- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Navnitprasad Champakprasad v. Commissioner Ahmedabad Municipal Corporation, Ahmedebad
Concise Analytical Summary of the Opinion (Dixit, J.)
Factual and Procedural Background
The two revisional applications raise a common question concerning the meaning of the expression "rent" in Rule 7(1) of the Taxation Rules contained in Chapter VIII of the schedule to the Bombay Provincial Municipal Corporations Act, 1949.
The applicants are owners of certain tenements within the Municipal Corporation of Ahmedabad. The rateable value for the years 1952–1953 and 1953–1954 had to be fixed. Leases contained covenants by which tenants agreed to pay both rent and municipal taxes to the landlords. The Municipal Corporation computed rateable value treating the rent plus municipal taxes as rent recovered by landlords.
The applicants objected, asserting that the municipal taxes collected from tenants should be deductible because the landlords acted as mere agents of the Corporation in collecting such taxes, and that rateable value should be fixed on rent alone. The Court of Small Causes, Ahmedabad held that the municipal taxes should be included with rent for determination of rateable value. The District Judge (learned Assistant Judge), Ahmedabad affirmed that decision on appeal. These orders were challenged by the present revisional applications to the High Court under Section 115 of the Code of Civil Procedure.
Legal Issues Presented
- What is the meaning of the expression "rent" as used in Rule 7(1) of the Taxation Rules in Chapter VIII of the schedule to the Bombay Provincial Municipal Corporations Act, 1949?
- Whether municipal taxes, though paid by tenants pursuant to lease covenants, should be included in the amount of "rent" for the purpose of fixing the rateable value of tenements under R. 7(1).
Arguments of the Parties
Applicants' Arguments (represented by Mr. C.K. Shah)
- The municipal taxes collected from tenants should be deductible when fixing rateable value because the landlords were merely agents of the Corporation in collecting such taxes.
- Accordingly, the rateable value should be fixed on the basis of the rent alone (i.e., excluding municipal taxes).
- It was contended that interpreting "rent" to include municipal taxes would amount to adding words to the statutory provision; the expression "rent" should mean rent and nothing else.
- Reference was made to the Bombay Municipal Boroughs Act, 1925 (Section 78) as containing a distinct provision, and that there was no corresponding provision in the 1949 Act — advanced to support their contention that municipal taxes should not be treated as part of rent under the 1949 Act.
Respondent / State Arguments and Representations
- Mr. V.S. Desai (Assistant Government Pleader) informed the Court of differing municipal practices: in Bombay and Poona municipal taxes were not taken into account, whereas in Ahmedabad they were taken into account along with rent. He indicated this practice distinction but did not argue that practice should determine statutory meaning.
- Mr. R.M. Shah relied on Section 413(1) of the Act to contend that where a rateable value fixed under the Act has not been complained of or no appeal is made, and where the District Court has decided an appeal, the decision of the District Court is intended to be final — implying limited scope for High Court revision under Section 115 CPC.
Table of Precedents Cited
No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court's analysis proceeds from a textual and contextual reading of R. 7(1) of the Taxation Rules and relevant statutory definitions:
- The Court reproduced R. 7(1): a flat 10% deduction is to be made "from the amount of the annual rent for which such land or building might reasonably be expected to let from year to year" and this deduction "shall be in lieu of all allowance for repairs or on any other account whatever." The phrase "in lieu of all allowances ... on any other account whatever" was treated as significant and indicative that, once the 10% deduction is applied, no other allowances are permissible under R. 7(1).
- The Act itself did not define "rent" for present purposes. The Court therefore referred to definitions elsewhere in the statutory scheme — first noting the definitions of "rack rent" and "rateable value" in Sections 2(53) and 2(54), and then going to Section 105 of the Transfer of Property Act for the definition of "rent" within the concept of "lease".
- Section 105 (Transfer of Property Act) defines "rent" broadly as a money payment, a share of crops, service, or "any other thing of value" to be rendered periodically or on specified occasions. The Court emphasized that "rent" is not limited to cash and may take non-monetary forms.
