Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Parbati Maiti v. The State Of West Bengal & Ors.

Calcutta High Court
Apr 29, 2013
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

These writ applications were filed by petitioners seeking payment of interest for delayed payment of gratuity. The petitioners, mainly Assistant Teachers of various West Bengal Recognised Non-Government Educational Institutions, claimed that gratuity payments were made after considerable delay despite timely submission of pension booklets. One petitioner’s claim arose from the deceased husband’s service. The applications were consolidated for analogous hearing due to identical issues. The Government had issued a scheme on May 26, 1998, prescribing procedures for pension and gratuity payments, including payment of interest for delayed gratuity disbursement and disciplinary action against responsible officials. The petitioners argued entitlement to interest under this scheme, while the State respondents contended that the claims were barred by delay in filing and practical difficulties in recovering interest from retired or changed officials.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the petitioners are entitled to interest for delayed payment of gratuity under the Government Order dated May 26, 1998.
  2. Whether delay in filing writ applications is a valid ground to reject claims for interest on delayed gratuity payments.
  3. The applicability and enforceability of disciplinary and recovery provisions against erring officials in cases of delayed gratuity payment.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' Arguments

  • The Government Order framed a scheme mandating payment of gratuity and interest for delay, making petitioners entitled to interest.
  • The petitioners submitted pension booklets timely, but gratuity payments were delayed without protest or reminder.
  • Delay in filing writ petitions should not bar claims as no parallel rights or third-party interests have been affected.
  • The State’s opposition contradicts government policy aimed at enforcing timely payment and recovery of interest from erring officers.

State Respondents' Arguments

  • Petitioners accepted gratuity payments without protest, and writ applications were filed after long delays, some exceeding ten years.
  • No explanation was provided for the delay in filing writ petitions.
  • Due to the passage of time, recovery of interest from retired or changed officials is practically infeasible.
  • Reliance on precedents supports rejecting stale claims and emphasizes procedural and practical considerations in enforcement.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Satya Ranjan Das v. State Of West Bengal & Ors. (2007) 3 Cal LT 531 (HC) Enforcement of Government Order mandating payment of gratuity and interest; disciplinary action against erring officials. Confirmed the right to interest and directed enquiry into lapses, holding officials responsible.
S.K Dua v. State of Haryana (2008) 3 SCC 44 Right to interest for delayed payment of retiral benefits even in absence of statutory rules, relying on constitutional rights. Supported petitioners’ entitlement to interest on delayed gratuity payments.
Union of India v. Tarsem Singh (2008) 8 SCC 648 Relief for continuing wrongs despite delay; exception where no settled third-party rights are affected. Applied to allow claims despite delay as no parallel rights were disturbed.
State of Madhya Pradesh v. Bhailal Bhai AIR 1964 SC 1006 General principle permitting rejection of belated claims in writ petitions. Held not applicable due to peculiar facts and government policy in these cases.
M.R Gupta v. Union of India (1995) 5 SCC 628 Delay in pay fixation claims. Distinguished and held inapplicable to delayed gratuity payment claims.
New Delhi Municipal Council v. Pan Singh (2007) 9 SCC 278 Delay and parity in pay scales claims. Distinguished and held inapplicable to gratuity payment cases.
Shiv Dass v. Union of India (2007) 9 SCC 274 Restriction of relief for pension claims to three years. Held not applicable due to different facts and circumstances.
A.P Steel Re-rolling Mill Ltd. v. State of Kerala & Ors. (2007) 2 SCC 725 Belated claims for concessional tariff. Held inapplicable due to distinguishable facts.
Bakshish Singh v. Darshan Engineering Works (1994) 1 SCC 9 Recognition of gratuity as a retiral benefit and not merely a discretionary bounty. Supported the characterization of gratuity as a legitimate service benefit.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court analyzed the Government Order dated May 26, 1998, which created a legal right to gratuity payment on retirement along with interest for delay and disciplinary consequences for officials responsible for lapses. The Court recognized gratuity as a retiral benefit, not a mere bounty, citing authoritative precedent. It rejected the State’s contention that delay in filing writ petitions barred claims, emphasizing that the rule against stale claims is a discretionary practice, not an absolute legal bar. The Court applied the principle that relief for continuing wrongs can be granted despite delay if no third-party rights are affected. It disapproved the State’s argument regarding practical difficulties in recovery, noting that recovery from erring officers is not a condition precedent for payment of interest to employees. The Court relied on prior judgments confirming the entitlement to interest and directing enquiry and disciplinary action where delays occurred. It distinguished precedents cited by the State as inapplicable due to differing facts and legal contexts. Ultimately, the Court directed the Government to conduct an enquiry within six months and mandated payment of interest at 9% per annum for delayed gratuity payments, with liberty to recover the amount from responsible officers and initiate disciplinary proceedings.

