Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Bajirao Yamanappa Hatgar v. Emperor

Bombay High Court
Apr 10, 1945
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Structured Summary of the Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

On 22 May 1942 S.V. Ghatnatti, Sub-Inspector of Police, was murdered at Kerur. The applicant was arrested on 27 August 1942 in connection with that offence and, together with others, was tried by the Sub‑Divisional Magistrate, First Class, Southern Division, Bijapur, under Sections 147 and 186 read with Section 149 of the Penal Code. The applicant was released on bail on 7 October 1942 and attended the trial on several dates in October 1942 and on 11 May 1943. He subsequently absconded.

On 24 May 1943 the District Magistrate, Bijapur, issued an order under Rule 26 of the Defence of India Rules directing detention of the applicant in Belgaum Central Prison for one year from the date of arrest. A proclamation under Section 87, CrPC, for his arrest was issued on 4 January 1944, and he surrendered on 8 April 1944. The other accused were disposed of and acquitted on 14 September 1943. The District Magistrate sanctioned withdrawal of the case against the applicant on 6 June 1944 and an order for acquittal was made on 24 June 1944.

The Government of Bombay issued an order under clause (b) of sub‑section (1) of Section 3 of Ordinance 3 of 1944 on 23 May 1944 for the applicant's detention; on 6 November 1944 the Government directed that the 23 May 1944 order should continue in force. The applicant was detained continuously from 8 April 1944 and filed the present application under Section 491, CrPC, challenging the legality of his detention and seeking release.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the order of 6 November 1944 (directing continuation of the 23 May 1944 order) issued by the Government of Bombay under Ordinance 3 of 1944 was valid and, consequently, whether the applicant's detention under that order was legal.
  2. Whether Section 10 of Ordinance 3 of 1944 (which declares that no order under the Ordinance shall be called in question in any Court) completely ousts the Court's jurisdiction under Section 491, CrPC, to inquire into the validity of the impugned detention order.
  3. Whether the detaining authority (the Government of Bombay) had, in fact, formed a lawful and proper satisfaction that the applicant's detention was necessary for purposes connected with the security of the State, public safety, maintenance of public order, or the efficient prosecution of the war, rather than for an ulterior or punitive purpose.
  4. Whether the procedural requirement that the proper detaining authority (as contemplated by Section 3 of the Ordinance) be satisfied was complied with in this case—specifically, the relevance of the Governor's role versus the Provincial Government.

Arguments of the Parties

Applicant's Arguments

  • The applicant contended that his detention under the 6 November 1944 order of the Government of Bombay was illegal and that he should be set at liberty.
  • It was argued that the detention was punitive—intended to punish the applicant for the alleged offence (the murder of S.V. Ghatnatti)—because the criminal prosecution had not resulted in his conviction and the Government was using the Ordinance to detain him after the failure to convict by due process.
  • The applicant asserted that the authority required to be satisfied under Section 3 of the Ordinance was the Governor personally and that in this case the Government (not the Governor) purported to be satisfied.
  • It was pointed out that the District Magistrate's R.26 order (24 May 1943) was made only after the applicant absconded, suggesting it was related to the criminal investigation rather than the security/war purposes of the Rules/Ordinance.