- Applying that width of meaning to the leases before the Court, the Court observed that although the covenant made the tenant liable to pay municipal taxes, the statutory liability under the municipal enactment is primarily upon the landlord (the Court referred to Section 139 of the municipal scheme indicating the landlord's primary liability). Where the statutory liability is on the landlord but the lease shifts the obligation to the tenant, the landlord is thereby saved that amount and receives a benefit. The Court reasoned that such a saving or benefit could be regarded as part of the consideration for the lease and thus fall within the broad concept of "rent" under Section 105.
- The Court relied on an authoritative commentary on the Transfer of Property Act (cited in the opinion) which stated that in Indian law any payment by the lessee that is part of the consideration of the lease is rent — for example, collection charges provided for in a lease being regarded as part of the rent. The Court accepted this statement as supportive.
- Turning back to R. 7(1), the Court read the phrase "on any other account whatever" as requiring a reasonable meaning: municipal taxes cannot be omitted from consideration in determining rateable value where they effectively form part of the tenant's consideration to the landlord by virtue of the lease covenant.
- The Court rejected the significance of differing municipal practices (Bombay and Poona versus Ahmedabad) as determinative of statutory interpretation: practice cannot supplant the meaning of R. 7(1). If the lease means the tenant relieves the landlord of the statutory liability, that benefit properly falls within the scope of "rent" for assessment.
- The argument based on Section 413 (finality of District Court decisions under the Act) was noted by the Court. Counsel for the respondents contended that Section 413 made the District Court decision final and thus unavailable to further revision. The Court acknowledged the limited scope of High Court revision under Section 115 CPC, but because the Court found the decision below to be correct on its merits, it did not find it necessary to resolve the precise reach of Section 413 in relation to Section 115.
Holding and Implications
Holding:
Rule discharged — the view taken by the Court below is right; the revisional applications fail.
Direct consequences and implications:
- The Municipal Corporation's method of calculating rateable value by treating municipal taxes paid by tenants (pursuant to lease covenants) as part of the rent for the purpose of R. 7(1) is upheld.
- The applicants' contention that municipal taxes collected from tenants should be excluded as mere agency collections is rejected; the municipal taxes, to the extent they relieve the landlord of statutory liability and form part of the consideration of the lease, may be regarded as rent for rateable value assessment.
- No broader change in statutory interpretation beyond the facts of these cases is announced in the opinion; the direct effect is confined to the dismissal of these revisional applications and the confirmation of the rateable-value calculations for the years in question. The opinion does not purport to set out a novel precedent beyond this interpretative application of R. 7(1) and the Transfer of Property Act's definition of "rent."
Disposition recorded in the opinion: Both revisional applications were dismissed and the rule discharged with costs.
Dixit, J.:— These two revisional applications raise a common question and the question raised is about the meaning to be given to the expression ‘rent’ as occurring in R. 7(1) of the Taxation Rules in Chapter VIII of the schedule to the Bombay Provincial Municipal Corporations Act, 1949.
2. The applicants are owners of certain tenements which were let out to different tenants. These tenements are situate within the limits of the Municipal Corporation of Ahmedabad and the rateable value of these tenements for the year 1952-1953 had to be fixed. It appears that there was a covenant in a lease executed between the applicants and their tenants whereby the tenants were to pay the rent as well as the Municipal taxes to their landlords. The Municipal Corporation calculated the rateable value, treating the rent and taxes as rent recovered by the landlords.
3. The applicants, feeling aggrieved by the aforesaid method of calculation, contended that they were entitled to deduct the amount of taxes as the applicants were merely the agents of the Corporation when they collected the taxes from their tenants. They took the contention that the rateable value should, therefore, be fixed on the basis of rent alone. The Small Cause Court, Ahmedabad before which this proceeding was taken, held that the taxes paid by the tenants should be included in the amount of the rent in determining the rateable value of the tenements. An appeal was preferred from the order of the Court of Small Causes in the Court of the District Judge, Ahmedabad and the learned Assistant Judge, Ahmedabad confirmed the view taken by the Court of Small Causes and dismissed the petitioners' appeal. It is from that order that the present application in revision has been brought.
