Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Bada Kristappa Alias Krishna Reddy v. Maya Kuntla Narasimha Reddy & Others

Andhra Pradesh High Court
Jul 11, 1980

(1) The plaintiff filed the suit against five defendants for a declaration of his title and for a permanent injunction restraining the defendants from interfering with his possession and enjoyment of the suit property. His case was that the suit land of aa extent of act 10. 20 cents in survey number 292 of nagareddipalli, kadiri taluk exclusively belonged to the 1st defendant, who sold it to the plaintiff under the registered sale deed dated 4th april, 1955 for rs. 1, 800/ - , at the time of the sale, an extent of act 1 - 75 cents which was the remaining portion in that survey number was sold to the 5th defendant, who was in possession and enjoyment of that portion. The 5th defendant's portion was a separate plot divided by ridges. The 2nd defendant is the junior paternal uncle of the 1st defendant, the 4th defendant is the son of the 2nd defendant, and the 3rd defendant is the grandson of the senior paternal uncle of the 1st defendant. Defendants 4 and 5 are the attestors to the sale deed in favour of the plaintiff. It is alleged that the 1st defendant got disappointed on account of the fact that the plaintiff had improved the land and also the price of the land has gone up. Hence the 1st defendant had set up defendants 2 to 4 to interfere with the possession and enjoyment of the plaintiff. The 5th defendant, who is the owner of the remaining portion in the survey number is actively instigating defendants 1 to 4 in their mala fide action. Hence the suit.

(2) The 5th defendant did not file any written statement, he remained exparte. Subsequently, he died on 14th december. 1977, the plaintiff filed a petition under order 22 rule 4 (4) c. P. C. , to exempt from the necessity of substituting the legal representatives of the 5th defendant. In that petition the plaintiff had stated that the 5th defendant died about three months before the date of the presentation of the petition, there was no obstruction from him after the date of the suit, he had no interest in the suit property and hence it was not necessary to imp'ead his legal representatives. That petition was opposed by the defendants. They stated that the 5th defendant died more than 1 1/2 years prior to the date of the petition and it was to the knoweldge of the plaintiff, that the suit had abated against him, and the power of the court to exempt under order 22 rule 4 (4) c. P. C. , could be exercised only before the abatement had taken place and could not be exercised after abatement, relying upon annapurna vs. Harsundari the principal subordinate judge, anantapur dismissed the petition. Questioning his order, the plaintiff has filed this revision.

(3) It is submitted by the learned counsel for the petitioner - plaintiff that the decision in annapurna vs. Harsundari is not correct. He relied upon velappan vs. Parappan and s. A. Rahim vs. Rajamma. Even otherwise it was submitted by the learned counsel for the petitioner that the petitioner did not claim any relief against the 5th defendant, that he was not a necessary party and that he was not also giving him any trouble and, therefore, he was prepared to give him up, and consequently, his legal representatives need not be brought on record.

(4) On the other hand, the learned counsel for the respondents has relied upon lakshmi charan vs. Satyabadi and also nani gopal vs. Panchanan and submittted that exemption under order 22 rule 4 (4) c. P. C. Could not be exercised after abatement.

(5) Order 22 rule 4 (3) c. P. C. Provides that where within the time limited by law to application is made under sub - rule (i) , the suit shall abate as against the deceased defendant. Sub - rule (4) reads as follows:

"the court whenever it thinks fit, may exempt the plaintiff from the necessity of substituting the legal representatives of any such defendant who has failed to file a written statement or who, having filed it, has failed to appear and contest the suit at the hearting and judgment may, in such case, be pronounced against the said defendant notwithstanding the death of such defendant and shall have the same force and effect as if it has been pronounced before death took place."

In order to invoke sub - rule (4) , the defendant must have failed to file a written statement, or having filed it had failed to appear and contest the suit at the hearing. Then the court can exempt the plaintiff from the necessity of substituting the legal representatives of any such defendant. The court can exercise that power, "whenever it thinks fit". A judgment could be pronounced in such case against the defendant, notwithstanding his death and that judgment shall have the same force and effect as if it has been pronounced before his death.

