Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

M.S Ramiah And Others v. The Special Land Acquisition Officer, Bangalore

Karnataka High Court
Nov 9, 1973
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The appellants were claimants in three references (L.A Misc. No. 612/67, 371/68 and 610/67) filed under Section 18 of the Land Acquisition Act before the Civil Judge, Bangalore District. These references sought determination of compensation amounts for lands acquired from the claimants. On 3rd June 1971, when the cases were called for hearing, the claimants’ counsel requested an adjournment, which was denied due to the prolonged pendency of the cases and previous adjournments granted without progress. In absence of evidence from the claimants challenging the adequacy of the Land Acquisition Officer’s award under Section 11 of the Act, the Civil Judge disposed of the references by confirming the awards and dismissing the claims.

Subsequently, the claimants filed applications under Rule 9 of Order IX of the Code of Civil Procedure seeking to set aside the dismissal order. The Land Acquisition Officer contended that the dismissal order was governed by Rule 3 of Order XVII of the Code and that the proper remedy was an appeal. The Civil Judge rejected this contention, held that the order was made under Rule 2 of Order XVII, and dismissed the applications for want of sufficient cause for the claimants’ non-appearance. The claimants then preferred the present appeals against this dismissal.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether a Court in a reference under Section 18 of the Land Acquisition Act can dismiss the claim for compensation due to the claimant’s absence or failure to adduce evidence.
  2. Whether the order dismissing the references without determining compensation conforms to the requirements of Section 26 of the Land Acquisition Act.
  3. The proper procedural remedy available to claimants against an order disposing of a reference under Section 18 of the Act.
  4. Whether applications under Rule 9 of Order IX of the Code of Civil Procedure are maintainable to set aside such dismissal orders.

Arguments of the Parties

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court analyzed the nature of references under Section 18 of the Land Acquisition Act, emphasizing that the award made by the Land Acquisition Officer under Section 11 is merely an offer and not binding unless accepted by the claimant. When a claimant disputes the award and seeks a reference, the Court is duty-bound to determine the compensation amount and cannot refuse jurisdiction even if the claimant is absent or fails to produce evidence.

The Court highlighted that the award passed by the Court under Section 18 must comply with Section 26 of the Act, which requires the award to be in writing, signed by the Judge, specifying amounts awarded under Section 23(1) clauses, and must include grounds for the award. This award is deemed a decree and judgment under the Code of Civil Procedure, thus enforceable accordingly.

The Court found that the Civil Judge’s order dated 3rd June 1971 did not demonstrate an application of mind to determine compensation and did not conform to Section 26’s requirements. The Court stressed that the Civil Judge should have relied on the Land Acquisition Officer’s award and evidence to apply valuation principles rather than dismissing claims outright. Additionally, the Court clarified that dismissal under Rule 8 of Order IX of the Code is not applicable to references under Section 18, rendering Rule 9 applications to set aside such dismissal orders misconceived.

Though the Civil Judge dismissed the applications under Rule 9 of Order IX, the Court held the reasons given were invalid but agreed with the dismissal on correct legal grounds.

Holding and Implications

The appeals were DISMISSED without costs.

The direct effect of this decision is the affirmation of the Civil Judge’s dismissal of the applications under Rule 9 of Order IX. The Court clarified procedural and substantive standards applicable to references under Section 18 of the Land Acquisition Act but did not set any new precedent beyond the case’s facts. The decision underscores that courts must pass reasoned awards under Section 26 and that procedural remedies must align with the proper provisions of the Code of Civil Procedure.

Show all summary ...

Govinda Bhat, C.J:— The appellants in the above appeals were the claimants in L.A Misc. No. 612/67, 371/68 and 610/67 on the file of the Court of the Civil Judge, Bangalore District, which were references made under Section 18 of the Land Acquisition Act (hereinafter called ‘the Act’) for determination of the amount of compensation for he lands acquired from the claimants. When the said references came up for hearing on 3rd June, 1971 before the learned Civil Judge, the counsel for the claiments sought for an adjournment of the cases, which was however rejected on the ground that the cases were pending for over four years and that on earlier occasions adjournment had been granted and yet the claimants had not taken necessary steps. In the absence of evidence adduced by the claimants to show that the amount awarded by the Land Acquisition Officer in the award made by him under Section 11 of the Act, is inadequate, the learned Civil Judge disposed of the references by an order dated 3rd June, 1971 which reads thus:

“Since there is no evidence to displace the correctness of the awards, the claims of the petitioners are dismissed. The awards are confirmed.

