- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Choice Enterprises, Chittoor v. Director Of Mines And Geology, Govt. Of A.P, Hyd. And Ors.
Summary of Court Opinion
Factual and Procedural Background
This judgment deals with multiple writ petitions arising from competing applications for quarry leases for extraction of cut or dressed blocks of black granite in adjoining "gap" survey areas in Yadamari Mandal, Chittoor District. Key facts shown in the opinion are:
- M/s. Choice Enterprises (petitioner in W.P. No. 16733/1996) filed an application dated 26-6-1995 for a quarry lease of 2,000 hectares described in the statutory form as falling in the gap area of Kottalam village.
- M/s. Tirumala Granites (4th respondent) filed an application dated 10-7-1995 for a quarry lease over 5,000 hectares in the gap area of Ottivaripalli and Patrapalli villages.
- Mandal revenue and divisional officers conducted inspections and issued initial and revised "no objection certificates" at various dates (initial NOC dated 10-12-1995 for Choice; revised NOC dated 29-1-1996 indicating the area within Patrapalli limits and noting competing applications).
- Choice Enterprises submitted a request dated 26-2-1996 asking the Director to treat its original application of 26-6-1995 as an application for Patrapalli village (i.e., seeking to change the village entry in the statutory form).
- The Director of Mines and Geology (1st respondent) issued impugned proceedings dated 9-8-1996 granting lease area in favour of Tirumala Granites (4th respondent); a lease deed was executed on 14-8-1996 by the 3rd respondent and work orders issued.
- Multiple writ petitions were filed challenging the grant and execution: W.P. No. 16733/1996 (Choice Enterprises), W.P. No. 22142/1996 (Manikanta Granites) and other related petitions. Interim relief (stay) was granted by telegraphic order on 19-8-1996 in one of the matters.
- The petitions raised questions about priority of application by date, correctness of surveys and demarcation, whether the statutory application form could be altered after filing, and compliance with the A.P. Minor Mineral Concession Rules, 1966 (notably rules 7 and 12(5)(b) and 12(5)(c)).
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the application of M/s. Choice Enterprises is earlier in point of time than the application filed by M/s. Tirumala Granites (i.e., should Choice's date be treated as 26-6-1995 or as 26-2-1996 after the request to change village entries)?
- Whether the Director (1st respondent) acted contrary to rule 12(5)(b) of the A.P. Minor Mineral Concession Rules, 1966 in granting lease to a later applicant without prior government approval or recorded reasons.
- Whether the rules (including rule 12(5)(c) and the statutory Form B-1 requirements) permit post-filing alteration of particulars in the application (for example, change of the village in which the applied area is stated to lie).
- Whether surveys and demarcations conducted prior to grant (by the 2nd respondent or mandal officers) have legal sanctity such that they bind the disposal of applications under the rules (and the legal effect of rule 7 as to post-grant demarcation and plan preparation).
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioner — M/s. Choice Enterprises
- Maintained that its statutory application dated 26-6-1995 (for 2,000 hectares in Kottalam gap area) was earlier than Tirumala's 10-7-1995 application and therefore should be considered first under rule 12(5)(b) (first-come-first-served principle).
- Relied on survey, inspection and consent given on 1-8-1995 (and survey/demarcation on 13-12-1995 in some instances) and earlier NOC of 10-12-1995 in its favour.
- Contended that revised NOC and later resurvey endangered the sanctity of earlier surveys and that any fresh resurvey would be contrary to fair administration under the rules.
- Sought to treat its application dated 26-6-1995 as an application for Patrapalli village by representation dated 26-2-1996, arguing the two applications related to the same gap area and that its priority should prevail.
- Relied on prior judgments (as recounted by the petitioner) to argue that authorities should not reject applications for incorrect or insufficient particulars and that procedural inspections/surveys prior to grant are a healthy administrative practice to avoid disputes.
Respondents 1 to 3 (Official Respondents — Director, District/Survey Authorities)
- Asserted that the Director (1st respondent) is the competent authority under rule 12(5) to receive, process and grant quarry leases and that it granted leases to Choice and to Tirumala for specified extents and directed resurvey before execution.
- Stated that the 3rd respondent (executing authority) is to resurvey and demarcate at execution stage and that surveys by the 2nd respondent prior to grant have no binding legal sanctity for final demarcation.
- Pointed out that notices for survey were sent and that Choice failed to attend certain surveys (the office reported inability to locate petitioner at the address provided), which justified administrative action.
- Maintained that orders dated 9-8-1996 are legal, valid and within the rules.
4th Respondent — M/s. Tirumala Granites
- Asserted that its application dated 10-7-1995 (for 5,000 hectares in Ottivaripalli and Patrapalli gap area) was earlier in respect of the Patrapalli/Ottivaripalli gap area and that the Director correctly granted lease to it in the extent of 3,980 hectares in Patrapalli by proceedings dated 9-8-1996.
- Contended that the statutory application form must be strictly complied with (village and survey numbers stated) and that a later attempt by Choice to treat its earlier application as applying to a different village is not permissible under the rules.
- Argued that the 2nd respondent’s survey (if any) before grant has no legal sanctity; the 3rd respondent is the authority for post-grant survey and demarcation under rule 7.
- Noted it had commenced operations after lease execution and that there was no illegality in grant or in the subsequent execution and work order.
M/s. Manikanta Granites (Petitioner in W.P. No. 22142/1996)
- Contended that its application (dated 12-7-1995 for 3,000 hectares over Ottivaripalli/Patrapalli gap area) was affected by defective survey and demarcation undertaken on different dates without notice to it, and therefore it was entitled to the remaining area after allocation to Choice Enterprises.
Table of Precedents Cited
The opinion cites prior judicial decisions. Each cited precedent and the role it played in the court's reasoning is summarized below.
