- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
B.C Sinha Alias Bimal Chandra Sinha v. Union Of India And Others
Judicial Opinion Summary
Factual and Procedural Background
The petitioner was an employee of the Railways who was deputed to M/s Burn Standard Company Ltd. (a Government company within the meaning of section 617 of the Companies Act and treated as a State under Article 12 of the Constitution) in 1984. The deputation was to the post of Deputy Manager (Personnel), and the petitioner thereafter, on account of exigencies, was asked to join M/s Bharat Brake and Valves Company (an associate company). The petitioner received promotions in 1985 while serving with Bharat Brake and Valves Company.
The deputation period effectively expired on 27 August 1985. The Railways indicated that no extension of deputation could be permitted. The company offered the petitioner permanent absorption; the petitioner accepted the offer and steps were taken to regularise absorption. Correspondence in early 1986 recorded the company's decision to absorb the petitioner and the Railways' communications confirmed no objection to permanent absorption effective 27 August 1985. An office order dated 1 July 1986 confirmed permanent absorption effective 27 August 1985.
On 25 August 1986 the company issued an order revoking the previously prepared (but not issued) office order and stated that the petitioner would be released on expiry of his extended deputation on 27 August 1986 on the ground that the petitioner had not submitted a formal resignation to the Railways. The Railways, however, had communicated to the company that the petitioner should not be relieved after acceptance of permanent absorption.
The petitioner challenged the company's release order by filing the present writ petition contending that the release after acceptance of absorption was arbitrary and unjust. The Court heard arguments from counsel for the petitioner, counsel for Burn Standard Company, and counsel for the Railways before delivering the impugned judgment.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether Burn Standard Company Ltd. could revoke or avoid the effect of the accepted permanent absorption and release the petitioner on the ground of non-submission of a formal resignation to the Railways after the company and the Railway authorities had accepted absorption effective 27 August 1985.
- Whether the petitioner was entitled to reinstatement to the post last held and to arrears of salary and allowances from August 1986 as a consequence of the company's action.
Arguments of the Parties
Appellant / Petitioner's Arguments (Mr. Malay Basu)
- The petitioner became a victim of administrative high-handedness and was released for unknown reasons despite acceptance of the offer of permanent absorption.
- After acceptance of the offer and regularisation of service in Burn Standard Company, the question of release did not and could not arise.
- The company’s action amounted to a virtual termination of service without formal termination proceedings.
Respondent: Burn Standard Company Ltd. (Mr. Pal)
- The company contended that the petitioner did not comply with necessary formalities, specifically submitting a formal letter of resignation to the Railways, and that without such compliance the absorption could not be given effect to.
- On that basis, the company argued it had no alternative but to release the petitioner back to the parent department (the Railways).
Respondent: The Railways (Counsel for Railways)
- The Railways' counsel submitted that once the Railways had accepted the employee's permanent absorption in another company, the Railways could not recall the employee back to its service.
- Accordingly, the Railways indicated to Burn Standard Company that after acceptance of permanent absorption the petitioner should not be relieved.
Table of Precedents Cited
No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court anchored its reasoning on several factual and normative observations recorded in the opinion:
- Normative principle: Governmental action must be free from arbitrariness or bias and must be fair, reasonable and in consonance with law. Where administrative high-handedness departs from accepted norms, courts exist to remedy the wrong.
- The Court reviewed the factual matrix: deputation in 1984, promotions in 1985, the expiry of deputation on 27 August 1985, the offer of permanent absorption which the petitioner accepted, and subsequent communications including the Railway Board's note of no objection dated 18 April 1986 and an office order of 1 July 1986 confirming permanent absorption with effect from 27 August 1985.
- The company subsequently issued an order dated 25 August 1986 revoking a prepared (but not issued) office order and announcing the petitioner's release on the ground of non-submission of formal resignation to the Railways. The Court observed that the Railways had expressly communicated that the petitioner should not be relieved after acceptance of permanent absorption.
- On these facts the Court found the company's volte-face to be arbitrary, contrary to fairness, and inconsistent with the conduct of both the petitioner and the company up to that point: the petitioner had accepted absorption and thereby relinquished his right to return to the parent department and had altered his position and expectations accordingly.
- The Court concluded that law courts cannot remain passive where an employee has altered his position in reliance on an employer's conduct and where justice, morality, fairness and equity require corrective action. The Court treated the company's action as an instance of administrative high-handedness that warranted judicial intervention.
- Applying these principles to the facts, the Court set aside the impugned order dated 25 August 1986 and directed appropriate relief to make good the petitioner’s position.