Government / Respondent Arguments

  • The Government relied on the face of the 23 May 1944 order and the 6 November 1944 continuation order, contending that Section 10 of Ordinance 3 of 1944 prevents the Court from inquiring into an order made under the Ordinance.
  • It was asserted that the proper authority (the Provincial Government, with the Governor's concurrence) had been satisfied: the order is issued by order of the Governor and Mr. Drewe (Secretary, Home Department) deposed that the Governor agreed to and considered the detention orders.
  • The District Magistrate swore he was satisfied on the basis of reports and information from responsible sources that detention was necessary to prevent the applicant from acting prejudicially to defence, public safety, public order, and the efficient prosecution of the war; the Government relied on that sworn satisfaction.
  • The learned Advocate-General submitted that even if the 23 May 1944 order were attacked, the 6 November 1944 order (which on its face stated it was made after further consideration of all circumstances) sustained the detention, and that further materials may have been placed before the Government between those dates.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
A.I.R. 1944 P.C. 861 (Federal Court; Sir Patrick Spens, C.J.) Affirmation that courts retain power to investigate whether an order purporting to be made under the Defence of India Rules / Ordinance was validly made; Section 10 of Ordinance 3 does not prevent courts from finding that an order was not validly made for established grounds. The court relied on this authority to explain that Section 10 does not completely oust judicial review: the Court may examine whether the detaining order was validly made (i.e., not colourable or otherwise beyond powers).
A.I.R. 1944 Lah. 3732 (Harries C.J.) Rule 129 (Defence of India Rules) or equivalent powers cannot be used for purposes other than ensuring security of the State and efficient prosecution of the war; orders made for wholly different purposes are misuse and not orders under the Rule. The court adopted and agreed with these observations, holding they apply equally to orders under Ordinance 3 of 1944 and using them to assess whether the detaining authority's satisfaction was properly directed to permissible purposes.
A.I.R. 1943 F.C. 753 (Federal Court; Zafrulla Khan J.) Interpretation suggesting that for the defence rules a "Provincial Government" in a Governor's Province contemplates the Governor acting (whether with or without advice); emphasis on the Governor's action. The court discussed this decision, acknowledged its view about the Governor's role, but held that Section 3 contemplates the Provincial Government (of which the Governor is a part); the court found the order issued by the Governor and supported by affidavit stating the Governor agreed, thus rejecting the applicant's formalistic challenge on this ground.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court began by identifying the threshold legal position under Section 10 of Ordinance 3 of 1944: Section 10 bars judicial interference only in respect of an order that is genuinely "made under the Ordinance." Thus the key inquiry is whether the detaining authority in fact made the order in the proper exercise of the power conferred by the Ordinance, observing all required procedures and safeguards, and for purposes within the scope of the Ordinance (security of the State, public safety, maintenance of public order, or efficient prosecution of the war).

The court explained the limits of review: it cannot ordinarily examine the sufficiency or reasonableness of the materials (i.e., substitute its view for that of the executive), but it can scrutinize any reasons that appear on the face of the record to ascertain the detaining authority's state of mind and whether the satisfaction was vitiated by colourable exercise, irrelevant considerations, or an ulterior purpose.

Applying these principles, the court found:

  • On its face the 23 May 1944 order purported to detain the applicant because the Government was satisfied detention was necessary to prevent actions prejudicial to public safety and the efficient prosecution of the war. The initial onus was therefore on the applicant to show the order was not validly made on any of the recognised grounds.
  • The applicant's contention that the Provincial Government requirement meant the Governor alone had to be satisfied was considered and rejected in form: Section 3 contemplates the Provincial Government (of which the Governor is a part) and the record showed the order was issued by order of the Governor and an affidavit by Mr. Drewe stated that the Governor agreed and considered the case.
  • The court accepted that the District Magistrate's affidavit in respect of the R.26 order of 24 May 1943 contained a clear statement of satisfaction based on reports and information; the Court said it could not go behind this sworn statement to substitute its own view as to sufficiency or reasonableness of those materials.
  • Crucially, however, the court examined a minute dated 21 May 1944 by the Governor's Secretary (Mr. Symington) which stated: "His Excellency agrees to the detention as proposed pending consideration of use of the Criminal Tribes Act." The court treated this minute as part of the material shedding light on the detaining authority's state of mind and motivations.
  • The court held that the consideration of whether to apply the Criminal Tribes Act is a separate and distinct inquiry from the considerations legitimately relevant under Ordinance 3 (security of the State/efficient prosecution of the war). The presence of the Criminal Tribes Act consideration on the record indicated that the Governor's mind was directed to a matter foreign to the proper scope of the Ordinance. As a result, the court concluded the satisfaction required by law was not reasonably formed.
  • The Advocate-General's submission that the 6 November 1944 order (stating it followed further consideration of all circumstances) validated the detention was rejected. The court reasoned that the applicant had been detained continuously between 23 May and 6 November 1944 and could not have taken steps in the interim to justify a fresh satisfaction; the Government might have placed further materials before the Governor but had not done so on the record, and the court would not speculate in the Government's favour.
  • Because the 6 November 1944 order merely directed that the 23 May 1944 order continue in force, it could not validate an originally invalid order. The court observed that a different outcome might have followed had the Government issued a fresh order under Section 3 on the basis of new materials placed before the court, but no such fresh order was made.