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Vajra Granites Limited v. State of Andhra Pradesh and Others — single judge judgment dated 5-8-1994; confirmed by Division Bench (W.A. Nos. 862 & 863 of 1994) — unreported Division Bench judgment dated 6-10-1994 (as cited in the opinion) | Held that particulars in applications need not receive an overly strict construction; where joint inspection showed that applicants sought the same area, authorities could proceed on merits and accept inspection reports rather than reject applications for imperfect particulars. | The court considered this decision but distinguished it: the facts in Vajra (where the exact location was unclear and applicants described areas imperfectly) were different from the present case where the villages (Kottalam, Ottivaripalli, Patrapalli) are distinct and the exact location of the gap area was not in dispute. Therefore Vajra was held to have no application to the present facts. |
| M/s. Ranjana Granites (P) Ltd. v. State of Andhra Pradesh, 1996 (3) ALT 121 (Division Bench) | Observed that there is a mandatory requirement to establish a cutting and polishing unit within two years (or extended time) failing which the lease may be liable to termination; also discussed export/processing ratios for granite. | The court held this decision was not relevant to deciding whether the earlier application date belonged to Choice or Tirumala. The Ranjana decision did not interpret rule 12(5)(b) and therefore had no bearing on the priority/date issue in the present case. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court proceeded by identifying the crucial statutory provisions and the central factual question. The analysis follows the sequence in the opinion:
- Identification of governing provisions: The court examined rules 12(5)(b) and 12(5)(c) of the A.P. Minor Mineral Concession Rules, 1966 and the statutory application Form B-1 (as required by rule 12(6) provisions cited in the opinion). Rule 12(5)(b) requires applications for quarry leases for granite to be disposed of by the Director in the order of receipt; when multiple applications are received on the same day, the Director (with government approval) shall grant lease to a deserving applicant with reasons recorded in writing. Rule 12(5)(c) allows rejection of applications for defaults such as not attending inspection/survey or not producing required documents.
- Framing the decisive question: The court framed the determinative question as whether Choice's application should be treated as filed on 26-6-1995 (the original application date) or on 26-2-1996 (the date on which Choice sought to amend or treat its original application as referring to a different village — Patrapalli).
- Interpretation of the statutory application form and amendment: The court noted that Form B-1 requires specific description of the area applied for, with attached sketch. The learned counsel for Choice was unable to point to any rule made under the 1966 rules that permits an applicant to alter or change entries in the statutory application form after filing. In the absence of any such provision, the court held that Choice could not alter or change its application so as to treat the original application as if it had been made for Patrapalli from the date of the original filing.
- Temporal effect of amendment: The court explained that if the Department accepts any change, the effective date of that altered application can only be the date on which the amendment was sought (i.e., 26-2-1996), and not the original filing date of 26-6-1995.
- Application of the rules to the facts: Given that Choice's attempt to change the village particulars could not be treated as effective from 26-6-1995, the court held that Tirumala's application of 10-7-1995 was earlier in point of time in relation to the Patrapalli/Ottivaripalli gap area. Therefore the Director's decision to grant lease to Tirumala was consistent with the requirement to consider applications in order of receipt under rule 12(5)(b).
- Treatment of precedents relied upon by parties: The court considered the Vajra Granites decision relied on by Choice (which held that imperfect application particulars need not be fatal where joint inspection clarified location), but distinguished that authority because the present case involved distinct adjoining villages and an identifiable gap area — unlike Vajra where location was unclear. The court also considered Ranjana Granites (regarding requirement to establish cutting and polishing units) and found it irrelevant to the priority/date issue under rule 12(5)(b).
- Ancillary procedural and survey arguments: The court noted competing contentions about the legal sanctity of pre-grant surveys conducted by the 2nd respondent and the role of rule 7 (which provides that arrangement for preparation of a plan and demarcation is to be made by the assistant director at the expense of the lessees after grant). The court observed that surveys by the 2nd respondent before grant would not necessarily have binding legal sanctity for final demarcation, and the main legal question remained the priority of applications and validity of the attempt to change the statutory application particulars.
Holding and Implications
Holding:
The court concluded that M/s. Choice Enterprises could not treat its original application dated 26-6-1995 as an application for Patrapalli village for the purposes of claiming priority ahead of M/s. Tirumala Granites. The attempted change of village particulars would, if accepted, have effect only from the date the amendment was sought (26-2-1996). Therefore, the court found that the application of M/s. Tirumala Granites was earlier in point of time for the Patrapalli/Ottivaripalli gap area.
The writ petitions were dismissed. The court's operative language on the result was:
DISMISSED. No costs.
Direct Consequences
- The challenge to the impugned proceedings dated 9-8-1996 (granting lease to M/s. Tirumala Granites) and the execution of the lease deed dated 14-8-1996 failed; the petitions were dismissed.
- The court held that alteration of particulars in the statutory Form B-1 after filing is not permitted by the rules to have retrospective effect to the original application date; any accepted change will take effect from the date of the requested amendment.
- The decision leaves intact the administrative determination that Tirumala's application was earlier for the Patrapalli/Ottivaripalli area and supports the Director's exercise of discretion under rule 12(5)(b) as applied on the facts.
Broader Implications
The opinion resolves the dispute primarily by application and interpretation of the statutory rules and Form B-1 requirements rather than by creating any new legal principle. The court distinguished prior authority relied upon by the petitioner and limited the relevance of cases concerning processing or post-grant obligations (such as establishing polishing units). The judgment emphasizes strict temporal treatment of application priority and the limited scope for treating post-filing amendments as effective from the original filing date in the absence of an express rule permitting such retrospective alteration.
