- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Jayant Oils & Derivatives Ltd. (S) v. Agriculture Produce Market Committee - Vadodara & 1 (S)
Structured Summary of the Opinion (Per: Honourable the Chief Justice Mr. K.S. Radhakrishnan)
Factual and Procedural Background
Respondent No. 2, Jayant Oils and Derivatives Limited (the Company), operates manufacturing and export units for castor oil and derivatives at GIDC, Makarpura, Vadodara, within the market area of the petitioner Agricultural Produce Market Committee (Market Committee).
The Market Committee issued a demand notice dated 05.03.2008 to the Company seeking Rs. 1,18,65,658/- as market fee and threatened a penalty equal to five times the demanded amount. The Committee maintained that the Company was bound to pay market fee under amended subsection (2)(a) of Section 28 of the Gujarat Agricultural Produce Markets Act, 1963 (the Act). The Company disputed liability by reply dated 08.03.2008 and again on 25.04.2008, asserting that it had not purchased agricultural produce within the market area and therefore no market fee was leviable.
On administrative review, the Revisional Authority relied on a prior Division Bench judgment (Letters Patent Appeal No. 139 of 2006 and connected matters) and Rule 48(2) of the Gujarat Agricultural Produce Markets Rules, 1965 (the Rules), holding that where an industrial concern brings agricultural produce from outside the market area for its own use, no market fee is payable. Consequently, by order dated 30.06.2008, the Revisional Authority quashed the demand notices.
The Market Committee filed the present Special Civil Application (No. 9705 of 2008) challenging the Revisional Authority's order. A Single Judge issued interim conditional directions on 13.11.2008 (part payment and undertaking). The Company challenged that interim order by Letters Patent Appeal No. 1383 of 2009, but by consent the Special Civil Application was posted for final hearing and heard finally by the Bench delivering this opinion.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether subsection (2)(a), added to Section 28 of the Gujarat Agricultural Produce Markets Act, 1963 by the Gujarat Agricultural Produce Markets (Amendment) Act, 2007, has the effect of taking away the substratum of the Division Bench judgment dated 24.04.2007 in Letters Patent Appeal No. 139 of 2006 and connected matters.
- Whether the Market Committee is legally entitled to levy market fee on the Company for castor seeds that were brought from outside the market area into the market area for the Company’s own industrial use, in light of Section 28(1) of the Act read with Rule 48(2) of the Rules and the amendments (including subsection (2)(a) to Section 28).
Arguments of the Parties
Appellant (Market Committee) — Principal Submissions
- The Revisional Authority erred in holding the Company exempt under Rule 48(2) by disregarding the amended provisions of Section 28 of the Act (specifically subsection (2)(a)).
- Rule 48(2) has become redundant or is overridden by the amendment; the Division Bench principle in Letters Patent Appeal No. 139 of 2006 is no longer applicable after the amendment.
- Subsection (2)(a) should be strictly construed to include a buyer who is a processor buying agricultural produce from any market other than the market area and to make such buyer liable to pay market fee unless proof of prior payment in another market is produced.
- Subsections (2)(a), (2)(b) and (2)(c) of Section 28 must be read together to hold that a processor like the Company is bound to pay market fee when produce is brought into the market area for processing.
- Rule 48(2) does not require that the agricultural produce brought from outside must be transported into the market area by the industrial concern itself; the earlier Division Bench interpretation is incorrect for omitting consideration of the Explanation to Rule 48(1).
- Relied on several authorities in support: Doshi Kantilal Ratilal v. State of Gujarat (1994), Government of the Province of Bombay v. Hormusji Manekji (1947 Privy Council), and Visitor, AMU v. K.S. Misra (2007) 8 SCC 593.
Respondent-Company — Principal Submissions
- The Company relied on the Division Bench judgment in Letters Patent Appeal No. 139 of 2006, which interpreted Section 28(1) read with Rule 48(2) to exempt industrial concerns that bring agricultural produce from outside the market area for their own manufacturing use.
- No stay having been granted by the Supreme Court on the Division Bench judgment, that judgment remains binding and applicable.
- The Amendment Act did not alter Section 28(1) or Rule 48(2); the critical question is whether any purchase or sale transaction occurred within the market area — the Company did not buy or sell within the market area.
- The Company produced forms and declarations (Form V and related documentation) to satisfy Rule 48(2) requirements and thus is entitled to exemption from payment of market fee.