Holding and Implications

DISPOSED OF

The writ applications were disposed of with directions to the Secretary to the Government of West Bengal, Education Department, to enquire into delayed gratuity payments and determine interest payable at 9% per annum. Payment of interest must be made within four weeks of the enquiry's decision. The State Government is granted liberty to recover the interest amount from erring officers and to initiate disciplinary proceedings within two months. No costs were ordered. The decision enforces government policy ensuring timely gratuity payments and interest for delay, reinforcing accountability of officials without creating new precedent beyond the facts of these cases.

Show all summary ...

JUDGMENT

1. All these writ applications have been filed by the petitioners praying for payment of interest for delayed payment of gratuity.

2. Since the issue involved in these writ applications are same: and identical, all these writ applications are taken up for analogous hearing.

3. All the aforesaid writ petitioners, except the writ petitioner in W.P No. 16953(W) of 2012, were Assistant Teachers of different West Bengal Recognised Non-Government Educational Institutions. In W.P No. 16953(W) of 2012, the deceased husband of the petitioner was an Assistant Teacher of a West Bengal Recognised Non-Government Educational Institution. The dates of retirement on attaining age of retirement on superannuation, the dates of payment of gratuity for the first time as also the respective dates of filing writ petitions are stated below:—

(1) (2) (3) (4) W.P No. Date of Retirement Date of issuing first P.P.O Date of affirming of the Writ Petition 19675(W)/2012 31-12-2000 12-03-2001 29-08-2012 19691(W)/2012 31-03-1996 07-05-1997 & 20-09-2001 29-08-2012 23950(W)/2012 31-12-1999 05-02-2002 16-10-2012 1497(W)/2013 30-05-2003 07-05-2003 16-01-2013 25463(W)/2012 31-10-2002 10-10-2002 23-11-2012 3215(W)/2013 31-01-2003 31-01-2003 30-01-2013 23591[W)/2012 31-03-2004 03-09-2004 09-10-2012 25460(W)/2012 31-01-2002 07-07-2003 23-11-2012 1-249(W)/2013 30-11-2004 06-06-2007 15-01-2013 599(W)/2013 28-02-2003 30-12-2005 08-01-2013 600(W)/2013 30-06-2005 26-09-2008 08-01-2013 25467(W)/2012 30-09-2000 14-08-2002 23-11-2012 19701(W)/2012 31-01-1996 15-05-1997 & 22-01-2002 29-08-2012 16442(W)/2012 31-01-2005 19-07-2005 25-07-2012 5043(W)/2013 31-03-2002 30-03-2002 14-02-2013 16548(W)/2012 31-05-2005 16-09-2005 25-07-2012 17250(W)/2012 30-09-1997 31-07-1998 & 02-05-2000 31-07-2012 16953(W)/2012 28-02-2002 31-03-2002 31-07-2012 26173(W)/2012 31-01-1996 17-06-1998 & 04-07-2000 06-12-2012 26279(W)/2012 28-02-2003 26-02-2003 07-12-2012 26320(W)/2012 31-05-2002 31-12-2002 07-12-2012 26281(W)/2012 31-03-2001 05-10-2001 07-12-2012 26313(W)/2012 31-03-2001 15-03-2002 07-12-2012 26311(W)/2012 31-05-2003 07-06-2004 07-12-2012 26310(W)/2012 30-04-2002 22-04-2002 07-12-2012 25938(W)/2012 31-01-1998 07-07-1999 & 16-05-2000 04-12-2012 26325(W)/2012 31-05-2003 13-06-2003 07-12-2012 26322(W)/2012 30-12-2002 23-06-2004 07-12-2012 26306(W)/2012 31-10-2005 20-09-2006 07-12-2012 25954(W)/2012 30-11-2001 25-03-2002 04-12-2012 25999(W)/2012 30-06-2003 03-06-2003 30-08-2012 25784(W)/2012 31-10-2003 02-07-2004 04-12-2012

