Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Sreepada Dey v. Amal Kr. Chattejee

Calcutta High Court
Apr 4, 1981
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner filed title suit no. 299 of 1978 seeking ejectment on the ground of reasonable requirement among other issues. Subsequently, the opposite party applied under section 35 of the West Bengal Premises Tenancy Act before the Rent Controller, Calcutta, seeking permission to carry out essential repairs on the disputed premises, describing himself as the sole tenant. The Rent Controller rejected this application, but on appeal, the learned Additional District Judge allowed it with directions for the tenant to execute repairs as per inspector estimates and submit cost statements for further determination and deduction from rent under section 34 of the Act. The petitioner challenged this order by filing the present revisional application.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the application for essential repairs under section 35 of the West Bengal Premises Tenancy Act can be entertained when an ejectment suit filed by the landlord is pending.
  2. Whether the absence of a finding on responsibility for damages affects the allowance of the application for repairs.
  3. Whether relief under section 34 and 35 of the Act precludes the tenant from seeking temporary injunction under Order 39 Rules 1 and 2 of the Code of Civil Procedure in an ejectment suit.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner’s Arguments

  • There is no determination in the impugned order as to who is responsible for the alleged damages, though the petitioner asserts the tenant is liable.
  • The ejectment suit (title suit no. 299 of 1978) is pending and relief regarding repairs was also sought therein, making the separate application unnecessary.
  • References were made to the decisions in Loken Bose vs. Asima and Nirendra vs. Lal Mohan to support these contentions.

Opposite Party’s Arguments

  • The ejectment suit is expected to take at least ten years for disposal, necessitating the present remedy for essential repairs.
  • Sections 34 and 35 of the West Bengal Premises Tenancy Act provide exclusive provisions for essential repairs, which cannot be denied merely because an ejectment suit is pending.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Loken Bose vs. Asima (81 CWN 948) Section 34 of the West Bengal Premises Tenancy Act does not bar relief under Order 39 Rules 1 and 2 of the Code of Civil Procedure; temporary injunction can be granted in ejectment suits for restoration of essential repairs. The court relied on this precedent to hold that the tenant’s application under section 34 should be rejected to avoid multiplicity of proceedings, and the tenant should seek relief in the pending ejectment suit instead.
Nirendra vs. Lal Mohan (1977 (2) CLJ 941) This precedent was cited by the petitioner to substantiate the argument regarding pending ejectment suit and relief for repairs. The court did not explicitly analyze this precedent in detail but considered it in the context of the petitioner’s submissions.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court noted that while the impugned order lacked a finding on responsibility for the damages, this issue would be addressed by the civil court in the ejectment suit. Drawing from the Loken Bose vs. Asima precedent, the court emphasized that section 34 of the West Bengal Premises Tenancy Act does not preclude tenants from seeking temporary injunctions under the Code of Civil Procedure in pending ejectment suits. It recognized that allowing separate proceedings under section 34 while an ejectment suit is pending would lead to multiplicity of proceedings. Therefore, to prevent such multiplicity, the court held that the tenant’s application under section 34 must be rejected, and the tenant should seek the necessary relief before the trial court hearing the ejectment suit.

Holding and Implications

The revisional application is allowed, the impugned order is set aside, and the rule is made absolute without any order as to costs.

This decision directs that the tenant’s application for essential repairs under section 34 should not proceed separately when an ejectment suit is pending, thereby avoiding multiplicity of proceedings. The tenant remains at liberty to seek relief for repairs within the pending ejectment suit. No new precedent was established; the court adhered to existing principles to streamline the litigation process between the parties.

Show all summary ...

B.N.Maitra, J.:-

(1) The petitioner filed title suit no. 299 of 1978 for ejectment on the 'ground of reasonable requirement and other questions were al3o raised. Thereafter the opposite party tiled an application under section 35 of the west bengal premises tenancy act before! the rent controller, calcutta, asking for an order for permitting him to effect remains of the disputed premises. He described himself as the sole tenant. The application was rejected. An appeal was taken out and it was allowed. The learned additional district judge directed the tenant to carry out the essential repairs according to the estimates submitted by the inspector. He ordered that a statement of the costs be submitted to the rent controller within three months from the date of his order and thereafter, the rent controller would make further enquiry, if any, determining the amount of costs. The further order is that the costs determined would be deducted from the rent paid by the tenant subject to the limits laid down by the provisions of section 34 of the act. Hence this revisional application.

(2) Two - fold submissions have been made on behalf of the landlord petitioner. It has been stated that there is no finding as to who is responsible for the alleged damage, though his clear case is that it is the tenant who is responsible for such damages. Secondly, the ejectment suit, viz. , title suit no, 2. 99 of 1978, is pending. In that suit, necessary relief in this respect was asked for. In order to substantiate this contention reference has been made to the decision of loken bose vs asima reported in 81 cwn 948 and nirendra vs. Lal mohan reported in 1977 (2) clj 941.

(3) The learned advocate appearing on behalf of the opposite party has contended that though the ejectment suit has, been filed, it will take at' least 10 years for its disposal. So, it will be absolutely necessary to pursue the present remedy. Exclusive provisions have been made under sections 34 and 35 of the west bengal premises tenancy act regarding essential repairs asked for by the tenant and such relief cannot be denied merely because an ejectment suit is pending at the instance of the landlord opposite party.

(4) In the well - known case of loken bose vs. Asima (supra) , it has been stated that section 34 of the west bengal premises tenancy act does not bar grant of relief under the provision of order 39 rules 1 and 2 of the code of civil procedure to the defendant where the landlord has filed a suit for ejectment. It has also been stated that it is not the intention of the legislature to drive a tenant to a separate proceeding under section 34 to avail of the relief provided for therein. If in spite of the fact that a suit. For eviction is pending, the tenant files an application under section 34 of the act, that will mean multiplicity of proceedings. A temporary injunction in this respect can be asked for and in a suit for eviction the power of the court to grant temporary mandatory injunction for restoration of essential repairs has not been fettered or restricted by the provisions of section 34 of the act. Hence, with a view to preventing multiplicity of proceedings, it must be held that the application filed by the plaintiff shall stand rejected. He will be at liberty to ask for such relief before the trial court.

(5) Of course, there is an infirmity in the judgment as there is no finding as to who is responsible for the alleged damages. But this - is unnecessary since this matter will be dealt with by the civil court.

(6) The rule is made absolute and the impugned order set aside without any order as to costs.