Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Smt. Malti Devi v. State Of U.P & Ors.

Allahabad High Court
Feb 19, 2008
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Judicial Opinion Summary — Sunil Ambwani, J.

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner, an elected Pradhan of Gram Panchayat Baraila, Block Bhadohi, district Sant Ravidas Nagar, challenged an order dated 13.11.2007 passed by the District Magistrate, Sant Ravidas Nagar. The District Magistrate had ceased the petitioner's administrative and financial powers under Section 95(1)(g) of the U. P. Panchayat Raj Act, 1947 and directed the Block Development Officer to appoint a three-member committee to exercise such powers until completion of a formal enquiry under the U. P. Panchayat Raj (Removal of Pradhans, Up Pradhans and Members) Enquiry Rules, 1997 (Rules of 1997).

Prior to making that order, the District Magistrate had appointed the District Basic Education Officer to conduct a preliminary enquiry and submit a report. The District Basic Education Officer's report dated 30.8.2007 stated that the Pradhan had not been serving mid-day meals to primary school children at Baraila since 15.12.2006. An inspection on 10.8.2007 (conducted by the Assistant Basic Education Officer at the direction of the District Basic Education Officer) recorded that children said meals were not cooked and served, while the Pradhan had received foodgrains regularly from the fair price shop.

The writ petition challenged the District Magistrate's order. After hearing, the Court dismissed the writ petition (final disposition recorded in the opinion).

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether, under Rule 4 of the Rules of 1997, the preliminary enquiry must be conducted personally by the District Panchayat Raj Officer or whether any other "district level officer" nominated by the District Magistrate may conduct (or cause to be conducted) the preliminary enquiry.
  2. Whether the District Basic Education Officer could delegate the fact‑finding visit/inspection to the Assistant Basic Education Officer and whether such delegation affected the validity of the preliminary enquiry or the power of the District Magistrate to cease the Pradhan's administrative and financial powers under Section 95(1)(g) of the Act.
  3. Whether the material collected during the preliminary enquiry was sufficient and relevant to justify cessation of the Pradhan's administrative and financial powers pending a formal enquiry, and whether natural justice (show‑cause opportunity) was observed.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • Under Rule 4 the enquiry officer must be the District Panchayat Raj Officer or another "district level officer" personally conducting the preliminary enquiry; the District Basic Education Officer, though a district level officer, could not delegate the enquiry to the Assistant Basic Education Officer.
  • The allegations against the petitioner were not substantiated; mid-day meals were cooked and served when the school was open from July to November 2007, and the petitioner relied on a register certified by the Headmaster to prove service of the mid-day meal.
  • Relying on several precedents, counsel contended that the competence of the officer to conduct the preliminary enquiry is important and that delegation to a lower-ranked officer was impermissible.