4. By a Government Order issued under Memo No. 88.SE(B)/EES/OIB/ IM-9/98 dated May 26, 1998 (hereinafter referred to as “the said Government Order”), the scheme for payment of pension and gratuity on the date of superannuation of the employees of West Bengal Recognised Non- Government Educational Institutions and Comprehensive Form in connection with sanction of pension cases was framed. In Paragraph 8 of the said Government Order, procedure for payment of interest for delayed payment of retiring benefits to the aforesaid employees have been dealt with and the aforesaid Paragraph is quoted below:—

“(8) Failure to comply with the provisions as stated above by the concerned authorities shall be seriously viewed and may make such Authorities liable for disciplinary action.

In particular the Head of the Institution, Sub-Inspector (Circle), Pension Sanctioning Authority, Asstt. Director of Accounts/Finance Officer, DPSC, the DPPG, WB, and the P.D.O/T.O shall be held personally responsible for non-compliance with the procedure required to be followed by them for payment of pension. For any lapses on their part in this regard, the concerned authorities apart from being liable for disciplinary action, may also be required to pay to the Government such amount which Government may have to pay additionally by way of interest for delayed payment of retiring benefits to the employees.”

5. According to the petitioners, all the concerned Assistant Teachers filled up their respective pension booklets and submitted the same to the appropriate authorities in time. The gratuity amounts were released by the respondent authorities after delay of considerable periods of time. These writ applications have been filed for payment of interest for, delay in payment of gratuity amounts for the period between due date of payment and actual date of payment.

6. It is submitted on behalf of the petitioners that a scheme prescribing procedure for payment of pension and gratuity on the date of superannuation of the employees of West Bengal Recognised Non-Government Educational Institutions has been introduced by the Government. The above scheme also laid down the procedure for payment of interest in case of delayed payment of pension and gratuity to the aforesaid employees. According to the petitioners, all of them are entitled to get interest for delayed payment of gratuity to the concerned Assistant Teachers of the Recognised Non- Government Educational Institutions.

7. According to the petitioners, delay in filing writ application cannot be a ground for rejecting their claims. According to them, the real test to be applied in dealing with the issue of delay is that no parallel right or third party interest has been created. It is further submitted on behalf of the petitioners that the decision of the respondent-authority to oppose the claims of the petitioners runs counter to the Government policy for payment of interest on the ground of delay in releasing pension and/or gratuity to the employees of West Bengal Recognised Non-Government Educational Institutions as also recovery of such interest from the erring Officer.

