Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Saf Yeast Company Private Limited v. State Of U.P And Another

Allahabad High Court
Oct 24, 2008
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Judgment Summary — U.K. Dhaon, J.

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner is a private limited company operating a unit at UPSIDC, Industrial Area, Sandila, District Hardoi, manufacturing yeast using molasses purchased from various sugar factories in Uttar Pradesh. The State enacted the U.P. Sheera Niyantran Adhiniyam, 1964 ("the Adhiniyam"), which, by section 7A(4) and (5), requires the occupier of a sugar factory to pay administrative charges (not exceeding Rs. 5 per quintal as notified) to the State on molasses sold or supplied and allows the occupier to recover that amount from the purchaser in addition to the price.

The petitioner challenged Notification No. ST-2-5784/X-10(1)-80-U.P. Act 15/48-Order-81 dated September 7, 1981 (issued under clause (d) of sub-section (1) of section 3A of the U.P. Sales Tax Act, 1948 read with section 21 of the U.P. General Clauses Act, 1904) insofar as the State sought to collect trade tax on goods specified in the Schedule, asserting that the State's collection of administrative charges under the Adhiniyam together with trade tax under the U.P. Trade Tax/Sales Tax Act amounted to double taxation on the same product (molasses).

The writ petition was filed in July 2003. The central procedural posture focused on the petitioner's claim for refund of trade tax collected from it through sugar mills after March 10, 2003 (the date on which the Supreme Court dismissed the State's Special Leave Petition against the D.S.M. judgment).

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the administrative charges levied under the U.P. Sheera Niyantran Adhiniyam, 1964 constitute a tax (as opposed to a fee) and whether that taxability prevents the State from also collecting trade tax on the same molasses transaction.
  2. Whether the U.P. Sheera Niyantran Adhiniyam, 1964 (a special enactment) prevails over the U.P. Trade Tax Act / U.P. Sales Tax Act (a general enactment) with respect to taxation of molasses.
  3. Whether the petitioner is entitled to refund of trade tax realised from it through sugar mills on purchases of molasses made subsequent to March 10, 2003.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments (as presented)

  • The administrative charges levied under the U.P. Sheera Niyantran Adhiniyam, 1964 are in substance a tax on molasses and are being collected by the State through sugar factories.
  • Because the special Adhiniyam already provides for collection of administrative charges on molasses, the general U.P. Trade Tax Act (formerly Sales Tax Act) cannot lawfully tax the same purchase of molasses — doing so amounts to double taxation.
  • The Supreme Court has held that the administrative charge under the Adhiniyam is a tax (citing Commissioner of Central Excise, Meerut v. Kisan Sahkari Chinni Mills Ltd. and related authorities), and a line of decisions supports that molasses is not taxable under the Trade Tax Act; consequently, the trade tax collected from the petitioner was illegal and should be refunded.
  • The petitioner relied on earlier decisions (including Gobind Sugar Mills, Belsund Sugar, D.S.M. Group) to support both the substantive point (non-taxability under the Trade Tax Act) and the prayer for refund.

Opposite Parties' Arguments (as presented)

