Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Rama Shankar Gupta Revisionist v. Dukhna (Smt.) And Another Opp. Parties.

Allahabad High Court
Jan 7, 2004
Smart Summary (Beta)

Judgment Summary — Criminal Revision No. 76/99 & Criminal Appeals Nos. 156 & 157 of 1999

Factual and Procedural Background

The criminal revision and appeals arise from a judgment and order dated 11-1-1999 of the III Additional District & Sessions Judge, Sultanpur. The prosecution case alleges that Km. Manorama, a six-year-old child and cousin of the informant Umesh Pratap Gupta, was murdered. The primary accused were Jai Shree Yadav and Dhani Ram; two female accused, Smt. Sukhraji and Smt. Dukhana, were also tried. The prosecution's narrative describes that Smt. Dukhana, who was childless, sought the assistance of Jai Shree Yadav for a ritual; during this period Manorama went missing and four days later information surfaced indicating she had been murdered purportedly for a sacrifice (BALI).

An FIR (Ext. Ka-1) was lodged by the informant at Lambhua police station. Investigation was conducted by Sri Ram Naresh Yadav (PW 13), who sealed the dead body, arranged post-mortem, prepared the site-plan (Ext. Ka-11) and submitted the charge-sheet (Ext. Ka-13). All four accused were charged under Sections 302/34 and 201 IPC. After trial, the Sessions Judge convicted Jai Shree Yadav and Dhani Ram and acquitted Smt. Sukhraji and Smt. Dukhana. The two convicted persons appealed (Criminal Appeals Nos. 156 & 157 of 1999) and the complainant preferred Criminal Revision No. 76 of 1999 against the acquittals. The High Court heard counsel for the parties and delivered a common judgment determining these matters.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the convictions of Jai Shree Yadav and Dhani Ram can be sustained where the prosecution case rests on circumstantial evidence including extra‑judicial confessions and recoveries under Section 27, Evidence Act.
  2. Whether omissions in the FIR and statements under Section 161 Cr.P.C. materially undermine the prosecution witnesses or the case against the accused.
  3. Whether the High Court may convert a finding of acquittal into one of conviction in revision proceedings (with reference to Section 401(3), Cr.P.C.).

Arguments of the Parties

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Chand Mal & another v. State of Rajasthan, 1976 SCC (Crl.) p. 120 The three tests for convicting on circumstantial evidence: (1) each circumstance must be firmly and cogently established; (2) taken cumulatively the circumstances must form a chain so complete that there is no escape from the conclusion of the accused's guilt; (3) the circumstances must be of a definite tendency unerringly pointing to guilt. The Court applied these tests and held that the prosecution had established circumstances (extra‑judicial confessions, recoveries and motive) which cumulatively formed a complete chain pointing to the guilt of Jai Shree Yadav and Dhani Ram.
Dayanidhi Bisoi v. State Of Orissa, 2003 SCW 3491 Followed the Chand Mal principles on circumstantial evidence. The Court noted that the Supreme Court has followed the same view in this ruling and relied on the established tests when assessing the circumstantial case before it.
State Of U.P v. Babu Ram, 2000 SCC (Crl.) 845 Also follows Chand Mal principles on circumstantial evidence. Referenced as a recent authority endorsing the Chand Mal tests; used to support the conclusion that the prosecution's circumstantial case was complete and cogent.
Piaru Singh & others v. State of Punjab, 1977 ACC 374 Holds that the law does not require that the evidence of an extra‑judicial confession must in all cases be corroborated. The Court relied on this principle to sustain reliance on proved extra‑judicial confessions where these confessions were supported by independent witnesses and an investigating officer without apparent animus.
Bhuleshwar Babern v. State, 1982 Criminal Law Journal 2346 Support for treating extra‑judicial confessions as a valid basis for conviction when they are true and voluntary. The Court held that the confessions in the instant case were true and voluntary and that the conviction and sentences based on confession were unassailable per this authority.
Krishna Chandra Santra v. State, 1986 Criminal Law Journal 2077 Seizure and recovery of victim's belongings from accused can be a most incriminating circumstance in circumstantial cases. The Court treated recoveries (weapon BANKA and victim's clothes) proved under Section 27 as highly incriminating and as connecting the accused with the crime.
State of Haryana v. Sher Singh & others, 1981 C.A.R. 122 FIR need not contain full details of occurrence; omissions in FIR do not automatically amount to contradictions. The Court used this authority to hold that omissions in the FIR were not material and did not render witnesses unreliable.
Matadin and others v. State of U.P., 1979 ACC 55 (Summary) Statements made to police under Section 161 are brief in nature and cannot substitute for court evidence. The Court cited this to explain that omissions in Section 161 statements are not fatal and do not make a witness a "self-contained liar."
Shyam Balu Chaugle v. State of Maharashtra, 1976 Criminal Appeals Reporter 49 Medical evidence can corroborate witness testimony and support the prosecution case. The Court relied on medical evidence (post‑mortem) corroborating witness testimony to strengthen reliance on the prosecution case.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court proceeded by examining the nature and sufficiency of the prosecution's evidence and whether it satisfied established legal standards for circumstantial cases and confession evidence. Key elements of the Court's analysis, as stated in the opinion, are summarized below.