8. The decisions of Satya Ranjan Das v. State Of West Bengal & Ors., reported in (2007) 3 Cal LT 531 (HC), Smt. Padma Rani Thakur v. The Secretary, Department of Home, reported in 2007(1) CLJ (Cal) 21, S.K Dua v. State of Haryana, reported in (2008) 3 SCC 44, Union of India v. Tarsem Singh, reported in (2008) 8 SCC 648, Niranjan Kumar Mondal v. The State of West Bengal, reported in (2012) 1 WBLR (Cal) 903, S.R Bhanrale v. Union of India, reported in (1996) 10 SCC 172 : AIR 1997 SC 27, unreported decision dated February 20, 2008 of Satya Ranjan Das v. State of West Bengal (In re: F.M.A.222 of 2008), Unreported decision dated July 1, 2008 of Abha Acharya v. State of West Bengal (In re: W.P 10750(W) of 2007), unreported decision dated May 14, 2009 of Mohan Ch. Haider v. State of West Bengal (In re: W.P No. 30264(W) of 2008), unreported decision dated February 12, 2010 of Dulal Chandra Pramanik v. The State of West Bengal (In re: W.P No. 1092(W) of 2010), unreported decision dated September 6, 2010 of Ramendra Nath Mukherjee v. The State of West Bengal (In re: M.A.T No. 933 of 2010), unreported decision dated March 1, 2011 of Mangal Sau v. State (In re: M.A.T No. 68 of 2011) and unreported decision dated June 6, 2012 of Bisweswar Rakshit v. The State of West Bengal (In re: W.P No. 3657(W) of 2012) are relied upon.

9. It is submitted on behalf of the State-respondents that all the Assistant Teachers under reference accepted payments of gratuity money without interest raising no protest. These writ applications are filed after a considerable period of delay praying for a direction upon the respondents for payment of interest due to delayed payment of gratuity. Delay in filing these writ applications is more than ten years in some of the cases.

10. It is also submitted on behalf of the respondents that no explanation is attributed in support of delay in filing these writ applications for realisation of interest on the ground of delayed payment of gratuity. According to the respondents, State Government issued the said Government Order providing for payment of interest for delay in disbursement of retiral benefits and for recovering such payment from erring Officer and/or for initiating disciplinary proceeding against erring officer in appropriate cases. But due to delay in filing the writ applications, there are cases where concerned erring Officers retired from the services on attaining the age of retirement on superannuation. The concerned Secretaries, Headmasters or Presidents of some of the concerned Non- Government Educational Institutions have been changed due passage of considerable period of time. Therefore, recovery of the aforesaid interests from the above persons are practically not feasible.

11. Reliance is placed by the State-respondents on the decisions of State of Madhya Pradesh v. Bhailal Bhai, reported in AIR 1964 SC 1006, M.R Gupta v. Union of India, reported in (1995) 5 SCC 628, Sri Ashok alias Somanna Gowda v. State of Karnataka, reported in (1992) 1 SCC 28 : AIR 1992 SC 80, New Delhi Municipal Council v. Pan Singh, reported in (2007) 9 SCC 278 , Shiv Dass v. Union of India, reported in (2007) 9 SCC 274, State of Orissa v. Mamata Mohanty, reported in (2011) 3 SCC 436 and A.P Steel Re-rolling Mill Ltd. v. State of Kerala & Ors., reported in (2007) 2 SCC 725.

12. I have heard the learned Counsel appearing for the respective parties at length and have considered the facts and circumstances of these cases carefully.

13. In Writ Petitions bearing Nos. 1497(W) of 2013, 25463(W) of 2012, 3215(W) of 2013, 5043(W) of 2013, 26279(W) of 2012, 26310(W) of 2012 & 25999(W) of 2012, though the Pension Payment Orders were issued in time, the gratuity money was paid to the petitioners after delay of considerable period.

14. So far as other cases are concerned, the period of delay in paying the gratuity money varied from 2 weeks to 2 years and 8 months. It is not in dispute that in all those cases, the gratuity money was received without raising any protest for delay in paying the same. The period of delay in filing the aforesaid writ applications varied from 4 years 4 months to 12 years 7 months. Gratuity is also termed as “bounty”. In Black's Law Dictionary, Eighth Edition (at Page 198) the term “bounty” is defined as follows:

“bounty. 1. A premium or benefit offered or given, esp. by a government, to induce someone to take action or perform a service a bounty for the killing of dangerous animals. 2. A gift, esp. in a will; generosity in giving the court will distribute the testator's bounty equally. 3. The portion of a salvage award exceeding what the salvor would be entitled to on the basis of quantum meruit. -Also termed gratuity; bonus.”

