Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

K. Sudarshana Chari v. G. Saidulu & Ors.

Andhra Pradesh High Court
Sep 18, 1996
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.

S.Parvatha Rao, J.:-

(1) Notice before admission was directed in this writ petition on 21 - 12 - 1995 and counter - affidavit has been filed on behalf of respondents 2and3.

(2) The petitioner questions the jurisdiction of the 3rd respondent, i. E. , the additional sessions judge at nalgonda to take cognizance of an offence under section 138 of the negotiable instruments act as chief judicial magistrate of nalgonda district.

(3) The facts, in brief, are that the 1st respondent gave a complaint in writing to the 3rd respondent under section 138 of that act stating that the petitioner issued a cheque for rs. 1,25,500/ - on 1 - 2 - 1994 in his favour and that the same was dishonoured when presented in the bank; and that the 3rd respondent took cognizance of the alleged offence and issued summons to him.

(4) The petitioner contends that the 3rd respondent was appointed as the chief judicial magistrate ofnalgonda district by the 2nd respondent, i. E. , the high court of andhra pradesh, in its proceedings in r. O. C. N0. 1354/so/82, dated 21 - 9 - 1982 even though he was not a judicial magistrate of the first class and that under sub - section (1) of section 12ofthe code of criminal procedure, 1973 ('the code' for short) only a judicial magistrate of the first class could be appointed as a chief judicial magistrate and, therefore, the said appointment of the 3rd respondent as the chief judicial magistrate is bad and, in the circumstances, the 3rd respondent could not exercise the powers of a chief judicial magistrate. He also submits that the summons dated 15 - 3 - 1994 issued to him by the 3rd respondent was in fact signed by him as additional sessions judge, nalgonda and not as the chief judicial magistrate, nalgonda. He further submits that even though the proceedings dated 21 - 9 - 1982 of the 2nd respondent, whereunder the 3rd respondent was appointed as chief judicial magistrate of nalgonda district, mentions that

"the additional district and sessions judge in the district head - quarters who is the judicial magistrate of first class in each district where one additional district and sessions judge is functioning in the district head - quarters and the first additional district and sessions judge in the district head - quarters who is the judicial magistrate of first class, in each district where more than one additional district and sessions judge are functioning in the district headquarters as chief judicial magistrates for the respective districts and confers on them all the powers of the chief judicial magistrate under the said code or under any other law for the time being in force"
, there was no proceeding appointing the additional district and sessions judge or the first additional district and sessions judge in a district, as the case may be, as a judicial magistrate of first class and, therefore, a mere recital that they are also judicial magistrates of first class in the districts concerned does not have the effect of appointing them as such under the proceedings of the 2nd respondent dated 21 - 9 - 1982. The learned counsel appearing forthe petitioner contends thatthere should be separate proceedings of the 2nd respondent, earlier to the proceed ings dated 21 - 9 - 1982, appointing them as judicial magistrates of first class under subsection (1) of section 11 of the code.

(5) The case of the petitioner proceeds on an erroneous basis that there was no antecedent separate proceeding appointing the 3rd respondent as judicial magistrate of first class under sub - section (2) of section 11 of the code. In exercise of the powers under sub - section (2) of section 11 of the code, the 2nd respondent in r. O. C. No. 25/so/74 - 1 dated 28 - 3 - 1974 issued notification no. I, which came into force on 1 - 4 - 1974, appointing the following classes of officials of the state to be judicial magistrates of the first class and conferred on them all the powers of a judicial magistrate of first class underthe code or any other law for the time being in force: -

(i) all additional district and sessions judges in the state within their respective sessions division; (ii) all subordinate judges in the state within their respective jurisdiction; and (iii) all district munsifs within their respective munsifies.

In view of this, the appointment of the 3rd respondent as chief judicial magistrate by the 2nd respondent under the proceedings dated 21 - 9 - 1982 cannot be faulted.

(6) As regards the issuance of summons by the 3rd respondentsigning it as additional sessions judge, nalgonda, the learned counsel for the petitioner does not press the same in view of the decision of a division bench of this court in pudapunaidu v. State ofa. P. (1) 1961 (1) crl. L. J. 461. In that case, the additional district and sessions judge, under that designation, issued proceedings purporting to be under section 192 of the criminal procedure code, 1898 ('old code' for short) transferring a p. R. Case from one j. S. C. M. To another j. S. C. M. That was questioned before the high court. Observing that the order ofthe additional district and sessions judge (sri d. Subbarao) contained several errors,, and that instead of mentioning section 528 crl. P. C. , he mentioned section 192 crl. P. C. , and that he was evidently acting under section 528 (2) read with 10 (2) of the old code because by virture of a notification issued by the state government he was also an additional district magistrate, the division bench held as follows:

"then again, the officer has signed the orderas additional district and sessions judge whereas in fact he was making the order in his capacity as additional district magistrate. Greater care and precision in passing the order would have avoided all the confusion and controversy in this case. We are however satisfied that these are all curable irregularities which do not affect the validity of the order if in point of fact sri d. Subbarao had the power to make the order. It is not the form of the order that matters but the power to make the order. This power (under section 528 (2)) as well as any of the other powers of a district magistrate under the criminal procedure code may also be exercised by an additional district magistrate when such powers are conferred on him by the state government under sub - section (2) of section 10 of the code. Sri d. Subba rao held two offices, namely, the office of the additional sessions judge and that of the additional district magistrate, and in the latter capacity he could exercise all the powers exercisable by adistrict magistrate under the criminal procedure code. When, therefore, sri d. Subba rao passed the order in question. , it must be taken that he did so not qua additional sessions district magistrate. In this view he had unquestionably the power to make that order under sub - section (2) of section 528. It is true that the notification reproduced above is defective in form in that it purports to appoint an additional sessions judge as an additional district magistrate whereas section 10 (2) envisages the appointment of a magistrate of the first class to be an additional district magistrate. This, however, does not undermine the legality of the notification as we are satisfied on the material placed before us that long before he was appointed as additional district magistrate and invested with powers under section 10 (2) , sri d. Subba rao had been appointed a magistrate of the first class and had been exercising magisterial powers"
.

(7) In the present case also, the additional district and sessions judge at nalgonda was conferred all the powers of a judicial magistrate of first class under the code by virtue of notification no. I issued by the high court in r. O. C. No. 25/so/74 - 1 dated 28 - 3 - 1974 under section 11 (2) of the code, and, therefore, his appointment as chief judicial magistrate at nalgonda under impugned proceedings dated 21 - 9 - 1982 issued under section 12 (1) of the code is valid. However, we have to observe that the 3rd respondent ought to have been careful and issued summons signing it as 'chief judicial magistrate' at nalgonda instead of 'additional sessions judge, nalgonda. But, that mis - description cannot invalidate the cognizance taken by him in the present case because he had undoubt jurisdiction to take cognizance as additional district magistrate, nalgonda.

(8) We therefore, do not find any merit in this writpetition. It is accordingly dismissed with costs. Advocate fee rs. 500/ - (rupees five hundred only).