- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Subedar And Others v. State Of U.P .
Factual and Procedural Background
This is an appeal by three accused — Subedar (son of Narayan Nai), Ram Bhajan (son of Chandan Ahir) and Suraj Pal alias Sarju (son of Anokhey) — against the judgment and order dated 30.9.1981 of the VIII Additional Sessions Judge, Bareilly in Sessions Trial No. 465 of 1980. Each appellant had been convicted under section 302 read with section 34 I.P.C. (life imprisonment), section 307 read with section 34 I.P.C. (five years' rigorous imprisonment) and section 449 I.P.C. (seven years' rigorous imprisonment). All sentences were ordered to run concurrently.
The incident occurred on the night of 7/8 October 1980 at about 2 a.m. in village Riona Dhimra, P.S. Fatehganj East, District Bareilly. The F.I.R. was lodged on 8.10.1980 at 9:30 a.m. by Shyam Behari (PW 1), an eye-witness. One child, Morsri alias Meera (about 11 years old), was killed by gunshot injuries; four others — Om Prakash (PW 2), Sumilla, Katori Devi and Nanhey — sustained injuries (gunshot and a lathi injury). The prosecution alleged that the three appellants, together with an unknown fourth companion, came with weapons (a Paunia gun, country-made pistols and a lathi), fired upon the household, demanded a gun, and fled after opening fire.
Investigation followed the F.I.R. The post-mortem on the deceased was conducted by Dr. J.N. Bhargava (PW 7), and medical examinations of injured persons were performed by Dr. Shabbir Hussain (PW 4). The prosecution examined seven witnesses, including the doctors and investigating officer; material witnesses included Shyam Behari (PW 1), Om Prakash (PW 2, injured) and Sri Krishna (PW 3). The accused denied the allegations and gave a defence of false implication due to local factional enmity. The trial court convicted and sentenced the appellants as noted above; the present appeal challenges those convictions and sentences.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the convictions of the three appellants for the offences charged (including murder under section 302 I.P.C.) are justified by the evidence produced at trial.
- Whether identification evidence of the prosecution witnesses (including injured eye-witnesses) is reliable, given the nocturnal occurrence and alleged lighting conditions.
- Whether absence of a proven motive or the appellants' contention of no motive undermines the prosecution case.
- Whether discrepancies concerning the number of shots fired (as alleged by the defence) affect the credibility of the prosecution or travel to the root of the case.
- Whether the appellants were falsely implicated because of village party/factional enmity.
Arguments of the Parties
Appellants' Arguments
- The appellants denied the prosecution allegations and claimed false implication due to enmity and local party/factional rivalries; Subedar, Suraj Pal and Ram Bhajan each contended they were falsely roped in for reasons of party faction or past incidents (e.g., a dacoity).
- Learned Counsel for the appellants argued there was no motive to commit murder (the demand made by appellants at the scene for Ram Swaroop's gun suggested intent to commit robbery/dacoity rather than murder).
- They challenged the ocular evidence on the ground of lack of sufficient light at night to identify the accused accurately.
- Defence argued inconsistency between the number of shots reportedly fired (three shots, per some witnesses) and the multiple gunshot injuries suffered by victims — arguing that the numerical discrepancy undermines the prosecution case.
Prosecution's Position
- The opinion records the prosecution's case in detail: prompt lodging of F.I.R. by an eye-witness (Shyam Behari PW 1), testimony of injured eyewitness Om Prakash (PW 2) and other witnesses (Sri Krishna PW 3), medical/post-mortem evidence describing multiple gunshot injuries to the deceased and to injured persons, recovery by police of 29 pellets and two cartridge empties at the scene, and identification of the accused in the light of torches and a household lamp.