(1) All the counsels agreed to dispose of the main writ petitions itself. As the points involved in both the writ petitions, are one and the same, they are being disposed of by a common judgment. W. P. No. 16733 of 1996
(2) This writ petition is filed by m/s. Choice enterprises challenging the impugned proceedingsno. 18915/k295,dated 9 - 8 - 1996 of the 1 st respondent directing fresh survey and demarcation in a particular manner and grant of over lapping area in favour of the m/s. Tirumala granites (4th respondent) and consequently, directing the 3rd respondent to execute the lease deed and issue work order in accordance with law i. E. , survey conducted and consented to by the petitioner m/s. Choice enterprises on 1 - 8 - 1995 with regard to its quarry lease application dated26 - 6 - 1995.
(3) The learned counsel for the petitioner submits that the petitioner - firm has applied for grant of quarry lease to the 1 st respondent for extraction of cut or dressed blocks of black granite in an extent of 2,000 hectares in survey number gap area of kottalam village, yadamari mandal chittoor district for a period of 15 years. The petitioner has complied with all the statutory requirements. The 2nd respondent has invited the petitioner for inspection, survey and demarcation of the applied area on 1 - 8 - 1995. Thereafter, the 2nd respondent requested the mandal revenue officer, yadamari mandal to send a report on the category and availability of the area and no objection certificate along with the details of land assessment and extracts of adangal 10 (1) , r. S. R. Etc. The mandal revenue officer, yadamari vide letter dated 10 - 12 - 1995 furnished the required details and granted no objection certificate together with a certified sketch indicating the are a applied for mining purpose in favour of the petitioner. It is learnt that in pursuance ofsuch information furnished by the mandal revenue officer, the 2nd respondent recommended the application ofthe petitioner on 12 - 12 - 1995 to the 1 st respondent.
3 (a). It is further stated that coming to know certain developments, the petitioner - firm was constrained to issue telegraphic notices to the 2nd respondent, district collector, jointcollector, revenue divisional officer and the mandal revenue officer, yadamari mandal, chittoor district followed by a petition dated 10 - 1 - 1996 addressed to the revenue divisional officer, chittoor with a prayer to call for the records, examine the matter and cancel the no - objection certificate issued to m/s. Tirumala granites by the mandal revenue officer, yadamari. On the very same day, the revenue divisional officer, chittoor deferred the letter dated 16 - 12 - 1995 issued by the mandal revenue officer, yadamari mandal in favourof m/s. Tirumala granites (r - 4) and further directed the deputy inspector of survey of his office to personally inspectthe site and submit a report. The deputy inspector ofthe revenue divisional office, chittoor inspected the site i. E. , the applied area and submitted a report after verifying the area situated in the gap area of patrapalli and kottalam villages based on the old survey marks existing on ground at site. Thereafter, the mandal revenue officer, yadamari mandal vide proceedings dated 29 - 1 - 1996 issued revised 'no objection certificate' in favour of the petitioner - firm duly indicating that the said area lies within the limits of patrapalli revenue village and that the petitioner - firm and the 4th respondent - firm haveapplied for the same area. Subsequently, on 26 - 2 - 1996, the petitioner - firm filed a petition before the 1st respondent to the effect that the area applied by it and the 4th respondent, is one and the same falls within gap area of patrapalli village panchayat limits. The petitioner also requested to treat its application dated 26 - 6 - 1995 as an application made for grant of lease for black granite in an extent of 2,000 hectares gap area ofpatrapalli village, yadamari mandal, chittoor district instead of gap area of kottalam village, yadamari mandal, chittoor district.
3 (b). In the above circumstances, relying on rules 12 (5) (b) and 12 (5) (c) of a. P. Minor mineral concession rules, 1966, he submits that the application of the petitioner is prior to the application filed by the other applicants including the 4th respondent, and, therefore, deserves consideration for grant of lease in its favour. He further submits that though the lease for the same area has been applied by the petitioner as well as the 4th respondent, but the petitioner's application for grant of quarry lease dated 26 - 6 - 1995 is prior to the date of application dated 10 - 7 - 1995 for grant of quarry lease by the 4th respondent; as such, the lease should have been granted to the petitioner. Yet the 1 st respondent granted the lease of the overlapping area in favour of the 4th respondent whose application for lease is later than the petitioner, butno prior approval/sanction of the government has been obtained or reasons have been assigned by the 1st respondent; as such it violates rule 12 (5) (b) of the a. P. Minor mineral concession rules, 1966. The impugned order suffers from an apparent error. Therefore, in so far as the distribution of the area between the applicants in a particular manner, is concerned, the petitioner's application, being earlier in point of time than the 4th respondent, and who have complied with all the formalities, should have been decided first in its favour.
(4) In the counter affidavit filed by respondents 1 to 3, it is stated that the 1st respondent i. E. The director of mines and geology is the authority to receive, process and grant the quarry leases for granite under rule 12 (5) of a. P. Minor mineral concession rules, 1966. Therefore, the 1st respondent granted the lease to the petitioner over an extent of 2,000 hectares and to the 4th respondent over an extent of 5,000 hectares and requested them to execute the lease deeds before the ass istant director of mines and geology, chittoor. Further, the 1st respondent directed the 3rd respondent to resurvey the area leased to the petitioner and the 4th respondent before execution. Accordingly, the 3rd respondent requested the petitioner and the 4th respondent to attend for survey and demarcation of the areas granted. In response to it, the 4th respondent attended the survey and demarcation of the applied area. Notice was sent by the office through the special messenger to the address of the petitioner, butthe neighbours of the address mentioned in the petitioner's application have informed that no such person is staying in the address mentioned in the application. The petitioner failed to attend for survey of the area. Therefore, the orders of the 1st respondent dated 9 - 8 - 1996 are legal, valid and within the jurisdiction of a. P: minor minerals concession rules, 1966.