On the basis of the above analysis the court held that the 23 May 1944 order and the continuation order of 6 November 1944 were invalid and the detention under them was illegal.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The Court held that the orders dated 23 May 1944 and 6 November 1944 (Government of Bombay) are invalid and that the detention of the applicant under those orders is illegal; the applicant and the applicants in Applications Nos. 427 and 428 of 1944 are to be immediately set at liberty.

Implications:

  • Direct effect on the parties: The applicant (and the applicants in the two related applications) were ordered to be immediately released from detention. The orders of 23 May 1944 and 6 November 1944 were declared invalid as applied to these applicants.
  • Legal consequence: The court reaffirmed the principle that Section 10 of Ordinance 3 of 1944 does not protect from judicial inquiry an order that was not in fact made in the proper exercise of the Ordinance's powers; courts may scrutinize the detaining authority's state of mind where relevant materials appear on the record. The decision applied established authorities to conclude the particular orders were vitiated by consideration of matters extraneous to the proper purpose of the Ordinance (e.g., the reference to the Criminal Tribes Act).
  • Broader precedent: The opinion rests on and applies existing principles from higher decisions; it does not purport to overrule or create a novel rule beyond the application of those principles to the facts of these applications.

Order accordingly.

Show all summary ...

Chagla, J.:— This is an application under Section 491 of the Cr PC. It seems that on 22nd May, 1942, one S.V Ghatnatti, Sub-Inspector of Police, was murdered at Kerur. In connexion with that offence the applicant was arrested on 27th August, 1942, and he along with others was tried by the Sub-Divisional Magistrate, First Class, Southern Division, Bijapur, under Ss. 147 and 186 read with S. 149, Penal Code. The applicant was released on bail by the Court on 7th October, 1942. The trial of the case went on 9th 10th, 14th, 15th and 16th October, 1942, and on 11th May, 1943. On all these days the applicant appeared at the trial. Thereafter he absconded. On 24th May, 1943, the District Magistrate, Bijapur, issued an order under R. 26, Defence of India Rules, for the detention of the applicant in the Belgaum Central Prison for one year from the date of arrest. On 4th January, 1944, a proclamation under Section 87 of the Cr PC, was issued for the arrest of the applicant, and he ultimately surrendered to the District Superintendent of Police, Bijapur, on 8th April, 1944. In the meanwhile, the case against the other accused was disposed of on 14th September, 1943, and all of them were acquitted. On 6th June, 1944, the District Magistrate, Bijapur, sanctioned the withdrawal of the case against the applicant and an order for his acquittal was made by the Resident Magistrate, First Class, Bijapur, on 24th June, 1944. On 23rd May, 1944, the Government of Bombay issued an order under cl. (b) of sub-s. (1) of S. 3 of Ordinance 3 of 1944, for the detention of the applicant, and on 6th November, 1944, the Government under S. 9 of the Ordinance directed that the order of 23rd May, 1944 should continue in force.