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the State respondents' oral or written arguments beyond the fact that learned standing counsel for the State respondents was heard.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Chunmun v. District Magistrate, Sonbhadra and another (1998) 3 UPLBEC 2061 : 1998 (3) AWC 1892 Cited regarding who conducted the preliminary enquiry (in that case a Junior Engineer was entrusted and completed the preliminary enquiry). The court noted this case as part of authorities relied upon concerning the competence of the enquiry officer; it recorded that prior cases held that the enquiry should be by the Enquiry Officer as defined in the Rules.
Smt. Sandhya Gupta v. District Magistrate, Awaia and others (1999) 1 UPLBEC 718 : 1999 (2) AWC 913 Cited concerning who conducted the preliminary enquiry (record showed Naib Tehsildar and Junior Engineer had submitted the report). The court observed this authority among others holding that the Rules provide for enquiry by the Enquiry Officer and that identity/status of the person conducting the enquiry had been focal in earlier decisions.
Smt. Sarojana Devi v. State of U. P. and others (2001) 2 SAC 256 : 2001 (4) AWC 2546 Cited for principle on preliminary enquiry (report submitted by Assistant District Panchayat Raj Officer in that case). Included by the court as part of the line of cases addressing the proper identity/competence of the enquiry officer under the Rules.
Chandrajit Raj Bhar v. District Magistrate, Pilibhit and others (2002) 1 SAC 227 : 2002 (1) AWC 674 Cited to show that in that case an Assistant Engineer, P.W.D., conducted the preliminary enquiry. Cited among authorities which earlier interpreted the Rules to require that the enquiry be by the named Enquiry Officer; the court surveyed them before stating its own view on the scope of "district level officer."
Smt. Shanti v. District Magistrate, Sultanpur and others 2000 (2) AWC 1395 Cited as an instance where preliminary enquiry was conducted by a specified officer (Alp Sankhyak Kalyan Adhikari in that case). Referred to in the court's review of prior case law on who may conduct preliminary enquiries under the Rules.
Moti Lal v. District Magistrate, Lalitpur and another (2003) 1 UPLBEC 736 : 2003 (5) AWC 3849 Cited in support of submissions regarding the competence of the officer to conduct the enquiry. Noted by the court as part of the precedential material relied upon concerning the identity of the enquiry officer; used in the survey that preceded the court's interpretative conclusion.
Krishna Devi (Smt.) v. District Magistrate, Ghaziabad and others (2003) 3 UPLBEC 2622 Cited regarding the competence/identity of officers conducting preliminary enquiries under the Rules. Included among the cases the court summarized as holding that an enquiry must be by the Enquiry Officer as defined in the Rules.
Satish Chandra Tripathi v. State of U. P. and others 2004 (96) RD 47 : 2004 (1) AWC 399 Cited on the question of who is competent to conduct preliminary enquiries under the Rules. Referenced by the court in the compilation of prior authorities on the scope of the term "Enquiry Officer" and competence to conduct preliminary enquiries.
Rajeshwari Kushwaha (Smt.) v. District Magistrate, Kanpur Nagar and others (2005) 2 UPLBEC 1216 : 2005 (2) AWC 1440 Cited as an instance where preliminary enquiry was conducted by the Deputy Director (Panchayat). Noted among authorities holding that the Rules provide for enquiry by the Enquiry Officer and that identity of the officer had been central to earlier rulings; the court surveyed these decisions before explaining its own approach.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court began by quoting and interpreting the relevant provisions of the Rules of 1997 — specifically Rule 2(c) (definition of "Enquiry Officer" as the District Panchayat Raj Officer or any other district level officer nominated by the District Magistrate), Rule 4 (preliminary enquiry procedure and 30-day reporting timeframe), and Rule 5 (constitution of committee and appointment of an enquiry officer other than the one who conducted the preliminary enquiry).

The Court observed that a village Pradhan is an elected office and the statute provides safeguards before removal or cessation of powers. A complaint, unless made by a public servant, must be supported by affidavit and contain sufficient material to initiate a preliminary enquiry. The State Government (or its delegate, the District Magistrate) may order an enquiry by the Enquiry Officer to determine if a prima facie case exists for a formal enquiry.

Addressing the central contention about the meaning of "district level officer," the Court noted that the statute and Rules do not further define that phrase. It rejected the submission that "district level officer" must be read to mean an officer equivalent in rank to the District Panchayat Raj Officer. The Court emphasized the object and purpose of the preliminary enquiry — to ascertain prima facie truth and collect material that may form the basis of a formal enquiry — and concluded that a rigid rank-based interpretation is inconsistent with that purpose.

The Court explained that the identity or rank of the officer who collects material is less important than the sufficiency and relevance of that material. The District Magistrate must be satisfied by the material collected; the Rules permit the District Magistrate to nominate any responsible district level officer to gather such material. The Court recognized that in particular subject-matter contexts (for example, technical construction issues or health/education schemes) officers from relevant departments may be better suited to conduct factual inquiries.

Concerning delegation: the District Basic Education Officer (a district level officer) had directed the Assistant Basic Education Officer to visit the school and report. The Assistant's report — recording conversations with children and teachers and the Headmaster's contradictory statements — was forwarded by the District Basic Education Officer to the District Magistrate. On the basis of that material and the Pradhan's reply, the District Magistrate found the children were not served mid-day meals since August 2007. The Court held that this material was relevant and sufficient to exercise powers under Section 95(1)(g) of the Act.

The Court further reasoned that where relevant material is collected and the Pradhan is given a show-cause notice together with the enquiry report, the status of the officer who collected the material loses decisive significance. Allegations of mala fide or bias by the Pradhan can be raised, but the mere fact that the enquiry was conducted by an officer of lesser status than the District Panchayat Raj Officer is not by itself a ground for invalidating the order if the material is sufficient and natural justice requirements are met.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The writ petition is dismissed.