- The Revisional Authority correctly quashed the demand notices and denied the Market Committee the right to levy market fee.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Division Bench judgment — Letters Patent Appeal No. 139 of 2006 (and connected matters) | Interpreted Section 28(1) of the Act read with Rule 48(2) of the Rules to hold that industrial concerns that bring agricultural produce from outside the market area for their own use are exempt from market fee (Rule 48(2) uses word "brought"). | The Court agreed with and followed this Division Bench interpretation; the Court found no reason to take a different view and applied that interpretation to quash the Market Committee's demand. |
| Doshi Kantilal Ratilal v. State of Gujarat (1994 (2) GLR 1706) | Relied upon by the Market Committee; the opinion records reliance but does not elaborate the specific principle drawn from it. | The Court noted reliance but did not base its decision on this authority; it upheld the Division Bench approach instead. |
| Government of the Province of Bombay v. Hormusji Manekji (1947 Privy Council 200) | Relied upon by the Market Committee; the opinion records reliance but does not specify the principle applied. | The Court recorded the reliance but did not adopt these authorities as determinative of the present issue; decision rests on statutory interpretation and the Division Bench precedent. |
| Visitor, Aligarh Muslim University v. K.S. Misra ((2007) 8 SCC 593) | Relied upon by the Market Committee; the opinion records reliance but does not set out the particular rule invoked. | The Court noted reliance but did not make this authority central to its resolution; the Court's analysis focused on statutory language and Rule 48(2) and the earlier Division Bench decision. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court's analysis proceeded from textual and contextual interpretation of Section 28 of the Act (both pre-amendment subsection (1) and the amended provisions) read with Rule 48 of the Rules. The reasoning steps, based on the opinion's explicit statements, are as follows:
- The Court accepted the Division Bench's earlier interpretation that subsection (1) of Section 28 applies when agricultural produce is "bought or sold" in the market area — i.e., the section presupposes a purchase or sale transaction within the market area.
- Rule 48(2) uses the word "brought" and expressly states that no fee shall be levied on agricultural produce "brought from outside the market area into the market area for use therein by the industrial concerns situated in the market area" (subject to declaration and certificate in Form V). The Division Bench had relied on that textual difference ("brought" v. "bought") to conclude exemption.
- On the facts, the Company produced evidence (forms, bills, declarations and proof of compliance) indicating that purchase and sale took place outside the market area and that the produce was brought into the market area for industrial use. The Court accepted that the Company complied with Rule 48(2) requirements.
- The Court examined the amendment (Amendment Act No. 17 of 2007) which added subsection (2)(a) to Section 28 and Section 28-A and Section 31-D. The Court held that subsection (2)(a) refers to the market fee specified in subsection (1) and operates in a fact situation where goods are bought or sold in the market area; subsection (2)(a) exempts from a second levy a buyer who has already had the market fee paid in another market, upon prescribed proof.
- Because the Company had not bought or sold any produce within the market area, it did not fall within the category of "buyer" contemplated by subsection (2)(a). Thus subsection (2)(a) does not bring within charge persons who merely brought produce from outside for their own consumption (i.e., there was no purchase in the market area to which subsection (2)(a) would apply).
- The Court further distinguished subsection (2)(b) and (2)(c) of Section 28 as addressing other fact situations (e.g., deposit of market fee when produce is brought in for commercial transaction, sale/resale, export) and observed that the Market Committee's demand did not rely on subsection (2)(b).
- Regarding Sections 28-A and 31-D, the Court observed that Section 28-A confers power on the State Government to exempt from payment of market fee those agricultural produce brought for sale or bought or sold in the market area — which reinforces that the legislative focus for exemption/levy is on sale/purchase in the market area. Section 31-D concerns private markets, e-markets and specific markets established under Section 31-M, which were not applicable here because the Market Committee was not shown to be a private market within the meaning of Section 31-C.
- On this textual and factual basis, and in agreement with the earlier Division Bench, the Court concluded that the Amendment Act did not alter the applicability of Rule 48(2) to cases where produce is brought in from outside for an industrial concern's own use; the Revisional Authority had therefore rightly quashed the demand notices.