- The prosecution relied on contemporaneous identification at the scene, medical evidence consistent with the account of firing and injuries, the naturalness of the eyewitnesses, and lack of any persuasive evidence of concoction or motive to falsely implicate the accused.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Lula Ram (D) through Luli Chand v. State of Haryana | That the exact number of shots fired is immaterial in a case of shooting; contradictions as to number of shots do not necessarily affect the nature of the offence. | The court relied on this principle to reject the appellants' contention that a discrepancy between the number of shots reported and the gunshot injuries sustained by victims invalidated the prosecution's case; the court treated the numerical discrepancy as inconsequential to the core issue of guilt. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court examined the primary factual and evidential matters and applied established legal principles as follows:
- Motive: The court reiterated that motive is not substantive evidence and is often known only to the accused. Absence of motive does not undermine a case when there is direct evidence of accused's participation. The court observed that a demand for Ram Swaroop's gun at the scene did not preclude an intention to kill, and therefore rejected the appellants' argument that the demand indicated intent only to rob, not to murder.
- Identification and Light Conditions: The court carefully considered defence attacks on identification due to darkness. It accepted the trial court's finding that there was sufficient light — a Dibbi (small lamp) glowing inside the house and torches held by Shyam Behari (PW 1), Om Prakash (PW 2) and Sri Krishna (PW 3). The court also noted that the accused themselves flashed torches, undermining the contention that recognition was impossible. Given proximity, known relationship or acquaintance between witnesses and household members, and the presence of light sources, the court found the identifying testimony reliable.
- Credibility of Eye-witnesses and Corroboration: The court found the testimony of Shyam Behari (informant), Om Prakash (injured eye-witness) and Sri Krishna (neighbour) to be credible and consistent. Om Prakash being an injured eyewitness was given particular weight. The court emphasized the naturalness and immediacy of their presence and responses, noting adjacency of houses and proximity at the time of the incident.
- Number of Shots Argument: The court treated defence reliance on an alleged mismatch between the number of shots fired and the number of injuries as a superficial challenge. Quoting the precedent (Lula Ram), it held that the exact number of shots is immaterial; witnesses may not be able to map which shot hit which victim in a chaotic incident. Medical evidence could not definitively say whether the multiple injuries were caused by only two shots, but the court held this uncertainty did not negate the prosecution's case.
- Medical and Investigative Corroboration: The post-mortem and medical reports described multiple gunshot injuries to the deceased and injured persons, consistent with firing. Police recovered 29 pellets and two cartridge empties near the dead body and observed blood-stained earth at the scene. Such physical evidence corroborated the ocular testimony.
- False Implication/Factionalism Plea: The court rejected the stock plea of false implication due to party factions. It found no evidence that witnesses and accused belonged to opposing factions or that there was a motive for concoction; prompt lodging of the F.I.R., inclusion of eyewitness names therein, natural witness selection and medical evidence aligned with the ocular account militated against a finding of false implication.
- Conclusion of Analysis: After weighing identification, medical evidence, physical recovery at the scene, the demeanour and proximity of witnesses and the insufficiency of defence explanations, the court concluded that the convictions were supported by the evidence and that the appeal lacked merit.
Holding and Implications
APPEAL DISMISSED.
Holding (core ruling): The court dismissed the appeal and affirmed the convictions and sentences imposed by the Trial Court on the three appellants for the offences charged (including murder under section 302 I.P.C., attempt to murder under section 307 I.P.C., and house trespass under section 449 I.P.C.). The sentences, previously ordered to run concurrently, remain in force.
Immediate consequences and directions:
- The appellants, who were on bail, are to be arrested by the Chief Judicial Magistrate, Bareilly and sent to jail to serve the sentences imposed by the Trial Court.
- The Chief Judicial Magistrate was directed to report compliance within two months from the date of receipt of a copy of the order.
The opinion contains no extended discussion of broader legal implications or the establishment of any new binding precedent beyond its application of existing principles (including the cited Supreme Court authority on the immateriality of the exact number of shots in a shooting incident).