4. Upon this application, it is contended on behalf of the applicants that the learned Assistant Judge was wrong in taking the view that the taxes should be taken into consideration along with the amount of the rent in determining the rateable value of these tenements. Mr. C.K Shah has drawn our attention to certain provisions of the enactments. To take the Bombay Provincial Municipal Corporations Act, 1949, first, the material provision which requires construction is R. 7(1) of the taxation rules. The rule in question runs as follows:
“In order to fix the rateable value of any building or land assessable to a property-tax there shall be deducted from the amount of the annual rent for which such land or building might reasonably be expected to let from year to year a sum equal to ten per cent, of the said annual rent, and the said deduction shall be in lieu of all allowance for repairs or on any other account whatever”.
5. It should be noticed that, according to R. 7(1), there is a flat rate of deduction which is a reduction of 10 per cent of the annual rent and it is significant that the rule goes on to provide that the deduction shall be in lieu of all allowances for repairs or on any other account whatever. The expression “in lieu of all allowances for repairs or on any other account whatever” is significant. This shows that once a ten per cent deduction is made then there is no other allowance permissible according to R. 7(1). Now, the expression ‘rent’ is not defined in the Act. But it will be convenient to mention two definitions as given in S. 2(53) and S. 2(54). In S. 2(53), the term ‘rack rent’ has been defined and it means the amount of the annual rent for which the premises with reference to which the term is used might reasonably be expected to let from year to year as ascertained for the purpose of fixing the rateable value of such premises. Then S. 2(54) defines ‘rateable value’ and it means the value of any building or land fixed in accordance with the provisions of the Act, and the rules for the purpose of assessment to property taxes. Now, we are here concerned with the rent and not the rack rent and, therefore, we will have to go, for the purpose of definition, to S. 105 of the Transfer of Property Act. Section 105 defines the expression ‘lease’ and it says:
“A lease of immoveable property is a transfer of a right to enjoy such property, made for a certain time, express or implied, or in perpetuity, in consideration of a price paid or promised, or of money, a share of crops, service or any other thing of value, to be rendered, periodically or on specified occasions to the transfer by the transferee, who accepts the transfer on such terms. The transferor is called the lessor, the transferee is called the lessee, the price is called the premium and the money, share, service or other thing to be so rendered is called the rent.”
6. It is apparent that the expression ‘rent’ as defined in S. 105 is wide. The expression ‘rent’ does not mean only money. The rent may be in the form of share. It may again be in the form of service or it may take the form of any other thing to be so rendered. Now, in this case, there was a covenant between the landlords and the tenants, and under the covenant the tenants were to pay the rent in addition to the municipal taxes to the landlords. There can be no doubt, therefore, that according to the terms of the lease, it was the tenant who was liable to pay the municipal taxes. But the liability under the Act is primarily the liability of a landlord. In this connection, reference may be made to S. 139 which, by sub-section (1)(b)(i), says: “If the premises are not so held, from the lessor if the premises are let.” This shows that the primary liability is upon a landlord and not upon a tenant. If this be the true position, as indicated in S. 139, what happens is that where the statutory liability is upon a landlord the liability to pay municipal taxes is transferred according to the terms of the lease, to a tenant. In other words, the position is that the landlord is saved the amount and it may well be that was a consideration while granting the lease. To the extent that a tenant pays these taxes, the landlord undoubtedly gets a benefit; and when the landlord has got this benefit in so far as the tenant is required to pay the municipal taxes, it may well be that was a consideration which influenced the landlord in fixing the amount of the rent. As we read the definition of the expression ‘rent’ occurring in S. 105 of the Transfer of Property Act, there is no difficulty in saying that the rent may not necessarily be in the form of cash only. If the rent can be in any other form as in this case in the nature of the payment of municipal taxes, there is no reason why we should not give the expression ‘rent’ a meaning which is consistent with the definition as occurring in S. 105. Mr. C.K Shah, who appears for the applicants, contends that in so interpreting the expression ‘rent’, we would be adding to the section words which do not occur there. He says that the expression ‘rent’ means rent and nothing else. He says that it cannot mean that in the expression ‘rent’ the municipal taxes need be included. But, we think that is not necessarily the only construction. After all, there is a coven, ant and under the covenant the liability is placed upon the tenant. But the primary liability is upon the landlord. Therefore, the payment of municipal taxes may well be in the nature of rent, though not the rent, strictly so-called.