4 (a). It is also stated that the petitioner filed an application in form b - 1 for the grant of quarry lease for black granite on 2 8 - 6 - 1995 to the director of mines and geology, hyderabad. Against col. No. 2 (a) , it is clearly mentioned by the petitioner that the area applied for is gap area of kottalam village, yadamari mandal, chittoor district and the extent of applied area is 2,000 hectares. In reply to the 2nd respondent's letter, the mandal revenue officer, yadamari mandal vide letter no. C. 942/9b, dated 10 - 12 - 1995 stated thatthe area applied by the petitioner is falling in survey no. 228 of kottalam village, yadamari mandal. The mandal revenue officer submitted his report without proper and physical verification of the area applied by the petitioner, which fact was accepted by the same mandal revenue officer in his letter no. C. 843/95, dated 29 - 1 - 1996. Based on the earlier 'no objection certificate' given by the mandal revenue officer, on 10 - 12 - 1995, the 2nd respondent recommended for the grant of quarry lease in favour of the petitioner in survey no. 228 ofkottalam village, yadamari mandal, chittoor district. Therefore, the petitioner is entitled to obtain the area in kottalam village, but not in any other revenue village limits.
4 (b). It is submitted that the 2nd respondent referred all the applications for grant of quarry lease to the mandal revenue officer, yadamari for classification and availability of the areaapplied by the different applicants. The mandal revenue officer, yadamari submitted 'noobjection certificate reports' on few applications without proper physical verification of the applied areas. By knowingthis fact, some ofthe applicants and the petitioner filed a representation before the revenue divisional officer, chittoor and requested to issue fresh 'no objection' certificates. The revenue divisional officer, chittoor in his letter no. E6/6905/95, dated 19 - 12 - 1995 and 10 - 1 - 1996 deferred the no objection certificates given by the mandal revenue officer, yadamari in favour of the petitioner, the 4th respondent and other applicants and directed the mandal revenue officer, yadamari to resurvey the area and issue revised 'no objection certificates'. Further, the revenue divisional officer requested the deputy inspector of survey of his office to survey the area and fix up the boundaries in between kottalam village, patrapalli and ottuvaripalli villages of yadamari mandal, chittoor district. The deputy inspector of survey of his office surveyed the area as per the existing survey stones physically available in the field on ground and prepared a map and on receipt of the same from the deputy inspector of survey, the revenue divisional officer vide his letter no. E/6905/95, dated 28 - 1 - 1996 directed the mandal revenue officer, yadamari to issue revised no objection certificate showing the locations of the areas applied by the different applicants in the gap area of the revenue villages concerned. Soon after the receipt of the revised no objection certificate from the mandal revenue officer, yadamari, the 2nd respondent submitted revised proposals to the 1 st respondent by duly recommending for the grant of quarry lease in favour of the 4th respondent in patrapalli village, while rejecting the quarry lease application filed by the petitioner.
4 (c). It is further submitted that the 4th respondent specifically mentioned the area required for him in the application form prescribed by the government by duly enclosing the village map showing the area in patrapalli village and ottuvaripalli village, yadamari mandal, whereas the petitioner requested the authorities to grant the area in kottalam village. Knowing fully well that the area applied by the petitioner is falling in patrapalli village limits, the petitioner made a representation to the 1st respondent to consider the application in patrapalli village instead of kottalam village. There is no provision in a. P. Minor mineral concession rules to change the area once applied for in a particular village. Therefore, the representation dated 26 - 2 - 1996 filed by the petitioner before the 1 st respondent cannot be entertained by the department. The application of the 4th respondent was the only application pending before the 1st respondent in gap area of patrapalli village, yadamari mandal, chittoor district. Therefore, the claim of petitioner that his application inpatrapalli village has got priority over the 4th respondent is baseless. Infact, no application of the petitioner was pending before the respondents for the grant of quarry lease in patrapalli village.
4 (d). The petitioner once again submitted a representation to the district collector and the assistant director of survey and land records, chittoor, on the reports submitted by the revenue divisional officer and the revised no objection certificate dated 29 - 1 - 1996 submitted by the mandal revenue officer, requested to resurvey the area again withan opinion that the area applied by him falls in kottalam village limits only. On that, the assistant director of survey and land records inspected the village boundaries of kottalam village, patrapalli and ottuvaripalli villages on 2 - 3 - 1996 and 3 - 3 - 1996 in the presence of deputy inspector of survey, chittoor, mandal surveyor of yadamari mandal, the petitioner and some people of surrounding village and prepared the surveyed map after physical verification of the stone points.
4 (e). It is also submitted that there is huge extent of black granite area available in the gap area of kottalam village limits and any application of the petitioner filed for the kottalam village limits has to be considered subject to priority etc. Therefore, in any circumstances, the petitioner is not entitled for grant of quarry lease, other than an area falling in village limits mentioned in the statutory application form i. E. Kottalam village. Therefore the petitioner is not entitled to claim the area in patrapalli village as against the area surveyed on 1 - 8 - 1995 by the 2nd respondent. However, the 1st respondent considered and granted lease over an extent of 2,000 hectares in patrapalli village limits under principles of natural justice to the petitioner, eventhough the petitioner applied in kottalam village. Therefore, there are absolutely no merits in the above writ petition and the petitioner is not entitled to any indulgence.