M.C Jain, J.:— There are three appellants, namely, (i) Subedar son of Narayan Nai, (ii) Ram Bhajan son of Chandan Ahir, and (iii) Suraj Pal alias Sarju Dhanuk son of Anokhey. They have preferred this appeal against the judgment and order dated 30.9.1981, passed by Sri Sushil Kumar, the then VIII Addl. Sessions Judge, Bareilly in Sessions Trial No. 465 of 1980. Each of them has been convicted under section 302 read with section 34 I.P.C with a sentence of life imprisonment under section 307 read with section 34 I.P.C with a sentence of five years' rigorous imprisonment and under section 449 I.P.C with a sentence of seven years' rigorous imprisonment. All the sentences have been ordered to run concurrently.
2. We have heard Sri K.D Tripathi, learned Counsel for the appellants and Sri Sudhir Kumar Agarwal, learned A.G.A from the side of State.
3. The relevant facts may be set forth. The incident occurred in between the night of 7/8.10.1980 at about 2 O'clock in village Riona Dhimra, P.S Fatehganj East, District Bareilly and the report was lodged on 8.10.1980 at 9.30 A.M by an eye-witness Shyam Behari PW 1. The distance of the police station from the place of occurrence was about 7 kms. One Morsri alias Meera daughter of Chhotey Lal was murdered in the incident whereas 4 others, namely, Om Prakash PW 2, Sumilla, Katori Devi and Nanhey sustained injuries. There was one another unknown companion of the present accused appellants. The accused appellant Subedar was allegedly armed with Paunia gun whereas two other accused appellants were armed with country made pistols and their unknown companion had a lathi. Shyam Behari PW 1 was sleeping in his house. At about 2 O'clock in the night he heard hue and cry emanating from the house of his brothers Chhotey Lal and Ram Ratan. He rushed up therewith a torch. Om Prakash PW 2 also reached, flashing his torch. They saw the present three accused appellants along with another unknown person with the weapons stated earlier. The accused appellants opened three fires to kill them and demanded the gun of Ram Swaroop. The shots hit Ram Swaroop, his mother and his brother Nanhey. Morsri daughter of Chhotey Lal was sleeping in the courtyard. Hearing the commotion, she was horrified and got up from the cot. One gunshot was inflicted upon her chest. Receiving the shot, she died at the spot. The wife of Chheda Lal was given lathi blow on the head by the 4th unknown companion of the accused appellants. All the inmates of the house were making hue and cry which attracted the villagers at the spot who challenged the accused appellants. Opening fire, they ran away from the place of occurrence through the northern door. They were very well identified in the light of torches on the spot and Dibiya (small lamp) glowing in the house of the incident. The miscreants were also flashing their torches during the commission of the offence. Ram Shankar, Sri Krishna and Bhajan Lal had also identified the accused appellant in the light of their torches.
4. On the lodging of the. F.I.R by Shyam Behari PW 1, a case was registered and the investigation entered into.
5. The Investigating Officer reached the spot and busied himself in the activities related to investigation. After preparation of the Panchayatnama of the, dead body of the deceased Morsri, he sealed it and sent for post-mortem which was conducted by Dr. J.N Bhargava PW 7 on 9.10.1980 at 3.30 P.M The deceased was aged about 11 years and about 1-½ days had passed since she died. The following ante-mortem injuries were found on her person:
1. Gunshot wound of entry .4 cm × .4 cm × skin deep on right side of forehead, 1 cm above lateral end of right eyebrow, no blackening or charring.
2. Gunshot wound of entry .4 cm × .4 cm × skin deep on right side of forehead, 1 cm above bridge of nose.
3. Three gunshot wounds of entry in an area 4 cm × 2.5 cm on left side of face just below left nostril, size .4 cm × .4 cm × skin deep.
4. Three gunshot wounds of entry in an area of 5 cm × 3 cm × skin deep on right side of cheek 2 cm below eyebrow, size .4 cm × .4 cm × skin deep.
