- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Dhanveer And Others Petitioner v. State Of U.P & Another
Judicial Opinion Summary
Factual and Procedural Background
This application under Section 482 Cr. P. C. was filed by Dhanveer and three others seeking quashment of the charge-sheet dated 12.1.2000 (Annexure 6) submitted in N. C. R. No. 311 of 2009 under Sections 323, 504 and 506 I. P. C. and of the entire proceedings of Case No. 1113 of 2010; State v. Dhanveer and others, and of the summoning order dated 7.5.2010 (Annexure 7) passed by the Judicial Magistrate, Court No. 1, Aligarh.
According to the material on record, the opposite party no. 2 filed a non-cognizable report on 3.12.2009 at P. S.-Iglas, District-Aligarh, upon which N. C. R. No. 311 of 2009 under Sections 323, 504 and 506 I. P. C. was registered. Opposite party no. 2 then moved an application under Section 155(2) Cr. P. C. requesting that the police station be directed to investigate. Pursuant to that order the police investigated and submitted a charge-sheet under Sections 323, 504 and 506 I. P. C. in the Court of Judicial Magistrate, Court No. 1, Aligarh, and Case No. 1113 of 2010; State v. Dhanveer and others, was registered. By order dated 7.5.2010 the Judicial Magistrate-Ist, Iglas, Aligarh summoned the applicants to face trial for the offences alleged.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether offences punishable under Sections 323, 504 and 506 I.P.C., being non-cognizable, permit the police charge-sheet (submitted after investigation) to be treated as a State case (i.e., permit cognizance to be taken by the Magistrate) or must such a charge-sheet be treated as a complaint under the Explanation to Section 2(d) Cr. P. C.?
- Whether the summoning order dated 7.5.2010 that proceeded on the basis of the police charge-sheet as a State case was legally permissible where the offences are non-cognizable?
Arguments of the Parties
Applicants' Arguments
- The offences alleged under Sections 323, 504 and 506 I.P.C. are non-cognizable, and therefore, by the Explanation to Section 2(d) Cr. P. C., a police report after investigation disclosing commission of a non-cognizable offence must be deemed to be a complaint and the police officer who submits it is deemed to be the complainant.
- Consequently, the matter could not proceed as a State case and had to proceed as a complaint case; the learned Magistrate erred in taking cognizance on the charge-sheet and issuing the summoning order dated 7.5.2010.
Opposite Party / A.G.A.
- Learned A. G. A. vehemently opposed the submissions made by learned counsel for the applicants. (No further detail of the opposition was recorded in the opinion.)
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Virendra Singh and others v. State of U. P. and others, 2000 (2) JIC 649 (All) : 2000 (45) ACC 609 | Held the Uttar Pradesh Government Notification No. 777.VIII-94 (2)-87 (which had made Section 506 IPC cognizable and non-bailable) to be illegal. | Used to establish that the earlier notification making Section 506 cognizable was invalid, and therefore Section 506 IPC is to be treated as a non-cognizable offence for present purposes. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court examined the record, the impugned summoning order and the relevant provisions of the Code of Criminal Procedure. It accepted that the offences under Sections 323, 504 and 506 I.P.C. are non-cognizable. Although an earlier Uttar Pradesh government notification had attempted to make Section 506 cognizable, the Division Bench decision in Virendra Singh (cited above) held that notification illegal, so Section 506 remains non-cognizable.
The court relied on the Explanation to Section 2(d) Cr. P. C., which provides that "A report made by a police officer in a case which discloses, after investigation the commission of a non-cognizable offence shall be deemed to be a complaint; and the police officer by whom such report is made shall be deemed to be the complainant." From this, the court reasoned that a charge-sheet submitted by the police in respect of a non-cognizable offence must be treated as a complaint and the procedural rules for complaint cases apply.
Applying that principle to the facts, the court concluded that the investigating officer's charge-sheet in this case should have been treated as a complaint and not as a State case. Thus, the Magistrate's action in taking cognizance of the charge-sheet as a State case (and issuing the summoning order dated 7.5.2010) was not permissible under law.
The opinion records that the learned A.G.A. opposed the applicants' submissions, but provides no elaboration of the opposing arguments; the court nonetheless found the applicants' submissions to have force.
Holding and Implications
The application is allowed in part and the summoning order dated 7.5.2010 is quashed.
Implications:
- The direct effect is that the impugned summoning order dated 7.5.2010 is set aside.
- The court directed that the matter shall be treated as a complaint case and that the procedure prescribed for hearing of a complaint shall be followed by the court concerned before any fresh summoning of the applicants.