  • The Additional Advocate-General (AAG) conceded several substantive points: that administrative charges under the Adhiniyam are a tax and that the special Adhiniyam prevails over the general Trade Tax Act; and that the Supreme Court dismissed the State's Special Leave Petition in relation to the D.S.M. judgment.
  • Despite these concessions, the AAG argued the petitioner was not entitled to a refund because (a) the petitioner paid trade tax without protest and did not challenge it to departmental authorities, and (b) the petitioner did not plead that it had not passed on the burden of the tax to its consumers — raising the defence based on unjust enrichment principles and reliance on Supreme Court authorities (Mafatlal, U.P. Pollution Control Board v. Kanoria Industrial Ltd., Somaiya Organics) to argue limits on restitution relief.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Commissioner of Central Excise, Meerut v. Kisan Sahkari Chinni Mills Ltd., (2001) 6 SCC 697 That the administrative charge levied by the State under the U.P. Sheera Niyantran Adhiniyam, 1964 is a tax. Cited by petitioner and acknowledged by the AAG; used to establish that administrative charges are taxes and therefore cannot be duplicated by trade tax on the same transaction.
Commissioner of Central Excise, Lucknow, U.P. v. Chhata Sugar Co. Ltd., [2004] 2 RC 614; (2004) 3 SCC 466 Held administrative charge is a tax (not a fee). Relied upon by the petitioner and conceded by the AAG; reinforced the court's view that administrative charges are taxable in nature.
Gupta Modern Breweries v. State of Jammu & Kashmir, [2007] 8 RC 688; (2007) 6 SCC 317 Administrative charges imposed are a tax and not a fee. Cited by petitioner as part of the authorities establishing the tax character of administrative charges; considered among the authorities supporting the petitioner's submissions.
Belsund Sugar Co. Ltd. v. State of Bihar, (1999) 9 SCC 620 Supports the principle that a special enactment prevails over a general enactment. Relied upon by the petitioner; the court treated it as part of the body of authority showing the Adhiniyam (special law) overrides the Trade Tax Act (general law).
Gobind Sugar Mills Ltd. v. State of Bihar, [1999] 115 STC 358; (1999) 7 SCC 76 Authority relied upon for the proposition that molasses is not taxable under the Trade Tax Act and that relevant special enactments govern taxation. Key precedent relied on by petitioner and expressly applied by the court to conclude that it was improper for the State to realise trade tax on molasses where administrative charges were being collected under the Adhiniyam.
Beg Raj Singh v. State of U.P., (2003) 1 SCC 726 Cited by the petitioner (no specific rule elaborated in the opinion text). Cited among other Supreme Court authorities relied upon by the petitioner; the opinion does not describe a discrete application beyond its inclusion in the petitioner's list of authorities.
D.S.M. Group of Industries v. Chairman, Trade Tax Tribunal, U.P., [2002] UPTC 955 Single-judge decision of this Court holding molasses is not taxable under the U.P. Trade Tax Act; the State's Special Leave Petition against that judgment was dismissed by the Supreme Court on March 10, 2003. The court treated this judgment (and the dismissal of the SLP) as decisive: after the SLP dismissal, the State could not lawfully continue to collect trade tax on molasses. The court ordered refunds of trade tax realised after March 10, 2003 on that basis.
Moti Laminates (P) Ltd. v. Union of India, [2002] 144 ELT 3 Cited by the petitioner (no specific principle described in the opinion text). Cited among petitioner authorities; the opinion does not spell out a particular application from this case.
Salonah Tea Co. Ltd. v. Superintendent of Taxes, Nowgong, [1988] 69 STC 290; (1988) 1 SCC 401 Cited by the petitioner (no specific principle described in the opinion text). Cited as part of supporting jurisprudence relied upon by the petitioner; no discrete application explained in the opinion text.
Arochem Industries v. Union of India, [1991] 56 ELT 505 (Bombay High Court) Cited by the petitioner (no specific principle described in the opinion text). Included among the authorities cited by the petitioner; the opinion does not detail a specific application from this High Court decision.
Mafatlal Industries Ltd. v. Union of India, [1998] 111 STC 467; (1997) 5 SCC 536 Constitution Bench holding (quoted) that Article 265 forbids the State from making unlawful levy or collecting tax unlawfully and that unlawfully collected taxes must be restored to the taxpayer. Quoted and applied by the court to support the conclusion that unlawfully collected trade tax must be refunded; the court relied on the constitutional mandate described in that decision.
U.P. Pollution Control Board v. Kanoria Industrial Ltd., [2002] 128 STC 26; (2001) 2 SCC 549 Cited by the AAG in support of the State's submissions regarding restitution / unjust enrichment limitations (as part of resisting refund). Cited by the AAG; the court recited that the AAG relied on it but ultimately found that the State's continued collection post-dismissal of the SLP was unlawful and ordered refunds.
Somaiya Organics (India) Ltd. v. State of U.P., [2001] 123 STC 623; (2001) 5 SCC 519 Cited by the AAG as part of the line of authorities about restitution/limitations on refunds. Cited by the AAG; the opinion notes the reliance but orders refund on constitutional grounds and prior authoritative rulings concerning molasses.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court proceeded by examining the admitted facts and the statutory provision. It noted the parties' admissions that:

  • The petitioner purchases molasses from sugar factories in U.P. for manufacture of yeast;
  • The U.P. Sheera Niyantran Adhiniyam, 1964 applies to molasses and, by section 7A(4)-(5), imposes administrative charges on sale/supply of molasses and permits the occupier to recover such charges from purchasers.