5. Four gunshot wounds of entry 9 cm × 4 cm of posterior aspect of right upper arm, 3 cm below shoulder.
6. Multiple gunshot wounds of entry in area of 23 cm × 14 cm in front of chest and upper part of abdomen. Various size .4 cm × .4 cm × skin, muscle, chest and abdomen cavity deep, no blackening or charring is present.
7. Gunshot wound of entry .4 cm × .4 cm × skin deep in front of left shoulder joint.
8. Gunshot wound of entry .4 cm × .4 cm × abdomen cavity deep left side of abdomen, 7 cm below sub-costal margin.
6. The death had occurred due to shock and hemorrhage owing to firearm injuries.
7. Injuries of the injured Sumilla wife of Ram Ratan, Smt. Katori wife of Chheda Lal, Om Prakash PW 2 son of Ram Ratan and Nanhey son of Ram Ratan were examined by Dr. Shabbir Hussain PW 4, M.C of P.H.C, Fareedpur, Bareilly on 8.10.1980 at 6.05 P.M, 6.30 P.M, 6.45 P.M and 7.15 P.M respectively. The following injuries were found on their persons:
8. Injuries of Sumilla:
1. Two gunshot wounds .5 cm × .2 cm × skin deep on left side of head 2-½ cm apart from each other, backward and front 10 cm above left ear.
2. Gunshot wound .2 cm × .2 cm × skin deep on left side forehead just above left eyebrow.
3. Traumatic swelling 5 cm × 4 cm on upper and lower eyelid on left side.
4. Gunshot wound .2 cm × .2 cm × skin deep on right upper eyelid, swelling with traumatic swelling 5 cm × 4 cm on both eyelids.
5. Two gunshot wounds .2 cm × .2 cm × skin deep 1-½ cm apart from each other on back of right hand, 1 cm below right wrist, surrounded by traumatic swelling 5 cm × 5 cm.
6. Gunshot wound .3 cm × .2 cm × skin deep on right side of chest, 14 cm below right shoulder.
7. Multiple gunshot wounds in an area of 7 cm × 3 cm in front of right breast 3 cm above right nipple, each measuring .2 cm × .2 cm × skin deep.
8. Two gunshot wounds .2 cm × .2 cm × skin deep 3/4 cm apart from each other upward and downward over front surface of right upper arm, 4 cm above right elbow.
Injury of Smt. Katori:
1. Lacerated wound 5 cm × 1-½ cm × bone deep on back of head right side, 3 cm behind right ear, clotted blood present and under observation.
Injuries of Om Prakash:
1. Gunshot wound .3 cm × .3 cm × skin deep on back of right hand, ½ cm above the base of right ring finger.
2. Gunshot wound .2 cm × .2 cm × skin deep on front of right forearm middle.
3. Gunshot wound .2 cm × .2 cm × skin deep on front of right elbow joint of forearm.
4. Two gunshot wounds 8 cm apart from each other, on aspect of left index finger and root of left thumb.
5. Multiple gunshot wounds in an area of 9 cm × 3 cm in front of left upper arm, in front of left forearm upper part, each measuring .2 cm × .2 cm × skin deep.
6. Multiple gunshot wounds in an area of 15 cm × 10 cm on left shoulder region with left upper scapula region, each measuring .2 cm × .2 cm × skin deep to .4 cm × .2 cm × skin deep.
7. Abrasion 1 cm × .2 cm × skin deep on right cheek, 3 cm below right eye.
8. Abraison .2 cm × .2 cm × skin deep on right cheek, ½ cm outer to nose.
9. Multiple gunshot wounds in an area of 12 cm × 12 cm on front of chest, each wound measuring .2 cm × .2 cm × skin deep.
10. Multiple gunshot wounds in an area of 15 cm × 14 cm on front of right thigh middle, each measuring .2 cm × .2 cm × skin deep.