  1. Absence of eyewitnesses: The Court acknowledged that no prosecution witness is alleged to have seen the killing; therefore the case necessarily rests on circumstantial evidence (para 5).
  2. Application of Chand Mal tests: The Court expressly applied the three tests from Chand Mal (firm establishment of circumstances; cumulative chain complete to exclude all reasonable hypotheses except guilt; and circumstances of definite tendency) and observed that these tests must be met where conviction rests on circumstantial evidence (paras 6–9).
  3. Extra‑judicial confessions: The Court found that extra‑judicial confessions were proved. Krishna Kumar Singh (PW 3) deposed to a confession by Dhani Ram; Raj Bahadur Singh (PW 6) deposed to a confession by Jai Shree Yadav and also proved recoveries under Section 27. The Investigating Officer (PW 13) corroborated the confessions and recoveries (para 8). The Court relied on authorities (Piaru Singh, Bhuleshwar Babern) to hold that confessions so proved may be relied upon even without further corroboration when they are proved true and voluntary.
  4. Recoveries under Section 27: Witnesses PW 6 and PW 9 and the IO (PW 13) testified to recovery of the weapon (BANKA) and the deceased's clothes at the instance of the accused. The Court treated these recoveries as strongly incriminating, citing Krishna Chandra Santra for the principle that such seizures are highly probative in circumstantial cases (para 9).
  5. Medical evidence: Post‑mortem evidence by Dr. A.K. Khare (PW 14) established that death resulted from an incised wound to the neck by a sharp‑edged weapon like a BANKA. The Court regarded the medical evidence as corroborating the witnesses' testimony (para 11).
  6. On omissions in FIR and Section 161 statements: The Court recognized defence submissions about omissions but held, following State of Haryana v. Sher Singh and Matadin v. State of U.P., that omissions in FIR and brief police statements are not necessarily material contradictions; police statements are brief and cannot supplant trial testimony. Therefore the omissions did not render witnesses unreliable (para 10).
  7. Cumulative conclusion: Considering extra‑judicial confessions, recoveries under Section 27, motive and medical corroboration, the Court concluded that circumstances taken cumulatively formed a complete chain of events that, within all human probability, pointed to the guilt of Jai Shree Yadav and Dhani Ram and excluded other hypotheses (paras 7, 12).
  8. On revision against acquittal: The Court noted Section 401(3), Cr.P.C., which it quoted to show that a High Court is not authorized to convert a finding of acquittal into one of conviction in revision proceedings (para 13). Thus, the revision against acquittal of Smt. Sukhraji and Smt. Dukhana could not result in their conviction.

Holding and Implications

Holding: All appeals by the convicted persons (Jai Shree Yadav and Dhani Ram) and the revision filed by the complainant challenging the acquittals were dismissed; the judgment and order of the trial court was maintained in its entirety. The convictions and sentences of Jai Shree Yadav and Dhani Ram were upheld. The two female accused (Smt. Sukhraji and Smt. Dukhana) remained acquitted.

Implications:

  • The direct effect on the parties is that the convictions of Jai Shree Yadav and Dhani Ram stand and they remain in custody to serve the imposed sentences (para 14).
  • The complainant's revision against the acquittal of Smt. Sukhraji and Smt. Dukhana failed; under Section 401(3), Cr.P.C. the High Court cannot convert an acquittal into a conviction in revision (para 13).
  • The opinion does not claim to lay down any new legal precedent; rather it applies existing Supreme Court authorities and established principles to the facts before the Court. No broader, novel legal rule was announced in the judgment beyond its application to the present facts.

Disposition: Appeals dismissed; revision dismissed; trial court judgment maintained.

Show all summary ...

Kamal Kishore, J.-

Criminal Revision No. 76/99 as well as Criminal Appeal Nos. 156 and 157 of 1999 have been preferred against the judgment and order dated 11-1-1999 passed by Sri Shamshad Ali, the then III Additional District & Sessions Judge, Sultanpur, hence the criminal revision as well as criminal appeals are being decided by a common judgment.

