Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Manindra Kumar Rai v. Paresh Chandra Dey .

Gauhati High Court
Mar 10, 1971
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The plaintiff filed a suit seeking declaration of right, title, and delivery of khas possession of certain land, along with a permanent injunction restraining the defendant from digging trenches and constructing a brick wall on the suit land. The defendant contested the claim, asserting that the disputed land did not correspond to the dags alleged by the plaintiff and that the brick wall was being constructed on his own land. The plaintiff requested a commission for a local investigation and survey of the land under Order XXVI, Rule 9 of the Code of Civil Procedure (CPC). The Munsiff appointed the Sub-Deputy Collector as Commissioner to survey the land, but the Commissioner could not provide a definite report. Subsequently, the Munsiff conducted a local inspection and measurement of the land, prepared a report indicating possession details, and rejected the plaintiff's application for a re-commission to ascertain encroachment by the defendant. The plaintiff filed a revision application against this refusal.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Munsiff erred in refusing the plaintiff’s prayer for a commission to conduct a local investigation and survey under Order XXVI, Rule 9 of the CPC.
  2. Whether the Munsiff improperly exercised jurisdiction under Order XVIII, Rule 18 of the CPC by effectively acting as a Commissioner and thereby denying the plaintiff the opportunity to cross-examine or produce further evidence.
  3. Whether the impugned order amounts to an illegal or materially irregular exercise of jurisdiction warranting interference under Section 115(c) of the CPC.

Arguments of the Parties

Defendant's Arguments

  • The defendant, through the Advocate-General of Meghalaya, argued that no case had been decided by the learned Munsiff against which revision under Section 115 of the CPC would lie.
  • Relied on Supreme Court precedents, particularly Baldevdas Shtvlal v. Filmistan Distributors ((1969) 2 SCC 201 : AIR 1970 SC 406) and S.S Khanna v. F.J Dillon (AIR 1964 SC 497), to contend that interlocutory orders may not attract revisional jurisdiction unless injustice is caused.

Plaintiff's Arguments

  • The plaintiff contended that the measurement and local inspection conducted by the Munsiff were incorrect and inadequate.
  • Prayed for a commission to be re-issued to properly survey the land and ascertain encroachment by the defendant using the old approved map.
  • Asserted that the impugned order denied him the opportunity to cross-examine or present further evidence regarding the key issue of land measurement.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Baldevdas Shtvlal v. Filmistan Distributors ((1969) 2 SCC 201 : AIR 1970 SC 406) Scope of revisional jurisdiction under Section 115 of the CPC regarding interlocutory orders. Used to address the preliminary objection that no revisional jurisdiction arises if no final case has been decided; court held that some interlocutory orders may be revised to prevent injustice or delay.
S.S Khanna v. F.J Dillon (AIR 1964 SC 497) Interpretation of the term "case" under Section 115 of the CPC as including parts of proceedings, not just entire suits. Supported the view that revisional jurisdiction includes interlocutory orders that affect the progress of the suit.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court analyzed the nature of the impugned order and the manner in which the Munsiff conducted the local investigation. Although the Munsiff purported to act under Order XVIII, Rule 18 of the CPC (which permits inspection of property), he effectively conducted a local investigation akin to a Commissioner’s role under Order XXVI, Rule 9 of the CPC by measuring the land and preparing a report. Under Order XVIII, Rule 18, the court’s inspection is limited to appreciation of evidence and does not allow cross-examination or make the court a witness. Conversely, a Commissioner appointed under Order XXVI, Rule 9 must be examinable by the parties, ensuring procedural fairness.

The Munsiff’s approach deprived the plaintiff of the opportunity to challenge the measurement or present further evidence, thereby prejudicing the plaintiff’s right to a fair trial. By undertaking the investigation and producing a report without allowing examination or further inquiry, the Munsiff effectively disqualified himself from adjudicating the matter impartially.

Given that the impugned order was passed early in the suit, before evidence was produced or issues framed, it hindered the proper progress and termination of the trial. The Court found that the learned Munsiff acted illegally or with material irregularity in exercising jurisdiction, thereby attracting Section 115(c) of the CPC. The preliminary objection that no revisional jurisdiction existed was overruled, and the impugned order and report were quashed to prevent injustice and ensure proper trial.