- The opinion does not purport to lay down any broader new precedent beyond applying the Explanation to Section 2(d) Cr. P. C. and the cited Division Bench authority concerning the invalidity of the notification; no express statement was made that this decision sets a new legal principle beyond the application to the present facts.
Date of Order: 7.9.2010
Heard learned counsel for the applicants and learned A. G. A. and perused the record.
This application under Section 482 Cr. P. C. has been filed by Dhanveer and three others with a prayer for quashing the charge-sheet dated 12.1.2000 (Annexure 6) submitted in N. C. R. No. 311 of 2009 under Sections 323, 504 and 506 I. P. C. and the entire proceedings of Case No. 1113 of 2010; State v. Dhanveer and others registered against the applicants pursuant to the submission of the aforementioned charge-sheet as well as the summoning order dated 7.5.2010 (Annexure 7) passed by the Judicial Magistrate, Court No. 1, Aligarh.
Learned counsel for the applicants submitted that the opposite party no. 2 filed a non-cognizable report on 3.12.2009 at P. S.-Iglas, District-Aligarh against the applicants on the basis of which N. C. R. No. 311 of 2009 under Sections-323, 504 and 506 I. P. C. was registered. The opposite party no. 2 moved an application before the Judicial Magistrate-I, under Section 155 (2) Cr. P. C. with a prayer that the concerned police station be directed to investigate the matter. Pursuant to the order passed on the aforesaid application the matter was investigated and police submitted a charge-sheet under Sections-323, 504 and 506 I. P. C. in the Court of Judicial Magistrate, Court No. 1, Aligarh against the applicants whereupon Case No. 1113 of 2010; State v. Dhanveer and others was registered against the applicants and the Judicial Magistrate-Ist, Iglas, Aligarh by the order dated 7.5.2010 summoned the applicants for facing trial for the offences punishable under Sections-323, 504 and 506 I. P. C. Learned counsel for the applicants submitted that the offences under Sections 323, 504 and 506 I. P. C. are non-cognizable, hence in view of the Explanation to Section 2 (d) of the Code of Criminal Procedure, the case could not proceed as State Case and it had to proceed as a complaint case. He further submitted that the learned Magistrate has erroneously passed an order taking cognizance on the charge-sheet.
It is not disputed that the offences under Sections 323, 504 and 506 I. P. C. are not-cognizable. The offence under Section 506 I. P. C. was made cognizable and non-bailable vide the Uttar Pradesh government Notification No. 777.VIII-94 (2)-87 dated July, 1989 published in U. P. Gazette, Extra Part-4 Section (Kha) dated 2nd August, 1989. This notification issued by the Government was held to be illegal by Division Bench of this Court in the case of Virendra Singh and others v. State of U. P. and others, 2000 (2) JIC 649 (All) : 2000 (45) ACC 609, and so the position now is that the offence under Section 506 I. P. C. is also a non-cognizable offence.
It is clear from above that all the three offences punishable under Sections 322, 504 and 506 I. P. C. are non-cognizable.
Explanation to Section 2 (d) of the Cr. P. C. runs as under:
“Explanation__A report made by a police officer in a case which discloses, after investigation the commission of a non-cognizable offence shall be deemed to be a complaint; and the police officer by whom such report is made shall be deemed to be the complainant.
In view of the said Explanation report of the police officer after investigation disclosing commission of non-cognizable offence is to be deemed to be a complaint and the police officer who submitted the report has to be deemed to be a complainant. In other words the charge-sheet submitted by the police in a noncognizable offence shall be treated to be a complaint and the procedure prescribed for hearing of complaint case shall be applicable to that case.”
In the present case from the material brought on record it transpires that the charge-sheet submitted by the Investigating Officer instead of being treated as a complaint, has been taken cognizance of by the concerned Magistrate as a State Case, which is not permissible under law.
Learned A. G. A. vehemently opposed the submissions made by learned counsel for the applicants.
After having considered the submissions made by learned counsel for the parties and perused the material on record as well as the impugned summoning order and examined the relevant provisions of the Code of Criminal Procedure, I am of the view that the submissions made by learned counsel for the applicants have force and are liable to be accepted.
For the aforesaid reasons, the present application is allowed in part, the summoning order dated 7.5.2010 is quashed. However, it is made clear that the case shall be treated to be a complaint case and the procedure prescribed for hearing of the complaint shall be followed by the court concerned before summoning the applicants.
Dated: 7.9.2010
Alert