Holding and Implications
Holding:
The Court's core ruling was to quash the impugned order dated 25 August 1986. In the terms used in the judgment, the impugned order (Annexure 'Q') is set aside and quashed and relief is granted to the petitioner.
Immediate directives and consequences for the parties (direct effects):
- The petitioner is ordered to be allowed to join the post last held by him on the same scale of salary and with all increments due, immediately.
- The petitioner is entitled to his entire salaries together with all allowances since August 1986; such arrear salaries and allowances are to be paid within a week from the date of the order, subject to deduction of amounts already received by the petitioner pursuant to prior orders of the Court.
- By reason of the special facts and circumstances, the petitioner is awarded costs of the application assessed at Rs. 1,500/-.
- Final disposition: "Application allowed." (the writ petition's challenge to the 25 August 1986 order succeeded).
Broader implications:
The opinion does not purport to lay down a new principle of law beyond the application of fairness and the remedial role of courts where administrative action is arbitrary. The decision's effect is confined to setting aside the specific administrative order and restoring the petitioner's position; the opinion does not identify the creation of a new binding precedent beyond the facts of this case.
Umesh Chandra Banerjee, J.:— The most accepted methodology of a governmental action is that it ought to be free from any arbitrariness or bias and it must always be fair, reasonable and in consonance with law. Law Courts exist to remedy the wrong in the even there is departure from the accepted norms of a governmental action. It is a plain exercise of judicial power to set right the wrong if inflicted on the basis of administrative high-handedness.
2. The principal contention raised in this writ petition is that by reason of administrative high-handedness the petitioner has had to suffer enormously and is now moving from pillar to post for the purpose of getting justice and for being reinstated in Burn Standard Company Ltd. Admittedly, M/s Burn Standard Company Ltd. is a Government company within the meaning of section 617 of the Companies Act and a State within the meaning of Article 12 of the Constitution. Before adverting however to the principal contentions raised, a brief narration of the facts would be relevant at this juncture.
3. The petitioner, originally in the employment of the Railways, was sent on deputation to M/s Burn Standard Company Ltd. as per latter's request in 1984. This deputation was effected after interviewing several persons. By a letter dated 28th June, 1984 addressed to the Secretary, Ministry of Railways, Railway Board, New Delhi, Burn Standard Company Ltd. requested for approval and release of the petitioner for appointment as Deputy Manager (Personnel) in the company in the scale of Rs. 1800–2400/- on usual terms and conditions of deputation and on 10th August, 1984 the Railways released the petitioner on deputation to Burn Standard Company Ltd. for appointment to the post of Deputy Personnel Manager. By an office order dated 3rd September, 1984 the petitioner's joining report was confirmed by the Deputy Manager (Personnel). Subsequently, by reason of exigencies of situation, the petitioner was further asked to join M/s Bharat Brake and Valves Company, an associate Company of M/s Burn Standard Company Ltd.
4. On 29th March, 1985 the petitioner was designated on promotion as the Chief of Personnel of M/s Bharat Brake and Valves Company and on 11th September, 1985 the petitioner was designated on promotion as Chief of Personnel and Administration in the rank of Deputy General Manager of Bharat Brake and Valves Company. There were requests from the Burn Standard Company Ltd. for extention of the deputation period but the Railways intimated by a telegram that extension cannot be allowed and the officer may be relieved positively on 27th of August, 1986. On 8th January, 1986 by reason of non-extension of the deputation period the petitioner was given an option for absorption in Burn Standard Company Ltd. or to go back to the parent department, namely, the Railways. The petitioner duly exercised the option for absorption in the company. By his letter dated 14th February, 1986 and finally on 28th February, 1986 the company indicated the terms and the company intimated its decision to absorb the petitioner.
5. As appears from records that for all intents and purposes the chapter of absorption of the petitioner with Burn Standard Company Ltd. was closed and as a matter of fact by a letter dated 8th April, 1986 the Assistant Manager (Accounts) intimated to the Senior Higher Divisional Accounts Officer as to the amount payable to the Railways on account of pension and leave salary contribution in respect of the petitioner for his deputation period and finally on 18th April, 1986 the Under Secretary, Railway Board intimated Burn Standard Company that the Department of Railways have no objection to the petitioner being permanently absorbed in the Burn Standard Company with effect from 27th August, 1985. The office order dated 1st July, 1986 confirms the permanent absorption of the petitioner in the scale of Rs. 1800-2400/- with effect from 27th August, 1985. The intimation from Burn Standard Company to Bharat Brakes and Valves Company dated 25th July, 1986 corroborates such a state of facts as regards the permanent absorption of the petitioner in M/s Burn Standard Company.