2. Thereafter the claimants filed applications under Rule 9 of Order IX of the Code of Civil Procedure for setting aside the aforesaid order. When the applications came up for hearing, it was contended on behalf of the Land Acquisition Officer that the order fell under Rule 3 of Order XVII of the Code of Civil Procedure and the remedy of the claimants is to prefer appeals. The learned Civil Judge rejected that contention and held that the Order was made under Rule 2 of Order XVII and not under Rule 3. He, however, held that there was no sufficient cause for non-appearance of the claimants when the cases came up for hearing and therefore dismissed the applications. Aggrieved by the said order, the claimants have preferred the above appeals.

3. The cases before the Civil Judge are references made by the Land Acquisition Officer under Section 18 of the Act for determination of the amount of compensation payable for the lands acquired as the claimants did not accept the awards made under Section 11 of the Act. An award made under Section 11 by the Land Acquisition Officer is in the nature of an offer to the claimants and therefore, unless the award is accepted by the claimants, the same is not binding. Where the claimant does not accept the award and seeks a reference under Section 18, the Land Acquisition Officer is bound to make a reference to the Court for determination of the amount of compensation for the lands acquired. When such a reference is made to the Court, it is the duty of the Court under the Act to deterine the amount of compensation payable for the land or lands acquired. The Court has no jurisdiction to refuse to deterine the amount of compensation even where the claimant remains absent or where he is present, fails to adduce evidence. The award of the court in a reference under Section 18 must be in the form provided under Section 26 of the Act. Section 26 reads thus:

“26. Form of Awards—.

(1) Every award under this Part shall be in writing signed by the Judge, and shall specify the amount awarded under clause First of sub-section (1) of Section 23, and also the amounts (if any) respectively awarded under each of the other clauses of the same sub-section, together with the grounds of awarding each of the said amounts.

(2) Every such award shall be deemed to be a decree and the statement of the grounds of every such award a judgment within the meaning of Section 2, clause (2), and Section 2, clause (9) respectively, of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (V. of 1908) and the provision of the said Code relating to execution shall, so far as may apply to the execution of such award”. (Proviso omitted as unnecessary).

4. It is plain from Section 26 that the award which the Court passes must be in the form of a judgment containing the statement of the grounds for the award. Where the claimant remains absent or does not produce evidence, it is not open to the court to dispose of the references stating that the claim of the claimant is dismissed or that the reference is rejected. The Court has to pass an award in the manner provided under Section 26. For making such an award, the court has necessarily to rely on the materials contained in the award of the Land Acquisition Officer under Section 11 and the evidence of the Land Acquisition Officer, if any, tendered before the Court. Ordinarily the burden is on the claimant to show that the compensation offered by the Land Acquisition Officer is inadequate and therefore he has to lead evidence in support of the claim for enhancement of compensation. But there may be cases where on the face of the award made under Section 11 the amount offered by the Land Acquisition Officer can be held to be arbitrary. If on the basis of the data furnished in the award of the Land Acquisition Officer, the court finds that the market value of the land has not been determined in accordance with settled principles of valuation, the court has to determine the compensation in accordance with such principles on the basis of the data available on record. Therefore, the Court has to apply its mind and make an award and cannot blindly confirm the award of the Land Acquisition Officer.

5. The order of the Civil Judge dated 3rd June, 1971 disposing of the references, does not show that the learned Civil Judge had applied his mind and determined the amount of compensation for the lands acquired. Prima facie, the order does not conform to the requirements of Section 26 of the Act. The remedy of the appellants is to appeal against the said order. The applications under Rule 9 of Order IX of the Code are wholly misconceived. As stated earlier, a reference under Section 18 cannot be dismissed for default under Rule 8 of Order IX of the Code. Consequently, Rule 9 of Order IX can have no application. This legal position when put to the learned counsel for the parties was not contested before me.

6. The learned Civil Judge was right in dismissing the application under Rule 9 of Order IX although the reasons given by him are not valid.

7. For the reasons stated above, these appeals fail and are dismissed but without costs.