11. Two gunshot wounds 13 cm apart from each other, upper and lower ankle of right leg, each wound measuring 2 cm × .2 cm × skin deep.
12. Multiple gunshot wounds in an area of 11 cm × 5 cm on front of left thigh lower part and left knee, each wound measuring .2 cm × .2 cm × skin deep.
13. Two gunshot wounds 8 cm apart from each other, on front of left leg middle, each measuring .2 cm × .2 cm × skin deep.
Injury of Nanhey:
1. Gunshot wound .4 cm × .2 cm × skin deep on the top of left shoulder.
9. The accused denied the allegations of the prosecution and claimed to be tried. According to them, they had been falsely implicated due to enmity. Subedar stated that there were two parties in the village, one led by Ranveer and the other by Sher Singh. Shyam Behari PW 1 belonged to the party of Ranveer Singh and he himself belonged to Sher Singh's party. Owing to party factions, he was falsely roped in this case. Suraj Pal stated that a dacoity took place at the house of Chhotey Lal and Ranveer Singh got him implicated falsely due to enmity. Ram Bhajan also claimed false implication owing to party factions.
10. Besides relying on documentary evidence, the prosecution in all examined seven witnesses including the Doctors and Investigating Officer. The material witnesses were Shyam Behari PW 1, injured. Om Prakash PW 2 and Sri Krishna PW 3.
11. The accused appellants did not adduce any evidence in defence.
12. The submission of learned Counsel for the accused appellants is that there was no motive on the part of the accused appellants to commit this crime and that the witnesses examined by the prosecution were not reliable to warrant their conviction. We propose to examine the worth of these submissions in the discussion that follows.
13. So far as the question of motive is concerned, it is not evidence in a case. Moreover, motive is the hidden spring of human action and is exclusively known to the accused. The prosecution can only place on record the sequence of happening and the facts known to it. It is also well settled that motive becomes insignificant when there is direct evidence of the commission of a crime by the particular accused. Learned Counsel for the accused appellants has urged that the accused could have no motive to commit the murder of Morsri, inasmuch as, according to the earliest version of the prosecution related in the F.I.R and as per the evidence adduced in the Court, they (accused) had demanded the gun of Ram Swaroop and had commanded it to be given to them. According to the learned Counsel, it indicated that their intention was to commit robbery/dacoity and not murder. It appears to us that the prosecution has truthfully placed on record as to what was shouted by the accused at the scene of occurrence. But mere demand of gun of Ram Swaroop does not detract from their intention of committing murder.
14. It has been admitted by Shyam Behari PW 1 in his cross-examination that about seven years back Ram Swaroop was an accused in the case of kidnapping or abduction of a lady. He also admitted that Ram Swaroop was holder of a licensed gun. May be that the accused appellants had some grudge against Ram Swaroop in that connection and commanded the inmates of the houses to hand over his gun to them.
15. Morsri alias Meera aged about 11 years daughter of Chhotey Lal was an innocent child. Several shots were fired by the accused. Morsri died of gunshot injuries and a number of gunshot injuries were inflicted on others also, namely, Sumilla, Om Prakash PW 2 and Nanhey. Besides that, the blunt weapon (lathi) injury was inflicted on the person of Smt. Katori Devi. It bears testimony to the effect that the accused appellants were adamant to kill all the inmates of the family. It was just by providence because of the arrival of the witnesses and pressure built up by them, that they had to retreat, but before doing that they had caused extreme damage by committing murder of one person and inflicting injuries on four others. They are liable and answerable for the offences committed by them and cannot get away by raising the technical plea that mere was no motive or intention on their part to commit murder. We, therefore, reject this first argument advanced from the side of the accused appellants.
