Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Mani Ram & Ors. v. State Of U.P & Ors.

Allahabad High Court
Sep 26, 2008
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Court Opinion Summary — Tarun Agarwala, J.

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner purchased a 250 square metre plot in Civil Lines, Jhansi by a registered sale-deed dated 3.3.2004. Stamp duty was paid at the rate of Rs. 5,000 per square metre treating the plot as residential; the sale-deed recorded Rs. 1,26,000 as stamp duty and Rs. 5,000 as registration charges. A complaint led to an enquiry report by the Deputy Inspector General (Stamps) dated 29.3.2004 stating that the plot was surrounded by commercial buildings near "Elite crossing" and had a potential value of Rs. 10,000 per square metre.

On that basis, the Collector, Jhansi initiated proceedings under Section 47A of the Indian Stamp Act and, by order dated 17.7.2006, assessed the land at Rs. 25,10,000, found a deficiency of stamp duty (assessed duty Rs. 2,51,000) and directed the petitioner to pay the deficiency of Rs. 1,25,000 and imposed an equal amount as penalty.

The petitioner objected, filed documentary evidence (sale-deeds of adjoining areas as exemplars, circle rate, master plan showing bazaar street limits) and contended the land was residential. The petitioner filed a revision under Section 56(1) of the Stamp Act; the revisional authority directed deposit of the full amount, and the petitioner deposited Rs. 3,27,300 on 20.7.2007 (this included a total of Rs. 2,50,000 for deficiency and penalty and interest of Rs. 77,300 at 18% p.a.).

During the revision, the A.D.M. (F. & R.) conducted a spot inspection and reported the Collector's circle rates for the area (Rs. 6,000 up to 50 metres; Rs. 5,000 between 50 and 150 metres; Rs. 4,000 beyond 150 metres) and indicated the plot was approximately 119 metres from the main road. The Commissioner, however, relied upon the earlier DIG (Stamps) report and affirmed the Collector's order by order dated 29.11.2007, rejecting the petitioner's revision. The petitioner then filed the present writ petition under Article 226 of the Constitution.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Collector's order dated 17.7.2006 (proceedings under Section 47A of the Indian Stamp Act) assessing deficiency of stamp duty and imposing penalty was legally valid.
  2. Whether the revisional order dated 29.11.2007 (under Section 56(1) of the Stamp Act) affirming the Collector's order was sustainable, particularly insofar as the revisional authority relied on an earlier DIG (Stamps) report and did not consider the A.D.M.'s spot inspection report.
  3. Whether the authorities were justified in treating the plot as commercial land (assessing market value at Rs. 10,000 per sq. m.) rather than residential land using circle rates/master plan and whether imposition of penalty for suppression was warranted.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments (learned counsel Smt. Rama Goyal)

  • The stamp duty was paid according to the prescribed residential rate of Rs. 5,000 per square metre and the land was a residential plot purchased for residential purposes.
  • The petitioner produced exemplars (sale-deeds of adjoining areas), circle rate, and the master plan showing bazaar street limits; these materials were not considered by the authorities.
  • The A.D.M.'s inspection report (dated 1.10.2007) showing the plot approximately 119 metres from the main road and circle rates applicable (Rs. 5,000 per sq. m. for 50–150 metres) was ignored by the revisional authority.
  • Under the master plan the bazaar street is defined up to 30 metres from the main road; the petitioner’s plot is beyond 30 metres and therefore cannot be treated as commercial land.
  • The DIG (Stamps) report and the valuation of Rs. 10,000 per sq. m. were based on surmise and conjecture and amounted to manifest error.

Respondent's Arguments (learned standing counsel Sri R. K. Chaubey for State of U.P.)