15. Although, the dictionary meaning suggested that gratuity is a premium or gratuitous payment or a reward for a long and meritorious service, it has been recognized as a retiral benefit in consideration of the past services rendered. Reference may be made to the decision of Bakshish Singh v. Darshan Engineering Works, reported in (1994) 1 SCC 9 and the relevant portions of the above judgment are quoted below:

“16 The dictionary meaning may suggest that gratuity is gratuitous payment, a gift or a boon made by the employer to the employee as per his sweet will. It necessarily means that it is in the discretion of the employer whether to make the payment or not and also to choose the payee as well as the quantum of payment. However, in the industrial adjudication it was considered as a reward for a long and meritorious service and its payment, therefore, depended upon the duration and the quality of the service rendered by the employee. At a later stage, it came to be recognised as a retiral benefit in consideration of the service rendered and the employees could raise an industrial dispute for introducing it as a condition of service. The industrial adjudicators recognised it as such and granted it either in lieu of or in addition to other retrial benefit(s) such as pension or provident fund depending mainly upon the financial stability and capacity of the employer. The other factors which were taken into consideration while introducing gratuity scheme were the service conditions prevalent in the other units in the industry and the region, the availability or otherwise of the other retiral benefits, the standard of other service conditions etc. The quantum of gratuity was also determined by the said factors. The recognition of gratuity as a retiral benefit brought in its wake further modifications of the concept. It could be paid even if the employee resigned or voluntarily retired from service. The minimum qualifying service for entitlement to it, rate at which it was to be paid and the maximum amount payable was determined likewise on the basis of the said factors. It had also to be acknowledged that it could not be denied to the employee on account of his misconduct. He could be denied gratuity only to the extent of the financial loss caused by his misconduct, and no more. Thus even before the present Act was placed on the statute book, the courts had recognised gratuity as a legitimate retiral benefit earned by the employee on account of the service rendered by him. It became a service condition wherever it was introduced whether in lieu of or in addition to the other retiral beriefit(s).”

16. Delayed payment of gratuity has been looked upon with strong disapproval by the Hon'ble Supreme Court and the authority is directed to pay interest for the period between due date of payment and actual date of payment relying upon administrative instructions or guidelines in absence of statutory rules. Reference may be made to the decision of S.K Dua (Supra) and the relevant portions are quoted below:

“13. Having heard the learned counsel for the parties, in our opinion, the appeal deserves to be partly allowed. It is not in dispute by and between the parties, that the appellant retired from service on 30-6-1998. It is also undisputed that at the time of retirement from service, the appellant had completed more than three decades in government service. Obviously, therefore, he was entitled to retiral benefits in accordance with law. True it is that certain charge-sheets/show-cause notices were issued against him and the appellant was called upon to show cause why disciplinary proceedings should not be initiated against him. It is, however, the case of the appellant that all those actions had been taken at the instance of Mr Quraishi against whom serious allegations of malpractices and misconduct had been levelled by the appellant which resulted in removal of Mr Quraishi from the post of Secretary, Irrigation. The said Mr Quraishi then became Principal Secretary to the Chief Minister. Immediately thereafter charge-sheets were issued to the appellant and proceedings were initiated against him. The fact remains that proceedings were finally dropped and all retrial benefits were extended to the appellant. But it also cannot be denied that those benefits were given to the appellant after four years.

14. In the circumstances, prima facie, we are of the view that the grievance voiced by the appellant appears to be well founded that he would be entitled to interest on such benefits. If there are statutory rules occupying the field, the appellant could claim payment of interest relying on such rules. If there are administrative instructions, guidelines or norms prescribed for the purpose, the appellant may claim benefit of interest on that basis. But even in absence of statutory rules, administrative instructions or guidelines, an employee can claim interest under Part III of the Constitution relying on Articles 14, 19 and 21 of the Constitution. The submission of the learned counsel for the appellant, that retrial benefits are not in the nature of “bounty” is, in our opinion, well founded and needs no authority in support thereof. In that view of the matter, in our considered opinion, the High Court was not right in dismissing the petition in limine even without issuing notice to the respondents.”