The court recorded the key concessions of the AAG: that administrative charges under the Adhiniyam are a tax (not a fee), that the Adhiniyam is a special enactment which prevails over the general U.P. Trade Tax Act, and that the Supreme Court had dismissed the State's Special Leave Petition against the D.S.M. judgment (which held molasses not taxable under the Trade Tax Act).

Framing the sole remaining issue as whether the petitioner was entitled to refund of trade tax collected from it through sugar mills, the court applied the following legal steps:

  1. Identified authoritative precedent establishing that administrative charges under the Adhiniyam are taxes (citing Supreme Court authorities) and that special enactments prevail over general enactments in the same field.
  2. Relied on D.S.M. Group of Industries decision and the fact that the Supreme Court dismissed the State's SLP on March 10, 2003 — concluding that after that date the State could not lawfully continue to collect trade tax on molasses.
  3. Invoked Article 265 of the Constitution and Mafatlal (Constitution Bench) to hold that unlawful collection of tax must be restored to the taxpayer, emphasizing the State's constitutional obligation to refund unlawfully collected tax.
  4. Concluded that collection of trade tax from the petitioner on molasses after March 10, 2003 was arbitrary, illegal and unjust because it violated the law as declared by higher courts and the constitutional bar against unlawful taxation.

The court considered but ultimately found the State's procedural/contentions (e.g., that the petitioner paid without protest or did not plead non-passage of burden) insufficient to defeat the constitutional and precedential obligation to refund taxes unlawfully collected after the SLP dismissal.

Holding and Implications

HOLDING: The writ petition succeeds and is partly allowed. Specifically:

  • The opposite parties shall not realise any trade tax from the petitioner on the purchase of molasses on the basis of the notification dated September 7, 1981 issued under the provisions of the U.P. Sales Tax Act (now the U.P. Trade Tax Act) read with section 21 of the U.P. General Clauses Act, 1904.
  • The opposite parties shall refund the amount of trade tax which was realised by them through the sugar mills subsequent to March 10, 2003.
  • Administrative directions: The petitioner is to submit details of the tax realised from them subsequent to March 10, 2003 within one month; the opposite parties must refund the specified amount within two months thereafter.
  • There shall be no order as to costs.

Implications: The direct operative effect is a mandatory prohibition on realising trade tax from the petitioner on molasses purchases (going forward) and an order for refund of trade tax collected after March 10, 2003. The opinion relies on existing Supreme Court authority and the constitutional mandate (Article 265) to require restitution; the court did not purport to lay down a new principle of law beyond applying the cited precedents to the facts of this petition.

All content in this summary is drawn exclusively from the provided opinion and does not add or infer facts beyond what the opinion states.

Show all summary ...

U.K Dhaon, J.:— Heard Sri Prashant Chandra, Senior Advocate, assisted by Sri Gaurav Mehrotra, learned counsel for the petitioner and Sri Jaideep Narayan Mathur, learned Additional Advocate-General assisted by Sri H.P Srivastava, learned Additional Chief Standing Counsel for the opposite parties.

2. The brief facts of the case in a nutshell are as under:

The petitioner which is a private limited company has alleged that its unit at UPSIDC, Industrial Area, Sandila District, Hardoi, is manufacturing yeast from molasses, which is raw material for the manufacture of yeast. The molasses is purchased from various sugar factories situated in the State of U.P The petitioner has further alleged that the State of U.P enacted the U.P Sheera Niyantran Adhiniyam, 1964 (hereinafter referred to as, “the Adhiniyam”). Sub-section (4) of section 7A of the Adhiniyam provides that the occupier of a sugar factory shall be liable to pay to the State Government, in the manner, prescribed, administrative charges at such rate, not exceeding Rs. 5 per quintal as the State Government from time to time notify, on the molasses sold or supplied by him.