Holding and Implications

The Court allowed the revision application, quashed the impugned order refusing the plaintiff’s prayer for a commission, and directed that the plaintiff’s application for a survey commission under Order XXVI, Rule 9 of the CPC be granted. The case record was ordered to be sent back to the court below for expeditious trial.

This decision ensures that procedural fairness is maintained by requiring proper investigation through a Commissioner who can be examined by the parties, preserving the plaintiff’s right to challenge evidence. The Court emphasized adherence to procedural rules distinguishing inspection from investigation, thereby preventing premature and prejudicial adjudication. The ruling directly affects the parties by enabling a fair trial on the critical issue of land measurement, but it does not establish any new legal precedent beyond the application of existing procedural safeguards.

Show all summary ...

Goswami, C.J:— This application in revision is directed against the order of the Munsiff, Sibsagar refusing to allow the prayer of the plaintiff for a commission to make local investigation by a proper survey under Order XXVI, Rule 9 of the CPC.

2. We may note how the matter arose in the suit before the learned Munsiff. The plaintiff brought a suit for declaration of light title and delivered of khas possession of certain land described, in the schedule to lite plaint and for permanent injunction restraining the defendant from digging trenches and raising brick wall on the suit land. The defendant resisted the claim stating that the disputed land does not fall in the dags as alleged. He contended that a brick wall was being constructed on his own land and not on the land of the plaintiff. The defendant raised various other pleas also.

3. On the prayer of the plaintiff, the Munsiff appointed the Sub-Deputy Collector of Sonari Circle as Commissioner to survey and measure the land in question. On 12th July, 1967 he submitted a report, which disclosed that he could not give a definite account of the suit land after investigation for certain reasons mentioned therein. Ultimately, the Munsiff held a local inspection of the suit land on 6th April, 1968 in presence of both parties. The Munsiff got the suit land measured by the Lot Mandal according to the old map.

4. The learned Munsiff also submitted a report about the measurement. It was stated in the said report that after measurement it appeared that the plaintiff was in possession of 2K. 15L. of Dag No. 330 (old) and the defendant was in possession of 1 K. 4 L. of the same dag (2 lechas more than he purchased). On 28th May, 1968, the plaintiff filed an application supported by an affidavit stating that the memorandum of local inspection prepared by the learned Munsiff was not correct on the grounds given in that petition. He, therefore, prayed for re-issue of a Commission to the Sub-Deputy Collector or Surveyor Kanango to ascertain the encroachment made by the defendant in Dag No. 330 (old) with the help of the old approved map. The learned Munsiff rejected that prayer and hence this revision.

5. At the very outset, the learned Advocate-General of Meghalaya appearing on behalf of the defendant, submits that this application should be rejected as no case has been decided by the learned Munsiff against which a revision application may lie under Section 115 of the CPC. He relies on a decision of the Supreme Court in (1969) 2 SCC 201 : (AIR 1970 SC 406), Baldevdas Shtvlal v. Filmistan Distributors. It will appear that this decision has reiterated what had been earlier decided by the Supreme Court in AIR 1964 SC 497, S.S Khanna v. F.J Dillon and the following passage at para. 11 is apposite:

“The expression “case” is a word of comprehensive import: it includes civil proceedings other than suits, and is not restricted by anything contained in the section to the entirety of the proceeding in a civil court. To interpret the expression “case” as an entire proceeding only and not a part of a proceeding would be to impose a restriction upon the exercise of powers of superintendence to which the jurisdiction to issue writs, and the supervisory jurisdiction are not subject, and may result in certain cases in denying relief to an aggrieved litigant where it is most needed, and may result in the perpetration of gross injustice.”

6. It is true that every interlocutory order may not attract the revisional jurisdiction of the High Court, but there may be some orders which, if not interfered with at the proper time, will lead to Inordinate delay in disposal of the real issues raised in the suit and in many cases resulting in hardship and injustice. As we will show presently, this preliminary objection is of no force.