6. On 25th August, 1986, however, the company sounded a different note to the following effect:
“Since despite repeated reminders, you have not submitted formal resignation terminating your services with the Railways and further that your extended period of deputation expires on 27th August, 1986, the proposal of your absorption in this company has been reviewed by the management. After consideration of the relevant facts the management has decided to release you on the expiry of your extended period of deputation with effect from 27th August, 1986 and the office order dated 1st July, 1986 which was prepared and signed by the Chief of Personnel of the Company but not issued, stands revoked….”
7. The Ministry of Transport, Department of Railways was informed of the same and in its turn the Railways intimated the Deputy General Manager (Personnel), Burn Standard Co. to the following effect:
“Sanctioned period of deputation of Mr. B.C Sinha with Burn Standard Company expired on 27th August, 1985. No extention was given beyond 27th August, 1985. Neither it is permissible under extent Government orders. Proposal for permanent absorption of B.C Sinha in Burn Standard Company with effect from 27th August, 1985 has already been approved. B.C Sinha should not be relieved.”
8. It is this order of M/s Burn Standard Company Ltd. in regard to release of the petitioner dated 25th August, 1986 after permanent absorption, which is under challenge as being totally arbitrary and being against all norms of justice.
9. Mr. Malay Basu, learned advocate appearing for the petitioner submitted that the petitioner became a victim of administrative wrath and has been released from the company for reasons which are unknown to the petitioner. It was strenuously contended that after acceptance of the offer by the petitioner and after regularisations of the service of the petitioner in Burn Standard Company the question of release of the petitioner does not and cannot arise. Mr. Pal, appearing for Burn Standard Company, however, submitted that because of non-compliance of the necessary formalities in regard to the letter of resignation to the Railways, the absorption cannot be given effect to and as such the company has had no other alternative but to release the petitioner to its parent department. The learned counsel appearing for the Railways, however, submitted that once an employee's permanent absorption in another company has been accepted by the Railways, the question of recalling him back any further does not and cannot arise. The situation therefore, in short, stands that the petitioner was asked to join the Burn Standard Company as a deputationist for a specific period, the period having expired the company permanently absorbed him and such permanent absorption was accepted by the parent department and after acceptance of such permanent absorption in the company, the latter released the petitioner and parent department also refused to have the employee back on its roll-a situation which is not only peculiar but rather strange and I find sufficient justification in Mr. Basu's submission that it amounts to a virtual termination of the service without so doing in a formal way.
10. Let us now analyse the situation a little further. Would the petitioner be still entitled to go back to the parent department and join?-the learned counsel appearing for the Railways in no uncertain terms submitted that the Railways cannot possibly take the petitioner back after grant of approval of the permanent absorption in the Burn Standard Company. Burn Standard Company is not prepared to keep him any longer but has invented a novel procedure to get rid of the petitioner without seeking recourse to termination of his services-a procedure which is undoubtedly novel and unknown to law. A technical objection of lack of formal resignation letter to the Railways may be raised if any by the Railway's itself and not by the Company. The Railways in no uncertain terms intimated the company that after acceptance of permanent absorption, the petitioner ought not to be relieved.
11. The other aspect of the matter is in regard to the conduct of the respondent, Burn Standard Company. The deputation period expired on 27th August, 1985 and the Railways indicated that no extension is possible thereafter-on hearing the same the company offered the petitioner permanent absorption on certain terms-the petitioner accepted the same and thereby relinquished his right to go back to the parent department. Both the petitioner and the company acted on the basis of such permanent absorption and thereafter all of a sudden the company shifts its stand and released the petitioner-does it stand to reason? can it be said to be in accordance with law? is it fair?-the only answer, in my view available, is in the negative.
12. The law courts cannot remain a passive spectator in a matter like this when by reason of definite conduct the petitioner alters his position and has had his expectation to serve the company on a permanent basis. The law court should rise up to the occasion and set right the wrong inflicted on an employee where justice, morality and fairness dictates such a course and equity so requires.
13. In that view of the matter, the impugned order dated 25th August, 1986 being Annexure ‘Q’ to the writ petition, is set aside and quashed and it is ordered that the petitioner be allowed to join the post last held by him on the same scale of salary together with all increments-due, if any, immediately. The petitioner is also entitled to his entire salaries together with all allowances since August, 1986. Such arrear salaries together with allowances be paid to the petitioner within a week from date less, however, the amount already received by the petitioner in terms of the orders of this Court. By reason of the special facts and circumstances of this case, the petitioner is also entitled to costs of this application assessed at Rs. 1500/-.
14. Application allowed.
Alert