Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Sakamuri Sivaram Babu v. Parasa Sunjan Raju

Andhra Pradesh High Court
Sep 24, 1991
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Structured Summary of the Opinion by Bhaskar Rao, J.

Factual and Procedural Background

The plaintiffs (appellants) entered into an agreement of sale with the defendant (respondent) on 10-12-1990 for certain immovable properties ("plaint 'a' schedule properties") for a total consideration of Rs. 6,40,000. On the same day the defendant received Rs. 50,000 (Rs. 25,000 cash and Rs. 25,000 by cheque). Subsequent payments of Rs. 90,000 (22-12-1990) and Rs. 20,000 (20-4-1991) were made. The plaintiffs arranged the balance through loans sanctioned by the Life Insurance Corporation (LIC): Rs. 3,10,000 to the first plaintiff and Rs. 1,70,000 to the second plaintiff.

Because the defendant did not cooperate in executing the regular sale deed, the plaintiffs issued a registered notice (12-7-1991) and filed a suit for specific performance of the agreement of sale.

The plaint was presented with requisite stamps and otherwise complying with formalities. The Subordinate Judge, Guntur, by order dated 24-9-1991 returned the plaint, directing the plaintiffs to deposit the balance sale consideration as a condition for entertaining the suit. The plaintiffs appealed that return order via the present miscellaneous appeal.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether a civil court has jurisdiction to return a plaint with a direction that the plaintiff deposit the balance sale consideration for the purpose of registering and entertaining a suit for specific performance of an agreement of sale.
  2. Whether an appeal against an order returning a plaint with such a direction is maintainable under Order 43 CPC, and if not, whether the High Court can nonetheless intervene by exercise of inherent powers or under Article 227.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The subordinate court lacked jurisdiction to direct deposit of the balance sale consideration as a precondition to registering the plaint and entertaining the suit.
  • To establish bona fides and readiness to perform, it is not necessary for plaintiffs to deposit the balance consideration; an averment of readiness suffices.
  • Section 16(c) of the Specific Relief Act does not require deposit of the balance sale consideration for purposes of entertaining a suit.

Respondent's Arguments

  • The trial court had ample power to direct deposit of the balance sale consideration, particularly where the sum is substantial (running into lakhs).
  • The order under appeal merely returned the plaint, and such an order is not appealable under Order 43 CPC; therefore this appeal should be dismissed as not maintainable.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
1974 (2) MLJ p. 62 Authority for the principle that it is not essential for a plaintiff to actually tender or deposit the money involved in the contract except when specifically directed by the court. The court relied on this decision to support that deposit is not ordinarily required to prove readiness to perform; the deposit direction is an exception and cannot be invoked at the plaint-registration stage.
1976 (2) MLJ p. 397 Same principle as above: deposit not essential except when court so directs. Used to reinforce that the general rule is non-deposit and that the exception (court direction) should not be applied at the inception/registration stage of a suit.
CRP 902/91 (20-3-1991) Earlier decision of this court setting aside a lower court order directing deposit of balance consideration. The court relied on its prior decision to set aside the impugned order similarly directing deposit, and directed the lower court to register the plaint (subject to other formalities).
Somasundaram v. Muthumanicka (AIR 1932 Mad 714) Principle that a High Court can interfere by revision (under statutory powers) even where an order passed by a trial court is not appealable; the High Court can set aside appellate orders in appropriate cases. Invoked to establish that even if an order is not appealable under Order 43 CPC, the High Court may exercise revisional/judicial supervisory power to correct errors of subordinate courts.
Andrew Anthony v. Dupant (1882) 4 Mad. 217 Authority cited by the Madras High Court in the context of supervisory/revisional power (as extracted in Somasundaram). Quoted (via Somasundaram) to support the proposition that the High Court can interfere under statutory supervisory/revisional provisions without an application by a party to the suit.
Batcha Saheb v. Abdul Gany (AIR 1914 Mad 675) Listed among authorities supporting the High Court's power to interfere under supervisory/revisional provisions. Referenced as one of the decisions demonstrating longstanding practice of High Courts revising subordinate court orders even when ordinary appeal may not lie.
Bai Kanta Nath v. Sita Nath (1911) 38 Cal 421 One of several older authorities cited in support of High Court supervisory/revisional intervention. Used as part of a group of authorities to justify revisional jurisdiction in appropriate cases.
Fisher v. Kanakasabapathy (1910) 5 IC 742 Another authority referenced on supervisory powers of superior courts (under small causes courts act in that instance). Included among precedents demonstrating the court's power to revise or interfere with lower court orders.
Debi Das v. Ejaz Hussain (1905) 28 All 72 Older authority supporting supervisory/revisional practice. Counted among cases showing the High Court's revisional competence.
Puran Mal v. Janaki Pershad Singh (1901) 28 Cal 680 Ancient authority cited in the same grouping concerning High Court intervention. Relied on as historical support that superior courts can revise subordinate court orders.
Inwaryam v. Amar (AIR 1954 SC 215) Authority for the proposition that Article 227 confers on High Courts power of superintendence which includes judicial revision, not confined to administrative superintendence. Relied upon to support the court's power to set aside erroneous subordinate court orders under Article 227 even where no ordinary appeal lies.
Banerjee v. P R Mukherjee (1953) SCR 302 Support for the scope of Article 227 as including judicial revision beyond mere administrative superintendence. Invoked together with Inwaryam to justify exercise of superintendence/revisional power by the High Court in the present matter.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court proceeded in a stepwise manner:

  1. It examined the procedural law governing institution and presentation of plaints (Section 26 CPC; Order VII rules; and rules of practice concerning presentation, endorsement, correction, registration). The court noted there was no contention that these provisions were not complied with in the present matter.
  2. The court considered Section 16(c) of the Specific Relief Act (personal bar to relief) and its Explanation (i), which states that where a contract involves payment of money it is not essential for the plaintiff to actually tender or deposit money except when so directed by the court. The court stressed that this deposit requirement is an exception and not the general rule.
  3. The court emphasized that the exception (court directing deposit) cannot be read as permitting a court to require deposit at the inception stage of a suit merely for purposes of registering the plaint and entertaining the suit. The statutory requirement is satisfied by averments of readiness and willingness to perform; actual deposit is not ordinarily necessary at the registration stage.
  4. The court observed that in the plaint the plaintiffs had averred readiness and willingness to perform, had already paid part consideration, and had arranged the balance via LIC loans—matters pleaded in the plaint to show readiness.
  5. The court referred to its own recent decision (CRP 902/91 dated 20-3-1991) which had set aside a lower court order directing deposit of the balance and had directed registration of the plaint subject to other formalities. That prior decision was applied by the court as a directly relevant precedent.
  6. Addressing the procedural point that an order returning a plaint may not always be appealable under Order 43 CPC, the court examined authority (Somasundaram and earlier cases) and Article 227 jurisprudence (Inwaryam, Banerjee) to conclude that the High Court possesses supervisory/judicial revisional power to set aside erroneous subordinate court orders even where no ordinary appeal lies.
  7. On the basis that the lower court's direction to deposit at the registration stage exceeded jurisdiction (an improper invocation of the exception in Section 16(c)), and in light of the plaintiffs' averments and supporting facts, the court concluded the order under appeal was without jurisdiction and liable to be set aside.

Holding and Implications

Holding:

THE IMPUGNED ORDER IS SET ASIDE.

Consequent directions and immediate effect:

  • The court below is directed to register the plaint if it is otherwise in order and to proceed according to law (i.e., to take steps appropriate after registration such as issuing summons etc., subject to compliance with formalities other than the deposit direction).
  • No costs were awarded.

Implications: The decision directly affects the parties by removing the requirement the subordinate court imposed (deposit of the balance consideration as a precondition to registration). The opinion treats the requirement to deposit as an exceptional power of the court under Section 16(c) Specific Relief Act but holds that imposing it at the plaint-registration stage was an exercise of jurisdiction not warranted by the statute or precedent. The opinion does not purport to lay down a broader new precedent beyond applying existing principles and prior decisions to the facts; it corrects the subordinate court's exercise of jurisdiction in the particular circumstances.

Show all summary ...

Bhaskar Rao, J.:-

(1) The plaintff appellants preferred this miscellaneous appeal against the order dated 24 - 9 - 91 of the subordinate judge guntur returning the plaint in cfr no. 11515 of 91 (unnumbered original suit) with a direction to deposit the balance sale consideration for purposes of entertaining the suit for specific performance of the agreement of sale.

(2) The brief facts relevant for the present purpose are : on 10 - 12 - 90 the defendant respondent executed an agreement of sale in respect of plaint 'a' schedule properties in favour of the plaintiffs for a total consideration of rs. 6,40,000/ and received on the very same day an amount of rs. 50,000/ - (rs. 25,000/ - in cash and the balance of rs. 25,000/ - through cheque) towards advance purchse money agreeing to execute the regular sale deed in the names of the plaintiffs or their nominees. Subsequently the plaintiffs also paid rs. 90,000/ - on 22 - 12 - 90 and rs. 20,000/ - on 20 - 4 - 91, they also made arrangements for payment of the balance through the life insurance corporation of india and that in fact the lic had sanctioned a loan of rs. 3,10,000/ - to the 1st plaintiff and rs. 1,70,000/ - to the 2nd plaintiff. Inasmuch as the defendant was not co operating with the plaintiffs in the execution of the regular sale deed they were forced to issue a registered notice on 12 - 7 - 91 and ultimately file the present suit for specific performance of the agreement of sale.