  • The authorities correctly relied upon the DIG (Stamps) report dated 29.3.2004 which was made after inspection in the presence of the petitioner.
  • Given the location in Civil Lines and that the plot was surrounded by commercial buildings, the authorities rightly treated the plot as having commercial potential and assessed market value accordingly.
  • The impugned orders were based on findings of fact following investigation and therefore should not be interfered with in writ jurisdiction under Article 226 of the Constitution of India.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
R. C. Bansal v. District Magistrate, AIR 1999 SC 2126 Circle rates are mere guidelines and prima facie give the rate of the area concerned. The Court used this to hold that circle rates do not definitively indicate market value but only provide an approximate guideline.
State of Punjab v. Mahabir Singh, AIR 1996 SC 2994 Reiteration that circle rates are guidelines (similar view to R.C. Bansal). Served to reinforce the principle that circle rates are not definitive proof of market value.
M/s. Maya Food v. C.C.R.A., 1999 RJ 619 (1998 (4) AWC 636) Market value cannot be determined with reference to the buyer's intended use; only potential value as on the date of sale can be taken into account (not future potential). The Court relied on this to reject valuing the land based on speculative or future commercial potential beyond the date of sale.
Shakumbari Sugar and Allied Industries Ltd. v. State of U.P., 2007 (102) RD 842 (2007 (3) AWC 2769) Consistent view on valuation principles and limits on relying upon potential/future use for market value. Cited as supportive authority for restricting valuation to existing market value as on the date of sale.
Smt. Sushila Verma v. State of U.P. and others, 2006 (2) AWC 1492 Similar view regarding determination of market value (restricting to existing value). Used to support the proposition that potential future use cannot determine present market value.
Ram Khilawan v. State of U.P., 2005 (98) RD 511 (2005 (2) AWC 1087) An ex parte inspection report may initiate proceedings under Section 47A but cannot be relied upon thereafter; inspection for valuation must be made by the Collector (or authority hearing the case) after due notice; inspection report should show distances and include sketch map where possible. The Court applied this to hold the DIG (Stamps) report (an earlier ex parte report) was insufficient to form the basis of valuation and could not replace an inspection/report made in the course of the enquiry under Rule 7.
Vijay Kumar & others v. Commissioner, Meerut Division, Meerut and another, 2008 (7) ADJ 293 (2008 (3) AWC 2997) Burden to prove that market value exceeds the minimum fixed by the Collector lies on the State; a mere approximate value report is insufficient. The Court relied on this to require the State to produce concrete evidence beyond an approximate report to justify higher valuation.
Adarsh Kumar & others v. State of U.P. and others, 2007 (7) ADJ 786 (2007 (4) AWC 3458) (As cited by State) — specific principle not detailed in the opinion text. The Court found this judgment inapplicable to the facts of the present case.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court examined the statutory framework (Section 47A of the Indian Stamp Act and Rule 7 of the Uttar Pradesh Stamp (Valuation of Property) Rules, 1997) and the evidence placed before the authorities. Rule 7 requires an enquiry and permits the Collector to admit evidence and inspect the property after due notice; however, the rules do not prescribe a specific method of holding the inquiry, so general principles of valuation apply.

The Court observed that the authorities primarily relied upon a DIG (Stamps) report dated 29.3.2004 which predated initiation of proceedings under Section 47A and which only gave an approximate valuation of Rs. 10,000 per square metre. The Court treated that report as suitable to initiate proceedings but not as a substitute for the enquiry and inspection mandated by Rule 7. Citing Ram Khilawan, the Court noted that an ex parte report may initiate proceedings but cannot be relied upon for final valuation; an inspection by the Collector or the authority hearing the case after notice is required, with details such as distance and sketch maps where possible.

The A.D.M.'s spot inspection report (dated 1.10.2007) indicated applicable circle rates set by the Collector: Rs. 6,000 per sq. m. up to 50 metres from the main road, Rs. 5,000 per sq. m. from 50 to 150 metres, and Rs. 4,000 beyond 150 metres; the plot was approximately 119 metres from the main road. The petitioner had paid stamp duty at Rs. 5,000 per sq. m. The Court found that the revisional authority and the Commissioner ignored this report and incorrectly relied on the earlier DIG report.