2. The applicant has been in detention since 8th April, 1944, and his contention is that his detention is illegal and he should be set at liberty. The applicant is at present detained under an order of the Government of Bombay dated 6th November, 1944, and we have to consider whether that order is valid and whether the detention of the applicant under that order is legal. Section 10 of Ordinance 3 of 1944 provides that no order made under the Ordinance shall be called in question in any Court, and no Court shall have power to make any order under Section 491 of the Cr PC, in respect of any order made under or having effect under the Ordinance, or in respect of any person the subject of such an order. But it is clear that the jurisdiction of the Court is only taken away provided the order on which the Government is relying is an order “made under the Ordinance.” It must be made by the detaining authority in the proper exercise of its powers. It would not be an order “made under the Ordinance” if it was made merely in the colourable exercise of its powers or if the detaining authority exceeded the powers given to it under the Ordinance. The detaining authority must satisfy the Court that it has complied with all the rules of procedure laid down in the Ordinance and has observed all the safeguards. The order must not be made for an ulterior purpose—a purpose which has no connexion with the security of the State or the efficient prosecution of the war. The order must not be intended to override the ordinary powers of the police for the investigation of a crime or to suspend the ordinary criminal tribunals of the land or prevent them from exercising their ordinary jurisdiction. The powers conferred on the executive under the Ordinance are for the purpose of preventive detention and they are not punitive in their nature. The executive must not detain a subject in order to punish him for what he has already done but in order to prevent him from doing something which in the opinion of the executive is likely to affect the safety of the State or the efficient prosecution of the war. It is not competent to the Court to inquire into the sufficiency of the materials and the reasonableness of the grounds on which the detaining authority was satisfied that it was necessary to make the order. But if any reasons which influenced the detaining authority in making the order appear on the record, then the Court can scrutinize them in order to see what was the condition of the mind of the detaining authority when it made the order. These principles which I have stated clearly emerge from the various decisions of the Federal Court and the High Courts in India which have been cited at the Bar. In A.I.R 1944 P.C 861 Sir Patrick Spens, C.J, delivering the judgment of the Federal Court, observed (p. 93):

“In our judgment, no further curtailment of the power of the Court to investigate and interfere with orders for detention has been imposed by Ordinance, 3 of 1944. The Court is and will be still at liberty to investigate whether an order purporting to have been made under R. 26 and now deemed to be made under Ordinance 3 or a new order purporting to be made under Ordinance 3 was in fact validly made, in exactly the same way as immediately before the promulgation of the Ordinance. If on consideration the Court comes to the conclusion that it was not validly made on any of the grounds indicated in any of the long line of decisions in England and this country on the subject, other than the ground that R. 26 was ultra vires, S. 10 of Ordinance 3 will no more prevent it from so finding than Section 16 of the Defence of India Act, did. Such an invalid order, though purporting to be an order, will not in fact be an ‘order made under this Ordinance’ or having effect by virtue of S. 6 as if made under this Ordinance at all for the purposes of section 10.”

3. And Harries C.J, in A.I.R 1944 Lah. 3732, in the course of his judgment, said (p. 375):

“In my judgment R. 129 cannot be used legally for any purpose, other than that for what it was intended, namely, to ensure inter alia the security of the State and the efficient prosecution of the war.

To use it for some entirely different purpose, wholly unconnected with the security of the State or the efficient prosecution of the war, is in my view a misuse of the powers given by that rule and an order passed for such purposes cannot be said to be an order under R. 129, Defence of India Rules.”

4. Further on the learned Chief Justice observed (page 376):

“It would in my view be extremely dangerous to hold that the police or the Provincial Government had any right to detain persons under R. 129 unless the order was made with the object of making it impossible for the person detained to interfere with matters connected with the defence of India or the efficient prosecution of the war.”

