- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
P. Buchi Reddy And Others v. Ananthula Sudhakar .
Factual and Procedural Background
This appeal arises from a suit filed by the plaintiffs (appellants) seeking permanent injunction restraining the defendant from interfering with their peaceful possession and enjoyment of two open plots situated within Warangal municipal limits. The plaintiffs claimed to have purchased the plots from Rukminibai (PW4) by registered sale deeds dated 9-12-1968 and have been in possession since. The defendant claimed title and possession through a registered sale deed dated 7-1-1977 from K.V. Damodara Rao (DW2), asserting that Rukminibai had no right in the property. The trial court held in favour of the plaintiffs, granting permanent injunction. The defendant appealed, and the lower appellate court reversed the trial court’s judgment, holding the plaintiffs’ suit for mere injunction without declaration of title as not maintainable, and dismissed the suit. The plaintiffs have now preferred this second appeal against the appellate court’s judgment.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the plaintiffs' suit for permanent injunction without seeking declaration of title is maintainable under law?
- Whether the acts and deeds of Damodara Rao (DW2) made the plaintiffs believe that Rukminibai is the ostensible owner of the suit property, thereby attracting the provisions of Section 41 of the Transfer of Property Act, and preventing DW2 from passing a better title to the defendant?
- Whether the alleged oral gift of the suit property in favour of Rukminibai by DW2 towards pasupukumkum is legal, valid, and binding on DW2 despite contravening Section 123 of the Transfer of Property Act?
Arguments of the Parties
Appellants' Arguments
- The lower appellate court erred in holding that the plaintiffs' suit for mere injunction without declaration of title is not maintainable.
- Rukminibai was the ostensible owner, having received the property as an oral gift (pasupukumkum) from her brother Damodara Rao, who attested the sale deeds in favour of the plaintiffs.
- Damodara Rao had no subsisting right to alienate the property to the defendant as he had already gifted it to Rukminibai.
- The plaintiffs were in possession since their purchase and cannot be dispossessed by the defendant who has no better title.
- The lower appellate court wrongly held that oral gifts of immovable property are invalid and failed to appreciate the evidence properly.
Respondent's Arguments
The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Bhuvanesivara Nayak Santoshrai vs. The Special Tahsildar, Land Reforms, Tekkali, Srikakulam District | Validity of oral gift of immovable property as pasupukumkum without registration under Hindu law. | The court held that such oral gifts are valid and do not require registration under Section 123 of the Transfer of Property Act, overruling the lower appellate court's contrary view. |
| Allam Gangadhara Rao vs. Collapalli Ganga Rao | Considered in relation to the legal requirements of gifts and registration. | Referenced in the Bhuvanesivara Nayak case to support the principle that pasupukumkum gifts are not gifts under Section 122 and thus need not be registered. |
| Swaminatha vs. Narayana Swamy | Entitlement to sue for injunction based on possession without declaration of title. | Supported the principle that lawful possession threatened by another justifies a suit for injunction without declaration of rights. |
| Fakir Bai vs. Nagan Lal (Bombay High Court Division Bench) | Maintainability of suit for injunction without proving title, focusing on lawful possession. | Affirmed that proving lawful possession suffices for injunction even if title is not established. |
| M. Kallappa Chetty vs. M. V. Lakshminarayana Rao (Supreme Court) | Grant of injunction based on possession despite failure to establish title. | Confirmed that possession can resist interference from persons with no better title. |
| Chepana Peda Appalaswamy vs. Chepana Appala Naidu and Others | Maintainability of suit for bare injunction without declaration of title. | Supported the view that a suit for injunction alone is maintainable. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court analyzed the evidence regarding ownership, possession, and the nature of the oral gift (pasupukumkum) claimed by the plaintiffs. It found the lower appellate court's rejection of the oral gift as invalid due to lack of registration to be contrary to binding division bench precedent, which held such gifts valid and not requiring registration. The court examined the testimonies of witnesses, including Rukminibai (PW4), Damodara Rao (DW2), and purchasers (PWs 3 and 5), concluding that DW2 had orally gifted the property to PW4, who exercised ownership rights and sold the plots to the plaintiffs with DW2’s knowledge and attestation. The conduct of DW2 created the impression that PW4 was the ostensible owner, attracting Section 41 of the Transfer of Property Act, barring DW2 from asserting a better title against the plaintiffs. The court noted that the plaintiffs were in possession, had municipal mutations and paid property tax, reinforcing their claim. It further held that a suit for injunction without declaration of title is maintainable where possession is established, as per Section 38 of the Specific Relief Act and judicial precedents. Thus, the plaintiffs had a better title and possession than the defendant, entitling them to permanent injunction.