Holding and Implications
Holding: The Special Civil Application lacks merit and is dismissed. The Court agreed with the Division Bench judgment in Letters Patent Appeal No. 139 of 2006 and connected matters, held that the amendment (subsection (2)(a) to Section 28) did not change the position under subsection (1) of Section 28 read with Rule 48(2), and concluded that the Revisional Authority rightly quashed the Market Committee's demand notices. The interim relief granted earlier is also vacated and the Rule is discharged.
Direct consequences:
- The demand notices dated 05.03.2008 and 15.04.2008 issued by the Market Committee against Jayant Oils and Derivatives Limited were properly quashed by the Revisional Authority and that decision is upheld.
- The Special Civil Application is dismissed; the Letters Patent Appeal and Civil Application connected to this matter are disposed of accordingly.
- The Court reaffirmed the Division Bench interpretation that industrial concerns bringing agricultural produce from outside the market area for their own consumption and complying with Rule 48(2) are not liable to pay market fees under Section 28(1).
The opinion does not state that it is laying down a novel legal principle distinct from the Division Bench judgment; rather, it follows and reaffirms the earlier Division Bench view and applies it to the present facts.
(Per: HONOURABLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE MR. K.S RADHAKRISHNAN)
The question that has come up for consideration in Special Civil Application No. 9705 of 2008 is ‘whether subsection (2)(a), added to Section 28 of the Gujarat Agricultural Produce Markets Act, 1963 (for short ‘the Act’), vide the Gujarat Agricultural Produce Markets (Amendment) Act, 2007, has the effect of taking away the substratum of the Division Bench judgment dated 24.04.2007 in Letters Patent Appeal No. 139 of 2006 and connected matters’.
Respondent no. 2-Jayant Oils and Derivatives Limited, Vadodara, the appellant herein, is engaged in the business of manufacture and export of castor oils and its derivatives in the Industrial Units at 480-483 at GIDC, Makarpura, Vadodara, within the market area of the petitioner-Agricultural Produce Market Committee, Vadodara, respondent no. 1 herein, within the market area of the petitioner-Market Committee. Respondent-Company was served with a demand notice dated 05.03.2008 by the Market Committee, raising a demand of Rs. 1,18,65,658/- towards market fee and further calling upon the Company to show cause why penalty of sum equal to 5 times of the demanded amount should not be imposed.
Market Committee pointed out that respondent-Company is bound to pay market fee for the market produce brought into the market area as per amended subsection (2)(a) of Section 28 of the Act. Respondent-Company submitted its reply vide letter dated 08.03.2008 stating that they are not bound to pay the market fee, since they have not purchased any agricultural produce from the market area. Market Committee reiterated the demand vide letter dated 15.04.2008, demanding a sum of Rs. 1,18,65,658/- along with penalty thereon of Rs. 5,93,28,290/- for the period from 02.02.2008 to 15.02.2008 The abovementioned letter was replied by respondent-Company vide letter dated 25.04.2008 denying the liability. When the Market Committee took further steps to enforce its demand, respondent-Company submitted before the Revisional Authority that Market Committee has no legal right to demand market fee from respondent-Company, since the issue is already covered by a Division Bench decision of this Court in Letters Patent Appeal No. 139 of 2006 and connected matters. They have stated that the Division Bench clearly laid down the law that once industrial concern is using market produce for its own manufacturing purpose, then no market fee is leviable thereon. It is pointed out that Section 28(1) r.w Rule 48(2) of the Gujarat Agricultural Produce Markets Rules, 1965 (for short ‘the Rules’) would clearly indicate that respondent-Company is not legally obliged to pay any market fee for agricultural produce, which has been brought from outside the market area into the market area for their own consumption.
Market Committee, however, submitted before the Revisional Authority that the Amendment Act would rope in a processor also within the meaning of subsection (2)(a) of Section 28, and since respondent-Company being a processor of the goods within the market area, Market Committee is justified in demanding market fee. Revisional Authority placed considerable reliance on the Division Bench judgment in Letters Patent Appeal No. 139 of 2006 and took the view that if the Concern uses agricultural product as a raw-material, it is exempted from market fee as contemplated in Rule 48(2). Revisional Authority also took the view that Section 28(2)(a) is inapplicable to the case of respondent-Company, since the same is covered by Section 28(1) of the Act. Revisional Authority, therefore, by order dated 30.06.2008, allowed the application filed by respondent-Company and quashed the demand notices dated 05.03.2008 and 15.04.2008
Aggrieved by the said order dated 30.06.2008 of the Revisional Authority, Market Committee has come up before this Court with the present Special Civil Application. Learned Single Judge of this Court passed a conditional order on 13.11.2008, directing respondent-Company to make part-payment of market fee, and to give an undertaking. Challenging the interim order dated 13.11.2008, respondent-Company preferred Letters Patent Appeal No. 1383 of 2009. When Letters Patent Appeal came up for hearing, by consent of the parties, we posted the Special Civil Application itself for final hearing and accordingly the matters were finally heard.