3. The petitioner has further alleged that the U.P Sheera Niyantran Adhiniyam, 1964 is a special Act and the same has been enacted for the control of storage gradation and price of molasses produced by sugar factories in Uttar Pradesh and the regulation of supply and distribution and sub-section (5) of section 7A provides that the occupier shall be entitled to receive from the person to whom the molasses is soid or supplied an amount equivalent to the amount of such administrative charges, in addition;to the price of molasses. The petitioner has further alleged that the State Government is already charging tax from the petitioner under the U.P Sheera Niyantran Adhiniyam, 1964 which is a special enactment for molasses only and as such under the provisions of the U.P Trade Tax Act, 1948 no tax can be realised from the petitioner as it will amount to double taxation on the sale of same product, i.e, molasses by the State Government under two different enactments.

4. The petitioner being aggrieved by the Notification No. ST-2-5784/X-10(1)-80-U.P. Act 15/48-Order-81 dated September 7, 1981 which has been issued in exercise of the powers under clause (d) of sub-section (1) of section 3A of the U.P Sales Tax Act, 19.48 (U.P Act No. 15 of 1948) read with section 21 of the U.P General Clauses Act, 1904 (U.P Act No. 1 of 1904), and in supersession of all pervious notifications issued from time to time under sub-section (1) of section 3A of the Act as it stood before its amendment by the U.P Sales. Tax (Amendment and Validation) Ordinance, 1981 (U.P Ordinance No. 12 of 1981), by which it has been provided that, with effect from September 7, 1981, the turnover in respect of the goods specified in column (2) of the Schedule to the notification shall be liable to tax at the point of sale specified in column (3) of the said Schedule at the rate specified against each in column (4) thereof, has filed the instant writ petition.

5. The learned counsel for the petitioner submitted that the levy of administrative charges on the sale of molasses is a tax and as the petitioner is paying administrative charges on the purchase of the molasses from the sugar mills, the opposite parties cannot realise the trade tax under the provisions of the U.P Trade Tax Act, 1948. on the same purchase of molasses. He further submitted that the honourable Supreme Court in the case of Commissioner of Central Excise, Meerut v. Kisan Sahkari Chinni Mills Ltd. reported in (2001) 6 SCC 697 has held that administrative charge levied by the State of U.P under the provisions of the U.P Sheera Niyantran Adhiniyam, 1964, on the sale and purchase of molasses is a tax. The learned counsel for the petitioner has also relied upon the decision of the honourable Supreme Court in the case of Commissioner of Central Excise, Lucknow, U.P v. Chhata Sugar Co. Ltd. reported in [2004] 2 RC 614; (2004) 3 SCC 466. He further submitted that the honourable Supreme Court in the case of Gupta Modern Breweries v. State of Jammu and Kashmir reported in [2007] 8 RC 688; (2007) 6 SCC 317 has held that the administrative charges imposed is a tax and not a fee.

6. He further submitted that the special enactment will prevail over-general enactment and as the U.P Trade Tax Act is a general Act relevant to the levy of tax on sale and purchase of goods in the State of U.P it will not apply to the petitioner in respect to the purchase of molasses from the Sugar factories as the sugar factory recovers administrative charges from the petitioner and passes them on to the/Government under the special enactment, i.e, U.P Act No. 24 of 1964. The learned counsel for the petitioner has relied upon the decision of the honourable Supreme Court in the cases of Belsund Sugar Co. Ltd. v. State of Bihar reported in (1999) 9 SCC 620, Gobind Sugar Mills Ltd. v. State of Bihar reported in [1999] 115 STC 358; (1999) 7 SCC 76 and Beg Raj Singh v. State of U.P reported in (2003) 1 SCC 726. He further submitted that in the case of D.S.M Group of Industries v. Chairman, Trade Tax Tribunal, U.P reported in [2002] UPTC 955, the honourable single judge of this court has held that molasses is not taxable under the U. P, Trade Tax Act, 1948 and that the special Act will prevail over the General Act and the Special Leave Petition. (C) No. 8845 of 2002, State of U.P v. D.S.M Group of Industries against the said judgment was dismissed by the honourable Supreme Court by the judgment and order dated March 10, 2003.

