- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Dr. (Sm.) Pushpika Chatterjee (Petitioner) v. State Of West Bengal And Ors. (S).
Factual and Procedural Background
The petitioner, Dr. (Sm.) Pushpika Chatterjee, a qualified anaesthetist since 1966, joined the Medical Service of the Government of West Bengal in 1962. She served at various locations, including muffasil areas, and was the Resident Medical Officer-cum-Clinical Tutor in the Department of Anaesthesiology at the Institute of Post Graduate Medical Education Research, Calcutta. On 20th July 1970, the petitioner was ordered by the Governor to act as Medical Officer (Anaesthetist) at Siliguri Sub-Divisional Hospital, replacing Dr. M.N. Mukherjee, who was simultaneously transferred to another hospital. Upon reporting to Siliguri, Dr. Mukherjee refused to hand over charge to the petitioner, who was then allowed to join without formal charge-taking.
Subsequently, a series of transfer orders were issued between July and November 1970, including cancellations and reassignments involving the petitioner and Dr. Mukherjee. The petitioner was transferred multiple times in quick succession, ultimately directed to Kurseong Sub-Divisional Hospital. She made representations against these frequent transfers citing family and educational disruption. The transfer orders were intermittently kept in abeyance pending further instructions.
After her representations were not complied with, the petitioner filed a constitutional writ petition in January 1971 challenging the transfer to Kurseong. The Court issued an interim order restraining the respondents from enforcing the transfer, which was later vacated with a direction for expeditious hearing. The respondents filed affidavits denying allegations of malafide intent and asserting the transfers were in public interest and administrative convenience.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the transfer orders passed against the petitioner were bona fide administrative orders made in public interest or were malafide and for collateral purposes.
- Whether the Court has jurisdiction to interfere with the administrative order of transfer in absence of financial or civil consequences.
- Whether the principles of postings and transfers, as contained in the Health Department's circular, have statutory force and can be enforced.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioner's Arguments
- The transfer orders violated the principles of postings and transfers as per the Health Department's circular dated August 10, 1967.
- The successive cancellation of transfer orders pertaining to Dr. M.N. Mukherjee indicated that the petitioner's transfer was made solely to accommodate Dr. Mukherjee, evidencing malafide intent.
- Frequent transfers caused personal hardship affecting family tranquility and the education of her child.
- The transfer was vindictive and not in public interest or administrative convenience.
Respondents' Arguments
- The transfers were made under Rule 24 of the West Bengal Civil Service Rules and were administrative orders not subject to judicial interference.
- The Health Department's circular relied upon by the petitioner has no statutory force.
- The transfers were in public interest and administrative convenience, causing no financial loss or adverse effect on service conditions of the petitioner.
- Allegations of malafide and vindictiveness against the respondents were denied and unsupported by cogent evidence.
- The petitioner’s husband’s representation for his own retention at Siliguri did not bind the petitioner’s transfer.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Mihir Kumar Sarkar v. State of West Bengal, 75 C.W.N 831 | Executive or administrative orders can be struck down if passed malafide or for collateral purposes. | The Court applied this principle to find the transfer order malafide and for a collateral purpose, thus liable to be quashed. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court recognized that government transfer orders are generally administrative decisions made for public interest and are ordinarily not subject to judicial review. However, relying on the precedent of Mihir Kumar Sarkar, the Court held that such orders are amenable to challenge if shown to be malafide or made for collateral purposes.
Examining the facts, the Court noted a pattern of successive transfer orders involving the petitioner and Dr. Mukherjee, with repeated cancellations of Dr. Mukherjee’s transfers and the petitioner being repeatedly moved. The refusal of Dr. Mukherjee to hand over charge and the Government’s inaction to resolve this created an anomalous situation with two incumbents at Siliguri, increasing State expenditure.
The Court found no satisfactory explanation or administrative justification for repeatedly cancelling Dr. Mukherjee’s transfer orders, suggesting the petitioner’s transfers were orchestrated solely to accommodate Dr. Mukherjee. This demonstrated a collateral purpose and malafide intent, not public interest or administrative convenience.
The Court refrained from adjudicating on personal allegations against individual officers and did not rely on the Health Department’s circular as it lacked statutory authority. Ultimately, the Court concluded that the impugned transfer order was malafide and unsustainable.