On valuation principles the Court reiterated established authorities (R.C. Bansal; State of Punjab v. Mahabir Singh) that circle rates are guidelines and do not by themselves conclusively determine market value. The Court also applied authorities (M/s. Maya Food and others) holding that market value must be assessed by reference to the state and potential of the land as on the date of sale, not by speculative future uses. The Court emphasized that the Stamp Act is a fiscal statute to be interpreted strictly and literally; there is no room for presumptions, approximations or reliance on future potential when assessing market value for stamp duty purposes.

Applying these principles to the facts, the Court concluded that the Collector's and revisional authority's valuation at Rs. 10,000 per sq. m. was based on presumption and was contrary to the material evidence (the A.D.M.'s report and the master plan extract). The Court further held that mere proximity to commercial buildings did not convert residential land into commercial land unless the use had been converted in the master plan under the U.P. Urban Development and Planning Act, 1973; the master plan extract showed bazaar street limited to 30 metres and the petitioner's land was beyond 30 metres.

The Court therefore found the assessment of deficiency and the imposition of penalty to be patently illegal and without jurisdiction, quashed the impugned orders and allowed the writ petition. Regarding amounts already deposited by the petitioner (Rs. 3,27,300), the Court directed refund with interest.

Holding and Implications

Core Ruling: The writ petition is allowed and the impugned orders (Collector's order dated 17.7.2006 and the revisional order dated 29.11.2007) are quashed.

Direct consequences for the parties:

  • The imposition of the deficiency stamp duty and the pari materia penalty was held illegal and without jurisdiction and cannot be sustained.
  • The petitioner is entitled to a refund of the amount deposited (Rs. 3,27,300) together with interest at the rate of 18% per annum calculated from the date of deposit until actual payment by the authority. The refund is to be made within six weeks from the date of presentation of the certified copy of the Court's order before the Collector.

Broader implications: The opinion reiterates established principles on valuation under Section 47A and Rule 7 — that ex parte or pre-initiation reports cannot replace formal enquiry and inspection after notice, circle rates are only guidelines, and potential future use cannot determine present market value. The Court did not purport to lay down a novel legal precedent beyond applying these established principles to the facts; no new doctrine was announced in this order.


Judge: Tarun Agarwala, J. — Opinion contains the court's analysis, citations and directions as set out above.

Show all summary ...

Tarun Agarwala, J.-

Heard Smt. Rama Goyal, the learned counsel for the petitioner and Sri R. K. Chaubey, the learned standing counsel for the State of U.P.

2. The petitioner has challenged the validity and legality of the order dated 17.7.2006 passed by the Collector Jhansi, whereby deficiency of stamp duty and penalty has been imposed under section 47a of the stamp act. The petitioner has also challenged the order dated 29.11.2007 whereby the revision of the petitioner has been rejected by the Commissioner, Jhansi Division, Jhansi under Section 56 (1) of the Stamp Act.

3. The facts leading to the filing of the present writ petition is, that the petitioner had purchased 250 square metre of land vide a registered sale-deed dated 3.3.2004 which was located in Civil Lines, Jhansi. The stamp duty was paid at the rate of Rs. 5,000 per square metre treating it to be a residential plot. The sale-deed records that Rs. 1,26,000 was paid towards stamp duty and Rs. 5,000 was paid towards registration charges. It transpires that a complaint was made and, on that basis, an enquiry report was submitted by the Deputy Inspector General (Stamps) stating therein that the plot in question was located and surrounded by commercial buildings near the "Elite crossing" in Jhansi and that the land had a potential value of Rs. 10,000 per square metre. On the basis of this report, the Collector initiated proceedings under section 47a of the stamp act.

4. The petitioner filed his objections stating therein that the stamp duty was paid on the basis of the prescribed rate of Rs. 5,000 per square metre and that the land in question was a residential land and that it was purchased for residential purposes. The petitioner also filed evidence namely, sale-deeds of adjoining areas by way of exemplar and also filed the circle rate as well as the master plan of the city of Jhansi showing the length of a bazaar street.

