- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Navin M. Raheja v. Union Of India And Others
Factual and Procedural Background
The Court, in the course of ongoing proceedings concerning animal welfare, addressed two recent incidents involving tigers: multiple deaths at Nandan Kanan, Bhubaneswar, and the live skinning of a tiger at a zoo in Andhra Pradesh. Disturbed by these events, the Court issued the present order to ensure accountability and prompt remedial action by the authorities responsible for the care of animals in zoos and reserved forests.
Legal Issues Presented
The opinion addresses a procedural matter and does not frame distinct legal issues.
Arguments of the Parties
The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.
Table of Precedents Cited
No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court expressed grave concern that captive tigers were left unprotected despite the custodial responsibility assumed by zoo authorities. Emphasising that the State must act to prevent any recurrence of such cruelty, the Court concluded that direct oversight was necessary. To obtain a clear picture of the measures being implemented, it ordered the personal appearance of the Chairperson or Director of the Central Zoo Authority and required a report detailing steps taken for tiger welfare after the reported incidents.
Holding and Implications
DIRECTIONS ISSUED: The Chairperson/Director of the Central Zoo Authority is to appear before the Court on the next date and file a detailed report on actions taken to preserve tiger populations; government counsel must convey these directions. The matter is scheduled to be listed after two weeks.
Implications: The order imposes immediate accountability on the Central Zoo Authority and mandates a status report on tiger protection efforts. Its effect is confined to ensuring prompt administrative action and does not establish a new legal precedent.
Order
1. From time to time, we have voiced our concern about the distressing state of affairs insofar as welfare of animals, both in the reserved forests and in the zoos, is concerned. We had made a reference, on the last date, to the issue arising out of death of tigers at Nandan Kanan, Bhubaneshwar. Lately, we have come across a report about a ghastly act in which a tiger was skinned alive at one of the zoos in Andhra Pradesh. It distresses us that a tiger in captivity should have received no protection from those who had undertaken to keep them in captivity and look after their welfare. Poor voiceless animals cannot be allowed to be treated in such a cruel manner. The State is obliged to take all such steps so that no such incident ever reoccurs in any of the zoos or reserved forests.
2. We consider it appropriate to direct the Chairperson or the Director, Central Zoo Authority, whoever heads the Authority, to appear before us in person on the next date and explain as to what steps are being taken for preserving tiger population, both in the reserved forests as also in the zoos. He shall place on record details of any steps taken for the welfare of tiger population, after the two unfortunate incidents referred to above.
3. Mr Krishan Mahajan, learned counsel, who appears for the Central Government is directed to convey directions of this Court to the Chairperson/Director of the Central Zoo Authority and ensure his appearance in this Court on the next date.
4. List the matter after two weeks.
Court Masters
Alert