Holding and Implications
The Court made the Rule absolute, issuing writs in the nature of Mandamus and Certiorari to restrain and quash the impugned order of transfer against the petitioner.
The direct effect of this decision is that the petitioner’s transfer order to Kurseong Sub-Divisional Hospital is set aside, and she is to be retained at her prior posting. No broader legal precedent was established beyond affirming judicial intervention where administrative orders are shown to be malafide or for collateral purposes. There was no order as to costs.
The Judgment of the Court was delivered by
Salil Kumar Datta, J.:— The petitioner Dr. (Sm.) Pushpika Chatterjee is the holder of M.B.B.S degree from the University of Calcutta with a Diploma in Anaesthesia and she was declared a specialist in anaesthesia in the year 1966. The petitioner's case is as follows:
The petitioner joined the Medical Service, Government of West Bengal in the year 1962. She served at different places including muffasil areas within the State and at the material, time she was the Resident Medical Officer-cum-Clinical Tutor, Department of Anaesthesiology in the Institute of Post Graduate Medical Education Research, Calcutta. By order dated the 20th July, 1970 passed by the Governor (annexure A to the petition), the petitioner was appointed to act until further orders as Medical Officer (Anaesthetist) Siliguri Sub-Divisional Hospital, Darjeeling with effect from the date on which she would join the post vice Dr. M.N Mukherjee also referred as Dr. Manindra Nath Mukherjee.
2. There was another order following on the same date whereby them Governor was pleased to appoint Dr. Manindra Nath Mukherjee then employed as Medical Officer (Anaesthetist) Siliguri Sub-Divisional Hospital Darjeejing to act until further orders as Medical Officer (Anaesthetist) Sadar Hospital, Suri Birbhum with effect for the date on which he would join the post vice Dr. A. Bose.
3. The petitioner, in obedience to this order proceeded to Siliguri to join the post inspite of great hardship and even though it resulted in deprivation to her of all the facilities of study and research. When she went to join her post in the Siliguri Sub-Divisional Hospital she was not allowed to resume her duties and the charge was refused to be handed over to her by Dr. M.N Mukherjee. She thereafter contacted respondent No. 5 Dr. A.K Roy, Deputy Director of Health Services and as per his instruction she was allowed to join by petting in an application to the authority but without taking any charge from Dr. M.N Mukherjee who had refused to hand over the charge. The petitioner made a representation because she was apprehensive of not getting her salary in view of her release from her former place of service. It appears that in the middle of October, 1970 the respondent No. 5 visited the Siliguri Sub-Divisional Hospital and stayed therein the Inspection Bungalow where Dr. Mukherjee met him. In the last week of October, 1970, Dr. H. Saha, Director of Health Services, Government of West Bengal respondent No. 3 had been to Siliguri and while he was going round the Hospital the petitioner mentioned before him the matter of non-payment of salary, and non-handing over of the charge by Dr. M.N Mukherjee. Dr. Saha thereupon told her that if the charge was not handed over to her by Dr. M.N Mukherjee she would be transferred again elsewhere very soon. Then petitioner stated to him about the unusual way of transferring her in violation of the rules and principles of posting and transfers of medical officers at which Dr. Saha seemed to be very much annoyed with her and asked her not to question the action of the Directorate. The petitioner became thus very much depressed at the attitude of the respondents Nos. 3 and 5 who seemed to be determined to act malafide and in a vindictive way against her.