(5) In the counter - affidavit filed by the 4th respondent, it is stated that it has applied for grant of quarry lease over an extent of 5,000 hectares in a gap area of 144 of ottuvaripalli and patrapalli villages, yadamari mandal, chittoor district for black granite on 10 - 7 - 1995. The application submitted by the 4th respondent was earlier in point of time for the grant of quarry lease. After completing all formalities, the 1 st respondent granted quarry lease for black granite in gap area of patrapalli village, yadamari mandal, chittoor district by the impugned order over an extent of 3,980 hectares. A quarry lease was executed on 14 - 8 - 1996 by the 3rd respondent who also issued work order permitting the 4th respondent to commence quarrying operations. It is also stated that the 3rd respondent informed that necessary orders will be issued for commencing quarry operations in the remaining 1. 02 hectares falling in ottivaripalli village soon. The 4th respondent has commenced quarry operations in the afternoon of 14th august, 1996 by taking the proclain and other machinery to the leased area which is only 18 kilometres from chittoor. Since then, he is continuously conducting the quarry operations. On 19 - 8 - 1996, this court granted interim - stay by telegraphic order.
5 (a). It is submitted by the counsel for the 4th respondent that it is having priority under rule 12 of the a. P. Minor mineral concession rules, 1966 and the application - form is prescribed under rule 9 which is a statutory form. Every applicant should invariably mention about the name of the village, survey number and also submit a map along with the plan. The quarry lease will be granted only in survey number and the village mentioned in the application form. Hence, if the particulars are vague or the area is not mentioned specifically in the application form or shown in the map, the application may be rejected.
5 (b). He submits that the petitioner had applied for a quarry lease over an extent of 2,000 hectares in kottalam village, yadamari mandal, chittoor district and so he is entitled for grant of quarry lease only in kottalam village, but not in patrapalli village. The petitioner cannot claim for grant of quarry lease in patrapalli village, for which he has not submitted any application. The assistant director, survey and land records, ananthapur visited the area and also confirmed that the area applied for by the 4th respondent is falling in patrapalli village and ottivaripalli village whereas the area applled for by the petitioner is falling in kottalam village. The petitioner has stated in his affidavit that it has submitted an application on 26 - 2 - 1996 (after a period of 8 months) to the 1 st respondent that its application dated 26 - 6 - 1995 for the grant of quarry lease in the gap area of kottalam village may be treated as the application for the grant of quarry lease in patrapalli village. Such a petition is not maintainable and such a request to treat its application in one village as an application for the area in another village, cannot be entertained by the department. The rules also do not provide for change of areas as and when the survey discloses any variations. It is further submitted that the 4th respondent is having a cutting and polishing unit in shed no. 3 in the industrial estate, chittoor; whereas the petitioner is not having any cutting and polishing unitanditdoesnotown any quarrying equipment also. Hence, it is prayed for vacating the interim stay granted by this court in w. P. M. P. No. 20563/96 in writ petition no. 16733/1996 and to dismiss the writ petition.
(6) In the reply affidavit submitted by the petitioner, it has narrated the administrative proceedings of the official respondents from the date of filing of the application for grant of quarry lease till the impugned order is passed in favour of the 4th respondent and also specifically stated that a - p - minor mineral concession rules, 1966 do not provide for rejecting the applications on the ground of furnishing incorrect or insufficient information. It is further stated that in similar facts and circumstances of the case, this court by judgment dated 5 - 8 - 1994 passed in writ petition nos. 10096/1994 and 10182/ 1994 allowed the same and the said judgment was later confirmed by the division bench on 6 - 10 - 94 in w. A. Nos. 862 and 863/1994 and the petitioner is given to understand that the above matter was later carried to the apex court by way of s. L. P. (civil) no. 20203/1994 and the same was dismissed on 3 - 2 - 1995. The petitioner reiterates the pleas already stated in the writ - affidavit and submits that any fresh resurvey as ordered in the impugned proceedings will endanger the sanctity of the survey and demarcation already conducted on 1 - 8 - 1995 and 13 - 12 - 1995, as the grant of quarry lease in favour of the 4th respondent is on the basis of irregular distribution of area in a particular manner which is against the spirit of a. P. Minor mineral concession rules, 1966 and also stated that it is not compulsory for any applicant to set up a granite cutting and polishing unit within the state of a. P. And the 1st respondent is not legally bound to show any preference for grant of quarry leases in favour of the persons who have established cutting and polishing units as held by the division bench of this court reported in 1996 (3) alt 121. It is also stated that the quarry lease granted under the order in question was already executed in favour of the 4th respondent hurriedly for the reasons best known to the respondents 3 and 4. W. P. No. 22142/96
(7) In this writ petition, the writ petitioner seeks a writ of mandamus declaring the proceedings of the 1st respondent in proceedings no. L8915/k2/95,dated9 - 8 - 1996 granting lease in favour of the 4th respondent and the subsequent action of the 3rd respondent in executing the lease deed dated 14 - 8 - 1996, as illegal, arbitrary and ultravires of the provisions of a. P. Minor mineral concession rules, 1966.
