- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Mahesh Prasad Kannaujiya v. State Of U.P
Factual and Procedural Background
The applicant challenged an order dated 28-4-2009 and an impugned notice dated 27-3-2009 issued by the Deputy Magistrate, Gola, Gorakhpur in the matter titled State v. Mahesh Prasad Kannaujiya. The present opinion records that learned counsel for the applicant was heard and that the learned Additional Government Advocate appeared for the State. The applicant sought setting aside of the order and notice on the ground that the notice under Section 110/111 Cr.P.C. was defective.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether a notice under Section 110/111 Cr.P.C. can be issued by an Executive Magistrate on a printed pro forma (cyclo-style) that merely fills in the name and particulars without recording the substance of material allegations received against the person.
- Whether the notice must specify the substance of the allegations so as to satisfy principles of natural justice and permit an effective reply by the person served.
Arguments of the Parties
Applicant's Arguments
- The applicant relied on the judgments Lola alias Manish Dhar Dubey alias Babloo v. State of U.P (2009 (2) ADJ 525) and Har Charan v. State Of U.P & Anr. (2008 (2) JIC 418; 2008 (4) ALJ 122) to contend that a notice under Section 110/111 Cr.P.C. can be issued by an Executive Magistrate only after recording the substance of the general nature of material allegations brought to his notice.
- It was submitted that a notice under Section 110 Cr.P.C. should not be issued on printed pro formas by merely filling in names and then attaching general allegations, because such notices do not inform the person of the substance of allegations sufficiently to enable an effective reply.
The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the State's legal arguments.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Lola alias Manish Dhar Dubey alias Babloo v. State of U.P 2009 (2) ADJ 525 | That a notice under Section 110/111 Cr.P.C. can be given by the Executive Magistrate only after recording the substance of general nature of material allegations brought to his notice. | The court relied on this authority to support the requirement that the notice must contain substance of the allegations and not be a blank pro forma. |
| Har Charan v. State Of U.P & Anr., 2008 (2) JIC 418; (2008 (4) ALJ 122 | That the notice under Section 110 Cr.P.C. should not be given on printed pro formas by filling in names followed by allegations which are general in nature. | The court applied this principle to hold the cyclo-style pro forma notice defective for lacking particulars necessary for a meaningful reply. |
| Gopalachari v. State of Kerala, 1980 Supp SCC 649 : AIR 1981 SC 674 | The Supreme Court stressed specificity of facts in Section 110 cases, warned against lax use of terms like "by habit", and emphasised that preventive sections affecting liberty require responsible judicial exercise and specificity to avoid being void. | The court invoked the passage (para 6) to underline the need for specificity of facts and to require that the magistrate's notice disclose the substance of the information so as to protect the person's right to be heard and to ensure orders are not made on indolent or ritualistic processes. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court examined the form and content of the notice dated 27-3-2009 and found it to be a "cyclo style pro forma" in which the Sub Divisional Magistrate had merely filled in the name and particulars of the applicant without setting out the substance of the allegations received against him. The court analysed Section 110 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, noting that it provides for taking security for good behaviour from habitual offenders upon information received by the Executive Magistrate of habitual commission of specified offences (clauses (b) to (g) of Section 110).
The court reasoned that a notice under Section 110 can only be issued after the magistrate has received information as to the person's criminal activity and that the notice must convey the substance of the particulars of habitual offences so that the person can reply effectively. Emphasising principles of natural justice, the court stated that a person must be informed of the allegations against him before any adverse order is passed and must be given a fair and reasonable opportunity to explain inaccuracies in the information.
The court relied on the Supreme Court's observation in Gopalachari v. State of Kerala that expressions such as "by habit" and "habitual" cannot be used loosely and that courts must insist on specificity of facts; preventive provisions affecting personal liberty demand careful judicial scrutiny and not ritualistic or indolent processes. On that basis the court held that a person is not required to reply to general and vague allegations printed on a pro forma sheet and that initiation of proceedings under Section 110 can only be legitimate when the notice contains the substance of the information that authorises such an order.
