Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Mysore State Board Of Wakfs, v. K.S Lakshmaiah Setty, .

Karnataka High Court
Aug 1, 1973
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Summary of the Opinion (Venkataramiah, J.)

Factual and Procedural Background

The plaintiff instituted O.S. No. 98 of 1966 in the Civil Judge, Bangalore City seeking a declaration of title to a parcel of land (the "suit property") described in the plaint schedule, a permanent injunction restraining the Mysore State Board of Wakfs (the defendant) from interfering with his possession, and correction of an entry in Notification No. MBW-19(1)-64 dated 7-6-1965 issued by the defendant to exclude the suit property from that notification. The plaintiff alleged he purchased the land by a registered sale deed dated 25-5-1958 and erected a building thereon at a cost of about Rs. 50,000. In 1965 the defendant published a notification under Section 5 of the Wakfs Act, 1954 listing the suit property as wakf property. As required by Section 6(1) of the Act, the plaintiff filed the suit and had issued a notice under Section 56 of the Act before instituting it.

The defendant contested the suit, pleading that the suit property and adjacent properties had been dedicated as wakf property, that there were three graves and an Ashurkhana on the property, and that an 'Urs' had been held there for a long time. The trial Court overruled the defendant's contentions and entered a decree in favour of the plaintiff, but fixed the pleader's fee at Rs. 30 and omitted to direct the correction of the notification entry. The defendant appealed (R.F.A. No. 57 of 1969) against the declaration of title and injunction; the plaintiff appealed (R.F.A. No. 22 of 1969) against the fixation of pleader's fee and the omission to direct correction of the notification. This opinion decides both appeals.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the suit property was a wakf (i.e., dedicated for religious purposes) and therefore beyond the plaintiff's title and possession.
  2. Whether the plaintiff was entitled to a declaration of title and a permanent injunction against the defendant.
  3. Whether the trial Court should have directed the defendant to correct/delete the suit property's entry in the Notification issued under Section 5 of the Wakfs Act and publish a corrigendum.
  4. Whether the pleader's fee fixed by the trial Court at Rs. 30 was appropriate, or whether it should be fixed ad valorem according to the value of the suit.

Arguments of the Parties

Plaintiff's Case

  • The plaintiff purchased the suit property under a registered sale deed dated 25-5-1958 (marked Ext. P-6) from previous owners and had constructed a building on it at considerable expense (about Rs. 50,000).
  • Municipal assessment was being collected in respect of the suit land (contrasting with typical practice that municipal assessment is not collected for property endowed for religious or charitable purposes under Section 64 of the Mysore City Municipalities Act).
  • The plaintiff and his predecessors-in-interest had been in possession of the property for over 30 years prior to suit.
  • The plaintiff sought deletion of the entry in the notification published under Section 5 of the Wakfs Act concerning the suit property.

Defendant's Arguments

  • The defendant pleaded that the suit property and adjacent properties had been dedicated as wakf property.
  • It was alleged that there were three graves of Muslim saints and an Ashurkhana on the property and that an 'Urs' had long been celebrated there, supporting a claim of wakf by dedication or by user.
  • The defendant relied on the principle of wakf by user and referred to precedents (including a Privy Council decision) to support the contention that burial/graveyards may indicate wakf status in appropriate circumstances.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Ali Muhammed Khan v. Ali Akbar Khan, AIR 1924 Lah 58 That mere burial of a saintly person or the presence of graves does not, by itself, convert land into trust/wakf property; onus to establish dedication lies on the party alleging it. The Court relied on this authority to hold that the mere existence of a few graves or occasional Urs does not prove dedication; the defendant failed to discharge the onus of proving a dedication.
Baquar Khan v. Raghavindra Pratap Sahi, AIR 1934 Oudh 263 Supports the proposition that existence of some graves on land is not sufficient by itself to presume wakf status. The Court cited this decision to reinforce that the presence of kachcha graves is insufficient to presume dedication as wakf property without stronger proof.
Court of Wards v. Ilahi Baksh, (1913) ILR 40 Cal 297 (PC) Recognized that a graveyard with many graves and official entries in land records may give rise to a presumption of wakf by user, especially where record entries (e.g., under the Punjab Land Revenue Act) support the presumption. The Court distinguished this Privy Council decision on its facts (large graveyard plus supportive entries in record-of-rights) and held it inapplicable to the present case, where there were only a few graves and no supporting official entries.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court analyzed both the evidentiary record and the applicable legal principles. Key elements of its reasoning were:

  • Title and documentary evidence: The plaintiff produced a registered sale deed dated 25-5-1958 (Ext. P-6) showing purchase from prior owners. The plaintiff had built on the land and municipal assessment was being collected, which the Court regarded as inconsistent with treatment as endowed religious/charitable property (referencing Section 64 of the Mysore City Municipalities Act).
  • Insufficiency of defendant's evidence on wakf status: The defendant's case relied on alleged graves, an Ashurkhana and the holding of an 'Urs'. The Court found that there were no graves on the suit land itself (graves were on adjacent land sold to another), and there was no satisfactory evidence of any Ashurkhana or Makan on the suit land. Testimony about prior celebrations (Urs or Sandal) was discrepant and unreliable, and crucial witnesses (such as members of the Jamait who participated, or managers supervising the celebrations) were not produced although said to be available.
  • On the principle of lost grant (wakf by user): The Court explained that to apply the lost grant principle (i.e., presuming a lost grant/dedication from long-standing user) there must be satisfactory evidence that the grant was lost in antiquity and that the property had been used as wakf for a long period without interference. Here, there was no satisfactory evidence of long uninterrupted user on the suit land; in particular no 'Urs or Sandal' took place there after 1958 and evidence about earlier celebrations was unreliable. Accordingly, the conditions for inferring dedication by lost grant were not satisfied.
  • Precedential support: The Court relied on earlier decisions (Ali Muhammed Khan; Baquar Khan) to hold that mere presence of a few graves or occasional religious activity does not establish dedication as wakf without proof of dedication. The Privy Council decision in Court of Wards v. Ilahi Baksh was considered distinguishable because that case concerned a large graveyard and was supported by entries in government records (which are absent here).
  • Possession and onus: Because the plaintiff had been in possession (and in light of his title evidence and long possession by predecessors), and because the defendant failed to prove wakf status and thus ownership/administration rights, the plaintiff was entitled to protect his possession against all but the true owner. The Court thus affirmed the trial Court's declaration of title and grant of injunction to the plaintiff.
  • Remedial and procedural corrections: Having found for the plaintiff on title, the Court held that the trial Court should have directed the defendant to delete the suit property's entry in the Section 5 notification and, if necessary, publish a corrigendum in the Mysore Gazette. Regarding costs/taxation, the Court found the trial Court gave no reason for fixing the pleader's fee at Rs. 30 and held that, given the nature and complexity of the suit, the pleader's fee should be fixed ad valorem according to the value of the suit and relevant rules.

Holding and Implications

Holding:

R.F.A. 57 of 1969 — DISMISSED (the defendant's appeal challenging the declaration of title and injunction was dismissed).

R.F.A. 22 of 1969 — ALLOWED (the plaintiff's appeal regarding correction of the notification and the pleader's fee was allowed, subject to directions below).

Direct consequences and orders:

  • The trial Court's decree declaring the plaintiff to be the owner of the suit property and granting injunction stands; the defendant failed to establish that the property was wakf.
  • The defendant (Mysore State Board of Wakfs) is directed to delete the entry in respect of the suit property from the Notification issued under Section 5 of the Wakfs Act and to publish a Corrigendum in the Mysore Gazette to that effect within four months from the date of the judgment.
  • The pleader's fee previously fixed at Rs. 30 by the trial Court is set aside; the pleader's fee is to be fixed ad valorem based on the value of the suit in accordance with the governing rules.
  • Costs: R.F.A. 57 of 1969 is dismissed with costs; R.F.A. 22 of 1969 is allowed with no order as to costs.

Implications for precedent or broader law: The Court applied existing principles (including the lost-grant concept and authorities establishing that mere graves or intermittent religious observance do not alone establish dedication). The opinion does not announce a new legal principle; it applies established tests and distinguishes earlier authority (including a Privy Council decision) on the facts.

Show all summary ...