5. The Collector without considering the circle rate and other evidence filed by the petitioner relied upon the report of the Deputy Inspector General dated 29.3.2004 and held that there was a deficiency of stamp duty and that the petitioner had concealed material facts. The authority found that the land in question was surrounded by commercial buildings and that it was 116 metres from the main road of "Elite crossing" in Civil Lines, Jhansi, and therefore, the land in question had a potential value of Rs. 10,000 per square metre and, accordingly, assessed the value of the land at Rs. 25,10,000 and held that Rs. 2,51,000 was payable towards stamp duty. The authority found that only Rs. 1,25,000 was paid as stamp duty, and accordingly, by its order, directed the petitioner to pay the deficiency of stamp duty amounting to Rs. 1,25,000 and also imposed a similar amount towards penalty.

6. The petitioner, being aggrieved by the said order, filed a revision under Section 56 (1) of the Act along with a stay application. It transpires that the revisional authority directed the petitioner to deposit the entire amount and, based on the said direction, the petitioner deposited a sum of Rs. 3,27,300 on 20.7.2007 which included deficiency of stamp duty and penalty amounting to Rs. 2,50,000 and interest at the rate of 18% per annum amounting to Rs. 77,300.

7. The revisional authority, during its pendency of the revision, directed the A.D.M. (F. & R.) to make a spot inspection and submit a report which was submitted in which it was indicated that the circle rate of that area was Rs. 6,000 per square metre upto 50 metres from the main road; Rs. 5,000 per sq. metre between 50 metres to 150 metres and, beyond 150 metres, the rate was Rs. 4,000 per square metre. The A.D.M. further reported that the plot-in-question was approximately 119 metres from the main road. The Commissioner, without considering this report, has relied upon the report of the Deputy Inspector General (Stamps) dated 29.3.2004 and affirmed the order of the Collector and rejected the revision of the petitioner. The petitioner, being aggrieved by the aforesaid order, has filed the present writ petition.

8. The learned counsel for the petitioner submitted that the authorities committed a manifest error in relying upon the report dated 29.3.2004 and had committed an error in treating the land to be of commercial value and that the valuation assessed by the authorities at Rs. 10,000 per square metre was purely based on surmises and conjectures. The learned counsel further submitted that the petitioner had filed sale-deeds by way of exemplars of the land in the vicinity of the plot in question which had not been considered. Further, the report of the A.D.M. dated 1.10.2007 had not been considered by the revisional authority. The learned counsel further stated that under the master plan, the bazaar street has been defined to be till 30 metres from the main road whereas, the petitioner's land is located 119 metres from the main road, and therefore, the said plot could not be treated to be a commercial land and that the land has to be assessed on the basis of the market value of the land for residential plots.

9. On the other hand, the learned standing counsel submitted that the authorities had rightly relied upon the report dated 29.3.2004 which was made pursuant to an inspection in the presence of the petitioner and that the authorities were justified in imposing a deficiency of stamp duty treating the plot as commercial land since it was located in Civil Lines and was surrounded by commercial buildings. The learned counsel further submitted that the land in question had a potential value for commercial purposes, and therefore, the value of commercial land was assessed. The learned standing counsel submitted that after investigation, the impugned orders were passed, which were based on findings of fact and therefore, the impugned orders should not be interfered in a writ jurisdiction under Article 226 of the Constitution of India.

10. Before proceeding further, it would be appropriate to consider the provision of Section 47A of the Indian Stamp Act as applicable in the State of U.P. which is quoted hereunder:

"47A. Under-valuation of instrument.-[(1) (a) If the market value of any property, which is the subject of any instrument, on which duty is chargeable on the market value of the property, as set forth in such instrument is less than even the minimum value determined in accordance with the rules made under this Act, the registering officer appointed under the Registration Act, 1908, shall, notwithstanding anything contained in the said Act, immediately after presentation of such instrument, and before accepting it for registration and taking any action under Section 52 of the said Act, require the person liable to pay stamp duty under Section 29, to pay the deficit stamp duty as computed on the basis of minimum value determined in accordance with the said rules and return the instrument for presenting again in accordance with Section 23 of the Registration Act, 1908.