16. Learned Counsel for the accused appellants then tried to castigate the testimony of the eye-witnesses on the premise of the alleged non-availability of light. We have carefully scrutinized the evidence in this behalf and we firmly endorse the finding of the learned Trial Court that there was sufficient light to facilitate the witnesses to identify the accused appellants. We have emphatic testimony of Shyam Behari PW 1 and Om Prakash PW 2, injured that a Dibbi (small lamp) was glowing inside the house of Chhotey Lal. That apart. Shyam Behari PW 1 as well as Om Prakash PW 2 had flashing torches in their hands, illuminating the scene. The torchlight did facilitate them to recognize the appellants.
17. It has also come in the testimony of Shyam Behari PW 1 and Om Prakash PW 2 that the accused were also flashing their torches. Indeed, they could not commit the operation in pitched darkness. There is not the slightest doubt that there was sufficient light to facilitate the recognition of the accused appellants by the witnesses who were known to them from before.
18. The third witness, namely, Sri Krishna PW 3 (whose name also finds place in the F.I.R) had seen and recognized the accused appellants coming out from the house of Chhotey Lal. He, too, had a torch. He had come out of his house on hearing the hue and cry from the houses of Chhotey Lal and Ram Ratan as also the sound of firing. With the lathi and torch he had stood by the side of the wall of Niranjan in the northern side of the house of Chhotey Lal at a distance of 10-12 paces only.
19. All the three witnesses correctly described the weapons also of the accused appellants. They were subjected to searching cross-examination which they faced boldly and nothing could come out to shake their testimony as to the availability of light which facilitated them in identifying the accused appellants as the participants of this crime.
20. Another ground advanced by the learned Counsel for the accused appellants to assail the testimony of the eye-witness is that according to them, only three shots had been fired by the accused appellants, whereas the gunshot injuries sustained by Morsri deceased, Sumilla, Om Prakash and Nanhey, taken together, were much more which could not be possible by three shots only. In our opinion, the argument proceeds on a superficial approach of the matter. It is beyond question that the deceased and the above named three injured received gunshot injuries attributed to the firing resorted to by the present three accused appellants. It being so, the number of actual shots fired by them is insignificant. The Supreme Court has held in the case of Lula Ram (D) through Luli Chand v. State of Haryana,1 that the number of shots is immaterial in a case of shooting. Contradiction in this regard does not travel to the root of the nature of offence. Moreover, it should also be pointed out that out of eight gunshot injuries received by the deceased Morsri as recorded in her post-mortem report reproduced earlier, four were on the facial region and the rest were on right upper arm, chest, abdomen and left shoulder. Dr. J.N Bhargawa PW 7 (who conducted autopsy) was asked in his cross-examination as to whether her injuries could be the result of two shots. He could not say anything in this behalf definitely. But, as we said, it is inconsequential whether she was hit by one shot or two shots. True, the evidence of Shyam Behari PW 1 and Om Prakash PW 2 was that the accused appellants had opened three shots. It is there in the testimony of Shyam Behari PW 1 that the shots so fired by them had hit Om Prakash, Sumilla, Nanhey and Morsri. Om Prakash PW 2 stated that the shot fired by Subedar hit him whereas the shot opened by Suraj Pal alias Sarju hit his mother and brother Nanhey. According to him, Morsri had been hit by the shot fired by Ram Bhajan. It is also there in the testimony of Om Prakash PW 2 and Sri Krishna PW 3 that they had tired two more shots while leaving the spot. Indeed, in an incident of shooting like the present one, it cannot be expected of the witnesses to specifically fix up in their memory as to whose shots hit whom and how many shots were received by a particular victim. It is not at all possible to doubt the prosecution case on the premise of number of shots received by each of the victims and by all of them cumulatively. All the accused appellants resorted to shooting as a result of which one girl aged about 11 years died and other three received gunshot injuries, whereas fourth injured received blunt weapon injury at the hand of their unknown companion armed with lathi.
