Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Haridas Das v. Santa Rani Das And Ors. Opposite Parties.

Gauhati High Court
Dec 19, 1991
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

This Civil Revision challenges the judgment and order dated 19.4.91 passed by the District Judge, Karimganj, which dismissed the appeal and affirmed the order dated 12.4.89 by the Munsiff No. 2, Karimganj, declining to restore Title Suit No. 201 of 1985. The petitioner initially filed a Title Suit against Kalipada Das (deceased) and others, which was dismissed for default on 11.12.85. Subsequently, the petitioner filed multiple applications under Order 9 Rule 9 of the Civil Procedure Code seeking restoration of the suit and later restoration of earlier applications, all of which were dismissed for default. After dismissal of the third such application, the petitioner filed an appeal before the District Judge, which was also dismissed, leading to the present revision petition under Section 115 of the Code of Civil Procedure.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether an appeal lies under Order 43 Rule 1(c) of the Civil Procedure Code against the dismissal of a petition filed under Order 9 Rule 9 for restoration of an earlier petition also filed under Order 9 Rule 9.
  2. Whether subsequent applications under Order 9 Rule 9 for restoration of earlier dismissed applications are maintainable and the scope of appeal against orders rejecting such applications.
  3. The legal effect and interplay between concurrent remedies available under Order 9 Rule 9 and Order 43 Rule 1(c) of the Civil Procedure Code.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The learned District Judge committed illegality and material irregularity in dismissing the appeal.
  • There was sufficient cause preventing the petitioner from appearing on the dates of hearing of the suit and subsequent miscellaneous cases.

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the respondent's legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court examined the procedural history and the applicability of provisions under the Civil Procedure Code, particularly Order 9 Rule 9 and Order 43 Rule 1(c), along with Section 141. It clarified that when an application under Order 9 Rule 9 is dismissed for default, the plaintiff may file another application under the same provision for restoration of the earlier application. Both remedies—an application under Order 9 Rule 9 and an appeal under Order 43 Rule 1(c)—are concurrent and can be pursued simultaneously. However, no appeal lies against the dismissal of a second application under Order 9 Rule 9 that seeks restoration of an earlier application, as the second application is not for restoration of the suit itself but for restoration of the earlier application. The court further reasoned that the appeal filed by the petitioner after dismissal of the third application was not maintainable under the relevant provisions. Consequently, without delving into the merits, the court dismissed the revision petition, holding that there was no illegality or material irregularity in the District Judge’s order.

Holding and Implications

The petition under Section 115 of the Code of Civil Procedure is dismissed.

The direct effect of this decision is the affirmation of the District Judge’s dismissal of the appeal and the refusal to restore the suit or earlier applications. The court did not find any illegality or irregularity warranting interference. No new precedent was established beyond the clarification of the concurrent remedies under Order 9 Rule 9 and Order 43 Rule 1(c) of the Civil Procedure Code. The costs were left as they stood, with no order as to costs.

Show all summary ...

1. This Civil Revision is directed against the judgment and order dated 19.4.91 passed by the learned District Judge, Karimganj in Misc. Appeal No. 4/90 dismissing the appeal and affirming the order dated 12.4.89 passed by the Munsiff No. 2, Karimganj, in Misc. Case No. 147/88 declining to restore the title Suit No. 201 of 1985.

2. The petitioner filed a Title Suit in the Court of Munsiff No. 1, Karimganj, against Kalipada Das (since deceased). The Predece-ssors-in-interest of the Opposite Parties. The said Title Suit was dismissed for default on 11.12.85 On 20.12.85 the petitioner filed a petition under Order 9 Rule 9 read with Section 151 of the Civil Procedure Code for restoration of the suit. This petition was registered as Misc. Case No. 88/85. This petition was also dismissed for default on 27.7.87-Against the order of dismissal, the petitioner instead of filing an appeal, filed yet another petition in the Court of the Munsiff No. 2, Karimganj under Order 9 Rule 9 of the Civil Procedure Code and this petition was registered and numbered as Miscellaneous Case No. 81/87. This Miscellaneous case was also dismissed for default on 17.11.88 Against this order of dismissal, the petitioner filed another Miscellaneous Case No. 147/88 in the Court of Munsiff No. 2, for setting aside the order of dismissal dated 17.11.88 By order dated 12.4.89, the learned Munsiff No. 2, dismissed the said Miscellaneous case also. Against that order of dismissal, a Miscellaneous Appeal was filed before the learned District Judge. Karimganj. This appeal was numbered and registered as Miscellaneous appeal No. 4/90. The learned District Judge, after considering the submissions made by the petitioner and on perusal of the records, dismissed the appeal holding that the appeal had no merit and thereby affirmed the order passed by the learned Munsiff No. 2, Karimganj.