7. Sri Prashant Chandra, further submitted that the petitioner is entitled for the refund of the trade tax which was collected by the State of U.P through the sugar mills from the petitioner on the purchase of molasses in view of the law declared by the honourable Supreme Court in the case of Gobind Sugar Mills Ltd. v. State of Bihar, [1999] 115 STC 358; (1999) 7 SCC 76 and D.S.M Group of Industries v. Chairman, Trade Tax Tribunal, U.P, [2002] UPTC 955.

8. The learned counsel for the petitioner has also relied upon the decision of the honourable Supreme Court in the case of Moti Laminates (P) Ltd. v. Union of India reported in [2002] 144 ELT 3, Salonah Tea Company Ltd. v. Superintendent of Taxes, Nowgong reported in [1988] 69 STC 290; (1988) 1 SCC 401 and the judgment of the Bombay High Court in the case of Arochem Industries v. Union of India, [1991] 56 ELT 505.

9. Sri J.N Mathur, learned Additional Advocate-General appearing on behalf of the opposite parties submitted that the U.P Sheera Niyantran Adhiniyam, 1964, is a special enactment for the control of storage gradation and price of molasses produced by sugar factories in Uttar Pradesh and the regulation of supply and distribution thereof. He fairly conceded that in view of the law declared by the honourable Supreme Court in the cases of Commissioner of Central Excise, Meerut v. Kisan Sahkari Chinni Mills Ltd., (2001) 6 SCC 697 and Commissioner of Central Excise, Lucknow, U.P v. Chhata Sugar Co. Ltd., [2004] 2 RC 614; (2004) 3 SCC 466 administrative charge is a tax and not fee. He also fairly conceded that in view of the law declared by the honourable Supreme Court in the cases of Gobind Sugar Mills Ltd. v. State of Bihar, [1999] 115 STC 358; (1999) 7 SCC 76 and Belsund Sugar Co. Ltd. v. State of Bihar, (1999) 9 SCC 620, special enactment will prevail over general enactment. He has also conceded that the special leave petition filed against; the judgment and order passed in the case of D.S.M Group of Industries, [2002] UPTC 955 has been dismissed by the honourable Supreme Court. He further submitted that the petitioner is not entitled for the refund; of the trade tax which he has paid to the sugar-mills while purchasing molasses for the manufacture of yeast. He further submitted that the petitioner is paying the trade tax without protest and they never raised any grievance, before the departmental authorities with respect to the relief claimed in the writ petition. He further submitted that the petitioner has not stated in the writ petition that he has not passed on the burden of tax paid by him to the consumer of the yeast and as such he is not entitled for refund on the principles of unjust enrichment. He has relied upon the decisions of the honourable Supreme Court in the cases of Mafatlal Industries Ltd. v. Union of India reported in [1998] 111 STC 467; (1997) 5 SCC 536, U.P Pollution Control Board v. Kanoria Industrial Ltd. reported in [2002] 128 STC 26; (2001) 2 SCC 549 and Somaiya Organics (India) Ltd. v. State of Uttar Pradesh reported in [2001] 123 STC 623; (2001) 5 SCC 519.

10. We have considered the submissions made by the learned counsel for the parties and gone through the record.

11. The petitioner which is a private limited company has alleged that its unit at UPSIDC, Industrial Area, Sandila District, Hardoi, is manufacturing yeast from molasses. It is admitted case of the parties that the petitioner is purchasing molasses for the manufacture of yeast from various sugar factories situated in the State of U.P It is also admitted case of the parties that the State of U.P enacted the U.P Sheera Niyantran Adhiniyam, 1964 (U.P Act No. 24 of 1964) for the control of storage, gradation of price of molasses produced by the sugar factories in Uttar Pradesh and the regulation of supply and distribution thereof. Section 7A of the U.P Act No. 24 of 1964 is as follows:

“7A. Application for molasses.— (1) Any person who requires molasses for his distillery or for any purpose of industrial development may apply in the prescribed manner to the controller specifying the purpose for which it is required.