2. The case of the prosecution, in brief, is that the deceased Km. Manorama, aged about 6 years, is the cousin sister of the informant Umesh Pratap Gupta. Both the convict appellants Jai Shree Yadav and Dhani Ram belong to the same village. Accused Smt. Sukhraji is the wife of convict Dhani Ram, while accused Smt. Dukhana is their daughter. Accused Smt. Dukhana was issue less and was trying to have issue. She took the help of convict Jai Shree Yadav, who used to do OJHA (a worship for removing evil spirit). It was the period of 'NAV RATRA'. The accused Smt. Dukhana came to the house of her father Dhani Ram where the convict Jai Shree Yadav was summoned, who used to do Tantran- Mantran so that Smt. Dhukhana may be get a child. The victim Manorama went to see television as usual. She had not returned on the day of occurrence, hence the informant side had search for her. It was on the fourth day of her since she was missing. Khelayee (PW 7) told regarding the murder of Manorama on which the informant reached the place of occurrence and found that some one has committed her murder with motive to commit sacrifice (BALI). The FIR (Ext. Ka-1) regarding the occurrence was lodged by the informant Umesh Pratap with the police station Lambhua within District Sultanpur on the basis of which chick FIR (Ext. Ka-5) was prepared. The case was investigated by Sri Ram Naresh Yadav (PW 13) S.O. of P.S. Lambhua, District Sultanpur, who has got the dead-body sealed and sent the same to mortuary for post- mortem and prepared the site-plan (Ext. Ka-11). Sri Ram Naresh Yadav (PW 13) SC has recorded the statement of the witnesses and has submitted the charge-sheet (Ext. Ka-13) after completing the investigation.

3. The charge was framed against all the four accused persons for the offences punishable under Sections 302/34 and 201 IPC. The accused pleaded not guilty to the charge framed against them. After full trial, the Additional District & Sessions Judge, Sultanpur has convicted Jai Shree Yadav of Criminal Appeal No. 156 of 1999 and Dhani Ram, who has preferred Criminal Appeal No. 157 of 1999 and has acquitted both the ladies accused Smt. Sukhraji and Smt. Dukhana for the aforesaid offences. Feeling aggrieved by the conviction, the accused have preferred both the aforesaid criminal appeals and the complainant has preferred Criminal Revision No. 76 of 1999.

4. We have heard the arguments of parties' Counsel in the aforesaid revision as well as the appeals preferred by the convicts.

5. None of the witnesses, examined by the prosecution, is alleged to have seen the occurrence of murder and the prosecution has believed its case on circumstantial evidence mainly extra- judicial confession made by the convicts Dhani Ram and Jai Shree Yadav and recovery made under Section 27 Evidence Act on the instance of both convicts, coupled with the motive etc.

6. It has been held by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the ruling reported in 1976 SCC (Crl.) p. 120, Chand Mal & another v. State of Rajasthan, that when a case rests entirely on circumstantial evidence must satisfy three tests :

Firstly, the circumstances from which an inference of guilt is sought to be drawn, must be firmly and cogently established.

Secondly, these circumstances, taken cumulatively, should form a chain so complete that there is no escape from the conclusion that within all human probabilities; the crime was committed by the accused and none-else. That is to say, the circumstances should be incapable of explanation on any reasonable hypothesis save that of accused's guilt.

Thirdly, the circumstances should be of a definite tendency unerringly pointing towards the guilt of accused.

7. The same view has been followed by Hon'ble Supreme Court in recent ruling also as reported in 2003 SCW 3491, Dayanidhi Bisoi v. State Of Orissa. and 2000 SCC (Crl.) 845, State Of U.P v. Babu Ram.. In the instant case, the prosecution has established its case against the accused cogently and firmly. The circumstantial evidence, adduced by the prosecution, of definite tendency unerringly pointing towards the guilt of the accused and the circumstances, if taken cumulatively, do form a complete chain to prove that in all probability the crime was committed by the accused and none-else.