(b) When the deficit stamp duty required to be paid under Clause (a), is paid in respect of any instrument and the instrument is presented again for registration, the registering officer shall certify by endorsement thereon, that the deficit stamp duty has been paid in respect thereof and the name and the residence of the person paying them and register the same.

(c) Notwithstanding anything contained in any other provisions of this Act, the deficit stamp duty may be paid under Clause (a) in the form of impressed stamps containing such declaration as may be prescribed.

(d) If any person does not make the payment of deficit stamp duty after receiving the order referred to in Clause (a) and presents the instrument again for registration, the registering officer shall, before registering the instrument refer the same to the Collector for determination of market value of the property and the proper duty payable thereon.]

(2) On receipt of a reference under sub-section (1), the Collector shall, after giving the parties a reasonable opportunity of being heard, and after holding an inquiry in such manner as may be prescribed by rules made under this Act, determine the market value of the property which is the subject of such instrument, and the proper duty payable thereon.

(3) The Collector may, suo motu, on a reference from any Court or from the Commissioner of Stamps, or an Additional Commissioner of Stamps or a Deputy Commissioner of Stamps or an Assistant Commissioner of Stamps or any officer authorised by the State Government in that behalf, within four years from the date of registration of any instrument, on which duty is chargeable on the market value of the property not already referred to him under sub-section (1), call for and examine the instrument for the purpose of satisfying himself as to the correctness of the market value of the property, which is the subject of such instrument, and the duty payable thereon, and if after such examination he has reason to believe that the market value of such property has not been truly set forth in such instrument, he may determine the market value of such property and the duty payable thereon:

Provided that, with the prior permission of the State Government an action under this sub-section may be taken after a period of four years but before a period of eight years from the date of registration of the instrument on which duty is chargeable on the market value of the property.

[Explanation.-The payment of deficit stamp duty by any person under any order of the registering officer under sub-section (1) shall not prevent the Collector from initiating proceedings on any instrument under sub-section (3)]

(4) If on enquiry under sub­section (2) and examination under sub-section (3), the Collector finds the market value of the property-

(i) truly set forth and the instrument duly stamped, he shall certify by endorsement that it is duly stamped and return it to the person who made the reference;

(ii) not truly set forth and the instrument not duly stamped, he shall require the payment of proper duty or the amount required to make up the deficiency in the same, together with a penalty of an amount not exceeding four times the amount of the proper duty or the deficient portion thereof.

[(4A)] The Collector shall also require along with the deficit stamp duty or penalty required to be paid under Clause (ii) of sub­section (4), the payment of a simple interest at the rate of one and half per cent per mensem on the amount of deficit stamp duty calculated from the date of the execution of the instrument till the date of actual payment:

Provided that the amount of interest under this sub-section shall be recalculated if the amount of deficit stamp duty is varied on appeal or revision or by any order of a competent court or authority.

(4B) The amount of interest payable under sub-section (4A) shall be added to the amount due and be also deemed for all purposes to be part of the amount required to be paid.

(4C) Where realisation of the deficit stamp duty remained stayed by any order of any court or authority and such order of stay is subsequently vacated, the interest referred to in sub-section (4A) shall be payable also for any period during which such order of stay remained in operation.

(4D) Any amount paid or deposited by or recovered from, or refundable to, a person under the provision of this Act, shall first be adjusted towards the deficit stamp duty or penalty outstanding against him and the excess if any, shall then be adjusted towards the interest, if any, due from him.]

(5) The instrument produced before the Collector under sub­section (2) or under sub-section (3), shall be deemed to have come before him in the performance of his functions.

(6) In case the instrument is not produced within the period specified by the Collector, he may require payment of deficit stamp duty, if any, together with penalty on the copy of the instrument in accordance with the procedure laid down in sub-sections (2) and (4)."