7. In this connection, one may refer to what the learned author* of the Transfer of Property Act, 4th Edition, 1956, has observed at page 609 under the caption ‘Rent’. The following passage occurs there:
“But in Indian Law, any payment by the lessee that is Part of the consideration of the lease is rent. Thus when the lease provides for collection charges in addition to rent, such charges are really part of the rent.”
8. With respect, this is the right view to take.
9. Mr. C.K Shah, says that so far as the Bombay Municipal Boroughs Act, 1925, is concerned there was a distinct provision and that provision is to be found in S. 78. He says that there is no corresponding provision to be found in the Bombay Municipal Corporations Act, 1949. But, in our view, rule 7(1) is, in itself, clear. It provides for a deduction of 10 per cent which, we think, is a flat rate, and what is significant is the expression ‘on any other account whatever’. Some reasonable meaning must be given to this expression. It means obviously, we think, that the municipal taxes cannot be omitted from consideration in determining the rateable value of a property.
10. Mr. V.S Desai, the learned Assistant Government Pleader, to whom we are indebted for mentioning to us the practice prevailing in the three Municipal Boroughs existing in this State, says that the practice as prevailing in Bombay and in Poona is that the municipal taxes are not taken into consideration, whereas in Ahmedabad the practice is to take into consideration the municipal taxes along with the rent in determining the rateable value of a property. But we think that the practice, if any, cannot surely be a determining factor in ascertaining the true meaning of R. 7(1). If there is a lease between a landlord and a tenant and by the lease the tenant agrees to pay the municipal taxes and the landlord is saved, to that extent, from the payment of municipal taxes, there is no reason why we should not consider the municipal taxes as forming part of the rent. It is at least in the nature of rent and this view is supported by the observations to which reference has been made already and also having regard to the definition of the expression ‘rent’ as occurring in S. 105 of the Transfer of Property Act.
11. In our view, therefore, the decision of the learned Assistant Judge is right.
12. Mr. R.M Shah, has pointed out S. 413 of the Act as affording an answer to the applicants' contentions. Section 413, by sub-section (1), provides that every rateable value fixed under the Act against which no complaint is made as hereinbefore provided, and the amount of every sum claimed from any person under this Act on account of any tax, if no appeal therefrom is made as hereinbefore provided, and the decision of the Judge aforesaid upon any appeal against any such value or tax if no appeal is made therefrom under S. 411 and if such appeal is made the decision of the District Court in such appeal shall be final. Mr. R.M Shah says that the intention seems to be that the order of the District Court is to be final, which means that the matter cannot be agitated further by way of revision in this Court. Now, the present application is under S. 115 of the Code and we can interfere only if the case falls within any one of the three clauses of S. 115. But, surely, it cannot be suggested that if the question is one of principle, the High Court will be powerless to interpret the provisions of law, and Mr. R.M Shah has not contended in that sense. His contention is that the jurisdiction of the High Court to interfere in revision is a limited jurisdiction and unless it is shown that the decision is one which strictly comes within one of the three clauses of S. 115, we should not interfere with the order of the Court below. There is something to be said in support of this contention; but as, in our view, the decision of the Court below is right, it is not necessary to consider the precise scope of S. 413 of the Act.
13. The result is that the view taken by the Court below is right. The application, therefore, fails and the rule will be discharged with costs.
14. Revisional application No. 80 of 1956 raises a similar point. In that application the applicants are the same and the year in question is the year 1953-1954. The point raised in this revisional application is precisely the same and for the reasons given in revisional application No. 825 of 1955, this application must also fail and the rule will be discharged with costs.
D.H.Z
Rule discharged.
Alert