Implications:

  • The District Magistrate's order dated 13.11.2007, which ceased the petitioner's administrative and financial powers under Section 95(1)(g) of the U. P. Panchayat Raj Act, 1947 and directed constitution of a committee pending formal enquiry, stands upheld by this Court on the facts and material before it.
  • The Court held that the phrase "district level officer" in Rule 2(c) of the Rules of 1997 need not be narrowly construed to mean an officer of the same rank as the District Panchayat Raj Officer; what matters is that a responsible district level officer be nominated and that material collected be relevant and sufficient for the District Magistrate to act.
  • This decision directly affects the parties by dismissing the petition and thereby validating the cessation of the petitioner's powers pending a formal enquiry. The opinion does not articulate any broader rule‑setting beyond its interpretative guidance; it confines its disposition to the facts and statutory interpretation as applied in this case.

Disposition recorded in the opinion: "The writ petition is dismissed."

Show all summary ...

Sunil Ambwani, J.-

Heard Shri B. D. Mandhyan, senior advocate assisted by Shri M. N. Singh for the petitioner and learned standing counsel for the State respondents.

2. By means of this writ petition, the petitioner has challenged an order dated 13,11.2007, passed by the District Magistrate, Sant Ravidas Nagar, by which he has ceased petitioner's administrative and financial powers as the elected Pradhan of Gram Panchayat, Baraila, Block Bhadohi, district Sant Ravidas Nagar, under Section 95 (1) (g) of U. P. Panchayat Raj Act, 1947 and has directed the Block Development Officer, Bhadohi to appoint a 'three-member committee', to exercise such powers until the formal enquiry under the U. P. Panchayat Raj (Removal of Pradhans, Up Pradhans and Members) Enquiry Rules, 1997 (in short, Rules of 1997) is concluded.

3. Before making the order, the District Magistrate appointed the District Basic Education Officer, Sant Ravidas Nagar, to enquire into the complaint against the petitioner and to submit his preliminary enquiry report. The District Basic Education Officer, in his report dated 30.8.2007, reported that the Pradhan is not serving with 'mid day meal' to the school children under the 'Mid-Day Meal Scheme' in primary school Baraila w.e.f. 15.12.2006. On an inspection the children informed the enquiry officer on 10.8.2007, that the 'mid-day meal' was not cooked and served to them. The Pradhan has received the foodgrains for cooking the meal regularly, from the fair price shop keeper.

4. Shri B. D. Mandhyan contends that under Rule 4 the enquiry officer could be either the District Panchayat Raj Officer or any other 'district level officer'. The preliminary enquiry could only be conducted by a 'district level officer'. The District Basic Education Officer is a district level officer. He however did not conduct the enquiry himself. Instead he directed the Assistant Basic Education Officer, to visit the primary school Baraila, Vikas Khand Bhadohi on 10.8.2007, and to make a report. He submits that the allegations against the petitioner were not substantiated, as 'mid day meal' was cooked and served every day when the school was opened in the months of July, 2007 to November, 2007 and has annexed the register certified by the Headmaster of the school to prove the service of 'mid day meal' to the children.

5. It is submitted that under the Rules of 1997, the financial and administrative powers may_be ceased, only after a preliminary enquiry is made by the District Magistrate through an enquiry officer. The 'enquiry officer' is defined in the rules as the 'District Panchayat Raj Officer' or any other 'district level officer', to be nominated by the District Magistrate. The District Basic Education Officer is a district level officer. He could not have delegated the powers further to the Assistant Basic Education Officer. He has relied upon the judgments in Chunmun u. District Magistrate, Sonbhadra and another, (1998) 3 UPLBEC 2061: 1998 (3) AWC 1892 Smt. Sandhya Gupta v. District Magistrate, Awaiya and others, (1999) 1 UPLBEC 718:1999 (2) AWC 913 Smt. Sarojana Devi v. State of U. P. and others, (2001) 2 SAC 256: 2001 (4) AWC 2546 Chandrajit Raj Bhar v. District Magistrate, Pilibhit and others, (2002) 1 SAC 227: 2002 (1) AWC 674: Smt. Shanti v. District Magistrate, Sultanpur and others, 2000 (2) AWC 1395 (LB) Moti Lal v. District Magistrate, Lalitpur and another, (2003) 1 UPLBEC 736: 2003 (5) AWC 3849 Krishna Devi (Smt.) v. District Magistrate, Chaziabad and others, (2003) 3 UPLBEC 2622 ' Satish Chandra Tripathi v. State of U. P. and others, 2004 (96) RD 47: 2004 (1) AWC 399 and Rajeshwari Kushwaha (Smt.) v. District Magistrate, Kanpur Nagar and others, (2005) 2 UPLBEC 1216: 2005 (2) AWC 1440, in support of his submissions regarding the competence of the officer to conduct the enquiry.