Shri K.G Vakharia, learned Senior Counsel appearing for the Market Committee, submitted that the Revisional Authority committed an error in coming to the conclusion that respondent-Company is entitled for exemption under Rule 48(2) ignoring the amended provisions of Section 28 of the Act. Learned Senior Counsel submitted that the provisions of Rule 48(2) of the Rules have become redundant in view of the amended provisions of Section 28 of the Act. Learned Counsel also submitted that the principle laid down in the Division Bench judgement in Letters Patent Appeal No. 139 of 2006 is no more applicable to the facts of the present case, in view of amendment effected to Section 28 of the Act. Learned Counsel referring to subsection (2)(a) of Section 28 contended that a strict construction of the said provisions, the buyer, who is a processor, and buys agricultural produce from any market other than the market area, is also liable to pay market fee. Learned Counsel submitted that such processor will not be levied market fee, if fees is paid in the market from where the market produce was bought and produces a proof regarding payment of fee. Learned Counsel submitted that Section 28(2)(c) puts an obligation upon the buyer purchasing from other market area to pay market fees to Market Committee, in whose area agriculture produce is brought for the purpose of processing, irrespective of the fact that the event of buying or selling has not taken place in the market area of the Market Committee, where market fee is required to be paid. Learned Counsel submitted that sub-sections (2)(b), (c) and (a) to Section 28 have to be read together, in the event of which, respondent-Company, who is a processor, is bound to pay market fee. Learned Counsel also submitted that interpretation given by Division Bench on Rule 48(2) is also incorrect. It is submitted that Rule 48(2) nowhere prescribes that agriculture produce brought from outside market area has to be by the industrial concern itself. Learned Counsel submitted that Division Bench has omitted to consider Explanation to Rule 48(1). In support of the above proposition, learned Counsel placed reliance on the judgment in Doshi Kantilal Ratilal v. State of Gujarat, 1994 (2) GLR 1706 of this Court, Government of the Province of Bombay v. Hormusji Manekji, 1947 Privy Council 200 and Visitor, AMU v. K.S Misra, (2007) 8 SCC 593.
Shri Mihir Thakore, learned Senior Counsel appearing for the respondent-Company, placed considerable reliance on the Division Bench judgment of this Court in Letters Patent Appeal No. 139 of 2006. It is pointed out that though Special Leave Petition was filed against the judgment, no stay has been granted by the Apex Court, therefore, the judgment still holds good. Learned Counsel further submitted that the Amendment Act has not brought any change to Section 28(1) of the Act and so also to Rule 48(2) of the Rules. Learned Counsel submitted that the only question is whether there is any element of sale or purchase in the market area, so far as respondent-Company is concerned. Respondent-Company has not bought or sold any agricultural produce within the market area, therefore, Market Committee is not entitled to claim any market fee from respondent-Company. Respondent-Company has only brought agricultural produce from outside market area into the market area for its own use and the same, therefore, it is clearly exempted from market fee under Section 48(2) of the Rules, and the judgment of the Division Bench squarely applies to the facts of the present case. Learned Counsel submitted that the Revisional Authority, therefore, rightly held that the Market Committee has no legal right to levy market fee on the respondent-Company.
