- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Nadendla Apparao v. B. Satyanarayana
Summary of the Opinion (Revision under Article 227 concerning amendment of an election petition)
Factual and Procedural Background
The revision arises under Article 227 of the Constitution of India. The factual matrix is an election for the office of Sarpanch of the Gram Panchayat of Pedakurapadu held on 4 June 1981 in which Nadendla Appa Rao (declared elected) defeated Balineni Satyanarayana by 63 votes. Balineni Satyanarayana filed O.P. No. 12/1981 under the Andhra Pradesh Gram Panchayat Act, 1964 (rule 50) challenging Appa Rao's election and alleging various irregularities.
In the original election petition the petitioner (Balineni) alleged, among other things:
- Paragraph 4(b): That some voters had died before polling day and Appa Rao arranged for persons to personate them and cast votes in his favour (eight names were listed).
- Paragraph 4(c): That some persons were registered and voted in this gram panchayat and also in other gram panchayats (48 names listed).
- Paragraph 4(d): That some persons were registered in more than one ward within the same gram panchayat and voted twice (53 names listed).
While the petition was pending (and before Appa Rao filed his counter), Balineni filed I.A. No. 999/1981 seeking amendments to the election petition to:
- Expand paragraph 4(b) by adding eight more names of deceased voters whose votes were allegedly cast by impersonation;
- Expand paragraph 4(d) by adding 20 more names;
- Introduce a new paragraph 4(dd) listing 17 names of voters said to have been employed elsewhere and allegedly impersonated so that their votes were cast in favour of Appa Rao.
The election tribunal allowed the amendment application. Appa Rao challenged that order by filing this revision under Article 227.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the amendment to paragraph 4(b) of the election petition (adding eight additional names of deceased voters alleged to have been impersonated) constituted a permissible amplification of particulars or amounted to a new corrupt practice that could not be raised after the period of limitation.
- Whether the introduction of paragraph 4(dd) (alleging that 17 named voters employed elsewhere were impersonated) was a valid amendment to the election petition or an impermissible new ground that should not have been allowed.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioner's Arguments (counsel for Appa Rao)
- The amendment of paragraph 4(b) and the introduction of paragraph 4(dd) amount to new grounds of corrupt practice being alleged after the limitation period for filing an election petition, and therefore should not be permitted.
- Relied upon precedent authorities (Manubhai v. Popatlal; Raj Narain v. Indira Gandhi; Hardwari Lal v. Kanwal Singh) stressing the requirement that full particulars of corrupt practices must be set out and that late amendments should be allowed only in exceptional circumstances.
Respondent's Arguments (counsel for Balineni Satyanarayana)
- No new corrupt practice is alleged by the amendment; rather the amendment is an amplification or addition of particulars to a corrupt practice already alleged in the original petition.
- The amendment therefore falls within the permissible scope under the election rules to give further particulars and is in order.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Harish Chandra vs. Triloki Singh, AIR 1957 S.C. 444 | Permissibility of adding further particulars to allegations in an election petition (amplification of the same corrupt practice). | The court cited this line of authority to support the proposition that adding further particulars of an already-alleged corrupt practice is permissible; used to justify allowing the additional names in paragraph 4(b). |
| Baiwan Singh vs. Prakash Chand, AIR 1976 S.C. 1187 | Permissibility of supplying further particulars / amendment to an election petition where the amendment does not introduce a new corrupt practice. | Applied together with other authorities to support the view that giving additional particulars in an amendment is permissible. |
| Judgment of Sambasivarao, J., W.P. No. 5760/1970 dated 7-9-1971 | Supporting authority for permitting further particulars/amendments (as cited in the opinion). | Relied upon as part of the body of authority permitting amplification of particulars already alleged. |
| Judgment of P. A. Choudary, J., W.P. No. 936/1982 dated 8-7-1982 | Supporting authority for permitting further particulars/amendments (as cited in the opinion). | Relied upon along with other cases to justify allowing additional particulars in paragraph 4(b). |
| Manubhai vs. Popatlal, A. I. R. 1969 S.C. 734 | When corrupt practice is charged the petition must set forth full particulars; the charge must be substantially proved as laid; court may allow amendment even after commencement of trial but late amendments should be exceptional. | Cited by the petitioner, but the court held that on the facts the decision did not assist the petitioner because the present amendment was merely additional particulars of an already-alleged corrupt practice rather than a new charge. |
| Raj Narain vs. Indira Gandhi, A. I. R. 1972 S.C. 1302 | Facts in an election petition must bring out all ingredients of the corrupt practice; if not, the defect may not be cured after limitation; but if material facts are present, further particulars may be allowed even after limitation. | The court acknowledged the holding but treated it as consistent with permitting particulars: it observed that these decisions did not help the petitioner because here the material corrupt-practice allegation was already in the petition and the amendment supplied further particulars. |
| Hardwari Lal vs. Kanwal Singh, A. I. R. 1972 S.C. 515 | Where corrupt practice is alleged, material facts and necessary particulars should be given. | Not disputed as a legal proposition, but the court held it did not preclude the amendment of 4(b) since the amendment supplied additional particulars of the same corrupt practice. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court identified the sole question as whether amendments to paragraph 4(b) and the introduction of paragraph 4(dd) were valid. The analysis proceeded in distinct steps, each grounded on the text of the election rules and relevant criminal provision cited in the opinion.
