Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Nelluri Brahmaiah v. Mohd. Sheik Mohiddin And Another .

Andhra Pradesh High Court
Oct 15, 1963

Chandra Reddy, C.J.:-

(1) This appeal under clause 15 of the letters patent is filed against the judgment of syed qamar hasan, j. , in c. M. S. A. No. 99 of 1959 with his leave.

(2) For a proper appraisal of the issues arising in this appeal, it is useful to state a few facts. O. S. No. 523 of 1955 on the file of the district munsif's court. Eluru, brought by the present second respondent resulted in a decree in his favour for a sum of about rs. 2,100. In execution of that decree, he brought to sale on 1st july, 1957 ac. 3 - 50 cents of wet lands and 19 acres of dry lands said to be situated in borrampalem village. They were purchased by the present appellant for a sum of rs. 5,400. As he committed default in making the initial deposit of 25 per cent. , the properties were put up for re - sale on 2nd september, 1957, and they were purchased by the decree - holder himself subject to a mortgage in his own favour over the same properties. Thereupon, the judgment - debtor, claiming the benefit of order 21, rule 71, civil procedure code, sought to recover from the defaulting first purchaser, i. E. , the appellant herein, the deficiency in price on re - sale amounting to rs. 2,900.

(3) This application was resisted by the appellant on the ground that there were material irregularities in the sale and, consequently, he was not liable to make good the deficiency. This objection prevailed with the trial court which dismissed the application. It was held by that court that the judgment - debtor had no saleable interest in one of the items of property, namely, the wet lands.

(4) This was affirmed on appeal by. The district judge, eluru. On a civil miscellaneous second appeal, our learned brother, syed qamar hasan, j. , set aside that order and granted the relief asked for by the judgment - debtor, i. E. , the present first respondent. The learned judge opined that there was no basis for holding that the judgment - debtor had no interest in any of the properties and that it was nothing more than a misdescription of the location of the wet lands. It may be mentioned here that when the decree - holder, auction purchaser, sought to recover possession of the wet lands, he found that the wet lands were, in fact, situate in venkatapuram, hamlet of tirumaladevipet, and, consequently, he apprehended that there might be trouble in his obtaining possession. So, he applied to the district munsif's court, eluru, for amendment of the sale certificate. In spite of the opposition of the judgment - debtor, the amendment was allowed and the auction - purchaser could take possession of the properties. In this appeal against the judgment of our learned brother, syed qamar hasan, j. , it is contended by the learned counsel for the appellant that order 21, rule 93,. Civil procedure code, could be properly invoked in this case, as admittedly the wet lands were not within the limits of borrampalem but in venkatapuram, which implies that the judgment - debtor had no saleable interest therein and hence, he could not be made liable for deficiency under order 21, rule 71, civil procedure code. We do not think that we could accede to this proposition. There is no dispute about the boundaries or about the survey number covering the lands in dispute or their extent. It is not also suggested that there was any other property of this description within those boundaries and covered by the same survey number in venkatapuram or in borrampalem. It is not also seriously disputed that the property attached and sold was the present property. The only defect attaching to it was that, it was described as lying within the limits of borrampalem instead of in venkatapuram, the hamlet of tirumaladevipet. Obviously, all those concerned proceeded on the footing that this item of property was in borrampalem and not in venkatapuram, both at the time of the execution of the mortgage and at the time of the issue of proclamation of sale. The description as given in the mortgage was carried into the proclamation of sale also.

(5) It is thus seen that it was the exact location of the property that was wrongly inentioned in the mortgage as also in the proclamation of sale. Evidently, it was originally thought that these properties were situated within the limits of borrampalem which adjoins venkatapuram. The properties seem to constitute the boundary between the two villages. It is because of this that the mistake seems to have crept in. There is absolutely no difficulty about the identity of the properties and the parries appear to have known also their location. In these circumstances, it is difficult to posit that the land brought to sale is different from that which really belonged to the judgment - debtor and that the latter had no saleable interset therein. It is clear that this plea is an after - thought. In this connection, we cannot ignore that the appellant belongs to the village of venkatapuram and it is difficult to conceive that he was not aware of the mistake. He knew perfectly well what he was purchasing. But he wants to take advantage of the misdescription of the property. Assuming that there is some substance in the complaint of the appellant regarding this item of land, there was no justification for him either not to make the initia deposit or to complete the purchase. It should be remembered that both these items of property were sold in one lot. That being so, he could not avoid the sale, as, unquestionably, the judgment - debtor had title to the 19 acres of dry land. It is only in the absence of interest in the entirety of the property that an auction - purchaser could have the sale set aside. That this is so, is clear from the language of order 21, rule 91, civil procedure code, which clothes an auction - purchaser with the right to have the sale avoided in certain circumstances. That provision of law runs as follows : - "the purchaser at any such sale in execution of a decree may apply to the court to set aside the sale, on the ground that the judgment - debtor had no saleable interest in the property sold. " it is manifest from the last clause of the rule, namely, " had no saleable interest in the property sold " that the want of saleable interest must extend to the whole of the property. If the judgment - debtor has even a partial interest in the property then the auction - purchaser cannot have recourse to order 21, rule 91, or, order 21, rule 71, civil procedure code. There is abundant authority for this principle. In venkatachellamayya v. Nilakanta girjee, kumaraswami sastriar, j. , who was one of the members of the full bench, observed that a purchaser could not avoid a sale so long as the judgment debtor had any interest, however small, in the property. In the same trend of thought in nagalinga chettiar v. Guruswamy ayyar, there, the auction - purchaser bought two items of property which were sold in one lot. When it was discovered that the judgment - debtor had no title in respect of some of the properties included in the lot, the auction - purchaser claimed a refund of proportionate amount of the purchase money paid by him into court. This claim was negatived by the division bench of the madras high court in the view that, where the judgment - debtor had some interest in the property, however small that may be, he could not resort to order 21, rule 93, civil procedure code. To a like effect are the observations of govinda menon, j. , in alapati subbarayudu v. Jallapalli lakshmayya, to the same effect is maung tha dun v. Chokalingam chetty,

(6) It is unnecessary to multiply citations. Suffice it to say that so long as the judgment - debtor has some interest, however small that may be, in the property sold, the auction - purchaser cannot seek to avoid the sale under order 21, rule 91, civil procedure code, or claim any relief under order 21, rule 71, civil procedure code. In the circumstances, we see - no ground to interfere with the order under appeal. In the result, the appeal is dismissed, but, in the circumstances of the case, there will be no order as to costs. Appeal dismissed.