Holding and Implications
The appeal is allowed with costs. The judgment and decree of the lower appellate court in A.S. No. 14 of 1986 are set aside, and the trial court’s judgment and decree in O.S. No. 279 of 1978 are restored.
This decision directly reinstates the plaintiffs’ entitlement to permanent injunction based on their possession and title derived through an oral gift recognized under Hindu law as pasupukumkum. No new precedent beyond the application of existing binding authority was established. The defendant’s claim and possession were held inferior to the plaintiffs’ rights, thereby affirming the principle that possession coupled with ostensible ownership and title, even if based on an oral gift, can sustain an injunction suit without declaration of title.
(1) This appeal by the plaintiffs is preferred against the judgment and decree dated 9 - 12 - 1991 in a. S. No. 14/86 on the file of the additional district judge, warangal, reversing the judgment and decree dated 31 - 5 - 1985 passed in o. S. No. 279/1978 on the file of principal district munsiff, warangal. The parties herein are being referred as they are arrayed in the suit.
(2) The appellants - plaintiffs filed the said suit o. S. No. 279/1978 for the reliefof permanent injunction restraining the defendant from interfering with their peaceful possession and enjoyment of the suit property which consists of open plots bearingno. 13/776/bmeasuring 110 sq. Yards and 13/776/c measuring 187 sq. Yards situated within the municipal limits of warangal. The case of the plaintiffs is that the 1st plaintiff purchased the plot bearing 13/776/b and the 2nd plaintiff purchased the plot 13/776/e from one rukumini bai (p. W. 4) for valid consideration of rs. 600/ - and rs. 1,000/ - respectively under two registered sale deeds exs. A - 1 and a - 2 dated 9 - 12 - 1968 and from the date of purchase the plaintiffs have been in possession and enjoyment of the said plots, that after purchase the said plots have been mutated in their names in the municipal records and that the defendant who has no interest or right in the suit plots is trying to interfere with their possession. Hence the plaintiffs filed the suit for the above said relief. Resisting the claim of the plaintiffs the defendant filed the written statement contending that the averments in the plaint are false that the suit plots belong to k. V. Damodar rao (d. W. 2) and the defendant purchased the same under the registered sale deed (the original of ex. B - 1) dated 7 - 1 - 1977 and he was put in possession of the same and that after purchase he approached municipality for permission for construction of a building and permission was granted and that he obtained a loan by mortgaging the land for construction of the house and that when he started construction the plaintiffs obstructed and that thereafter the plaintiffs filed the suit, and that the suit is not maintainable as the plaintiffs' vendor rukuminibai had no right in the suit property. The trial court settled the following issues for trial: (1) whether the plaintiffs are in exclusive possession of the suit property (house plots) ; (2) whether the defendant has interfered with the possession of the plaintiffs over the suit plots; and (3) whether the plaintiffs are entitled for permanent injunction. During the course of trial p. Ws. 1 to 5 were examined and exs. A - 1 to a - 14 were marked on behalf of the plaintiffs. The defendant examined d. Ws. 1 and 2 and exs. B - 1 to b - 11 were marked on behalf of the defendant, and exs. X - 1 and x - 2 were marked as they were produced by the witness. The 2nd plaintiff and the 1st plaintiff got themselves examined as p. Ws. 1 and 2 respectively. The plaintiffs' vendor rukuminibai was examined as p. W. 4. The defendant got himself examined as d. W. I and his vendor was examined as d. W. 2. On a consideration of the oral and documentary evidence placed before him, the learned district munsiff held on issue number one that the plaintiffs have been in possession and enjoyment of the suit property as purchasers from rukuminibai on the date of the filing of the suit and on issue no. 2 