Holding and Implications
Holding: The Criminal Miscellaneous Application was allowed. The orders dated 28-4-2009 and 27-3-2009 were set aside.
Implications: The direct effect is that the impugned notice and subsequent order are quashed and the applicant is relieved of any consequences stemming from those specific actions. The court granted liberty to the Executive Magistrate to initiate proceedings afresh in accordance with law (i.e., after recording and communicating the substance of the information as required). The opinion does not purport to lay down a broader new precedent beyond applying the cited authorities to the facts of this case.
1. Heard learned counsel for the applicant. Learned AGA appears for the State.
2. The applicant has prayed for setting aside the order dated 28-4-2009 and impugned notice dated 27-3-2009 passed by Dy. Magistrate, Gola, Gorakhpur State v. Mahesh Prasad Kannaujiya.
3. It is contended by learned counsel for the petitioner relying upon the judgment in Lola alias Manish Dhar Dubey alias Babloo v. State of U.P 2009 (2) ADJ 525 and Har Charan v. State Of U.P & Anr., 2008 (2) JIC 418; (2008 (4) ALJ 122) that a notice under Section 110/111 Cr.P.C can be given by the Executive Magistrate only after recording the substance of general nature of material allegations brought to his notice. The notice under Section 110 Cr. P.C should not be given on printed pro formas by filling in names of the persons to whom notices are given in the blank columns followed by allegations, which are general in nature.
4. The notice was given to the applicant on a cyclo style pro forma in which the Sub Divisional Magistrate has simply filled in the name and particulars of the applicant. It does not give substance of the allegations received against the petitioner so that the petitioner may give an effective reply to the notice.
5. Section 110 of the Code of Criminal Procedure provides for security for good behaviour to be taken from habitual offenders. On an information received by the Executive Magistrate that there is within his local jurisdiction a person who is by habit a robber, house-breaker, thief or forger, or falls in any other categories for habitually committing crimes in clauses (b) to (g) of Section 110, a Magistrate may in a manner provided in Section 111 to 124 require such person to show cause, to execute a bond with such sureties for such good behaviour for a period not exceeding three years, as the Magistrate may think fit.
6. A Magistrate is empowered to give notice under Section 110 of the Code of Criminal Procedure only after he has received the information with regard to the criminal activity of a habitual offender. The notice must give substance of the particulars of the habitual offences committed by the person, so that persons may be able to reply the same. The principles of natural justice require a person to be informed with the allegations against him, before any adverse order is made. He should get a fair and reasonable opportunity to reply to the Magistrate and to explain if the information against him is not correct. In Gopalachari v. State of Kerala, 1980 Supp SCC 649 : AIR 1981 SC 674 the Supreme Court observed in para 6:
“In cases under S. 110 of the Code, the exercise is often an idle ritual deprived of reality although a man's liberty is at stake. We direct the trial magistrates to discharge their duties, when trying cases under S. 110, with great responsibility and whenever the counter-petitioner is a prisoner give him the facility of being defended by counsel now that Art. 21 has been reinforced by Art. 39A. Otherwise the order to bind over will be bad and void. We have not the slightest doubt that expressions like ‘by habit’, ‘habitual’, ‘desperate’, ‘dangerous’, ‘hazardous’ cannot be flung in the face of a man with laxity of semantics. The Court must insist on specificity of facts and be satisfied that one swallow does not make a summer and a consistent course of conduct convincing enough to draw the rigorous inference that by confirmed habit, which is second nature, the counter-petitioner is sure to commit the offences mentioned if he is not kept captive. Preventive sections privative of freedom, if incautiously proved by indolent judicial processes, may do deeper injury.”
7. A person is not required to give reply to the general and vague allegations, which are printed on a cyclo style sheet. The object of initiating proceedings can be met only after notice is given with the substance of the information received by the Magistrate and which may give him authority in law to make an order for giving security for good behaviour.
8. The Criminal Misc. Application is allowed. The orders dated 28-4-2009 and 27-3-2009 are set aside, with liberty to the Executive Magistrate to initiate proceedings afresh in accordance with law.
9. Application allowed.
Alert