Venkataramiah, J.:— These two appeals are filed against the decree passed in O.S No. 98 of 1966 on the file of the Civil Judge, Bangalore City. The plaintiff instituted the said suit for a declaration of his title to the property described in the schedule attached to the plaint and for a permanent injunction restraining the defendant, i.e Mysore State Board of Wakfs from interfering with his possession. It was also prayed that an entry made in the Notification No. MBW-19(1)-64, dated 7-6-1965 issued by the defendant, should be suitably corrected excluding the plaint schedule property from the operation of the said Notification. The plaint schedule property is a piece of land situated in Old Taluk Cutcheri Road, Bangalore City, on which a building has been recently constructed. The case of the plaintiff is that he had purchased the land referred to above from its predecessors-in-interest under a registered sale deed dated 25-5-1958 and thereafter had constructed a building thereon at a cost of about Rs. Fifty thousand. In the year 1965 the Mysore State Board of Wakfs (the defendant), published a notification under Section 5 of the Wakfs Act, 1954 (hereinafter referred to as the Act) mentioning at Sl. No. 143 thereof that the suit property was a Wakfs property. As required by Section 6(1) of the Act, the plaintiff filed the above suit for declaration of his title, permanent injunction and other reliefs. Before instituting the above suit, the plaintiff had issued a notice to the defendant under Section 56 of the Act intimating the defendant that such a suit would be filed.

2. The defendant contested the suit. On behalf of the defendant it was pleaded, that the suit property along with certain other properties lying adjacent to it had been dedicated as Wakf property. It was further pleaded that on the said Wakf property there were three graves of Muslim saints and an Ashurkhana. It was also alleged that at that place a ‘Urs’ was going on from a long time. In view of the foregoing, it was claimed by the, defendant that the property in question was a Wakf. The trial Court after overruling the contention of the defendant, made a decree in favour of the plaintiff. While doing so, it fixed the Pleader's fee at Rs. 30 and omitted to give a direction with regard to the correction of the entry in the notification published under Section 5 of the Act, as prayed for in the plaint.

3. The defendant has filed R.F.A No. 57 of 1969 questioning the decree in so far as it declared the title of the plaintiff and granted injunction against the defendant and the plaintiff has filed R.F.A No. 22 of 1969 in so far as the Court below fixed the Pleader's fee at Rs. 30 and omitted to issue a direction for the correction of the notification. Hence these two appeals.

4. We shall first take up for consideration the appeal filed by the defendant. The plaintiff's case is that he had purchased the suit property under a registered sale deed lated 25-5-1958 marked as Ext. P-6 in the case executed by its previous owners Abdul Rahim Khan, Maimuna Khatun Chandbi, Ameena Khatun and Saffla Khatun.

5. It is also seen that Municipal assessment was being collected in respect of the suit land. Ordinarily no municipal assessment would be collected in respect of a property which is endowed for religious or charitable purposes (vide Section 64 of the Mysore City Municipalities Act). We are not satisfied from the evidence on record that Abdul Rahim (P.W 1) had ever functioned as a Muthavalli, or a Muzavar, or a Makandar, or a Manager of the Wakf property and, therefore, any alienation made by him cannot be considered as an alienation made by a Muthavalli of Wakf Property.

6. It is no doubt true that it is stated in Ext. P-1 that there were three graves on the land dealt with therein and that there is also a reference to a Makan therein. It is admitted on all hands that there are no graves on the suit land. There is also no satisfactory evidence to show that on the suit land, there ever existed an Ashoorkhana or a Makan. Graves are admittedly on a piece of land sold to one Anantharamaiah which is adjoining the suit property. P.W 1 Abdul Rahim has deposed that the said graves were of his great-grandfather, his brother and his son. D.W 3 has stated that the place where Panjas were being kept during Muharam was situated to the west of the graves and the place where the graves were situated and 10-15 feet open space all-round the grave had been sold in favour of Anantharamaiah. It is, therefore, clear that on the suit land, there was neither a grave nor a Makan or an Ashoorkhana. The question for consideration is whether on the evidence that is available in the case it is permissible for the court to presume relying upon the principle of lost grant, on which reliance was placed by Shri Savanur, learned counsel for the defendant that the property in question was a Wakf by user. As already mentioned by us there is no satisfactory evidence to show that any ‘Urs or Sandal’ was being carried on the suit property. No member of the Jamait who actually participated in such ‘Sandal or Urs’ has been examined as a witness in this case. The Manager or a person who was supervising the ‘Sandal or Urs’ has not been examined by the defendant, although it is stated by D.W 1 that they were available. In order to hold that the property had become Wakf by user by applying the principle of lost grant, there must be satisfactory evidence to show that the grant itself was lost in antiquity and the evidence about it was not available and further that the property was being used as Wakf property for a long time without interference. Admittedly from 1958, after the plaintiff purchased the property, no ‘Urs or Sandal’ took place there and the evidence regarding the celebration of ‘Urs’ prior to that is hopelessly discrepant and unreliable. In this state of affairs, it is very difficult to hold that the defendant had established that the property was Wakf by user by applying the principle of lost grant. Mere presence of 2 or 3 graves on a piece of land is not sufficient to hold that the property on which the graves are situated had been dedicated as Wakf property. In Ali Muhammed Khan v. Ali Akbar Khan, AIR 1924 Lah 58, Shadi Lal, C.J, has observed as follows:

“Mr. Tek Chand for the appellant is unable to cite any authority to support the contention that the mere burial of a saintly person in a plot of land has the effect of converting that land into trust property, and we do not think that the circumstance that Urs was held for a few years without any demur by the defendants materially advances the case for the plaintiff…… Be that as it may the onus was clearly upon the plaintiff to establish a “dedication”, express or implied, to public religious uses, and we consider that he has failed to discharge that onus.”

7. It is, therefore, clear that the mere existence of two or three graves on or near the suit land or the circumstance that Urs was being carried on there for some time, even if true, is not sufficient to hold that it is wakf property without proof of dedication of the same for religious purpose. To the same effect is the opinion of the High Court of Allahabad in Baquar Khan v. Raghavindra Pratap Sahi, AIR 1934 Oudh 263 wherein it was held that the existence of some kachha graves of the members of the defendant's family on a land, was not by itself sufficient to presume that the land was wakf property. Reliance was however placed by Sri Savanur on a decision of the Privy Council in Court of Wards v. Ilahi Baksh, (1913) ILR 40 Cal 297 (PC) in support of his contention that a grave-yard must be considered as Wakf property. The facts of that case are clearly distinguishable from the facts of the present case. The subject-matter of the above decision was a grave-yard on which there were a large number of graves and in the Record of Rights maintained by the Government it had been mentioned that the said graveyard was in the possession of Mohammedans of the locality. The Privy Council relying upon the entries made in the Registers maintained under the Punjab Land Revenue Act was of the opinion that the land in question was a Wakf by user in the absence of any reliable evidence to rebut the presumption arising under the said Act Hence the said decision is of no avail to the defendant.

8. The plaintiff has been admittedly in possession of the property and he is entitled to maintain his possession against the whole world except the true owner. The defendant has failed to show that it was Wakf property and it is entitled to administer the same. The plaintiff is, therefore, entitled to the relief of injunction prayed for by him. The evidence adduced by the plaintiff in the casa shows that he and his predecessors-in-interest have been in possession of the same for more than 30 years prior to the date of suit. In the circumstances, we are of opinion that the Court below was right in declaring that the plaintiff was the owner of the suit property and that the defendant had failed to establish its case. We, therefore, find no substance in the appeal—R.F.A 57/1969—filed by the defendant.

9. In R.F.A 22/1969 filed by the plaintiff, there are two prayers: (1) that the Court below was wrong in not issuing direction to the defendant to rectify the Notification issued by it by deleting the suit property from the list of Wakf properties; and (2) the Court below was wrong in fixing the Pleader's fee at Rs. 30 for the purpose of taxation of costs. When the Court below came to the conclusion that the suit property belonged to the plaintiff and that it was not Wakf property, it should have issued a direction to the defendant to delete the suit property from the list of Wakf properties and publish if necessary, a Corrigendum in Mysore Gazette to that effect. As the continuance of an entry in respect of the suit property in the Notification issued under Section 5 of the Act is likely to create a cloud on the title to the property, we accept the submission made by the plaintiff in that behalf and direct the defendant to delete the entry in respect of the suit property in the Notification issued under Section 5 of the Act and to publish a Corrigendum in Mysore Gazette to the above effect. In so far as Pleader's fee is concerned, the Court below has not given any reason for fixing it at Rs. 30. The suit was one for declaration of title and injunction. Having regard to the complex questions involved in the case and the nature of the suit, the Court below was wrong in fixing the Pleader's fee at Rs. 30. We direct that the Pleader's fee should be fixed ad valorem on the basis of the value of the suit in accordance with the rules governing the said question. The decree passed by the Court below is modified by (1) directing the defendant to delete the entry in respect of the suit property from the Notification issued under Section 5 of the Act and to publish a Corrigendum to that effect in Mysore Gazette within a period of 4 months from today; and (ii) directing the Pleader's fee to be fixed in accordance with the rules according to the value of the suit as directed above. R.F.A 22 of 1969 is allowed accordingly.

10. In the result, R.F.A 57 of 1969 is dismissed with costs and R.F.A 22 of 1969 is allowed, but with no order as to costs.

R.F.A 57 of 1969 dismissed;

11. R.F.A 22 of 1969 allowed.