-
Statutory framework and classification:
- The court referred to Rule 51(2) of the election rules which requires an election petition to contain a concise statement of the material on which the petitioner relies and particulars of any corrupt practice alleged.
- The court examined Rule 60, distinguishing clause (a) (which applies where a returned candidate, his agent or any person with their connivance commits or abets an election offence) from clause (b)(i) (which applies where the corrupt practice is committed by a person who is not a candidate or his agent or acting with their connivance).
-
Characterisation of the allegations:
- Paragraph 4(b) of the election petition charged that Appa Rao had "managed to get his own men personate" deceased voters and secure votes for himself. The amendment added eight further names on the same factual assertion (i.e., further instances of the same practice).
- The court held these allegations fall within clause (a) of Rule 60 because they allege that the returned candidate managed to get his men to personate deceased voters — i.e., implicating the candidate or persons acting with his connivance.
-
Criminal offence underpinning:
- The court referred to Section 171-D of the Indian Penal Code (personation at elections) which criminalises voting in the name of any other person, living or dead, or abetting such conduct; applying for a voting paper in the name of a dead person and voting in that name is an offence under that section.
- The court observed that if proved, the allegation of personation of dead voters would constitute an offence under Section 171-D and bring the matter within clause (a) of Rule 60.
-
Application of precedents and permissibility of amendment to 4(b):
- Given Rule 51(2)'s requirement and the fact that the original petition already alleged personation of deceased voters (with eight names), the court found that adding eight more names in the amendment petition was merely providing additional particulars of the same corrupt practice and not introducing a new corrupt practice.
- The court relied on authorities (Harish Chandra, Baiwan Singh and other judicial orders cited) to support the proposition that it is permissible to add particulars of an already-alleged corrupt practice.
- The court examined the petitioner's reliance on Manubhai, Raj Narain and Hardwari Lal but concluded that those decisions did not aid the petitioner on the facts: Manubhai stresses full particulars and cautious leave to amend late, Raj Narain emphasises the need for material facts to constitute a triable issue but allows particulars to be added in some circumstances, and Hardwari Lal requires material facts and particulars — the court held the present amendment was consistent with those principles because it did not introduce a new charge but amplified existing particulars.
-
Analysis of the introduction of paragraph 4(dd):
- Paragraph 4(dd) alleged that 17 named voters employed at places such as Hyderabad, Macharla and Bellampalli were not present in Pedakurapadu on the polling day and that the petitioner secured votes by personation for those voters.
- The court noted that the record did not show that any objection was taken below to the amendments to paragraphs 4(b) and 4(d); the district munsif's order, however, shows the objection was only to adding paragraph 4(dd).
- The learned district munsif allowed the addition of 4(dd) on the basis that "such a plea was already taken in the election petition." The revising court disagreed: the main petition had no particulars of persons working elsewhere whose votes were allegedly cast in Pedakurapadu. The main petition contained only a vague allegation that "hundred invalid votes were polled in favour of the petitioner."
- Because the original petition did not contain particulars or an allegation of that specific category of impersonation (voters employed elsewhere), introducing 4(dd) was not a permissible amplification of particulars but in substance a new allegation which the district munsif should not have allowed.
-
Conclusion on validity of amendments:
- The court concluded that the amendment to paragraph 4(b) was valid as it supplied further particulars of an already alleged corrupt practice.
- The introduction of paragraph 4(dd) was not justified and was therefore disallowed.
Holding and Implications
Holding: REVISION ALLOWED IN PART.