6. In Chunmun (supra), a Junior Engineer was entrusted and had completed the preliminary enquiry. In Smt. Sandhya Gupta (supra) the Court could not find as to who conducted the preliminary enquiry. The record proved that Naib Tehsildar and Junior Engineer had submitted the report to the Sub-Divisional Magistrate, who forwarded the same to the District Magistrate. In Smt. Sarojana Devi (supra) the preliminary enquiry report was submitted by the Assistant District Panchayat Raj Officer. In Chandrajit Raj Bhar (supra) the preliminary enquiry was conducted by the Assistant Engineer, P.W.D., Pilibhit. In Rajeshwari Kushwaha (Smt.) (supra) the preliminary enquiry was conducted by the Deputy Director (Panchayat) and in Smt. Shanti (supra) the preliminary enquiry was conducted by Alp Sankhyak Kalyan Adhikari. In all these cases it was held that the rules provide for an enquiry by the Enquiry Officer and since the Enquiry Officer is defined in the rules, no other officer can make the preliminary enquiry.

7. Rule 2 (c). Rule 4 and Rule 5 of the Rules of 1997 are quoted as below:

"2. (c) 'Enquiry Officer' means the "District Panchayat Raj Officer or any other district level officer, to be nominated by the District Magistrate.

4. Preliminary enquiry.- (1) The State Government may, on the receipt of a complaint or report referred to jn Rule 3, or otherwise order the Enquiry Officer to conduct a preliminary enquiry with a view to finding out if there is a prima facie case for a formal enquiry in the matter.

(2) The Enquiry Officer shall conduct the preliminary enquiry as expeditiously as possible and submit his report to the State Government within thirty days of his having been so ordered.

5. Where the State Government is of the opinion, on the basis of the report referred to in sub-rule (2) of Rule 4 or otherwise that an enquiry should be held against a Pradhan or Up-Pradhan or Member under the Proviso to Clause (g) of sub­section (1) of Section 95 it shall forthwith constitute a Committee envisaged by Proviso to Clause (g) of sub-section (3) of Section 95 of the Act and by an order ask an Enquiry Officer, other than the Enquiry Officer nominated under, sub-rule (2) of Rule 4, to hold the enquiry."

8. A village Pradhan holds an elected office. The statute has taken care to provide for sufficient safeguards before he may be removed from the office. The complaint, unless it is made by a public servant, should be supported by the affidavit and must contain sufficient allegations and material to initiate a preliminary enquiry. The State Government may, on the receipt of such complaint or otherwise, order the Enquiry Officer under Rule 4 to conduct a preliminary enquiry with a view to find out, if there is a prima facie case for a formal enquiry in the matter. The 'enquiry officer' under Rule 2 (c) means the 'District Panchayat Raj Officer' or any other 'district level officer' to be nominated by the District Magistrate. After submission of the preliminary enquiry report, the District Magistrate, under the delegated powers of the State Government may, considering the gravity of allegations and the prima facie proof, cease the administrative and financial powers of the Pradhan under the proviso to Section 95 (1) (g) of the Act of 1997, and initiate a formal enquiry under Rule 5 or may order a formal enquiry. In case he chooses to cease the financial and administrative powers, he is required to give a show-cause notice to serve the principle of natural justice, seeking the explanation from the concerned Pradhan on the charges found prima facie established in the preliminary enquiry report.