(2) On receipt of an application under sub-section (1) and after making such inquiries in the matter as he may think fit, the controller may make an order under section 8.

(3) In disposing of an application under sub-section (1) the controller shall consider:—

(a) the general availability of molasses;

(b) various requirements of, molasses;

(c) the better utilisation to which molasses may be put in the public interest;

(d) the extent to which the requirements of the applicant are genuine; and

(e) reasonable likelihood or otherwise of the molasses that may be obtained by the applicant being diverted to purposes other than those specified in the (application and where the application is rejected in whole or in part, he shall record reasons therefor.

(4) The occupier of a sugar factory shall be liable to pay to the State Government in the mariner prescribed, administrative charges at such rate, not exceeding five rupees per quintal as the State Government from time to time notify, on the molasses sold of supplied by him.

(5) The occupier shall be entitled to receive from the person to whom the molasses is sold or supplied an amount equivalent to the amount of such administrative charges, in addition to the price of molasses.”

12. The petitioner has alleged that the State of U.P, is levying and collecting administrative charges which is tax on the molasses through the sugar factories under the U.P Sheera Niyantran Adhiniyam, 1964 and also collecting trade tax under the U.P Trade Tax Act, thus subjecting the same purchase of molasses by the petitioner to tax twice under two different Acts. The petitioner contended that the U.P Sheera Niyantran Adhiniyam, 1964, being a special enactment overrides the provisions of the Trade Tax Act with reference to levy of administrative charges on molasses as the latter is a general Act providing for collection of taxes on sale and purchase of goods.

13. Sri J.N Mathur, learned Additional Advocate-General, has fairly conceded that administrative charges collected by the sugar mills on the purchase of the molasses by the petitioner is a tax. He has also conceded that the U.P Sheera Niyantran Adhiniyam, 1964, being a special enactment will override the provisions of the U.P Trade Tax Act, which is a general Act providing for collection of taxes on sale and purchase of goods. Sri J.N Mathur has also conceded that in the case of D.S.M Group of Industries v. Chairman, Trade Tax Tribunal, U.P, [2002] UPTC 955, the honourable single judge of this court has held that molasses is not taxable under the U.P Trade Tax Act, 1948 and the special leave petition preferred by the State of U.P against the said judgment was dismissed by the honourable Supreme Court on March 10, 2003.

14. Now the only question for determination in the writ petition is regarding the refund of the trade tax which the opposite parties have realised from the petitioner through sugar mills on the purchase of molasses.

15. It is admitted case of the parties that the State of U.P is realising administrative charges on the purchase of the molasses by the petitioner from various sugar mills in the State of Uttar Pradesh. It is also admitted case of the parties that in addition to the administrative charges, the petitioner has also paid trade tax on the same purchase of molasses from the sugar mills. It is also admitted case of the parties that the State of U.P has levied and collected administrative charges on the molasses purchased by the petitioner from the sugar mills situated in the State and also realised trade tax under the U.P Trade Tax Act on the same purchase of molasses by the petitioner. In view of the law declared by the honourable Supreme Court in the case of Gobind Sugar Mills Ltd. v. State of Bihar, [1999] 115 STC 358; (1999) 7 SCC 76, it was not proper for the opposite parties to realise trade tax from the petitioner on the purchase of molasses as they were realising and collecting administrative charges which is a tax on the same purchase of molasses. In the case of D.S.M Group of Industries v. Chairman, Trade Tax Tribunal, U.P, [2002] UPTC 955, the honourable single judge of this court, on the basis of the various pronouncement of the honourable Supreme Court, held that molasses is riot taxable under the U.P Trade Tax Act, 1948.? It was also held that the U.P Sheera Niyantran Adhiniyam, 1964, is a special Act, which will prevail over general Act of the State of U.P which operates in the same field. It is also an admitted case of the parties that the Special Leave Petition (C) No. 8845 of 2002 preferred by the State of U.P against the judgment and order dated February 6, 2002 in the case of D.S.M Group of Industries v. Chairman, Trade Tax Tribunal, U.P, [2002] UPTC 955. was dismissed by the honourable Supreme Court on March 10, 2003. The instant writ petition was filed by the petitioner in July 2003. Once it has been held that molasses is not taxable under the U.P Trade Tax Act, 1948 as the U.P Sheera Niyantran Adhiniyam, 1964, which is a special Act will prevail over U.P Trade Tax Act, 1948, the trade tax levied and collected by the opposite parties from the petitioner on the purchase of molasses through sugar mills was illegal and unjust. The trade tax paid by the petitioner on the purchase of molasses during the pendency of the writ petition was under protest as the realisation of the tax was against the law declared by the honourable Supreme Court