Rule 7 of the Uttar Pradesh Stamp (Valuation of Property) Rules, 1997 provides that procedure for adjudication of the dispute under Section 47A of the Act, which is quoted hereunder.

"7. Procedure on receipt of a reference or when suo motu action is proposed under Section 47A.-(1) On receipt of a reference or where action is proposed to be taken suo motu under Section 47A, the Collector shall issue notice to parties to the instrument to show cause within thirty days of the receipt of such notice as to why the market value of the property set forth in the instrument and the duty payable thereon be not determined by him.

2. The Collector may admit oral or documentary evidence, if any, produced by the parties to the instrument and call for and examine the original instrument to satisfy himself as to the correctness of the market value of the subject-matter of the instrument and for determining the duty payable thereon.

3. The Collector may:

(a) call for any information or record from any public office, officer or authority under the Government or local authority;

(b) examine and record the statement of any public officer or authority under the Government or local authority;

(c) inspect the property after due notice to the parties to the instrument.

4. After considering the representation of the parties, if any, and examining the records and other evidence, the Collector shall determine the market value of the subject-matter of the instrument and the duty payable thereon.

5. If, as a result of such inquiry, the market value is found to be fully and truly set forth and the instrument duly stamped according to such value, it shall be returned to the person who made the reference with a certificate to that effect. A copy of such certificate shall also be sent to the registering officer concerned.

6. If as a result of such inquiry, the market value is found to be undervalued and not duly stamped, necessary action shall be taken in respect of it according to relevant provisions of the Act."

11. A perusal of the aforesaid rules indicate that the authority is required to hold an enquiry in such manner as may be prescribed by the rules. Rule 7 provides for the holding of an enquiry but the method of holding the enquiry has not been given. Consequently, the market value of the land in question is required to be determined on the general principles applicable for the determination of the market value of the land in question.

12. In R. C. Bansal v. District Magistrate, AIR 1999 SC 2126, the Supreme Court held that the circle rates are mere guidelines and prima facie gives the rate of the area concerned. Similar view was again reiterated by the Supreme Court in State of Punjab v. Mahabir Singh, AIR 1996 SC 2994.

13. Consequently, the circle rates, as prescribed by the District Magistrate, does not indicate the market value of the land in question and only gives a guideline of the approximate value of the land.

14. In M/s. Maya Food v. C.C.R.A., 1999 Revenue Judgments (RJ) 619: 1998 (4) AWC 636, the Court held that the market value of the land cannot be determined with reference to the use of the land to which the buyer intends to put it in use and that, in determining the market value, the potential value of the land, as on the date of the sale alone, could only be taken into account and not the potential value that it may fetch in the distant future.

15. Similar view was held in Shakumbari Sugar and Allied Industries Limited v. State of U, P. and others, 2007 (102) RD 842: 2007 (3) AWC 2769 and Smt. Sushila Verma v. State of U.P. and others, 2006 (2) AWC 1492.

16. In Ram Khilawan v. State of U.P., 2005 (98) RD 511: 2005 (2) AWC 1087, the Court found that the entire basis of the determination of the market value for the purpose of stamp duty was an ex parte report of the Tehsildar. The Court held that an ex parte inspection report may be relevant for initiating a proceeding under section 47a of stamp act but no reliance could be placed upon the said report thereafter. After initiation of the case, an inspection is to be made by the Collector or authority hearing the case after due notice to the parties to the instrument as provided under Rule 7 (3) of the Rules of 1997. Moreover in the inspection report distance of the property from other residential or commercial properties and road must be shown and wherever possible sketch map must also be annexed along with the report so that the correct valuation could be ascertained with reasonable certainty.

17. In Vijay Kumar and others v. Commissioner, Meerut Division, Meerut and another, 2008 (7) ADJ 293: 2008 (3) AWC 2997, the Court held that the burden to prove that the market value was more than the minimum value fixed by the Collector was upon the State authorities and a mere report of approximate value of the land was not sufficient.