3. The petitioner has come before this Court invoking the power under Section 115 of the Code of Civil Procedure against the judgment dated 19.4.91 passed by the District Judge, Karimganj.

4. I have heard the learned counsel for both the parties. The learned counsel for the petitioner urged that the learned District Judge committed illegality and with material irregularity in exercise of his jurisdiction by dismissing the appeal. He also urged that there was sufficient cause which prevented the petitioner in appearing on the date of hearing of the suit and subsequent Miscellaneous cases.

5. Before entering into the merit of the case, it is to be seen whether the appeal lies under Order 43 Rule (1)(c) of the Civil Procedure Code against the dismissal of a petition filed under Order 9, Rule 9, to restore another petition under Order 9, Rule 9 of Civil Procedure Code for restoration of a suit which was dismissed for default.

6. Now the main question is when an application under Order 9, Rule 9 of the Civil Procedure Code is dismissed for default ano ther application can be filed under the said provision and whether the provision of Order 9, Rule 9 is applicable in the subsequent peti tion to restore the petition under Order 9, Rule 9 of the Civil Pro cedure Code, dismissed for default. On the dismissal of the suit as per Rule 9, Order 9, the plaintiff can file application for restoration of the suit. If the said application is also dismissed for default, the plaintiff may file another petition for restoration of the said application under the provisions of Order 9 Rule 9 of the Code of Civil Procedure, as the said application also comes within the purview of Rule 9, Order 9 in view of section 141 of Code of Civil Procedure. Now it is to be seen that whether an appeal will lie under Order 43 Rule 1(c) of the Code of Civil Procedure when the second petition for restoration of the earlier petition filed under Order 9 Rule 9 to restore a suit which was dismissed either by default of on merit. The second petition which was filed for restoration of an earlier petition was not to set aside the dismissal of a suit, it was only for an order to set aside the dismissal of an application.

7. Therefore, when an application under Order 9 Rule 9 of Code of Civil Procedure is itself dismissed for default, it is apparent that an application lies under Order 9, Rule 9 read with Section 141 of the Civil Procedure Code for restoration of the said application. This is clear from the provisions laid down under Section 141 of the Civil Procedure Code. In order to succeed this second petition, the petitioner has to satisfy the court that he was prevented by suffici-ent cause from appearing on the date, when the application was called on for hearing.

8. The order of dismissal for defaults the application is appea lable under Clause (c) of Rule 1 of Order 43 of the Civil Procedure Code. Both the remedies by way of application under Order 9, Rule 9, and the appeal under Order 43, Rule 1(c) are concurrent. They can be resorted simultaneously. Neither excludes the other. The scope of each of the above proceedings are different. When an appeal is decided, one way or other, the order of dismissal for default appealed from gets merged in the order of the appellate court, and thereby, the applications filed under Order 9, Rule 9 becomes jnfructuous. But no appeal lies from an order rejecting the applica tion under Order 9, Rule 9 filed for restoration of the earlier appli cation under Order 9, Rule 9, which was dismissed for default.

9. It is now settled that as per provision of Section 141 of the Civil Procedure Code, an application under the provision of-Order 9, Rule 9 for restoration of an earlier application filed for restoration of a suit is maintainable. But, as stated above, any order passed in the second petition is not appealable under the provision of Order 43, Rule 1(c), inasmuch as, the second petition is not for restoration of a suit, but for restoration of an application filed under Order 9, Rule 9 of the Civil Procedure Code.

10. In the instant case, when the first application filed under Order 9, Rule 9 was dismissed for default, the petitioner had two-avenues available, one to prefer an appeal under Order 43, Rule 1(c) and another an application under Order 9, Rule 9 for restoration;: of the earlier application. The petitioner choosed the second remedy and filed an application for restoration of the earlier application: invoking the power under Order 9, Rule 9 of the Civil Procedure-Code, which was also dismissed. Thereafter, another application was filed for restoration of the said application, which was dismissed on contest. After the said order of dismissal of the third petition, the petitioner preferred an appeal.

11. In my view, the appeal itself was not maintainable as per provision of Order 9, Rule 9, read with Section 141 of the Civil Procedure Code. That being the position, I am constrained to hold that the appeal itself was not maintainable. Therefore, without going to the merit of the case, I dismiss the petition, inasmuch as there is nothing to show that the learned District Judge committed any illegality and with material irregularity in exercise of the jurisdiction. Therefore, the petition deserves dismissal, which I accordingly do.

12. In view of the facts and circumstances of the case, I make no order as to costs.