Specific orders and immediate consequences:
- The court set aside the order of the learned District Munsif to the extent that it allowed the addition of paragraph 4(dd) to the election petition (i.e., the introduction of the 17 names of voters alleged to be employed elsewhere and impersonated was disallowed).
- The court confirmed the District Munsif's order allowing the amendment petition in the other respects (notably the amendment to paragraph 4(b) adding further names was permitted and the amendment to paragraph 4(d) was not challenged by counsel for the petitioner and was left intact).
- Costs were directed that each party should bear his own costs in the revision; advocate's fee awarded: Rs. 100/-.
Broader legal implications: The opinion does not purport to lay down a new rule of law beyond applying established principles concerning the scope of permissible amendments to election petitions (i.e., distinguishing between amplification of particulars and introduction of new corrupt-practice allegations). On the facts, the court permitted amplification (4(b)) but disallowed a substantively new allegation (4(dd)).
(1) The revision is filed under article 227 of the constitution of india by nadendla appa rao, the 1st respondent in i. A. No. 999/1981 in o. P. No. 12/1981. Balineni satyanaryana the 1st respondent in this revision and nadendla apparao the petitioner herein and two others contested for the office of the sarpanch of the gram panchayat of pedakurapadu in the election held on 4th june, 1981. Nadendla apparao was declared elected as sarpanch by a majority of 63 votes over balineni satyanarayana thereupon, balineni satyanarayana filed 0 p no. 12/1981 questioning the election of nadendla apparao under rule 50 of the rules relating to conduct of election etc. Under the andhra pradesh gram panchayat act, 1964. In that petition the petitioner (balineni satyanarayana) among other things, alleged the following irregularities against appa rao. In paragraph 4 (b) he stated that some voters died long before the polling day and appa rao managed to get his own men personate for such deceased voters and got such votes cast in his favour. He mentioned 8 names. In paragraph 4 (c) he stated that some persons were registered as voters in the gram panchayat of pedakurapadu and also in other gram panchayats. They have exercised their franchise in the elections in both the panchayats. He mentioned 48 names. In paragraph 4 (d) he stated that some persons were registered as voters in more than one ward of pedakurapadu gram panchayat and they have exercised their franchise twice. He mentioned 53 names.
(2) The petition was taken on file. Sri apparao did not so for file his counter. While so, balineni satyanarayana filed i. A. No. 999/1981 to amend the election petition. In that petition he wanted to amend paragraph 4 (b) of the election petition so as to include the names of 8 more deceased voters whose votes were cast by impersonation, at the instance of appa rao. He also wanted to amend paragraph 4 (d) of the election petition so as to include 20 more names, who have voted in more than one ward of pedakurapadu gram panchayat. He wanted to introduce paragraph 4 (dd) in the election petition by including 17 names of voters who were working at other places, but whose votes were cast in favour of appa rao by false personation in the gram panchayat. That petition was opposed by appa rao. Nevertheless, the election tribunal allowed the petition. Questioning his order, sri appa rao has filed this revision petition.
(3) Sri b. V. Subbaiah, the learned counsel for the petitioner did not question the power of the election tribunal to amend the election petition. He did not also question the amendment of paragraph 4 (d) that relates to voters who are registered in more than one ward at pedakurapadu panchayat and have exercised their franchise twice. His grievance was against the amendment of paragraph 4 (b) and introduction of paragraph 4 (dd) in the election petition. He submitted that the amendment sought for in paragraph 4 (b) and 4 (dd) of the election petition constitute new grounds of corrupt practice and the 1st respondent cannot be permitted to raise them after the period ot limitation prescribed for filing election petition on the other hand, the counsel for the 1st respondent submitted that no new corrupt practice is alleged, but it is only an amplification of the currupt practices that were already alleged in the election petition, and. Thererore,the amendment is in order.
(4) The only question for my consideration in this petition is whether the amendment o ( paragraph 4 (b) and 4 (dd) of the election petition is valid?
(5) In the main election petition in paragraph 4 (b) it is stated as follows.
"voters nos. 2981, 2990, 3258, 3376, 3449, 4594, 4642 and 4645 died long before the poll day. The 1st respondent (petitioner herein) managed to get his own man personate for such deceased voters and got such votes cast in his favour. It is a corrupt practice amounting to an election offence vitiating his election. The following are trie persons who died before and whose' votes are illegally cast in favour of the 1st respondent on 4 - 6 - 81 in the panchayat elections."