4. Thereafter, the second order was passed, viz. the order of the Governor, dated the 6th November, 1970 by way of regularisation, whereby the petitioner was appointed to act untilfurther orders as the Medical Officer (Anaesthetist) Siliguri Sub-Divisional Hospital, Darjeeling with effect from the date she would join her post and this order cancelled the previous order dated the 20th July 1970 regarding her transfer. On the same day there was a further order passed by the Governor whereby Dr. Manindra Nath Mukherjee then employed as Medical Officer at Siliguri was appointed to act until further orders as the Medical Officer (Anaesthetist) Balurghat Sadar Hospital. West Dinajpur with effect from the date he would join the post. This order also cancelled the previous order dated 20th July, 1970 regarding the transfer of Dr. Manindra Nath Mukherjee to Suri Birbhum. This order is annexure D to the petition. Barely after about three weeks' of the order dated November 6, 1970 another order dated the 27th November, 1970 was passed by the Governor whereby the petitioner was directed to act until further orders as Medical Officer (Anaesthetist) Kurseong Sub-Divisional Hospital with effect from the date she would join her post. This order dated the 27th November, 1970 cancelled the earlier order dated the 6th November, 1970 relating to the posting of Dr. M.N Mukherjee (Anaesthetist) of Siliguri Sub-Divisional Hospital, Darjeeling to the Balurghat Hoshpital West Dinajpur. The petitioner thereafter made a representation to the Secretary, Directorate of Health Services stating that she was working in the present post for a period of 3½ months only and such frequent transfers from one place to another affected her family tranquillity and also the education of her child. She, accordingly, asked for cancellation of her transfer. It appears that by an order passed on the application made by the petitioner the order of transfer already passed was kept in abeyance till the 31st December, 1970. Subsequently by a letter dated the 11th December, 1970 the Director of Health Services informed the Chief Medical Officer that Dr. (Sm.) Pushpika Chatterjee should be released to Kurseong S.D Hospital by January 15, 1971 positively if under local arrangement—her substitute did not join in the meantime. A copy of this letter/order was sent to the petitioner with instruction that she would be released from her duty on the forenoon of January 1, 1971. Subsequently the order of transfer was kept in abeyance till January 15, 1971.
5. The petitioner in the meantime served her demand of justice on the authority on the 9th January, 1970 for recalling the older of transfer to Kurseong. As this requisition was not complied with the petitioner moved this court in Constitutional writ jurisdiction and obtained the Rule on January 14, 1971. It appears that an interim order restraining the respondents from giving effect to the impugned order till 8 weeks from the date of the order was also passed by the court and ultimately this interim order was not extended with the observation that if the petitioner succeeded in the Rule, the respondents would bring back the petitioner to her place of posting.
6. Against this order vacating the interim order the petitioner filed an appeal, namely, F.M.A.T 3151/71 and ultimately, the appeal was dismissed with direction for expeditious hearing of the Rule.
7. An affidavit in opposition was filed by the respondents Nos. 1 and 2, the State Government and its Deputy Secretary of the Medical Department. All material allegations in the petition were denied and it was stated that the transfer of the petitioner was in the interest of public service. The petitioner by reason of the transfer would suffer no financial loss nor the conditions of her service would be affected adversely. It was also stated that the petitioner's husband Dr. K.K Chatterjee, also in the State Medical Service made personal representation for retaining him at Siliguri while the petitioner could be moved to Kurseong. Reliance was also placed on the affidavit of Dr. Saha in interlocutory proceedings as to the personal allegations against him as he was in leave preparatory to retirement.
8. There was another affidavit-in-opposition on behalf of respondent No. 5 in which he denied all allegations made against him personally. It was admitted that the petitioner was asked to join her post at Siliguri by making an application and without taking over charge when such charge was not being handed over to her by Dr. M.N Mukherjee immediately after her transfer to Siliguri in July, 1970. The allegations that the order of transfer was malafide and vindictive or to feed his grudge were denied. An affidavit-in-reply was filed by the petitioner controverting all allegations in, the said affidavits and she reiterated the allegations made by her in the petition. As to her husband's statement regarding her transfer to Siliguri she denied that no such representation was made and further that she was not bound by it. It was stated that frequent orders of transfer made against the petitioner in order to accommodate Dr. M.N Mukherjee would show, that the transfer of the petitioner was passed malafide and as a vindictive measure.
9. Mr. Amar Prasad Chakraborty, the learned Advocate for the petitioner has contended that the impugned order of transfer against the principles of postings and transfers of Medical Officers as contained in the Health Department's Circular No. Estt/4993.IM-186/67 of August 10, 1967. It is contended that the corresponding successive orders canceling the orders of transfer of Dr. Mukherjee would show that the instant transfer of the petitioner was made not for administrative purposes or in public interest out only for the purpose of accommodating Dr. Mukherjee at Siliguri and thus was malafide.