16. Article 265 of the Constitution of India forbids the State from making unlawful levy or collecting tax unlawfully. The Constitution Bench of the honourable Supreme Court in the case of Mafatlal Industries Ltd. v. Union of India, [1998] 111 STC 467; (1997) 5 SCC 536 has held in para 123 (at page 553, STC) as under:

“10. A point has been made that the manufacturer has passed on the burden of the illegal levy to his customers by raising his price of the goods. But that is no reason why the guarantee given by the Constitution should not be enforced. The manufacturer may have been compelled to raise the price because of the imposition of an illegal levy. But that is no reason to dilute the mandate contained in article 265 of the Constitution. Article 265 forbids the State from making an unlawful levy or collecting taxes unlawfully./The bar is absolute. It protects the citizens from any unlawful exaction of tax. So long as article 265 is there, the State cannot be permitted to levy any tax without authority of law and if any tax has been collected unlawfully that must be restored to the person from whom it was collected. If the tax has been collected from any person unlawfully, it is the tax-payer's money which is in unlawful possession of the State. The State has a constitutional obligation to give back the money to the tax-payer. An Act done in violation of constitutional mandate is void and no right flows out of that void Act to the State. The State is in unlawful possession of the tax-payer's property. The State cannot retain it on any equitable ground nor can it give it to any other person out of any supposed equitable consideration. The constitutional mandate cannot be ignored on the pretext of any rule of equity or on the ground of what is perceived as substantive justice. Every word of the Constitution has to fee treated as sacrosanct and respected and obeyed by the State and the Legislature and enforced by the court.”

17. The court has a duty to up hold the Constitution in letter and spirit. If the court comes to the conclusion that the levy of tax is unlawful, the court will direct the Government to return the tax. After the decision of this court in the case of D.S.M Group of Industries v. Chairman, Trade Tax Tribunal, U.P, [2002] UPTC 955 affirmed by the honourable Supreme Court on March 10, 2003, it cannot be said that the State was unaware that molasses is not taxable under the U.P Tirade Tax Act. The action of the opposite parties in collecting and realising the trade tax from the petitioner on the purchase of molasses from various sugar mills in the State of U.P subsequent to the dismissal of Special Leave Petition (C) No. 8845 of 2002, Mate of U.P v. D.S.M Group of Industries on March 10, 2003 by the honourable Supreme Court is arbitrary; illegal and unjust.

18. We are of the view that the petitioner is entitled or the refund of the trade tax which was illegally realised and collected by the opposite parties on the purchase of the molasses through sugar mills of the State of U.P subsequent to March 10, 2003.

19. In the result the writ petition succeeds and is partly allowed the opposite parties on the basis of the notification dated September 7, 1981 issued under the provisions of the U.P Sales Tax Act, 1948 now the U.P Trade Tax Act read with section 21 of the U.P General Clauses Act, 1904 shall foot realise any trade tax from the petitioner on the purchase of molasses. The opposite parties shall/refund the amount of trade tax which was realised by them through the sugar mills subsequent to March 10, 2003. The petitioners shall submit the details of the tax which the opposite parties have realised from them subsequent to March 10, 2003 within one month from today and the opposite parties shall refund the amount of trade tax to the petitioners within two months thereafter.

20. Under the circumstance, there shall be no order as to costs.