17. While examining the claim of the petitioners for payment of interest on the ground of delayed payment of gratuity, I find that the first ground of opposing the claim of the petitioners is Inordinate delay in filing the writ petitioners (sic petitions). The rule which says that the High Court may not enquire into belated and stale claim is not a rule of law but the rule of practice based on sound and proper exercise of discretion.

18. It is revealed from the peculiar facts and circumstances of these cases that a right is created by the said Government Order in favour of the West Bengal Recognised Non-Government Educational Institutions to get the benefit of gratuity on the date of retirement as also to get interest on it for delayed payment. The said Government Order further provides for initiating disciplinary proceeding against the erring Officer in appropriate cases for delayed payment of gratuity. Therefore, it is an executive policy of the State Government to ensure payment of gratuity to the employees of West Bengal Recognised Non-Government Educational Institutions on the date of retirement of the employee concerned. Therefore, any error or omission in carrying out the above Government policy results in payment of interest to an employee of the West Bengal Non-Government Educational Institution without any reminder or protest for non-payment of such interest.

19. Secondly, belated approach to the Court by the retired employees of Non-Government Educational Institutions for enforcing their legal right cannot be rejected in view of the settled principle of law that payment of interest in these cases will not make any settled position unsettled. Nor parallel rights have accrued to others by reason of delay in filing these writ petitions which may be disturbed. Reference may be made to the decision of Tarsem Singh (supra) and the relevant portions are quoted below:

“7 .. Where a service related claim is based on a continuing wrong,

relief can be granted even if there is a long delay in seeking remedy, with reference to the date on which the continuing wrong commenced, if such continuing wrong creates a continuing, source of injury. But there is an exception to the exception. If the grievance is in respect of any order or administrative decision which related to or affected several others also, and if the reopening of the issue would affect the settled rights of third parties, then the claim will not be entertained. For example, if the issue relates to payment or refixation of pay or pension, relief may be granted in spite of delay as it does not affect the rights of third parties.”

20. This Court disapproves the submissions made on behalf of the State respondents that due to delay in filing these writ applications there may not be any scope for recovery of the money to be paid to the petitioners towards interest either due to retirement of erring officials or to change of President, Secretary of Managing Committee and/or Headmasters of the concerned Non- Government Educational Institutions. Because, recovery of the money payable towards interest is not condition precedent in accordance with the provisions of the said Government Order. Moreso, the money payable towards interest can be recovered from the retired erring Officer or an erstwhile President, an erstwhile Secretary of Managing Committee or a retired Headmaster by way of raising public demand. That apart, a party to a proceeding cannot pray for a premium for lapse or fault on its part in implementing a Government policy.

21. The issue of payment of interest on the ground of delayed payment of gratuity to the employees of West Bengal Recognised Non-Government Educational Institutions has been answered in favour of the employees concerned by a Single Bench of this High Court in the matter of Satya Raryan Das (supra) and the relevant portions of the above decision are quoted below:

“41. The State of West Bengal through its Principal Secretary, Department of School Education, shall conduct an enquiry and come to a finding whether the procedure that was required to be followed in terms of the Memorandum dated 26th May, 1998, was strictly adhered to or not, by the concerned authority/authorities, who were responsible to follow such procedure, while processing and disbursing the retiral dues of the writ petitioner. While, conducting such enquiry, if it is found that there was even an iota of lapse/ negligence on the part of any such person or persons, the State Government shall fix responsibility upon such delinquent official/officials. The State Government shall immediately thereafter initiate disciplinary action against such delinquent official/officials. If it is found upon completion of enquiry that the procedure which was required to be followed by the concerned official/officials in terms of the Memorandum dated 26th May 1998 was not strictly adhered to, the State Government shall be entitled to hold them personally responsible for such lapse and for non-compliance of the laid down procedure.”