18. In the light of the aforesaid decisions, it is clear that the report dated 29.3.2004 was relied upon by the authorities. This is a report which was submitted prior to the initiation of the proceedings under Section 47A of the Act. Such report could form the basis of the initiation of the proceedings under Section 47A of the Act but could not form the basis of evidence under Rule 7 of the Rules of 1997. In any case, the report is not based on any concrete evidence which could indicate the market value of the land in question. The said report only indicates the approximate value at the rate of Rs. 10,000 per square metre.

19. In my opinion, the finding on the market value of the land is based on presumption and is patently against the material evidence on record. The authorities have estimated the value of the land at the rate of Rs. 10,000 per square metre on the ground that the land in question is surrounded by commercial buildings and that the value of the land upto 9 metres from the main road was Rs. 15,000 per square metre as fixed by the Collector and further concluded that since the land in question was beyond 9 metres, the value of the land was approximately Rs. 10,000 per square metre. This finding is patently perverse and against the material evidence on record.

20. The circle rate fixed by the Collector has been indicated in the report of the A.D.M. dated 1.10.2007 which indicates that the value of the land upto 50 metres from the main road is Rs. 6,000 per square metre and from 50 metres to 150 metres, the rate is Rs. 5,000 per square metre. Admittedly, the land in question is 119 metres from the main road. Therefore, the rate applicable as per the Collector's circle rate is Rs. 5,000 per square metre. The petitioner has paid the stamp duty at the rate of Rs. 5,000 per square metre. The authorities have valued the land at Rs. 10,000 per square metre on the strength of the finding that the land is surrounded by commercial buildings, and that, the said land has a potential value for commercial purposes.

21. In my opinion, such presumption cannot be drawn by the authorities. The Stamp Act is a fiscal statute and the provisions has to be interpreted strictly and literally. There is no room for presumptions or approximation. The market value of the land is required to be assessed on the nature of the land as existing on the date of the sale of that land. What the land could be put in use in future could not be taken into consideration by any stretch of imagination. The market value of the land as existing as on the date of the execution of the sale-deed is required to be considered. The potential value of the land, which could fetch in future is not required to be taken into consideration.

22. There is another aspect. Admittedly, the land is a residential land close to a commercial area. The mere fact that the land in question is surrounded by commercial buildings will not make a residential land into a commercial land unless the use of the land is converted in the master plan under the provisions of the U.P. Urban Development and Planning Act, 1973. The petitioner has also filed an extract of the master plan indicating that the distance of a bazaar street is 30 metres from the Elite crossing, Civil Lines, Jhansi. Consequently, as per the master plan, land upto 30 metres from the crossing is to be treated as commercial land and beyond 30 metres, the land is treated as a residential land. The petitioner's land is admittedly beyond 30 metres.

23. In view of the aforesaid, the judgment cited by the learned standing counsel in the case of Adarsh Kumar and others v. State of U.P. and others, 2007 (7) ADJ 786: 2007 (4) AWC 3458 has no application to the facts and circumstances of the case. This Court finds that there is no suppression of material fact. The potential of the land, which it could fetch in future is not required to be spelt out in the recital of the sale-deed and such details does not amount to suppression of any material fact which could invite imposition of penalty.

24. In view of the aforesaid, the imposition of stamp duty and the imposition of penalty is patently illegal and without jurisdiction. The impugned orders cannot be sustained and are quashed. The writ petition is allowed.

25. It has come on record that the petitioner has deposited a sum of Rs. 3,27,300 on 20.7.2007, which included a sum of Rs. 77,000 towards interest calculated at the rate of 18% per annum as imposed by the Collector in its order under Section 47A of the Act. Since, the amount has already been deposited, the petitioner is entitled for a refund of the amount along with interest at the rate of 18% per annum calculated from the date of deposit till the date of actual payment made by the authority to the petitioner. The amount so deposited is required to be refunded to the petitioner within six weeks from the date of presentation of the certified copy of the order before the Collector.