7. By the impugned order, the learned Munsiff purported to exercise his power under Order XVIII, Rule 18 of the CPC. Since the measurement of the land was done in pretense of the plaintiff and his lawyer, it is held by the Munsiff that he cannot raise any objection to the measurement. The learned Munsiff observed:

“I fail to understand as to how this court, which itself made the investigation, can revise its earlier order, x x x it is seen from the Memorandum that the measurement of the suit land was just and there cannot be any ground for rejecting the said measurement, x x x”

8. It is, therefore, clear that although the learned Munsiff wanted only to do an inspection of the land in suit under Order XVIII, Rule 18 of the CPC, he was actually constituting himself a Commissioner for surveying the land with the help of the land records staff under Order XXVI, Rule 9 of the CPC. The report which has been read to us also shows that certain measurement has been done and some conclusion has been arrived at by the learned Munsiff. Under Order XXVI, Rule 9 of the CPC the court, in an appropriate case, may issue a commission to such person as it thinks fit directing him to make such investigation and to report thereon to the Court. Under sub-rule (2) of Rule 10 of that Order, the Court or, with its permission, any of the parties to the suit, may examine the Commissioner personally in open Court touching any of the matters referred to him or mentioned in his report, or as to his report, or as to the manner in which he has made the Investigation. Under sub-rule (3), where the Court is for any reason dissatisfied with the proceedings of the Commissioner, it may direct such further inquiry to, be made as it shall think fit. Under Order XVIII, Rule 18, it was not possible for the Munsiff to make a local investigation in the manner done in this suit. Under that rule, the Court may, at any stage of a suit, inspect any property or thing concerning which a question may arise. Although the Court is empowered to inspect the property in a suit at any stage, it is not permissible for the Court to conduct an enquiry in order to furnish evidence in the suit for a proper decision of the issues raised in the suit. Power under Order XVIII, Rule 18 is ordinarily exercised in order to appreciate the evidence adduced in the suit by inspection of property or thing concerning which any question is raised. The Court in its discretion uses this power in a proper case. When the Court inspects the property under this Rule, it makes a memorandum of inspection for the purpose of the record. There can be no cross-examination of the court with regard to such a report and the court does not become a witness to the proceeding by making this inspection. On the other hand, a Commissioner under Order XXVI. Rule 9 has to offer himself as a witness, if required, to satisfy the court regarding the correctness or accuracy of his report or even about the manner in which he has conducted the proceeding. This right under Order XXVI, Rule 10 is available to either party in the suit. By the impugned order, the court, although purported to exercise its power under Order XVIII, Rule 18 of the CPC, in fact, made a survey report and also at the same time denied opportunity to the plaintiff to question the same or to furnish other appropriate evidence which he thinks, should be given in order to establish his case with regard to the measurement of the land in suit. In other words, the court in this case has become a witness to the most important issue about the actual measurement of the area of the land and its location and this was the only serious Issue to be fought between the parties in the suit. After having performed the function of the Commissioner under Order XXVI, Rule 9, as it appears to be, the learned Munsiff almost disqualified himself from further continuing adjudication of the suit. Besides, by the impugned order, the learned Munsiff has refused the plaintiff an opportunity to furnish evidence which he considers necessary for the purpose of the suit. This is, therefore, a case in which the learned Munsiff has acted, even in the exercise of his jurisdiction, illegally or with material irregularity. A proper trial has been forestalled, as it were, by the impugned order. If we allow this order to remain, there will be absolutely no proper trial or adjudication of the main issue in this suit. Besides, the impugned order has been passed only after submission of the written statement before production of any evidence by the parties and even prior to the framing of the Issues in this suit. Section 115(c) of the CPC is clearly attracted in this case and that is the reason why we have already overruled the preliminary objection of the respondent. It is clear that progress of the trial to a proper termination under the legal process has been hindered by the impugned order. We ave, therefore, no hesitation in quashing the impugned order as well as the report of the Munsiff dated 8th April, 1968, which we hereby do under Section 115 of the CPC.

9. In the result, the application is allowed and the plaintiff's application for survey commission under Order XXVI, Rule 9 of the CPC is allowed. There will be no order as to costs. The records shall go down to the court below Immediately for an expeditious trial.

10. D.M Sen, J.:— I agree.

11. Application allowed.