Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Smt. Tahira Petitioner v. State Of U.P And Others

Allahabad High Court
Nov 11, 2010
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner, Smt. Tahira, filed a writ petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India seeking to quash two orders: one dated 9.11.2009 passed by the Chief Judicial Magistrate (CJM), Sidharth Nagar, and another dated 21.5.2010 passed by the Additional Sessions Judge, Court No. 1, Sidharth Nagar. The petitioner had initially moved an application under section 156(3) CrPC before the CJM, which was registered as Misc. Criminal Case no. 1203/2009. The CJM dismissed the application on the ground that the occurrence took place in Bombay, and thus he lacked jurisdiction. The Additional Sessions Judge upheld this dismissal in a criminal revision petition, relying on the Supreme Court decision in Manish Ratan and others v. State of Madhya Pradesh. The petitioner challenged these orders on jurisdictional grounds, asserting that part of the cause of action arose within the territorial jurisdiction of the CJM, Sidharth Nagar.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Chief Judicial Magistrate, Sidharth Nagar, had jurisdiction to entertain the application under section 156(3) CrPC despite part of the alleged offence occurring outside his territorial jurisdiction.
  2. Whether the offence of cruelty for dowry can be considered a continuing offence for the purpose of jurisdiction under sections 177, 178, and 179 CrPC.
  3. Whether the orders of the CJM and Additional Sessions Judge dismissing the application on jurisdictional grounds were legally sustainable.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner’s Arguments

  • The petitioner contended that the deceased was subjected to cruelty and harassment within the territorial jurisdiction of the CJM, Sidharth Nagar, as the husband’s house was located there.
  • It was alleged that the accused took the deceased to Bombay with intent to kill her, but the initial torture and harassment continued in Sidharth Nagar, constituting part of the cause of action within that jurisdiction.
  • The petitioner argued that jurisdiction should be determined based on the allegations in the complaint and not merely on the location where the final act occurred.

Respondents’ Arguments

  • The respondents, supported by the orders of the CJM and Additional Sessions Judge, maintained that since the occurrence took place in Bombay, the CJM, Sidharth Nagar, lacked jurisdiction.
  • The Additional Sessions Judge relied on the Supreme Court decision in Manish Ratan and others v. State of Madhya Pradesh, which held that cruelty for dowry is not a continuous offence, to dismiss the revision petition.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Manish Ratan and others v. State of Madhya Pradesh, 2007 (1) SCC 267 Held that the offence of cruelty for dowry is not a continuous offence and jurisdiction lies where the entire cause of action arises. The court distinguished this case on facts, noting that unlike Manish Ratan, in the present case, the cruelty and harassment continued within the jurisdiction of the CJM, Sidharth Nagar, thus jurisdiction was valid there.
Sujata Mukherjee (Smt) v. Prashant Kumar Mukherjee, AIR 1997 SC 2465 Application of sections 178(b) and (c) CrPC regarding continuing offences committed partly in one area and partly in another, allowing jurisdiction in any such area. The court applied this principle to hold that since the offence of dowry harassment was continuing and partly committed within Sidharth Nagar, the CJM had jurisdiction to entertain the application.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court analyzed the jurisdictional provisions under sections 177, 178, and 179 of the CrPC. Section 177 mandates that offences be tried in the jurisdiction where they are committed, while section 178 allows for jurisdiction in cases where offences are committed partly in multiple local areas or are continuing offences. Section 179 further allows jurisdiction where an offence results from acts and consequences occurring in different areas.

The court found that the Additional Sessions Judge misapplied the precedent in Manish Ratan by not appreciating the factual differences. Unlike the cited case, where the victim had no allegations of harassment in the jurisdiction where the application was filed, here the petitioner alleged continuous cruelty and harassment within the territorial jurisdiction of the CJM, Sidharth Nagar.

Relying on the Supreme Court’s ruling in Sujata Mukherjee, the court held that the offence of dowry cruelty and harassment is a continuing offence, and jurisdiction can be exercised by courts in any local area where part of the offence occurred. Since part of the cause of action arose within Sidharth Nagar, the CJM had jurisdiction to take cognizance under section 190 CrPC and entertain the application under section 156(3) CrPC.

Therefore, the dismissal of the application on the ground of lack of jurisdiction was incorrect and could not be upheld.

Holding and Implications

The court’s final decision was to allow the writ petition and quash the impugned orders dated 9.11.2009 and 21.5.2010.

The Chief Judicial Magistrate, Sidharth Nagar, was directed to reconsider the application under section 156(3) CrPC and pass a fresh order in accordance with law.

This decision directly reinstates the petitioner’s right to have the application heard by the CJM, Sidharth Nagar, but does not establish any new legal precedent beyond clarifying the application of jurisdictional provisions in continuing offences of dowry cruelty.