We find no reason to take a different view from the view expressed in the judgment of the Division Bench in Letters Patent Appeal No. 139 of 2006 and connected matters on the interpretation of Section 28(1) of the Act r.w Rule 48(2) of the Rules. In this connection, it is profitable to reiterate the interpretation given by the earlier Bench of this Court on Section 28(1) of the Act r.w sub-rule (2) of Rule 48:
“8 Section 28 of the Act empowers the Market Committee to levy and collect fees on notified agricultural produce bought or sold in the market area, subject to the provisions of the Rules and at the rate maxima and minima, from time to time prescribed. Thus, the power of the Market Committee to levy prescribed fees is envisaged in the above section. In juxtaposition to the above section, it is necessary to refer to Rule 48 of the Rules, and more particularly Rules 48 and 49, placed in Part VI with heading ‘Fees, Levy and Collections’, pertaining to market fees. Rule 48, sub-rule (1) and the explanation is highlighted by the learned Single Judge and discussion has taken place on the basis of certain material available on record with regard to sale of castor seeds by one Manish Trader of Ahmedabad to the Company and after relying upon Sections 19 to 22 of the Sale of Goods Act, the learned Single Judge found that sale does take place within the market area and, therefore, the Company is liable to pay market fees. However, sub-rule (2) of Rule 48 of Part VI of the Rules clearly prescribes that no fee shall be levied on agricultural produce brought from outside the market area into the market area for use therein by the industrial concerns situated in the market area or for export and, in respect of which declaration has been made and a certificate has been obtained in Form V. Thus, the above sub-rule (2) of Rule 48 nowhere prescribes that agricultural produce brought from outside the area of market committee has to be by the industrial concern itself. The preceding word is ‘brought’ and not ‘bought’. Even the facts of the present case are examined, nowhere it is mentioned that purchase took place within the area of the market committee. In the affidavit-in-reply filed by the Company, it is clearly mentioned that purchase of castor seeds did take place outside the market area and no sale takes place within the market area. Even, weighment, etc. is also done outside the market area and bills are prepared accordingly and, that too, after selection by the representative of the Company. Not only that, but, the Company has produced bills of one Manish Traders at page 109 of Letters Patent Appeal No. 195 of 2006, having numbered as Bill No. 93, dated 3rd May 2004, is clearly indicative of the fact that sale does not take place within the area of Market Committee, Baroda. Besides, the octroi paid to the Baroda Municipal Corporation on the goods, namely, castor seeds imported and produced at page 107 is also suggestive of the fact that sale does not take place within the area of market committee. Even, the Company has produced number of forms prescribed under Rule 48, sub-rule (2) from page 79 to 86, the fact not denied by the Market Committee, which also establishes the case of the Company with sufficient declaration and a certificate that the above-mentioned agricultural produce, namely, castor seeds, has been brought from outside the limits of the market area and brought within the limits of market area for industrial purpose, and for production of castor oil and other by-products. Thus, the Company fully complied with the requirement of Rule 48 of the Rules and is entitled for exemption from payment of market fees. Therefore, exercise undertaken by the learned Single Judge to find out the place of sale, so as to bring the case of the Company under Rule 48, sub-rule (1) of the Rules, is of no help and the finding, on that basis, arrived at by the learned Single Judge, will have to be quashed and set aside in the back-drop of the above discussion and the fact-situation.”
We are of the view that the Amendment Act No. 17 of 2007 has not brought any change in subsection (1) of Section 28 of the Act. Subsection (2)(a) added to Section 28 reads as follows:
“28. (1) xx xx
(2)(a) The market fee specified in sub-sec. (1) shall not be levied for the second time in any market area from the buyer who is a processor, grader, packer, value addition centre or exporter of an agriculture produce and market fee has already been paid on that agricultural produce in any market and the information in this context has been furnished, as prescribed, by the person concerned that the payment of market fee has already been made in other market, provided such proof as may be prescribed is furnished to the Director by the buyer who is doing processing, grading, packing, value addition or export within such period as may be prescribed by the Government.”
Section 28-A was also inserted in the amended Act, which reads as follows:—
“28-A. Power to grant exemption from payment of market fee.— The State Government may, by notification published in the Official Gazette, and subject to such conditions and restrictions, if any, as may be specified therein exempt in whole or part any agricultural produce brought for sale or bought or sold in the market area specified in such notification, from the payment of market fee for such period as may be specified.”
Section 31-D has also some relevance which was also added by the Amending Act, which is also extracted herein below for easy reference:
“31-D. Levy of market fees.— (1) The managing body of the private market, e-market and the markets established under Sec. 31-M shall levy and collect the fees on the agricultural produce referred to in clause (a) of sub-sec. (1) of Sec. 31-C brought or transacted in the private market, e-market and the markets established under Sec. 31M at such rate and in such manner as may be prescribed.
(2) No market fee shall be levied for second time in any market area for agricultural produce on which market fee has been paid in a private market, e-market and the markets established under Sec. 31-M on production of such proof as may be prescribed.
(3) The private market, e-market and the markets established under Sec. 31-M which has collected the fee under sub-sec. (1), shall contribute to the Development Fund established under Sec. 34-L, such percentage of fees in such manner, as may be prescribed.
