- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Amura Rathniah v. Mysore Kasamma .
(1) This is a civil revision petition against the order of the district judge, secunderabad, the appellate authority in rent control proceedings. The petitioner is the tenant.
(2) An application was filed by the landlady for eviction of the tenant on two grounds : (a) that the tenant was irregular in the payment of rent and was in arrears to the extent of rs. 80 upto 11th june, 1953 and (b) that he had put up an unauthorised construction in the house. A counter was filed by the tenant to say that he was never irregular in payment and that the practice generally was for the landlady to send her men at an interval of two or three months to collect the rent and on the last occasion as the landlady refused to receive the rent, it was sent by m. O. The landlady examined on her side her husband who is her duly constituted agent and the tenant examined himself and another witness.
(3) The rent controller came to the conclusion that the construction of the shed did not amount to an act of waste, and as such it did not furnish a ground for eviction but he relied upon sub - section 2 (1) of section 10 of the hyderabad houses (rent, eviction and lease) control act, 1954, which said that the tenant was liable to be evicted if he had not paid or tendered rent due by him within 15 days after the expiry of the time fixed in the agreement of tenancy with his landlord or where there is no agreement, on failure to pay by the last day of the month next following for which the rent is payable, the tenant was liable to be evicted. In the instant case he was of the opinion that the tenant was irregular in the payment of rents and defaulted to pay or tender rents continuously for 4 months. The explanation offered by the tenant, viz. , that he expected that the landlady's husband would take the rent did not appeal to him. He, therefore, directed eviction on the ground of wilful default, purporting to act under section 10 (2) (1) of the act referred to. The appellate authority, the district judge, secunderabad, concurred with the rent controller and held that there was a wanton omission on the part of the tenant to pay the rent due, justifying eviction. The tenant has come up in revision. Learned counsel argued that both the tribunals fell into an error in coming to a conclusion that there was wilful default on the part of the tenant, and that the approach of both the subordinate tribunals was entirely wrong.
(4) The tribunals below have based their decision, directing the eviction of the tenant, on the sole ground of wilful default on the part of the tenant. Therefore the question to be considered is whether having regard to the evidence led in the case, and the other circumstances disclosed by the evidence, the finding could be upheld. Ordinarily the revisional court would be loath to interfere with concurrent findings of fact. As the expression " wilful default " has obtained a technical significance in the law relating to rent control, this court would have to consider whether on the facts established the inference has been correctly drawn. What may be considered to be a wilful default in ordinary parlance may not amount to wilful default as envisaged by the rent control law.
(5) The tenant's allegation is that the usual practice was for the landlady to send ther servants to collect the rents and this used to be done not necessarily every month but sometimes once in two or three months. The first allegation is rebutted by the landlady's husband (who is her agent) but with regard to his second allegation he states in his deposition : "rents were used to be paid by the respondent once in two months and sometimes once in three months and i used to receive the same without any objection. " :so far as the first allegation is concerned it may be stated that in the absence of a contract to the contrary the lessee must seek out his landlord and make the payment to him. The further question that has to be considered is whether the fact that sometimes a landlord used to accept rents after they had accumulated to 3 or 4 months, could the tenant take it as an established practice and pay the rent once in two or three months and not every month as agreed to. A practice cannot foe said to have been established of collecting rents perodically once in two months and sometimes once in 3 or 4 months. Although it may not be urged as a ground for committing default in payment of rent, neverthless in order to determine as to whether there was a wanton and deliberate omission by the tenant to constitute "wilful default" this circumstance may be taken into consideration. " wilful default" connotes that the default or omission has been the result of deliberation and supine indifference. As to whether the omission was deliberate and intentional would have to be judged from the various circumstances arising in the case, such, as past conduct, the normal behaviour of the tenant in the discharge of his obligations to the landlord and performing the other conditions of the tenancy.
(6) It may be observed that the spirit of the original hyderabad rent control order of 1353 - f (1944) and of the act of 1954 was that in a proper case the court, before passing an order of eviction on the ground of default, would take into consideration as to whether the tenant has been guilty of gross negligence amounting to wilful default in paying the rent, and if the court was of the opinion that there was no wanton and deliberate omission on his part, the court would relieve the tenant from the penalty of eviction for non - payment of rent.
(7) That the object of all legislation relating to house accommodation control is to penalise only deliberate and wanton defaulters is also clear from the corresponding section, viz. , section 12 in the bombay rent control act of 1947 which says :
" (1) a landlord shall not be entitled to the recovery of possession of any premises so long as the tenant pays, or is ready and willing to pay, the amount of the standard rent and permitted increases, if any, and observes and performs the other conditions of the tenancy, in so far as they are consistent with the provisions of this act".
(8) According to this section the tenant is entitled to retain possession of the premises if he is ready and willing to pay all the amount of the standard rent and permitted increases, and further on condition that he observes and performs other conditions of the tenancy. It may be observed that there is a locus penetentiae allowed to the defaulting tenant if he pays or tenders in court at the hearing of the suit the standard rent or the permitted increases together with costs, of the suit.
(9) The hyderabad high court had occasion to construe the provisions of section 8 (3) of the hyderabad rent control order of 1353 - f. (1944) and the view taken by the court was that a tenant would be held to be willing and ready to pay if he actually tendered the amount when the rent controller was ready to hear the objections of the parties before him, and did not adopt a cantankerous attitude. The same question came up for consideration before the hyderabad high court after the coming into force of the hyderabad houses (rent, eviction and lease) control act, 1954. While considering the scope of the proviso to section 10 (2) (1) of the act which is as follows :
"provided that in any case falling under clause (i) if the controller is satisfied that the tenan's default to pay or tender rent is not wilful, he may before making an order as aforesaid give the tenant a reasonable time not exceeding 15 days, to pay or tender the rent to the landlord up to the date of such payment or tender",
The learned judges held that the rent controller had been given a discretion under the above proviso to give time to the tenant to pay if the default according to the rent controller was not wilful. Vide joint family firm of maisanna and sons v. C. K. Durvasulu, i. L. R. (1955) hyd. 584.
(10) These decisions would indicate that in order to arrive at a finding of the tenant being in wilful default the only fact of the tenant being in arrears of rent would not be enough, but the court would have to consider as to whether there was a conscious violation of the obligation to pay rent or that he had exhibited a supine indifference. In this case the landlady's husband has admitted in his evidence : "sometimes rents used to be paid by the tens". T once in two months and sometimes once in three months and i used to receive the same without any objection ". This circumstance coupled with the fact that the accrued rent was sent by m. O. , without demur before the proceedings commenced would not warrant a conclusion that the tenant was a wilful defaulter. A default is different from wilful default which has not been established in this case. The finding of the tribunals that the tenant made wilful default cannot be sustained in the circumstances of this case, and is therefore set aside and this revision allowed with costs. Revision allowed.
Alert