8. The prosecution has proved the chain of extra-judicial confession. The prosecution has examined Krishna Kumar Singh (PW 3), who has deposed regarding extra-judicial confession made by the convict-accused Dhani Ram and PW 6 Raj Bahadur Singh, who has deposed regarding extra-judicial confession made by the convict- appellant Jai Shree OJHA (wizard). Raj Bahadur Singh (PW 6) has also proved the recovery of the articles under Section 27 Evidence Act. The Investigating Officer examined by the prosecution, as PW 13 has also corroborated the extra-judicial confession made by the accused and the recovery of BANKA, the weapon of assault in the instant case as well as the frock and kachchha of victim Km. Mandrama at the instance of accused Jai Shree Yadav and Dhani Ram. It has been held by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the ruling, reported in 1977 ACC 374, Piaru Singh & others v. State of Punjab, that law does not require that the evidence of an extra-judicial confession should in all cases be corroborated. In the instant case, the extra- judicial confession was proved by an independent witness and a responsible officer, who bore no animus against the accused and there was hardly any justification for the Sessions Judge to disbelieve the evidence. We find that the extra-judicial confessions were true and voluntary and accordingly, the conviction and sentences, based on confession were unassaiable as per the ruling, reported in 1982 Criminal Law Journal 2346, Bhuleshwar Babern v. State. Accordingly, in view of the aforesaid ruling of Hon'ble Supreme Court, we find that the extra-judicial confession, made by the accused Jai Shree Yadav and Dhani Ram inspires confidence and the prosecution has been able to prove this chain of extra-judicial confession also.

9. Raj Bhadur Singh (PW 6) and Ram Yagya Pathak (PW 9) have deposed regarding recovery of weapon of assault and clothes were by victim Km. Manorama. PW 13, the Investigating Officer of this case has duly proved the recovery and seizure of the articles at the instance of Jai Shree Yadav and Dhani Ram, convict- appellants. This separates the case. The recovery and seizure of the articles recovered under Section 27 Evidence Act is most incriminating circumstance. In a case of like nature where victim's muffler and radio were recovered from the possession of the accused, the seizure of the articles was held to be the most incriminating fact in the case, based on circumstantial evidence, as per the ruling reported in 1986 Criminal Law Journal 2077, Krishna Chandra Santra v. State. Under these circumstances, we find that the prosecution has connected the accused with the present crime.

10. The defence has also pointed out some omissions in the FIR and in the statements of the witnesses, made under Section 161 Cr. P.C. The Hon'ble Supreme Court has observed in State of Haryana v. Sher Singh & others, 1981 C.A.R. 122, that the FIR need not contain the details of occurrence and omission in the FIR is not a contradiction. In Matadin and others v. State of U.P., 1979 ACC 55 (Summary), it was held that the statements, given by the witnesses before the police are meant to be brief statements and could not take the place of evidence in the Court. As such the omissions here and there in the FIR or statements under Section 161 Cr. P.C. pointed out by the defence, are firstly not material and secondly these FIR and the statements are meant to be brief. The statement, given before the trial Court, must contain full facts and circumstances leading to those facts. Hence, such omissions did not make a witness self- contained liar and the argument of the learned Counsel for the defence, to the contrary is not tenable.

11. The case of the prosecution and the testimony of the witnesses examined by the prosecution finds further support from the medical evidence. The prosecution examined Dr. A.K. Khare (PW 14), who has conducted post-mortem on the dead-body of victim Km. Manorama. On the post-mortem, Dr. A.K. Khare has found incised wound on the neck of the deceased by which the throat of the victim was cut away. He has further deposed that the deceased has died during the relevant date and time as a result of injuries sustained by sharp edged weapon like BANKA. The medical evidence thus corroborates the testimony of the witnesses and supports the case of the prosecution and since the testimony of the witnesses is supported by the medical evidence also, we have every reason to place reliance on the testimony of the witnesses and the case of the prosecution, as has been held by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the ruling reported in 1976 Criminal Appeals Reporter 49, Shyam Balu Chaugle v. State of Maharashtra.

12. Thus we find that so far as the convict-appellants Jai Shree Yadav and Dhani Ram are concerned, the prosecution has firmly and cogently established the circumstances of extra-judicial confession, recovery made under Section 27 Evidence Act and the motive of the convict-appellants to commit the present crime and these circumstances, taken cumulatively form a complete chain to the effect that there is no escape from the conclusion that within all human probability, the crime was committed by the convict-appellants and none-else. The circumstances are of definite tendency unerringly pointing towards the guilt of both the appellants.

13. The complainant Rama Shanker Gupta has filed revision against the acquittal of Smt. Dukhana and Smt. Sukhraji. According to Section 401(3) of Criminal Procedure Code, nothing in this section shall be deemed to authorize a High Court to convert a finding of acquittal into one of conviction.

14. In the result, the revision preferred by the complainant as well as both the appeals preferred by both convicts Jai Shree Yadav and Dhani Ram are dismissed. The judgment and order recorded by the learned trial Court is maintained in its totality. Convicts Jai Shree Yadav and Dhani Ram (both the appellants) are in jail and shall serve out the imprisonment awarded to them.

Appeal dismissed.