(4) In case of e-market, the market fee shall be paid by the buyer on the purchase of goods at such rate and in such manner, as may be prescribed. Out of the fees so collected, such percentage of fees as may be prescribed shall be contributed to the Development Fund established under Sec. 34-L.
(5) Where the agricultural produce is purchased directly from the agriculturist, the market fee shall be paid to the market committee constituted under Sec. 11 from whose market area the agricultural produce has been bought and removed.”
The Division Bench has already noticed that sub-section (1) of Section 28 used the expression ‘bought or sold’. Bought means, some agricultural product has to be purchased or bought from the market area. Sold means, some agricultural product has to be sold within the market area. Division Bench has categorically found that respondent-Company has not bought or purchased or sold any agricultural produce within the market area, therefore, there is no question of levy of any market fee from respondent-Company under Section 28(1) of the Act. Further, sub-rule (2) of Rule 48 clearly says that no fees shall be levied on agricultural produce brought from outside market area into market area for use therein by industrial Concerns situated in the market area. In sub-rule (2) of Rule 48, expression used is ‘brought’. Facts clearly indicate that respondent-Company has brought agricultural produce from outside market area into market area. Therefore, reading sub-section (1) of Section 28 with sub-rule (2) of Rule 48, we are clearly of the view that the castor seeds brought by the respondent-Company from outside market area into market area for its own use cannot be subjected to any levy of market fee by the Market Committee. We are, therefore, in agreement with the view expressed by the Division Bench and hence no reference is called for to the Full Bench.
We are also of the view that the Amendment Act, by which sub-section (2)(a) was added to Section 28, would no way rope buyers of agricultural produce brought from outside market area into market area for own consumption. Sub-section (2)(a) specifically refer to market fee specified in sub-section (1). Subsection (1) will apply only in case goods are bought or sold in the market area and in that process, market fee shall not be levied for the second time from a buyer, who has purchased the agricultural produce from the market area. Such a buyer may be a processor, grader, packer, value addition centre or exporter of an agriculture produce. Respondent-Company has not bought anything from the market area, therefore, it is not a buyer within the meaning of sub-section (2)(a) of Section 28 of the Act. Only those buy goods from the market area are exempted from levy of market fee, provided they show a certificate that the product had already been subjected to a levy outside the market area. Sub-section (2)(b) to Section 28 provides a different fact situation, which says that on the agricultural produce brought into market area for commercial transaction or for a processing, market fee shall be deposited by the buyer or processor, as the case may be, in the office of market committee, within fourteen days, but, before sale or resale or processing or export outside the market area, permit issued under clause (e) has not been submitted. Clause (e) says that any agricultural produce shall be removed out of market area only in the manner and in accordance with the permit issued in such form, as may be prescribed. The vehicle carrying agricultural produce shall be accompanied by such proofs as may be prescribed. It is also stated that the purchaser of the agricultural produce must himself remove the agricultural produce from one place to another, without such permit, within such market. Respondent company would not fall under the above category since no goods are bought for sale or resale or export outside the market area.
In the demand notice issued by the Market Committee also there is no case for the Market Committee that the respondent-Company would fall under subsection (2)(b) of Section 28.
Section 28-A deals with the powers of the Government to grant exemption from payment of market fee. Power is conferred by State Government by notification to exempt agricultural produce brought for sale or bought or sold to those agricultural produce brought for sale or bought or sold. If intention was to levy market fee from people who brought agricultural produce from outside the market area into the market area, power also would have been given to the Government to exempt them. Since Legislature never intended to demand or levy market fee for produce brought from outside market area into the market area for own consumption, the question of granting exemption under Section 28-A does not arise. Section 31D deals with private market, e-market and markets established under Section 31M. There is nothing to show that the Market Committee is a private market or e-market. Establishment of private market is referred to in Section 31C. The petitioner-Market Committee is not private market committee within the meaning of Section 31C and therefore Section 31D, as such, would not apply.
Above being the factual and legal situation, we are of the view that the Revisional Authority has rightly interfered with the demand notices issued by the Market Committee. Special Civil Application, therefore, lacks merit and the same is dismissed as also interim relief granted. Rule is discharged.
Since we have dismissed the Special Civil Application, Letters Patent Appeal and Civil Application are disposed of accordingly.
Alert