(3) The plaint was filed with the requisite stamps representing court fee and after complying with the other formalities. However the court below through the orders under appeal returned the plaint with a direction to the plaintiffs to deposit the balance of sale consideration. Hence this miscellaneous appeal assailing the said order.

(4) The main contention of the learned counsel for the appellant plaintiffs is that the court below has no jurisdiction to driect deposit of the balance sale consideration for purposes of registering the plaint and entertaining the suit. He submitted that to establish bonafide and readiness to perform their part of the contract it is not necessary the plaintiff's should deposit the balance of sale consideration. He also submitted that section 16 (c) of the specific relief act does not contemplate depositing ef the balance sale - consideration for purpose of entertaining the suit. The learned counsel for the respondent on the other hand contended that the court below has ample power to direct depositing the balance sale consideration more so when it is heavy running in lakhs and therefore no interference of this court is called for. He also contended that the order is only returning the plaint against which no appeal lies under order 43, on this count according to the learned counsel the appeal is liable to be dismissed.

(5) In view of these contentions the main question for considration is whether the civil court has got jurisdiction to return the plaint with a direction to deposit the balance of sale considration for purposes of entertaining the suit filed for specific performance of the agreement of sale.

(6) Section 26 of the civil procedure code dealing with the institution of suits prescribes that every suit shall be instituted by the presentation of a plaint or in such other manner as may be prescribed. Order vii rule i speaks of the particulars a plaint is to contain. Rule 3 deals with suits subject matter of which is immoveable property. It state :

"where the subject matter of the suit is immovable property the plaint shall centain a description of the property sufficient to identify it and in case such property can be identified by boundaries or numbers in a record of settlement or survey the plaint shall specify such boundaries or numbers. Rule 5 prescribes that the plaint shall show that the defendant is or claims to be interested in the subject matter and that he is liable to be called upon to answer the plaintiif s demand. Rule 10 refers to the return of plaint. It states that the plaint shall at any stage of the suit be returned to be presented to the court in which the suit should have been instituted. These are the rules relevant for the present purpose governing the entertaining and return of the plaint. Again rule 20 of the civil rules of practice dealing with presentation of proceedings states"
.

" (1) all plaints, written statements, applications and other proceedings and documents may be presented to or filed in court by delivering the same by the party in person or by bis recognised agent or by his advocate or by a duty; registered clerk of the advocate to the chief ministerial officer of the court or such other officers as may be designated for the purpose by the judge before 4 - 00 p m on any working day. Provided that in case where the limitation expires on the same day they may be received by a judge even after, 4 - 00 p m.

(2) the officer to whom such, documents were presented shall at once endorse on the documents the date of presentation the value of the stamp affixed and if the proceedings are thereby instituted shall insert the serial number

(3) in case of paper bearing court fee stamps he shall if requird issue a receipt in form no 17 in appendix iii - l to these rules

(4) every plaint or proceeding presented to or filed in court shall be accompanied by as many copies on plain paper of the plaint or proceeding and the document referred to in rule 16 as there are defendants or respondents unless the. Court otherwise dispenses with such, copies of the documents by reason of their length or for any other sufficient , reason. "

Rule 22 of the civil rules of practice prescribing the procedure on presentation runs tkus :

" (1) on presentation of every plaint the same shall be entered in register no, 17 in appendix ii part ii volume ii and examined by the chief ministerial officer of the court.

(2) if he finds that the plaint complies with all the requirements he shall make an endorsement on the plaint examined and may be registered with the date and his signature and placed before the judge. The chief ministerial officer shall also endorse on the plaint or proceedings if any caveat has been filed. If he thinks that the plaint shall be returned for presentation to the proper court or be rejected under order vii rule 11 or for any other person he shall place the matter before the judge for orders.

(3) subject to the provisions of sub - rule (2) any non compliance with these rules or any clerical mistake may be required by the chief ministerial officer to be rectified. Any rectification so effected shall be initialled and dated by the party or his advocate making the same and the chief ministerial officer shall note the number of corrections in the margin and shall initial and date the same.

In the event of such rectification not being made within the time specified the chief ministerial officer shall place the matter before the judge for orders. " rule 23 is in respect of registration of plaint and it says that on examination, where the plaint is found to be in order, it shall be entered in the register of suits, and the judge shall pass orders as to the issue of summons or otherwise.