(8) The learned counsel for the petitioner submits that the petitioner had applied for grant of lease of cut or dressed blocks of black granite over an extent of 3,000 hectares in survey number gap area of ottivaripalli village and patrapalli village vide its application dated 12 - 7 - 1995. The 4th respondent - m/s. Tirumala granites has also made an application for grant of lease of cut or dressed blocks of black granite over an extent of 5,000 hectares in the same survey gap area of ottivaripalli village and patrapalli village of yadamari mandal, vide its application dated 10 - 7 - 1995. It is further submitted that as both the applicants have applied for grant of lease of the same area in question, the office of the 2nd respondent invited both the petitioner and the 4th respondent for inspection, survey and demarcation of the applied areas on21 - 9 - 1995and 1 l - 12 - 1995. Unfortunately, both the applicants could not attend the said inspection. Thereafter on 13 - 12 - 1995, the 2nd respondent while proceeding to gundlasagaram village has conducted the inspection, survey and demarcation in favour of the 4th respondent who attended the same and also gave the consent to take the surveyed extent of 5,000 hectares. It is stated that the petitioner was reliably given to understand that the surveyor belonging to the office of the 2nd respondent has made an observation that the surveyed area of 5,000 hectares in favour of the 4th respondent is overlapping with that of the earlier application dated 28 - 6 - 1995 of m/s. Choice enterprises and the later application dated 12 - 7 - 1995 of the petitioner. It is also submitted that the petitioner - firm was invited for inspection, survey and demarcation of the applied area on 25 - 3 - 1996 by the 2nd respondent. The said inspection, survey and demarcation on the said date was effected and the petitioner gave consent for the surveyed area by way of a letter dated 25 - 3 - 1996 followed by an affidavit dated 24 - 9 - 1996. While so, the petitioner came to understand that the application of the 4th respondent was considered and disposed of by the 1st respondent vide the impugned proceedings. The learned counsel for the petitioner submits that the exercise of discretion with regard to the distribution of area in between the applicants is contrary to the provisions of a. P. Minor mineral concession rules, 1966.
(9) The official respondents have not filed any counter.
(10) In the counter - affidavit filed by the 4th respondent, he denies the allegation that the 2nd respondent while proceeding to gundlasagaram village has conducted the inspection, survey and demarcation and also he is not aware of the application made by the petitioner referred in the affidavit and the joint survey was conducted at any time. It is stated that on 13 - 12 - 1995, the 2nd respondent after issuing notice to the 4th respondent, inspected and surveyed the area applied by it. The 2nd respondent did not survey the area applied and shown by the 4th respondent by saying that northern portion of it falls in reserve forest area for the reasons best known to him, but actually that northern portion is not in reserve forest area. As such, the 4th respondent did not accept and give any consentto the said survey. Further, it is submitted that either the act or the rules do not contemplate any survey before the grant, more particularly by the 2nd respondent and rule 7 of the a. P. Minor mineral concession rules, 1966 reads thus:
"when a quarry lease is granted over an area, arrangement shall be made by the assistant director at the expense of the lessees for the preparation of a plan and the demarcation of the area granted under the lease."
The third respondent is the authority to survey the area and fix the boundaries after the grant. As such, the survey by the 2nd respondent has no legal sanctity and the relief sought for by the petitioner cannot be granted. The survey reports were not given to the 4th respondent. As such, the 4th respondent cannot state whether the reports contain regarding overlapping or other observations. The allegation that the area applied for by the 4th respondent was demarcated and a plan was prepared showing the exact area on the ground by the 2nd respondent for which, the 4th respondent gave consent in writing, is false and incorrect. The alleged said survey has no legal sanctity and not binding on the 4th respondent, as no notice of the said survey was given to the 4th respondent. There is no illegality or irregularity in the impugned proceedings either in grant of quarry lease or consequential execution of the lease deed and issue of work order by the 3rd respondent.
(11) In the reply affidavit to the counter, the petitioner has reiterated about the objections with regard to the survey conducted in favour of the 4th respondent and with regard to rule 7 of the a. P. Minor mineral concession rules, 1966. It is stated that rule 7 is followed only where the lessees opt for reduction of the area granted in their favour. Infact, the concept of prior inspection, survey and demarcation in favour of the applicants is only to avoid controversy and clash of interests, as under the a. P. Minor mineral concession rules, 1966, the lease applications have to be disposed on a first come first serve basis i. E. According to the date of receipt of the applications. Any deviation from the above said administrative practice may give scope for litigation among the applicants. It is submitted that any inspection, survey and demarcation of the applied areas prior to the grant of leases is a healthy practice and may help in avoiding unnecessary litigation which is important for mineral development and public interest.
(12) The thrust of the argument of mr. P. Srinivas, the learned counsel for the petitioner - m/s. Choice enterprises in writ petition no. 16733/1996 is that the impugned order suffers from non - compliance of rule 12 (5) (b) of a. P. Minor mineral concession rules, 1966, as his client's application was filed before the 1st respondent for grant of quarry lease for extraction of cut or dressed blocks of black - granite in an extent of 2,000 hectares in survey gap area of kottalam village, yadamari mandal, chittoor district by application dated 26 - 6 - 1995. The 2nd respondent invited the petitioner for inspection, survey and demarcation of the applied area on 1 - 8 - 1995. It is stated that the petitioner attended and gave its consent for the surveyed area of 2,000 hectares. The 2nd respondent's office called for the report from the mandal revenue officer, yadamari mandal to send a report on the category and availability of areas and 'no objection' certificate and the said mandal revenue officer even granted no objection certificate on 10 - 12 - 1995 in favour of the petitioner - firm. The mandal revenue officer also certified a sketch indicating the area applied for. At that point of time, the petitioner - m/s. Choice enterprises applied to the revenue divisional officer and the mandal revenue officer, yadamari mandal, chittoor district requesting to cancel the no objection certificate issued to the 4th respondent - m/s. Tirumala granites. The revenue divisional officer deferred the said letter, inspected the site and directed the deputy inspector of survey belonging to his office to personally inspect the site and submita report. Accordingly, a report dated 25 - 1 - 1996 was submitted to the revenue divisional officer, chittoor district after verifying the said applied area and in this report, it is stated that the gap area of patrapalli and kottalam villages based on the old survey numbers was existing on the ground at site. On this basis, the mandal revenue officer, yadamari mandal in his proceedings dated 29 - 1 - 1996 issued the revised no objection certificate in favour of the petitioner - m/s. Choice enterprises indicating that the said area lies within the limits of patrapalli revenue village and the 4th respondent has applied for the same area. On the basis of this report, the petitioner - m/s. Choice enterprises filed an application on 26 - 2 - 1996 to the 1st respondent stating that the area applied for by it and the 4th respondent - m/s. Tirumala granites, is one and the same within the gap areaofpatrapalli village panchayat limits. It is prayed to the 1st respondent to consider the application for grant of quarry lease dated 26 - 6 - 1995 as an application for grant of lease for black granite in an extent of 2,000 hectares gap area of patrapalli village, yadamari mandal, chittoor district instead of gap area of kottalam village, yadamari mandal, chittoor district.