that the defendant had interfered with the possession of the plaintiffs and on issue no. 3 that the plaintiffs are entitled for permanent injunction as prayed for and consequently the plaintiffs' suit was decreed with costs. Aggrieved of that judgment and decree the defendant preferred the appeal a. S. 14/83 to the district court. The learned lower appellate judge on reappraisal of the oral and documentary evidence on record reversed the findings of the trial court. The lower appellate court held that the plaintiffs' suit for mere injunction without seeking declaration of title is not maintainable that it was the defendant who was in possession of the suit plots on the date of the filing of the suit and as such the plaintiffs are not entitled for permanent injunction. Consequently the lower appellate court allowed the appeal with costs and set aside the judgment and decree passed by the trial court and dismissed the suit. Aggrieved by the judgment of the lower appellate court the plaintiffs have come with this second appeal.
(3) Heard the counsel on either side. Learned counsel for the appellants - plaintiffs took me through the impugned judgment and also that of the trial court and the evidence on record.
(4) The learned counsel for the appellants raised the following contentions:
(i) the lower appellate court erred in holding that the plaintiffs' suit for mere injunction without seeking declaration of title is not maintainable; (ii) the plaintiffs' vendor rukminibai was the ostensible owner of the suit property having got the same from her brother damodara rao (d. W. 2) towards pasupukumkum in the year 1960 - 1961 and since then she had been in possession and enjoyment of the same and that the said damodara rao (d. W. 2) made the plaintiffs and others believe that his sister rukminibai had saleable interest in that property and made them to purchase for valid consideration and that he also attested the sale deeds (exs. A - 1 and a - 2) executed by rukminibai in favour of the plaintiffs; (iii) k. V. Damodara rao (d. W. 2) had no subsisting right or interest in the suit property so as to alienate the same in favour of the defendant under the original of ex. B - 1 as he had already gifted the same to his sister rukminibai towards pasupukumkum and thus the defendant gets no title to the suit property; (iv) the plaintiffs were put in possession of the suit property since the date of their purchase under exs. A - 1 and a - 2 and that they cannot be dispossessed by the defendant who had no better title than them; (v) the lower appellate court erred in holding that the oral gift of the suit property by damodara rao in favour of her sister rukminibai is not recognised in law and as such rukminibai gets no title to the suit property; (vi) the lower appellate court failed to appreciate the oral and documentary evidence adduced on behalf of the plaintiffs in proper perspective and came to wrong conclusion that the plaintiffs were not in possession of the suit property and that the plaintiffs' vendor rukminibai had no title to the suit property to alienate the same in favour of the plaintiffs.
(5) The learned counsel for the respondent - defendant, on the other hand,submitted his arguments in support of the impugned judgment of the lower appellate court.
(6) The substantial questions of law involved in this matter are as under:
(i) whether the plaintiffs' suit for permanent injunction without seeking declaration of title is maintainable under law ? (ii) whether the acts and deeds of damodara rao (d. W. 2) made the plaintiffs to believe that rukminibai is the ostensible owner of the suit property and thus made them to purchase the suit property for valid consideration and, therefore, the provisions under section 41 of the transfer of property act are attracted and as such d. W. 2 could not pass on a better title to the defendant under ex. B - 1? (iii) whether the alleged oral gift of the suit property in favour of rukminibai by d. W. 2 towards pasupukumkum is legal, valid and binding on d. W. 2 though effected in contravention of the provisions under section 123 of the transfer of property act?