Then he mentioned the names of the deceased persons. In the amendment petition relating to paragraph 4 (b) the petitioner has stated: in para 4 (b) of the election petition, i gave a tabulation of the deceased persons in whose name, the 1st respondent secured votes by impersonation and false personation. My subsequent enquiries reveal that the 1st respondent secured some more votes by exercise of such corrupt practice. A further list of such cases of false personation and impersonation is herewith submitted. He gave 8 more names of deceased voters in the list to be added in the tabulation of paragraph 4 (b).
(6) Reading the allegations in paragraph 4 (b) of the election petition and the amendment petition, i do not agree with the learned counsel for the petitioner that the 1st respondent has alleged a new corrupt practice in the amendment of paragraph 4 (b) of the election petition. In the election petition, the 1st respondent had stated that the petitioner had managed to get his own men personate for eight deceased voters and got such votes cast in his favour and it is a corrupt practice amounting to an election offence vitiating his election. In the amendment petition he had stated that his subsequent enquiries revealed that the petitioner had secured some more votes by exercise of such cor rupt practice and he has given a further list of eight such cases. Thus, in the election petition as well as in the amendment petition his allegation was that the petitioner had managed to get his own men personate for some deceased voters and got such votes cast in his favour. In this connection it is necessary to refer to rule 51 (2) of the election rules. It says, that the election petition shall contain a statement in concise form of the material on which the petitioner relies, and the particulars of any corrupt practice which he alleges, and shall where necessary, be divided into paragraphs numbered, consecutively. Rule 60, to the extent it is relevant reads as follows: - if in the opinion of the election court -
(a) a returned candidate, his agent or any other person with the connivance of such candidate or agent, has committed, or abetted the commission of any election offence falling under chapter ix - a of the indian penal code or any law or ru!e relating to the infringement of the secrecy of an election; or
(b) the election of a returned candidate has been procured or induced or the result of the election has been materially affected, by any of the following corrupt practices namely: - (i) any election offence falling under chapter ix - a of the indian penal code or any law or rule relating to the infringement of the secrecy of an election when committed by a person who is not a candidate or his agent or a person acting with the connivance of a candidate or his agent. Clauses (ii) , (iii) and (c) omitted) the election of such returned candidate shall be void; provided that if the election court is of opinion that any corrupt practices specified in clause (b) of this rule, which does not amount to any form of bribery other than treating as heare in - after explained has been committed and if the election court is further of opinion that the candidate has satisfied the election court that -
(i) no corrupt practice was committed at such election by the candidate and that any corrupt practices committed were committed contrary to the orders and without the sanction or connivance of such candidate; and
(ii) such candidate took all reasonable means for preventing the commission of corrupt practices at such election; and
(iii) the corrupt practices committed were of a trivial, unimportant and limited character; then the election court may find that the election of such candidate is not void. "
Clause (a) of rule 60 applies to as returned candidate, his agent or any - other person with the connivance of such candidate or agent, has committed, or abetted the commission of any election offence falling under chapter ix - a of the indian penal code. Clause (b) (i) of rule 60 applies to a person who is not a candidate or his agent or a person acting with the connivance of ar candidate or his agent. The allegations made in paragraph 4 (b) of the election petition fall within the purview of clause (a) , for the 1st respondent had stated that the petitioner had managed to get his own men personate for some dead voters and got such votes cast in his favour. Similarly, the allegation in the amendment petition relating to paragraph 4 (b) was that the petitioner secured some votes by exercise of such corrupt practices. Thus, it also falls under clause (a) of rule 60. I do not agree with the learned counsel for the petitioner that the corrupt practices mentioned by the 1st respon dent falls under Clause (b) (i) of rule 60.
(7) In this connection i may also refer to the relevant section in chapter ix - a of the indian penal code. Section 171 - d relatesto personation at elections it says, that whoever at an election applies for at voting paper or votes in the name of any other person whether living or dead, or in a fictitious name or who having voted once at such election applies a the same election for a voting paper in his own name, and whoever abets, procures or attempts to procure the voting by any person in any such way, commits the offence of personation at an election. Thus, applying for a voting paper of a dead person and voting in the name of a dead person is an offence. The 1st respondent has alleged in his election petition as well as in the amendment petition that the petitioner has managed to secure his own men personate for some deceased voters and cast such votes in his favour if proved, it is an offence falling under section 171 - d i f c. And coming with the purview of clause (a) of rule 60.