9. The word 'district level officer' has not been further defined in the Act or the Rules. The submission, that it must be read in the context namely that the officer should be equivalent in the rank to District Panchayat Raj Officer does not find support from the object and purpose of the Act and the Rules. The basis of an enquiry against the Pradhan is the complaint supported by the affidavit of the complainant or otherwise, when such information is received. The preliminary enquiry is made to find out prima facie truth in the complaint. If the allegations are found to be prima facie true and are serious in nature, the District Magistrate may cease the administrative and financial powers of the Pradhan. If the allegations are not so serious the matter may be dropped, or further enquiry may be directed or not be directed. The District Magistrate may order a 'three-member committee' to be constituted under Rule 5 to further enquire into the charges and in such case a detailed procedure is to be followed under Rules 6, 7 and 8 is to be followed.

10. The object and purpose of preliminary enquiry is to verify the truth of the allegations against the Pradhan and to collect, as far as possible, any material, which may form the basis of a formal enquiry. The submission that only the district head of the department is a district level officer has no co-relation with the object sought to be achieved by the preliminary enquiry. The District Panchayat Raj Officer is Head of the Department of the local bodies. He is as such relevant officer to make an enquiry. The rules however do not insist that any other officer to be nominated by the District Magistrate must also be Head of the Department of that district.

11. The object and purpose of the Act, and the nature of the office held by the Pradhan, requires that the District Magistrate has to be prima Jade satisfied with the truth of the allegations in the complaint and the material on the basis of which he may proceed to take further action in the matter. Such material may be collected by any officer nominated by him. The word 'district level officer' as such should not be confined only to the Head of the Department of the district stationed at the District Headquarters. The term at best may indicate a responsible officer. It is the District Magistrate, who has to ultimately satisfy with the material collected by the officer. The Courts need not insist that such officer should be equivalent of the rank of District Panchayat Raj Officer or should at least be heading any department in the district. Such a blind adherence to law would be too rigid and superfluous interpretation of Rule 4 of the Rules of 1997. It is the material collected sat sfies the District Magistrate, and is more relevant than the status held by the enquiry officer, loses its significance.

12. In administrative enquiries, the material collected by the competent authority, and not the person who collected the material, is relevant for the purposes of taking any action. Where the material collected and reported to the competent authority is relevant to the allegations he may rely upon it irrespective of the source from which it was collected. Further the competence of the officer conducting enquiry should be relevant to the allegations made against him. Where the technical evaluations of any constructions are in issue, an engineer would be more competent than the officer of any other department in example education or health, to conduct an enquiry. Similarly where the allegations relate to any scheme relating to health or education, the deputation of an officer of the Health Department or Education Department, as the case may be, would be more relevant. Once sufficient and relevant material is collected and the delinquent Pradhan is given a show cause notice alongwith enquiry report, the status of officer collecting the material loses significance. The Pradhan may allege mala fide, bias or prejudice, if there is any, against the enquiry officer. His insistence, that irrespective of the sufficiency or relevancy of the material the enquiry is vitiated. If it is conducted by an officer, who is lesser in status than District Panchayat Raj Officer, is incorrect and would not be taken as a ground to challenge the order. In all the judgments cited as above, the Courts have not interfered only on the ground that the enquiry officer was not of the status of a district level officer. The courts have further relied upon the sufficiency and relevancy of the material and have insisted that the concerned Pradhan must be given an opportunity to meet the allegations and material collected against him before any order is made against him.

13. In the present case, the preliminary enquiry was entrusted to the District Basic Education Officer. He asked the Assistant Basic Education Officer to make a spot inspection. The Assistant Basic Education Officer visited the school and talked to the children and the teachers. He was told by the Headmaster that the mid-day meal is being served. The children denied the fact. The report of the Assistant Basic Education Officer was forwarded by the District Basic Education Officer to the District Magistrate and on the basis of the material as well as the reply given by the village Pradhan, it was found that the children were not served with the 'mid-day meal' since August, 2007. This material was relevant and was sufficient to exercise powers under Section 95 (1) (g) of the Act.

14. Learned counsel for the petitioner submits that the meal was cooked in the school and that the Headmaster certified the same. The register, annexed as Annexure-8 to the writ petition, would show that in the remarks column it was clearly stated by the Headmaster of the school that the food was cooked at the house of the Pradhan and was sent to the school. The contradiction clearly establishes that the register was not correctly maintained and that prima facie the allegations were established against the Pradhan and were serious enough to cease her administrative and financial powers till the conclusion of the formal enquiry.

15. The writ petition is dismissed.