Show all summary ...

Hon'ble Shri Kant Tripathi, J.

Heard the learned counsel for the petitioner (Smt. Tahira) and the learned AGA for the respondents and perused the record. This is a writ petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India for quashing the order dated 9.11.2009 (Annexure no. 4) passed by the Chief Judicial Magistrate, Sidharth Nagar and order dated 21.5.2010 (Annexure no. 5) passed by the Additional Sessions Judge, Court No. 1, Sidharth Nagar in criminal revision no. 185/2009.

The facts of the case are that the petitioner moved an application under section 156 (3) CrPC in the court of Chief Judicial Magistrate, Sidharth Nagar, which was registered as Misc. Criminal Case no. 1203/2009. Learned Chief Judicial Magistrate dismissed the application on the ground that the occurrence took place in Bombay, therefore, he had no jurisdiction to entertain the petition under section 156 (3) CrPC. Learned Additional Sessions Judge was also of the same view and he accordingly dismissed the revision. The Additional Sessions Judge placed reliance on Manish Ratan and others v. State of Madhya Pradesh and another, 2007 (1) SCC 267 and held that the offence of cruelty for the dowry is not a continuous offence. In my opinion, the learned Additional Sessions Judge failed to appreciate the facts of the aforesaid case. In that case the victim had been given maltreatment for dowry in the house of her husband. She left the house of her husband and started to live in the house of her parents within the territorial jurisdiction of the Magistrate at Datiya, Madhya Pradesh. In that case there was no allegation that any torture, harassment or demand of dowry was made during the period the victim had been living with her parents, and the entire cause of action had arisen in the house of her husband within the local limits of the courts at Jabalpur. In this view of the matter, the Supreme Court held that the court at Datiya had no jurisdiction. In my opinion, in the present case, the allegations are that the deceased had been subjected to cruelty and harassment in the house of her husband for dowry. Her husband's house situates within the territorial jurisdiction of the Chief Judicial Magistrate, Sidharth Nagar. It was also stated in the application that the accused persons, with the intention of killing the deceased, took her to Bombay and killed her there and buried the dead body, therefore, according to the allegations made in the petition filed under section 156 (3) CrPC the torture and harassment to the deceased was given within the territorial jurisdiction of the courts at Sidharth Nagar and continued that torture even in Bombay, therefore, it can not be contended that the entire cause of action arose only in Bombay. According to the allegations made in the complaint, a part cause of action arose well within the jurisdiction of Chief Judicial Magistrate, Sidharth Nagar. The question of jurisdiction should be decided on the basis of allegations made in the complaint and not on any other basis. If the complaint allegations are taken at their face value, it can not be inferred that no cause of action arose within the territorial jurisdiction of the C.J.M Sidharth Nagar.

According to section 177 CrPC, every offence shall ordinarily be inquired into or tried by a court within whose local jurisdiction it was committed. According to section 178 CrPC, when it is uncertain in which of several local areas an offence was committed, or where an offence is committed partly in one local area and partly in another, or where an offence is a continuing one, and continues to be committed in more local areas than one, or where it consists of several acts done in different local areas, the offence may be inquired into or tried by a court having jurisdiction over any of such local areas. According to section 179 CrPC, when an act is an offence by reason of anything which has been done and of a consequence which has ensued, the offence may be inquired into or tried by a court within whose local jurisdiction such thing has been done or such consequence has ensued.

In the case of Sujata Mukherjee (Smt) v. Prashant Kumar Mukherjee, AIR 1997 SC 2465, the Apex Court applied the provisions of section 178 (b) and (c) of the Code of Criminal Procedure in regard to the offence of demand of dowry and harassment, which was found as a continuing offence, committed partly in one area and partly in another, and held that the court having jurisdiction over any of such areas has power to inquire into and try the matter.

It is no doubt true that power under section 156 (3) CrPC is to be exercised by the Magistrate who has the power to take cognizance of the offence under section 190 CrPC, therefore, he can direct for police investigation under section 156 (3) CrPC. When a part cause of action arose within the territorial jurisdiction of Chief Judicial Magistrate, Sidharth Nagar, he had power to take cognizance of the offence under section 190 CrPC, therefore, he had also jurisdiction to entertain the application under section 156 (3) CrPC and to pass appropriate order on merit. The views of the courts below that the learned Chief Judicial Magistrate, Sidharth Nagar had no jurisdiction, were not correct and as such can not be upheld.

For the reasons discussed above, the instant writ petition is allowed. The impugned orders dated 9.11.2009 (Annexure no. 4) and dated 21.5.2010 (Annexure no. 5) are quashed and the learned Chief Judicial Magistrate, Sidharth Nagar is directed to reconsider the matter and pass a fresh order in accordance with law.

Order Date :- 11.11.2010

RKSh