256 of 1984. Respondent 2 Jayant Kumar Misra referred to as workman, filed his written statement pursuant to the reference by the State Government as to whether the employers in terminating the services of respondent 2 workman with effect from 1 May 1982 is legal and justified, if not to what relief the workman is entitled.

2. The petitioner as well as respondent No. 1 filed their written statements before the Labour Court. The case set up by respondent-workman was that he was appointed on the post of Operator with effect from 11 July 1979 by Executive Engineer, Uttar Pradesh Jal Nigam, Gorakhpur, and was posted at Pumping Station Jal Nigam, Elahibagh, Gorakhpur, and since then he was in continuous service and at the time of termination of his service, he is drawing wages at the rate of Rs. 324 per month and was lastly posted at Nautanwa Drinking Water project. The employers have illegally dismissed him from service with effect from 30 April 1982 without giving him any opportunity for submitting his explanation. He further stated that due to illness of his wife he submitted the application for leave on 4 April 1982 and left the working place. On that very day the Superintending Engineer made a surprise inspection and found the workman concerned absent. The services of the respondent-workman were terminated with effect from 1 May 1982, which is wholly illegal as the workman concerned was not given any opportunity for hearing. The employers in their written statement denied the case set up by the workman concerned. The employers' case is that the workman was appointed on the post of operator on 11 July 1979. His appointment was purely as daily-wager and he was not given any letter of appointment. Since the work for which the workman was appointed as daily-wager, came to an end, the requirement of the workman was no more in the department and therefore, his services were terminated. His daily-wager appointment was terminated on 1 May 1982. The employer further states that in fact the workman was posted as chaukidar and he was found absent from his duty by the higher authority, but since he was only a daily-wager, his services were terminated as no longer required. He was not a permanent employee. Therefore, he was not given any opportunity before terminating his services. The employer also set up his case that Jal Nigam is not an industry as defined under Uttar Pradesh Industrial Disputes Act. Therefore, the reference is not in accordance with law. The Labour Court has found that Jal Nigam is an industry and therefore the dispute was rightly referred to the Labour Court. Since it is no more in doubt that Jal Nigam is covered by the definition of industry, this question has not been disputed by the petitioner. So far as the merit of the case is concerned, it is admitted case of the parties that before terminating the services of the workman concerned, no domestic enquiry was conducted nor any opportunity was given to the workman concerned for submitting his defence. In reply to this, the employers have stated that the services have been terminated by a simple order of termination and the workman was only a daily-wager. Therefore it was not necessary to give him an opportunity. However it is admitted by the workman concerned that petitioner's services were terminated because he was found absent without leave. It is settled by the Apex Court that the termination whatever form it may be, is covered by the definition of retrenchment under the provisions of Uttar Pradesh Industrial Disputes Act. Therefore, it was incumbent on the part of the employers to follow the provisions of S. 6-N of the Uttar Pradesh Industrial Disputes Act before terminating the services of respondent-workman. Counsel for the petitioner has relied on two decisions one of Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of “Himanshu Kumar Vidyarthi v. State of Bihar [1997 (2) L.L.N 982] and another decision of the Single Judge of this Court in the case of Channey Lal v. Director, Malaria Research Centre, New Delhi [1999 (82) F.L.R 76], wherein the Apex Court as well as this Court has found that provision of S. 6-N, which is pari materia to the provisions of S. 25-F of the Industrial Disputes Act need not be observed while terminating the services of a daily-wager as a daily-wager employee has no right to the post. Learned counsel for the petitioner has accepted the concept of the daily-wager that he is an employee for a fixed term. That the contract of the employment begins with the day and ends at the end of toe day automatically and therefore, for this reason also the daily-wager is covered by the exception of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947. Exception, which is an excuse as to what would not amount to retrench within the meaning of the words used under the Act. That one more decision is relied upon by the learned counsel for the petitioner in the case of Municipal Committee, Tauru v. Harpal Singh [1998 (80) F.L.R 680], wherein the Hon'ble Supreme Court has held that in case of the inconsistent statement with regard to the claim by the workman, the Labour Court cannot justify in granting any relief ignoring the inconsistency in claim on the ground of substantial justice. Here in this case the workman has set up the case that he was appointed as operator and was working at the relevant time at Nautanwa Drinking Water Scheme, when on hearing his wife's illness, he has submitted his application for leave and left the place without even waiting for the result of the application nor could be any time thereafter to ascertain as to whether the leave has been sanctioned or not. When the employer's case was set up that on the same day on inspection by the Superintending Engineer the concerned workman was found absent from the place of posting. That before terminating his services, he was not afforded any opportunity. The fact that he found absent, has not been denied rather admitted and justified by the workman and he states that on hearing the illness of his wife, he proceeded on leave after submitting an application. In these circumstances and by the law laid down by the Apex Court and the learned Single Judge of this Court to which I also agree. I found that the view taken by the Labour Court in holding that since the services of the concerned workman have been terminated without complying of the provisions of S. 6-N of the Uttar Pradesh Industrial Disputes Act which is pari materia to S. 25-F of the Industrial Disputes Act and that being the position, the termination is held to be illegal and reinstatement with continuity of service has been granted by the Labour Court. I am of the view that the relief granted by the Labour Court is contrary to the law laid down by the Apex Court and followed by this Court. In the facts and the circumstances of the case the relief granted by the Labour Court for reinstatement of workman with continuity of service, with back-wages is not justified. The award of the Labour Court Annexure IV to the writ petition deserves to be quashed and is hereby quashed.

3. In view of what has been stated above, the award of the Labour Court is modified to this extent that the workman is not entitled for any relief as held by the Apex Court, in view of inconsistent stand taken by the workman, the workman is not entitled for any relief. In the facts and the circumstances of the case, there will be no order as to costs.