(8) In view of rule 51 (2) the election petition should contain a statement in concised form of the material on which the petitioner relies, and the particulars of any corrput practice which he alleges. Admittedly, in this case, the 1st respondent has given the particulars of the corrupt practice, namely, that the petitioner has managed to secure some dead votes polled in his favour in his election petition. He has mentioned eight names. In the amendment petition he has mentioned eight more names. It means that he has given some more particulars of the same corrupt practice, which he has already alleged in the election petition. That is permissible, see harish chandra vs. Triloki singh (1) air 1957 s. C. 444; baiwan singh vs. Prakash chand (2) air 1976 s. C. 1187; judgment of sambasivarao, j. In w p no. 5760/1970 dated 7th september, 1971 and the judgment of p a choudary, j. In w p. No. 936/1982 dated 8th july, 1982.
(9) The learned counsel for the petitioner has relied upon manubhai vs. Popatlal (3) a. I. R. 1969 s. C. 734; raj narain vs. Indira gandhi (4) a. I. R. 1972 s. C. 1302; and hardwari ial vs. Kanwal singh (5) a. I. R. 1972 s. C. 515.
(10) In manubhai vs. Popatlal (3) supra; a case arising under the representation of the people act, 1951, it has been held by the supreme court that when a corrupt practice is charged against the returned candidate, the election petition must set forth full particulars of the corrupt practice so as to give the charge a definite character to enable the court to understand what the charge is. The charge mus be substantially proved as laid and evidence cannot be allowed to be given in respect of a charge not disclosed in the particulars. It was also held that the court has power to allow an amendment even after the commencement of the trial, but as a rule leave to amend at a late stage should be given in exceptional cases where the petitioner could not with reasonable diligence have discovered the new facts earlier.
(11) In raj narain vs. Indira gandhi (4) (supra) a case arising under the representation of the people act, 1951, it was held that the facts stated in an election petition relating to any corrupt practice must bring out all the ingredients of the corrupt practice alleged, and if the facts stated fail to satisfy that requirement then they do not give rise to a triable issue and such defect cannot be cured by amendment ofter the period of limitation for filing the election petition. But, even if all the material facts are stated in the election petition for a proper trial better particulars may still be required and if those particulars are not set out in the election petition, they may be incorpo - fated into the election petition with the permission of the court even after the period of limitation.
(12) Hardwari lal vs. Kanwal singh (5) is again a case arising under the representation of the people act, 1951. There it was held that in an election petition where corrupt practice is alleged the material facts and the necessary particulars should be given.
(13) There can be no dispute with the propositions of law laid down in these cases. I do not see how these decisions are helpful to the petitioner in deciding the question in issue. On the facts of this case i hold that the 1st respondent is not alleging any new corrupt practice by seeking amendment of paragraph 4 (b) of the election petition he has given some more particulars in the amendment petition of the corrupt practice already alleged by him in the election petition.
(14) The learned counsel for the petitioner also submitted that the learned district muhsif erred in allowing the amendment by adding paragraph 4 (dd). Here i may add that the order of the learned district munsif does not show that the petitioner has taken any objection before him for amendment of paragraph 4 (b) and (d). His objection was only for adding paragraph 4 (dd). Through the amendment petition the 1st respondent wanted to introduce paragraph 4 (dd) by stating that the voters as per the tabulation mentioned thereunder were employed at other places, like hyderabad macharla and bellampalli and they were not present at pedakurapadu on 4th june 1981 and did not exercise their franchise and they had marked their attendance on that day at the place of their employment but the petitioner got his own men personate for such voters and secured their votes by impersonation and such votes must be excluded from the votes polled for him. Then he mentioned 17 names. The learned district munsif allowed the amendment for introducing paragraph 4 (dd) by stating that such a plea was already taken in the election petition, and therefore, the amendment could be allowed. I find it difficult to agree with him. In the main election petition he has given the particulars of some dead voters. Voters that voted in this grampanchayat and other gram panchayats and voters that vote in more than one ward of the same gram panchayat. He never gave any particulars of any voter working elsewhere, but still his vote being cast in favour of the petitioner at the instance of his men in the election petition the 1st respondent made a vague allegation that hundred invalid votes were polled in favour of the petitioner. In these circumstances i hold that the learned district munsif was not justified in allowing the amendment for the introduction of paragraph 4 (dd)
(15) Consequently, i set aside me order of the learned district munsif in so far as it allowed adding of paragraph 4 (dd) to the election petition i confirm his order allowing the amendment petition in other respects. Accordingly the revision is allowed in part. In the circumstances of the case, i direct each party to bear his costs in this provision. Advocate's fee rs. 100/ -.
Alert