5. With respect, I entirely agree with these observations of the learned Chief Justice, and, in our opinion, these observations apply as much to an order made under Ordinance 3 of 1944 as to an order made under R. 129, Defence of India Rules. In this case the order made by the Government of Bombay is valid on the face of it. The original order was made on 23rd May, 1944, and it purports to order the detention of the applicant because the Government of Bombay was satisfied that it was necessary to do so with a view to preventing the applicant from acting in a manner prejudicial to the public safety and the maintenance of public order; and the order of 6th November, 1944, directs that the original order shall continue in force which direction was given by the Government of Bombay after a further consideration of all the circumstances of the case. It is, therefore, for the applicant to satisfy us that it was not validly made on any of the grounds which I have indicated above.

6. The first ground on which the order is attacked is that before the applicant could be validly detained the authority that has got to be satisfied is the Governor of Bombay, and in this case it is not the Governor of Bombay that is satisfied but the Government of Bombay. This contention is clearly untenable because it is opposed to the clear and specific language of S. 3 of the Ordinance which requires that it is the Provincial Government which has got to be satisfied. But reliance is placed on a decision of the Federal Court in A.I.R 1943 F.C 753. In that case Zafrulla Khan J. took the view that for the definition of “Provincial Government” for the purpose of the defence of india rules, recourse must be had to the General Clauses Act; and the General Clauses Act defines in S. 3(43a)(a) “Provincial Government” in a Governor's Province as:

“the Governor acting or not acting in his discretion, and exercising or not exercising his individual judgment, according to the provision in that behalf made by and under the said Act (Government of India Act).”

7. And in the course of his judgment the learned Judge observed (p. 85):

“In each case, it must be the Governor who acts, whether without the advice of his Ministers or after such advice has been tendered, and in the latter case, whether in accordance with such advice or differing from such advice.”

8. Therefore the effect of this decision is that in every case the Governor either with or without his Ministers is the authority which has got to be satisfied before the powers are exercised under S. 3 of the Ordinance. But the Governor who has to be satisfied is as a part of the Provincial executive and not in any way in contrast with or in contradistinction to the Provincial executive. It is true that in no case can the Provincial Government exercise its powers unless the Governor has applied his mind and is satisfied as required by S. 3 of the Ordinance. But all the same the authority contemplated by S. 3 is the Provincial Government and not the Governor. In this case there is nothing on the face of the order to show that the Governor as a part of the Provincial Government was not satisfied with respect, to the applicant that he should be detained. The order itself is issued by order of the Governor of Bombay, and in his affidavit, made on this application Mr. Drewe, Secretary to the Government of Bombay, Home Department, specifically states that His Excellency the Governor agreed to the detention of the applicant when the order of 23rd May, 1944, was made and His Excellency considered the case of the applicant when the order of 6th November, 1944, was made directing that the order of 23rd May, 1944, shall continue in force.

9. It is further contended by the applicant that he is detained not for any purpose connected with the security of the State or the efficient prosecution of the war, but in order to punish him for the alleged offence in connection with the murder of S.V Ghatnatti. It is urged that because the prosecution in that case did not have sufficient evidence to warrant his conviction the Government availed themselves of the powers under the defence of india rules and under Ordinance 3 of 1944, and detained the applicant in custody having failed to secure his conviction by due process of law. It is pointed out that the District Magistrate made the order on 24th May, 1913, only after the accused had absconded on 12th May, 1943; that if Government had any materials to suspect the applicant of any activities prejudicial to the safety of the State or the efficient prosecution of the war, an order under R. 26, Defence of India Rules, would have been made long prior to 24th May, 1943; and that the order of 24th May, 1943 was made in order to detain the applicant in connection with his alleged connection with the murder of S.V Ghatnatti. It has to be remembered that the order of 24th May, 1943, was made 12 days after the accused had absconded, and the District Magistrate in his affidavit swears that he was satisfied from reports and information received by him from responsible sources that with a view to preventing the applicant from acting in a manner prejudicial to the defence of British India, the public safety, the maintenance of public order and the efficient prosecution of the war, it was necessary to make the order. It is not open to the Court to go behind this statement of the learned District Magistrate. Whether he had sufficient materials or whether the grounds on which he acted were reasonable is not for the Court to inquire into and, therefore, in our opinion it is not open to the applicant to challenge the order made on 24th May, 1943. With regard to the order of 23rd May, 1944, Mr. Drewe in his affidavit says that “there is a note written on 21st May 1944, by His Excellency the Governor's Secretary Mr. Symington that His Excellency agreed to the detention of the applicant.” We have seen this minute, and what the minute says is this:

“His Excellency agrees to the detention as proposed pending consideration of use of the Criminal Tribes Act.”