(7) The plaintiffs filed the suit for bare injunction restraining the defendantand his men from interfering with their peaceful possession and enjoyment of the suit property. The suit property consists of two vacant house plots situated at matwada in warangal town within its municipal limits. The first plot belonging to the first plaintiff bears the municipal number 13/776/b measuring 110 sq. Yards within specific boundaries. The second plot belonging to the second plaintiff bears the municipal number 13/776/c measuring 187 sq. Yards situated adjoining the first plot within specific boundaries. The plaintiffs 1 and 2 purchased these plots from one rukminibai under two registered sale deeds, exs. A - 1 and a - 2, on 9 - 12 - 1968 for a valid consideration of rs. 600/ - and rs. 1,000/ - respectively. It is the case of the plaintiffs that they were put in possession of the suit plots on the date of their purchase and continued to be in possession and enjoyment of the same. The defendant also purchased an open house plot measuring 300 sq. Yards from k. V. Damodara rao (d. W. 2) for a consideration of rs. 5,400/ - on 7 - 1 - 1977 under a registered sale deed - the original of ex. B - 1 within specific boundaries. On the strength of this sale deed in his favour, the defendant tried to dig the foundation for raising construction of a house in the month of may, 1978 and on coming to know of it the plaintiffs filed the suit for permanent injunction restraining the defendant and his men from interfering with their possession and enjoyment of the suit land. Thus, the plaintiffs and the defendant are claiming the suit property, though there is some variation with respect to the boundaries mentioned in the sale deeds of the defendant and that of the plaintiffs. Their claim is with respect to the suit house plots only. The plaintiffs are claiming title and possession from their vendor - rukminibai (p. W. 4) while the defendant is claiming title and possession through his vendor damodara rao (d. W. 2). As could be seen from the registered sale deeds, exs. A - 1, a - 2 and b - 1, the vendors have not mentioned their source of title to the suit property in those documents. It is simply asserted that they are executing the said sale deeds claiming as absolute owners of the same. It is also significant to note that neither the plaintiffs nor the defendant have produced any title deeds of their vendors into court.
(8) Rukminibai the vendor of the plaintiffs, examined as p. W. 4, deposedthat she got title to the suit property by virtue of the gift in her favour towards pasupukumkum by her brother damodara rao (d. W. 2) in the year 1960 - 1961; that it is an oral gift and that she had been in possession and enjoyment of the same since the date of gift in her favour. Damodara rao - the vendor of the defendant examined as d. W. 2 deposed that the suit site forms part of the larger extent of land purchased by him about more than 50 years ago and that he had been in possession and enjoyment of the same. He also denied the suggestion made to him that he gifted the suit property in favour of his sister - rukminibai towards pasupukumkum. The lower appellate court held mat even if the alleged gift by d. W. 2 in favour of his sister - p. W. 4 is true, it is invalid in law as it is not written and registered. In para 8 of its judgment, the lower appellate court observes thus:
"as the gift by a hindu of immovable property worth more than rs. 100/ - has to be compulsorily registered and the judgment already referred above prove that even a gift at the time of marriage by way of pasupukumkum to the daughters either at the time of marriage or after are invalid if there is no written document and it is not registered and oral gift at the time of marriage is invalid. As such, in the eye of law the alleged gift by damodara rao of the vacant land in favour of rukminibai is not registered and as such it is invalid in law and it does not pass title to rukminibai".