21. We have carefully scrutinized the testimony of eye-witness and the same is found inspiring judicial confidence. Out of the three witnesses, Om Prakash PW 2 is himself an injured whose testimony is entitled to great weight. Presence of other two eye-witnesses, namely, Shyam Behari PW 1 (informant) and Sri Krishna PW 3 (who saw the accused appellants and their fourth unknown companion/coming out of the house of Chhotey Lal and running) was also most natural. The house of Chhotey Lal was adjacent in the western side to that of Shyam Behari PW 1. Chhotey Lal being his brother, it was most natural that he (Shyam Behari PW 1), on hearing hue and cry from the houses of Chhotey Lal and Ram Ratan rushed to the scene with lathi and torch. Ram Swaroop and Ram Ratan are real brothers, being sons of Phuttu Lal and their houses were just adjacent in the west to that of Chhotey Lal. Ram Swaroop; and Ram Ratan are also brothers of Shyam Behari PW 1. Sri Krishna PW 3 was also the immediate neighbour, his house being just two houses away from that of Chhotey Lal. He woke up on hearing hue and cry from the houses of Chhotey Lal and Ram Ratan and the sound of three shots. Raising shouts, with lathi and torch he rushed towards the scene and stood by the side of the wall of Niranjan, 10 or 12 paces in the north of the house of Chhotey Lal where-from he saw the three accused appellants (whom he has named with their weapons) and their fourth unknown companion armed with lathi coming out of the house of Chhotey Lal and running towards the western side, opening two shots. Om Prakash PW 2 is the son of Ram Ratan. Chhotey Lal is his uncle. On the day of incident, his father as well as Ram Swaroop were not present at the house and had gone Out. On hearing shouts from the house of Chhotey Lal, he himself, his mother and brother Nanhey had awaken. He had flashed torch towards Chhotey Lal's house where his uncle Shyam Behari PW 1 had also reached with lathi and torch.
22. There is no manner to doubt the place of incident also. It deserves mention that blood stained earth had been found at the spot. The Investigating Officer had also recovered 29 pellets from near the dead body of the deceased girl. Two empties of cartridges were also found by him at the spot.
23. The stock plea of false implication owing to party factions does not carry conviction at all. Groupism on caste lines or because of petty polities is the normal feature of rural life but it does not mean that one would falsely implicate his opponents in serious offences. In the present case, there is no evidence to this effect either that the prosecution witnesses and the accused appellants belonged to opponent groups or factions.
24. As a matter of fact, there is no reason for the false implication of the accused appellants. The F.I.R was lodged without any delay. The names of the eye-witnesses find place therein. Out of the three eyewitnesses, one is himself the injured and inmate of the house where the incident occurred. The other two are also most natural witnesses of the incident. There was no attempt of any concoction on the part of the prosecution and it is clear from this fact that Shri Krishna PW 3 did not claim himself to be the witness of the actual incident. He deposed only about what happened before his eyes i.e, the three accused appellants and their fourth unknown companion coming out of the house of Chhotey Lal and fleeing towards the western side, firing two shots. Had there been any malice on the part of the prosecution against the accused appellants, he, too, could pose to be the witness of the actual incident. Nothing of the kind was done. The deceased and three injured sustained injuries of firearms used by the accused appellants. The fourth injured sustained lathi injury. It would be recalled that the lathi was wielded by the fourth unknown companion of the accused appellants. To say shortly, the medical evidence is in conformity with ocular version. The three accused appellants were acting in concert with their fourth unknown companion with previous meeting of minds.
25. To come to a close, we do not find any merit in the arguments advanced by the learned Counsel for the accused appellants in support of the appeal. The accused appellants have rightly been convicted and sentenced for the various offences committed by them.
26. We hereby dismiss the appeal. The accused appellants are on bail. The Chief Judicial Magistrate, Bareilly shall cause them to be arrested and sent to jail to serve out the sentences imposed upon them by the Trial Court. He shall report compliance within two months from the date of receipt of a copy of this order.
Appeal Dismissed.
Alert