- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Raj Narain And Others v. Deputy Director Of Consolidation, Ghazipur And Others
Structured Summary of Judgment — Prakash Krishna, J.
Factual and Procedural Background
The petitioner approached the court by way of a writ petition seeking certiorari to quash two orders of the Deputy Director of Consolidation, Ghazipur:
- The order dated 30.4.1997 by which Revision Nos. 15/17/15/328 were allowed; and
- The order dated 14.6.1999 by which the petitioner's recall application was dismissed.
Background: Against an order dated 23.8.1977 of the Settlement Officer of Consolidation, the contesting respondents No. 2 and 3 filed the revision under section 48 of the U.P. Consolidation of Holdings Act before the Deputy Director of Consolidation. The revision was allowed on 30.4.1997. The petitioner filed an application to recall that order on the ground that one of the opposite parties in the revision, Sakal Deo, had died on 4.7.1996 and his heirs were not impleaded before the revision was heard and decided. The recall application was dismissed by the Deputy Director on 14.6.1999, following which the present writ petition was filed.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the revision could validly be heard and decided after the death of a party (Sakal Deo) without the substitution/impleading of his heirs.
- Whether the Deputy Director of Consolidation was justified in dismissing the petitioner's recall application seeking to set aside the revision on the ground that heirs of the deceased were not substituted.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioner's Arguments
- The petitioner contended that one of the opposite parties in the revision, Sakal Deo, had died on 4.7.1996.
- The petitioner argued that because the deceased's heirs were not impleaded/substituted, the revision ought not to have been heard and decided on merits and thus the recall application should have been allowed.
Respondents' Arguments
- The respondents' counsel submitted that the sons of the deceased, Sakal Deo, participated in the revision proceedings and had full knowledge about the revision, and on that basis supported the impugned order.
Table of Precedents Cited
No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court proceeded by first recording that it was not disputed that Sakal Deo had died on 4.7.1996 and that the revision was decided after that date. The respondents' contention that the sons of the deceased participated in proceedings was noted by the court.
The court evaluated the respondents' contention and rejected it for the following reasons (expressed in the opinion):
- The heirs of Sakal Deo had not been formally substituted in the revision proceedings; substitution had not been carried out by following the proper procedure.
- The factual finding that the sons participated was characterized by the court as an "irrelevant consideration" in the absence of formal substitution — i.e., mere participation, without compliance with procedure to substitute heirs, could not validate continuation of the revision in the deceased party's absence.
- Given the failure to follow the substitution procedure, the Deputy Director of Consolidation was not justified in rejecting the petitioner's recall application.
- In the interest of justice, the court concluded that the dispute should be resolved after giving adequate opportunity to the parties (which requires proper substitution of heirs and fresh adjudication of the revision).
Holding and Implications
Holding: The court set aside the order dated 30.4.1997 (allowing the revision) and the order dated 14.6.1999 (dismissing the recall application). The writ petition was allowed.
Direct consequences and directions:
- The matter was restored to its original number and the Deputy Director of Consolidation was directed to hear and decide the revision afresh after giving an opportunity of hearing to the petitioners.
- By way of clarification, the court ordered that no further notice was required to be given to the petitioners; they were required to appear before the Deputy Director of Consolidation on 12.1.2009 along with a certified copy of this order.
- The authority concerned was directed to fix a date for hearing thereafter, and the Deputy Director was advised to endeavour to decide the revision preferably within a period of six months from the date of production of a certified copy of the order.
Implications beyond the parties: The opinion does not assert or announce any broader precedent; it addresses the specific procedural deficiency (failure to substitute heirs and follow substitution procedure) and directs fresh adjudication. No new precedent was expressly stated in the text.
Prakash Krishna, J.:— By means of the present writ petition, the petitioner has sought a writ of certiorari for quashing the orders dated 30.4.1997 and 14.6.1999 passed by the Deputy Director of Consolidation, Ghazipur whereby and where under he has allowed Revision Nos. 15/17/15/328 on 30.4.1997 and dismissed the recall application filed by the petitioner on 14.6.1999 It appears that against the order dated 23.8.1977 passed by the Settlement Officer of Consolidation, the contesting respondents No. 2 and 3 filed the aforesaid revision under section 48 of U.P Consolidation of Holdings Act before the Deputy Director of Consolidation. The said revision was allowed on 30.4.1997 Thereafter an application to recall the said order was filed on the ground that one of the opposite parties i.e Sakal Deo in the revision has died on 4.7.1996 and as such without impleading his heirs, the revision could not have been heard and decided on merits. The said application having been dismissed by the order dated 14.6.1999, the present writ petition has been filed.
2. Heard the Counsel for the parties and perused the record.
3. It was not disputed before me that Sakal Deo one of the opposite party in the revision expired on 4.7.1996 and the revision was decided subsequently.
4. The learned Counsel for the respondents submits that sons of Sakal Deo participated in the proceedings and they had full knowledge about the revision. On this basis, he supports the impugned order.
5. I have given careful consideration to the aforesaid submissions, but it is difficult to agree with him. The fact remains that the heirs of Sakal Deo were not substituted in the revision. The finding that sons of Sakal Deo participated in the proceeding is based on irrelevant consideration and proper procedure which is required to be followed to substitute the heirs of a deceased was indisputably not followed in the revision.
6. In this view of the matter, the Deputy Director of Consolidation was not justified in rejecting the recall application filed by the petitioner by the impugned order. The interest of justice also demands that the dispute should be settled between the parties after giving adequate opportunity to them.
7. In view of above discussion, the order dated 30.4.1997 allowing the revision and the order dated 14.6.1999 dismissing the recall application are hereby set aside. The matter is restored to its original number. The Deputy Director of Consolidation shall hear and decide the revision afresh after giving an opportunity of hearing to the petitioners. By way of clarification, it is added that no further notice is required to be given to the petitioners and they are required to appear before the Deputy Director of Consolidation on 12.1.2009 along with a certified copy of this order. The authority concerned shall fix a date for the hearing of the revision thereafter.
8. With the aforesaid direction, the writ petition succeeds and is allowed. The Deputy Director of Consolidation shall make an endeavour to hear and decide the revision afresh preferably within a period of six month from the date of production of a certified copy of this order.
9. Petition Allowed.
Alert