10. Mr. A.P Sarkar, learned Advocate appearing for the respondents has contended that under Rule 24 of the West Bengal Civil Service Rules a government servant may be transferred from one place to another and the circular referred to above has no statutory force. It is contended by him that the instant order was an administrative order and no writ would lie against such administrative order. It is further stated that in view of the facts of this case no reliance should be placed on the allegations made personally against some of the respondents and there is no cogent evidence in support of such allegations made by the petitioner. It is farther stated that the order of transfer would result in no loss to the petitioner, financial or otherwise and there is no civil or evil consequences arising to it of the order of transfer. In the circumstances it is submitted that the court has no jurisdiction to interfere and should not interfere with the impugned order of transfer.
11. It is no doubt true that orders of transfer of Government servants like any other Government administrative or executive order are passed invariably for administrative purposes or in public interest. Such order normally are outside the purview of examination by courts of law. It is also the law, as observe by this Court in (1) Mihir Kumar Sarkar v. State of West Bengal, 75 C.W.N 831 (46), that an executive decision or action or an administrative decision is liable to be struck down if it is used malafide or for a collateral purpose.
12. In this case on the face of the record there is Something which impels me to hold that the order was not passed in the interest of public service or for administrative purposes. The first order of transfer of the petitioner is dated July 20, 1970 whereby the petitioner was asked to relieve Mr. M.N Mukherjee at Siliguri who was transferred by an order of the same date to the Suri Hospital. Dr. Mukherjee did not hand over charge to the petitioner and the result was that there were two incumbents for the same office at Siliguri at the cost of State Exchequer. When this fact was pointed out to the authority by the petitioner she was advised to file her joining report without taking over charge from Dr. Mukherjee, while it appears no steps were taken by the Government for taking charge from him.
13. This state of affairs continued till November 6, 1970 when the petitioner by another similar order was again appointed to act as Medical Officer (Anaesthetist) Siliguri Sub-Divisional Hospital with effect from the date she would join the post. By this order the first order dated July 20, 1970 transferring the petitioner to Siliguri was cancelled. As is seen by two successive orders of the same date, Dr. Mukherjee was transferred to Balurghat Sadar Hospital and his transfer to Suri was cancelled. It would also appeal, though there is no express averment, Dr. Mukherjee continued to stay at the Siliguri Hospital even during this period till by another order dated the 27th November, 1970 the petitioner was transferred to Kurseong Sub-Divisional Hospital. By this order again the posting of Dr. Mukherjee Medical Officer, Siliguri Hospital to Balurghat Sadar Hospital was cancelled.
14. It would appear, as is obvious, from the successive transfer orders of the petitioner that such orders were made only to enable Dr. Mukherjee to remain in the Siliguri Hospital. The order of transfer of this officer from Siliguri Hospital was conceited thrice and there is no disclosure in the affidavit-in-opposition as to the reasons of such cancellation or that he was retained for administrative purpose or in public interest. It is too obvious that the petitioner was being transferred to Kurseong with the same object in view that is for accommodating Dr. M.N Mukherjee at the Siliguri Hospital for undisclosed reasons.
15. Considering all this it appears to me that the order transferring the petitioner to Kurseong with which we are concerned here, was not for public interest as stated in the affidavit-in-opposition nor it was for administrative purposes as has been submitted. It is patently for the purpose of retaining Dr. Mukherjee at the Siliguri Hospital. The order therefore is for collateral purpose and is malafide and cannot be sustained. I am of the opinion that this is a fit case where the order of transfer should be interfered with even though no civil or evil consequences would follow from such order. As against the personal allegations made by the petitioner against the officers of the Medical Directorate I think I should refrain from dealing with such allegations as it is not necessary to consider the same. I am also not relying on the circular enunciating the principles of postings and transfers of Medical Officer as it does not appear to have been issued by statutory authority and thus contain merely executive instructions. In the result the application succeeds and the Rule is made absolute. Let a Writ both in the nature of Mandamus be issued restraining the respondents from giving effect to the impugned order of transfer being annexure E to the petition in so far as it relates the petitioner. Let also a Writ in the nature of certiorari be is sued quashing the impugned order annexure ‘E’ in so far as it relates the petitioner.
16. Let the Writs be drawn up accordingly.
17. There will be no order for costs.
Alert