(7) It need to be pointed out here itself that it is not the case on hand that any one of the referred provisions of the civil procedure code or of the civil rules of practice are not complied with or followed it is also not the case that there are any other provisions on the aspect that in a suit for specific performance, the plaintiff in order to prove his readiness and willingness to fulfil his part of the contract has to deposit the balance consideration of the sale even for purposes of instituting the suit. In the case ob hand the metter was at the threshold and not even registration of the plaint as a suit has taken place. Further section 16 (c) of the specific relief act says :

"16. Personal bar to relief : spe" cific performance of a contract cannot be enforced in favour of a person (a). (b). (c) who fails to aver and prove that he has performed or has always been ready and willing to perform the essential terms of the contract which are to be performed by him, other than terms the performance of which has been prevented or waived by the defendant. Explanation: - for the purpose of clause (c) , - (i) where a contract involves the payment of money, it is net essential for the plaintiff to actually tender to the defendant or to deposit in court any money except when so directed by the court, (ii) the plaintiff must aver performance of, or readiness and willingness to perform, the contract according to its true construction".

Explanation (i) as extracted states that in cases where payment of money is involved, it is not that essential for the plaintiff to actually tender or deposit the, money, except when so directed by the court. The direction to deposit the money is as a matter of exception, the general rule being that there is no necessity of the money being deposited in order to prove one's own readiness or willingness to perform his part of the contract. Further the direction envisaged by the explanation as a measure of exception cannot be understood as one at the inception stage of the suit for purposes of registering the plaint ane entertaining the suit. Even the decisions relied upon by the court below, viz. 1974 (2) mlj page 62 and 1976 (2) mlj page 397, clearly lay down that it is not essential to the plaintiff to actually tender the money involved or deposit the money in the court, except when so specifically directed by the court. This exception does not mean that the court has jurisdiction to issue, direction for deposit of balance consideration even at the inception stage of the proceedings, i. E. At the stage of registering and entertaining the suit. What all required by section 16 (c) of the specific relief act is that the plaintiff should aver performance of, or readiness and willingness to perform, his part of the contract. Admittedly, there is such an averment and in fact certain money was paid even at the time of entering into the agreement, some more later on, and the balance money is obtained by the plaintiffs as a loan sanctioned by the life insurance corporation and there are specific averments in this behalf made in the plaint.

(8) In a matter similar to the one on hand, this court in crp 902/91 dated 20 - 3 - 1991 set aside the order of the lower court directing deposit of the balance consideration and directed the lower court to register the plaint aad pass appropriate orders, subject of - courte complying with formalities other than this. In view of all this, we find that the order under appeal is one made without jurisdiction and accordingly it is liable to be set aside.

(9) Now, turning to the other contention that the order under appeal is not one covered by order 43 cpc. , and therefore the present appeal is not maintainable. True. Order 43 rule l (a) of the code of civil procedure speaks of only orders passed returning a plaint to be presented to the proper court and does not envisage a return with a direction to deposit the balance consideration. Pealing with a similar question, the madras high court in somasundaram vs. Muthumanicka (1) air 1932 madras 714 held that even in matters where the order passed by the trial court is not appealable and still the appeal happened to be entertained, the high court in a revision can revise the original order of the trial court by setting aside the appellate order. While so holding the madras high court referred to the decision in andrew anthony vs. Dupant (1882) 4 mad. 217) rendered by sir charles turner cj and kindersley, j, the madras high court extracted the observations of the learned judges thus :

"the high court can interfere under section 622 (equivalent to section 115 of the present cpc) of the code with out an application made to it by a party to the suit : see also batcha saheb vs. Abdul gany (air 1914 mad 675) , bai kanta nath vs. Sita nath (191l) 38 cal 421) and fisher vs. Kanakasabapathy (1910) 5 1c 742) (under small causes courts act,) debi das vs, ejaz hussain (1905) 28 - all 72) and puran mal vs. Janaki pershad singh (1901) 28 cal,680)"

Apart from all this, under article 227 of the constitution of india, as held inwaryamvs amar (air 1954 sc 215) and banerjee vs. Pr mukherjee (1953) scr 302) , it is settled law that the power of superintendence conferred upon this court by article 227 is not confined to administrative superintendence only, but includes the power of judicial revision also even where no appeal or revision lies to the high court under the ordinary law. In view of this case law, even assuming that no appeal is provided to this court against orders of return of the plaint with a direction to deposit the balance sale - consideration, still not only as an inherent nature of power but also under article 227 of the constitution of india this court can set aside erroneous orders passed by the subordinate courts.

(10) Ia the result, the order impugned in this appeal is set aside and the court below is directed to register the puiot, if otherwise in order, and proceed ahead according to law. No costs.