(6) In my opinion, since the court could exercise that power "whenever it thinks fit" and since the judgment delivered against such defendant is deemed to have the same force and effect as if it was pronounced before his death, that power could be exercised even after abatement. Otherwise, the words "whenever it thinks fit" and also giving that judgment the same force and effect as if it had been pronounced before his death will have no meaning. It is true that sub - rule (3) provides that where within the time limited by law no application is made under sub - rule (1) , the suit shall abate as against the deceased defendant. But we should construe the provisions in a manner, so as to give effect to the object and intendment of the legislature, evidently, when a defendant fails to file a written statement or having filed he has failed to appear and contest the suit, there is no point in insisting that his legal representatives should be brought on record after his death. It will only be waste of time and futile. In view of that, and also to shorten the litigation, the legislature has introduced sub - rule (4) by the civil procedure code (amendment) act, 1976. Here it may be noted that we had a similar provision in this state by virtue of an amendment made by the madras legislature. Therefore, i am of the opinion that a petition under sub - rule (4) could be filed even after the abatement and it need not necessarily be filed only before the abatement of the suit against the deceased defendant.

(7) In velappan vs. Parappan it was held by the madras high court that the provisions of order 22 rule 4 (4) could be availed of at any time before judgment, that sub - rules (3) and (4) of rule 4 must be read together, that sub - rule (3) would not operate in cases where an order under sub - rule (4) was made and statutorily the automatic operation of sub - rule (3) was taken away when an exemption was granted under sub - rule (4) , and that was because sub - rule (3) provided that as its exception and full effect had to be given to the exception. It was also observed that where the deceased defendant had no interest in the litigation, the rule providing for abatement does not apply. The learned judge dissented from nani gopal vs. Panchanan and lakshmi charan vs. Satyabadi.

(8) In s. A. Rahim vs. Rajamma it was held by the karnataka high court that the power to exempt from necessity of substitution under order 22 rule 4 (4) c. P. C. , could be exercised even after the abatement had taken place. The learned judge observed that once exemption fiom necessity to substitute the legal representatives was granted and the judgment was pronounced in the suit, it should be deemed to have been pronounced against the deceased defendant before his death. It, therefore follows that no abatement as such shuld be deemed to have taken effect. The learned judge further observed that the legal fiction introduced by rule 4 (4) with regard to the deemed date of pronouncement of judgment had to be taken into account and as no abatement was deemed to have taken effect, the contention that the power of exemption under rule 4 (4) could not be exercised after 90 days from the date of death of the deceased after the abatement had taken place, had no force. He further observed that the power of exemption could be exercised by the court ''whenever it thinks fit" before the disposal of the suit. He dissented from lakshmi charan vs. Satyabadi and referred to velappan vs. Parappan

(9) Thus, the decision of the madras and karnataka high courts is that the court could exempt the substitution of the legal representatives of the deceased defendant even after abatement under order 22 rule 4 (4) c. P. C. It is true that in nand gopal vs panchanan a division bench of the calcutta high court held that the court's power to exempt under order 22 rule 4 (4) could be exercised only before an abatement bad taken place and it could not be exercised after abatement had taken place. That was followed in lakshmi charan vs. Satyabadi of the orissa high court. With great respect, i am not able to agree with the decisions of the calcutta and orissa high courts. I prefer to follow the decisions of the madras and karnataka high courts.

(10) I, therefore, hold that the principal subordinate judge was not correct in holding that the court could not exercise the power under order 22 rule 4 (4) c. P. C. After the abatement had taken place. Even otherwise, the only grievance of the plaintiff in the plaint against the sth defendant was that he was instigating the defendants 1 to 4 in their malafide action. He did not specifically claim any relief against him. In the affidavit filed in support of the petition under order 22 rule 4 (4) c. P. C. The plaintiff had stated that there was no obstruction from the 5th defendant after the date of the suit and he had no interest in the suit property.

(11) In rani vs. Santa bala it was observed by the supreme court that in a suit against several defendants, if one of them dies against whom no releif was claimed, for failure to bring legal representatives on record the appeal did not abate.

(12) In the result, i set aside the order of the principal subordinate judge, and allow the petition filed by the plaintiff under order 22 rule 4 (4) c. P. C. , exempting the plaintiff from the necessity of substituting the legal representatives of the 5th defendant. Appeal allowed.