10. This minute clearly shows that the Governor was considering the use of the Criminal Tribes Act against the applicant and pending his decision on that question, he agreed to the detention of the applicant under ordinance 3 of 1944. Now the considerations which must weigh with the Governor in deciding whether he should use the Criminal Tribes Act against the applicant or not are quite foreign to those which must weigh with him in deciding whether he should detain the applicant under S. 3 of ordinance 3 of 1944. The scope and ambit of the Criminal Tribes Act have no bearing upon the purpose for which the extraordinary powers vested in the executive have to be exercised under S. 3 of the Ordinance. In our opinion this minute of Mr. Symington throws a flood of light on the condition of mind of the detaining authority when it made the order. Its mind was directed not on what it should have been directed to, namely, the question of the security of the State or the efficient prosecution of the war, but it was directed to the more parochial, and limited question as to whether the Criminal Tribes Act should be used or not against the applicant. It is unnecessary to emphasize that when wide powers are given to the executive to deprive His Majesty's subjects of their liberty without the intervention of the Courts of law, the detaining authority must consider each case with that care and caution which the exercise of so tremendous a power should call for. The liberty of the subject is not to be lightly taken away. The satisfaction which the law requires on the part of the detaining authority before a subject can be detained is a reasonable satisfaction—a satisfaction not vitiated by any consideration which is foreign to the scope and object of Ordinance 3 of 1944. In this case, in our opinion, it is impossible to hold that the Government of Bombay was reasonably satisfied that it was necessary to detain the applicant with a view to prevent him from acting in a manner prejudicial to the public safety and the maintenance of public order.

11. It is contended by the learned Advocate. General that even though the order of 23rd May, 1944, be had the applicant is detained not under that order but under the order of 6th November, 1944, and that order on the face of it states that it was made after a further consideration of all the circumstances of the case, and the affidavit of Mr. Drewe further bears out the fact that His Excellency the Governor considered the case of the applicant before his detention was continued under that order. I take it that all the materials were before His Excellency the Governor when he made the order on 23rd May, 1944. After that date, the applicant continued to be in detention and was never free even for a single hour. Therefore he could not have done anything between 23rd May, 1944, and 6th November, 1944, to cause the Government of Bombay to be satisfied that his detention was necessary. The learned Advocate-General says that further materials about his activities prior to his detention might have been placed before the Government of Bombay. We refuse to speculate and certainly not to the prejudice of the subject. It was open to the Government once the original order of 23rd May, 1944 was successfully challenged to place further materials before the Court, but it has not chosen to do so.

12. But it is unnecessary to consider this argument further because in our view when the order of 23rd May, 1944, is invalid the order of 6th November, 1944, must also as a necessary consequence be equally invalid, because all that the order of 6th November, 1944 does is to direct that the original order of 23rd May, 1944, shall continue in force, and if the original order is bad, the subsequent order directing it to continue cannot validate it. The position might perhaps have been different if the Government of Bombay had made a fresh order under S. 3 of the Ordinance but that they have not done.

13. In our opinion, therefore, the order of 23rd May, 1944, and the order of 6th November, 1944, extending the former order are invalid, and the detention of the applicant under these orders is illegal.

14. We, therefore, direct that the applicant should be immediately set at liberty. In Applications Nos. 427 and 428 of 1944 which are also applications under Section 491 of the Cr PC, our decision is the same on the same grounds, and we direct that the applicants in both those applications be also set at liberty immediately.

15. Order accordingly.