22. The above decision has also been upheld with a slight modification by a Division Bench of this Court by a judgment dated February 20, 2008 in the matter of Satya Raryan Das v. State of West Bengal (In re: F.M.A 222 of 2008 with C.A.N 7837of 2007) and the operative portions of the above decision are quoted below:

“We find merit in the aforesaid submissions made by Mr. Chakraborty and in the facts and circumstances of the present case, we are not inclined to vary the rate of interest as decided by the learned Single Judge. However, we do not think that payment of interest to the petitioner can be dependant on realisation of the amount from the erring official/officials of the State Government. Once the interest amount is determined finally by the competent authority of the State Government then the same has to be paid immediately to the concerned employee, namely, the appellant herein and under no circumstances the appellant should be asked to wait till the realisation of the said amount from the erring official/officials.

In the aforesaid circumstances, we modify the aforesaid direction issued by the learned Single Judge directing the respondent authorities herein to make necessary payment of interest after determination of the same in terms of the judgment and order under appeal at an early date but positively within a period of six weeks from the date of determination of the said amount by the competent authority of the State Government

However, the State Government will be at liberty to realize the said amount from the erring official/officials in terms of the judgment and order under appeal and appropriate the same accordingly.

Only with the aforesaid modification, this appeal stands disposed of

In view of disposal of the appeal, no further order is required to be passed in the connected application for stay and the same is also disposed of accordingly.

There will, however, be no order as to costs.”

23. The general rule of rejecting a belated claim in an application under Article 226 of the Constitution of India as laid down in the matter of Bhailal Bhat(supra) does not help the respondents in these cases, in view of the peculiar facts and circumstances involved in it.

24. In the matter of M.R Gupta (supra), the Hon'ble Supreme Court decided the issue of delay in the matter of fixation of pay. The above decision has no manner of application in these cases involving delay in payment of retiral benefits to the concerned employees ignoring the executive policy of the State Government. For the same reason, the decisions of Pan Singh (supra) and Mamata Mohanty (supra) with regard to parity in pay-scales has no manner of application in these cases.

25. In the matter of Sri Ashok alias Somanna Gowda (supra), the issue of raising a claim in the matter of appointment was decided. It has no manner of application in the matter of retiral benefits to the employees on the basis of the executive policy of the State Government.

26. In the decision of Shiv Dass (supra), the Hon'ble Supreme Court was not inclined to reject the claim for payment of pension altogether and the relief was restricted to the period of 3 years. In view of the distinguishable facts and circumstances of this case, the above decision is also not applicable in these cases.

27. In view of the distinguishable facts and circumstances of these cases, the decision of A.P Steel Re-rolling Mill Ltd. (supra) relating to belated claim of concessional tariff has no manner of application in these cases.

28. In view of the discussions and observations made hereinabove, the Secretary to the Government of West Bengal, Education Department, is directed to conduct an enquiry with regard to delayed payment of gratuity to the petitioners taking into consideration the provisions of the said Government Order and to arrive at a decision within six months from the date of communication of this order. In the event, it is found that there was lapse or negligence on the part of any Government Officer, President/ Secretary of Managing Committee or the Headmaster of the Non-Government Educational Institution concerned, payment of interest at the rate of 9 per cent per annum for the period between due date of payment and actual date of payment shall be released in favour of the concerned petitioner concerned within four weeks from the date of the above decision.

29. Liberty is given to the State Government to realise the above interest from the erring Officer or the person concerned from his salary or by way of raising public demand by initiating appropriate proceeding within two months from the date of the decision of the Secretary to the Government of West Bengal, Education Department for protection of public interest by recovery of money to be spend from public exchequer. The State Government will also be at liberty to initiate disciplinary proceeding against the erring Officer within two months from the date of above decision of the Secretary to the Government ‘of West Bengal, Education Department in appropriate cases.

30. These writ applications are disposed of accordingly.

31. There will be, however, no order as costs.

32. Urgent Photostat certified copy of this judgment, if applied for, be given to the parties, as expeditiously as possible, upon compliance with the necessary formalities in this regard.

33. Writ application disposed of