(13) Mr. V. Rajagopala reddy appearing for the 4th respondent - tirumala granites, contends that as per rule 12 (5) (c) of a. P. Minormineral concession rules, 1966, the 4th respondent had applied for grant of lease over an extent of 5,000 hectares in survey no. Gap area of 144 of ottivaripalli and patrapalli villages, yadamari mandal, chittoor district for black granite on 10 - 7 - 1995; as such, the application submitted on behalf of the 4th respondent should be treated earlier in point of time over the gap area of ottivaripalli and patrapalli villages, as the petitioner - m/s. Choice enterprises applied for quarry lease originally in kottalam village. The revenue divisional officer had also issued no objection certificate through the mandal revenue officer, yadamari mandal on 16 - 5 - 1995 and on consideration, the 1st respondent granted quarry lease in its favour for black granite in the gap area of patrapalli village, yadamari mandal, chittoor district under the impugned proceedings dated 9 - 8 - 1996 over an extent of 3. 980 hectares which falls in patrapalli village as applied for by the 4th respondent. A lease deed was executed on 14 - 8 - 1996 by the 3rd respondent who also issued work order permitting the 4th respondent for commencing the quarry operations of black granite over an extent of 3. 980 hectares falling in patrapalli village and that an order was issued by the 3rd respondent that necessary orders would be issued for commencing the quarry operations in the remaining area of 1. 02 hectares falling in ottivaripalli village, yadamari mandal, chittoor district soon and that he has already commenced quarry operations in the afternoon of 14 - 8 - 1996. Relying on the date of applications of each of the petitioner - firm and the 4th respondent, he submits that the petitioner - m/s. Choice enterprises' application shall be deemed to have been filed on 26 - 2 - 1996, for on that day, the petitioner requested the 1st respondent to treat the village in the statutory application - form as patrapalli village, yadamari mandal, chittoor district instead of gap area of kottalam village, yadamari mandal. As such, the application ofthe 4th respondent is prior to the date of application of the petitioner - firm.
(14) Mr. C. V. Mohan reddy, appearing for the petitioner - m/s. Manikanta granites in writ petition no. 22142/1996 submits that the petitioner - m/s. Manikanta granites has also applied for grant of lease of cut or dressed block of black granite in an extent of 3,000 hectares in survey gap area of ottivaripalli and patrapalli villages vide its application dated 12 - 7 - 1995. Though his client's application is later to the date of application for the grant of quarry lease of the m/s. Choice enterprises the petitioner in writ petition no. 16733/1996, the survey and demarcation of the area is defective, for both of them have applied for the gap area of ottivaripalli and patrapalli villages and as survey and demarcation were done on different dates in respect of the areas without issuing notice to it and as such, the petitioner - m/s. Manikanta granites is entitled for the remaining area after the area which is allotted to the petitioner - m/s. Choice enterprises in writpetitionno. 16733/1996.
(15) The other contention of mr. P. Srinivas, appearing for the petitioner - m/s. Choice enterprises in writ petition no. 16733/1996 is that the 1st respondent has no jurisdiction to distribute the area when there are two applicants for the quarry lease over the same area and without the prior approval of the government and for any special reasons to be recorded in writing, allotting the area not exceeding the extent of 2,000 hectares falling between the village boundaries tri - junction and bye junction demarcated in favour'of m/s. Choice enterprises and from bye junction towards west, an extent of 5,000 hectares demarcated in favour of the 4th respondent - m/s. Tirumala granites, is contrary to rule 12 (5) (b) of the a. P. Minor mineral concession rules, 1966.
(16) In view of the above submissions, the important question that falls for determination is whether the application for grant of quarry lease of m/s. Choice enterprises is earlier in point of time than the application filed by m/s. Tirumala granites.
(17) In order to appreciate the contentions, it is necessary to see the rules 12 (5) (b) and 12 (5) (c) and the statutory form b - 1 of the a. P. Minor mineral concession rules, 1966 which deal with the regulation and grant of leases for granite, which are to the following effect: 12 (5) (b) :
"the applications for grant of quarry lease for granite shall be disposed of by the director in the order of their receipt. Whenever more than one application are received on the same day, the director with the approval of the government shall grant lease to the deserving applicant on merits to be recorded in writing. Provided that the director may grant quarry lease to an applicant whose application is received later in preference to earlier application with the prior approval of the government for any special reasons to be recorded in writing."
2nd proviso: provided further that the directorxxxxxxx'. 12 (5) (c) :
"applications for grant of quarry leases shall be disposed of by the director. The director shall reject the applications in the event of any default on the part of the applicant for not attending the inspection or survey or submission of mineral revenue clearance certificate or any other material papers as required by the director. The lease deed shall be executed xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx"
(18) rule 12 (5) (b) of the rules specifically states that when there are more than one application received on the same day, they shall be disposed of by the director in the order of their receipt and the director with the approval of the government shall grant lease to the deserving applicant on merits to be recorded in writing.
(19) By reading the above rule, it is clear that the director i. E. The 1 st respondent has to dispose of the applications for grant of quarry lease in the order of receipt. Now the only question is whether the date of application of m/s. Choice enterprises should be considered as 26 - 6 - 1995 or 26 - 2 - 1996. If its date of application is considered as 26 - 6 - 1995, the application of m/s. Choice enterprises is earlier in point of time than that of m/s. Tirumala granites which was filed on 10 - 7 - 1995, but if the date of application of m/s. Choice enterprises is considered from the date of amendment of the application to the change of the village, it is later than that of m/s. Tirumala granites. The application has to be in form b - 1 (see rule 12 (6) (a) and (f) (xiii) wherein against item - 2, it is to the following effect, "2. Description of the area applied for.
(a) situation and as per sketch boundaries: attached
(b) revenue sy. Nos. Kottalam (v) , or block no. G aparea (in case of kottalam (v) , reserve forest) yadamari mandal chittoor dist. (ap)
(c) area 2. 000 hectares. "
As could be seen from item - 2, the particulars of sketch have to be attached.
(20) The learned counsel for the petitioner - m/s. Choice enterprises has not brought to my notice any rule framed under the rules, 1966 wherein an applicant can, after filing the application for grant of quarry lease of the particular village, alter or change the entries in the statutory application - form.
(21) In the absence of any such provision, i hold that m/s. Choice enterprises cannot alter or change the entries in its application. At best, if any change is accepted by the 1 st respondent, it shall be from the date of application (i. E.) dated 26 - 2 - 1996 for asking for amendment or change of the village from kottalam to patrapalli village, yadamari mandal, chittoor district. Viewing as above, the application for grant of quarry lease of m/s. Tirumala granites is earlier in point of time; as such, the petitioner - m/s. Choice enterprises cannot be deemed to be the earlier applicant than that of the 4th respondent - m/s. Tirumala granites.
(22) In the view which i have held above, the contention of mr. P. Srinivas, the learned counsel for m/s. Choice enterprises, has no substance; as such, it is rejected.
(23) He relied on an unreported division bench judgment dated 6th october, 1994 in vajra granites limited v. State of andhra pradesh and others (1) writ appeal nos. 862 and 863 of 1994 wherein their lordships were considering whether the particulars mentioned in the application form should receive strict compliance and the applicants shall not be permitted to depart from what is stated in their applications. At page 22 of the xerox copy of the above judgment. Their lordships have held thus:
"we propose to consider his contention that the particulars mentioned in the applications should receive strict construction and the applicants shall not be permitted to depart from what is stated in their applications. Linked with this contention is the contention of sri m. V. Ramana reddy that the applications of midwest granites is defective and the application of deccan granites alone should have been considered. We are not impressed with any of these contentions for reasons more than one. There is no provision in the rules enabling the authorities to reject the applications on the ground of furnishing incorrect or insufficient information. As already noticed, nobody was sure of the exact location of gangadevi gutta' till the joint inspection was conducted pursuant to the order of this court. In none of the applications filed by vajra granites, it is stated that the quarry lease is sought in respect of gangadevi gutta'. Likewise, deccan granites described the quarry area as survey no. 1034 of ingurthy village, which is obviously incorrect. The assistant geologist and the assistant director of mines and geology, warangal, who inspected the area, have reported that the area applied for by all the applicants is one and the same. The primary authority viz. The deputy director mines and geology, warangal having accepted the said report, proceeded to consider all the applications on merits. The revisional authority viz. Government of a. P. Also proceeded on the same premise and rendered its decision on merits. Having regard to all these facts, we are fully convinced that vajra granites and deccan granites have no case to complain. This finding of ours would also set at rest the rival claim between vajra granites and deccan granites."
(24) In the instant case, it is not disputed before me that the three villages viz. , kottalam, ottivaripalli and patrapalli of yadamari mandal, chittoor district, are different and distinct villages though they are adjoining to each other and the survey no. Gap areas located within the boundary of patrapalli and ottivaripalli villages. As such, there is no doubt with regard to the exact location of the quarrying area as considered in the above division bench judgment of this court. The facts therein are altogether different to the present case; as such, that judgment has no application.
(25) Next, mr. P. Srinivas, learned counsel for m/s. Choice enterprises relied upon the division bench judgment of this court in m/s. Ranjana granites (p) ltd. V. The state of andhra pradesh (2) 1996 (3) alt 121 (d. B.) for the proposition that it is not a consideration to grant quarry lease to the applicant whose application is received later in preference to earlier application on the ground that the applicant is already having a cutting and polishing unit, for in para - 30 at page 131. Their lordships were considering the rules framed by the state government in respect of minor minerals under sub - section 1 section 15 which provides for the state government to make rules for regulating the grant of quarry leases, mining leases or other mineral concessions in respect of minor minerals and for the purposes connected therewith while dealing with the rules, held that there is a mandatory requirement of establishing a cutting and polishing unit within two years or further extended time, lest the lease is liable to be terminated. Further, after establishment of cutting and polishing unit, after polishing the granite a ratio is fixed in exporting the processed granite and raw granite. It is 1:1 and 3:7 in respect of black and colour granite respectively.
(26) From the above para, it is clear that their lordships were not dealing with or interpreting rule 12 (5) (b) of the rules; but merely observed that there is a mandatory requirement of establishing a cutting and polishing unit within 2 years or further extended time, lest the lease is liable to be terminated. In the present case, this decision has no relevance to the facts of the present case, forthe 1st respondent did not grant the lease in favour of m/s. Tirumala granites (r - 4) on the ground that the receipt of application by the director was later in point of time than m/s. Choice enterprises, but also not on the ground that m/s. Tirumala granites (r - 4) has already established the cutting and polishing unit. In the above circumstances, the 1st respondent has granted the lease to m/s. Tirumala granites keeping in view the rule 12 (5) (b) of the rules only but not the second proviso of rule 12 (5) (b).
(27) In view of the findings which i have held in the foregoing paragraphs, there are no merits in the above two writ petitions and accordingly, they are dismissed. No costs.
Alert