This reasoning of the lower appellate court is contrary to the decision of a division bench of this court in bhuvanesivara nayak santoshrai vs. The special tahsildar, land reforms, tekkali, srikakulam district. The first question that was referred to the division bench in that case was
"whether a gift of land made in favour of daughter or sister towards 'pasupukumkum as marriage provision requires to be conveyed by a registered document". The division bench, after elaborately considering the case law on the point including the decision in allam gangadhara rao vs. Collapalli ganga rao2 relied on by the lower appellate court observed in para 5 thus:
"what becomes manifest from the conspectus of above case law is that a daughter under hindu law had at the time of 'manu' a right to share in the father's property along with her brothers. After a considerable passage of time, the ultimate remnant is that a father is under an obligation to maintain her within the meaning of section 3 of the adoptions and maintenance act which includes the reasonable expenses of her marriage and therefore any property movable or immovable, given to her for or at the time of marriage cannot be termed as a 'gift' within the meaning of section 122 of the transfer of property act as the essential ingredients of gift are conspicuous by their absence in this transaction of giving the property to the daughter by way of "pasupu kumkuma" which is both involuntary as well as for consideration. Once the said transaction is taken out of the ambit of section 122 of the transfer of property act, it is not at all obligatory that the said document, if it is in writing, requires any registration within the meaning of section 123 of the transfer of property act and under section 17 of the registration act. In fact, it is quite apparent that the transaction of giving away the property by way of "pasupu kumkuma" could very well be done orally and if any instrument in writing has been brought into existence the same does not require any registration as the said instrument can be used for the proof of transaction by way of evidence".
The learned counsel for the respondent - defendant failed to produce any authority overruling the decision of the division bench or a decision of the supreme court contrary to the view expressed in this decision. Hence, the decision of the division bench is binding on me and therefore it has to be held that if in case the plaintiffs succeed in establishing that d. W. 2 had gifted this property in favour of p. W. 4 orally towards her pasupiikumkum it is valid in law and p. W. 4 gets valid title for the same.
(9) The next aspect to be considered is how far the plaintiffs have establishedthat d. W. 2 orally gifted the suit property in favour of p. W. 4 who is her sister towards pasupukumkum and whether p. W. 4 had exercised the rights of ownership over the property that was gifted to her? p. W. 4 deposed in her examination in - chief thus: "the suit land and other plots of land were givea to me towards "ada bidda pasupukumkuma' by my brother sri k. V. Damodara rao. My brother sri k. V. Damodara rao and myself sold the suit land and plots of land which i got towards 'pasupu kumkuma'. The settlement of sale terms has taken place at warangal as well as at hyderabad. My brother k. V. Damodara rao had no right, title or interest over the plots of land which he gave to me towards 'pasupu kumkuma'. In her cross - examination, p. W. 4 stated that "the open land was given to me tow as is 'pasupu kumkuma' by k. V. Damodara rao. The said open land extended to the boundary line of smt. Tara bayamma's house. I cannot give the extent of the vacant land adjacent to the above said houses. The said vacant land was given to me towards 'pasupu kumkuma' by my brother k. V. Damodara rao. There was no special occasion for that. No land was given to my other sister. They were given other things. The said land was given to me in the year 1960 - 1961 and it is not evidenced by any document. I cannot give the boundaries of land given to me at this point of time". She further stated that she exercised the rights of ownership over the suit land and that she sold away the same to others including the plaintiffs. P. W. 4 further stated in her cross - examination thus:
"i sold the land given to me to the plaintiffs p. Malla reddy, vadala ramachandram and one venu. There is no other vacant land left after the above sale".
P. Ws. 3 and 5 are the purchasers referred to by p. W. 4 with respect to the house - sites under exs. X - 1 and x - 2. Thus, it is clear from the testimony of p. W. 4 that d. W. 2 had orally gifted some vacant site belonging to him to p. W. 4 towards 'pasupu kumkuma' and she alienated the same through the negotiations and settlement of price by d. W. 2 to the plaintiffs, p. W. 3, p. W. 5 and one venu. P. W. S - malla reddy also deposed that he purchased a plot under ex. X - 1 from rukminibai (p. W. 4) and thathe negotiated to purchase of the said land through damodara rao (d. W. 2) and that d. W. 2 also attested the registered sale deed, ex. X - 1. P. W. 3 further stated that before the purchase of plot under ex. X - 1, d. W. 2 informed him that plot belongs to his sister - rukminibai and that she was given that plot by her father. It is also in the evidence of p. W. 3 that he negotiated with d. W. 2 on behalf of the plaintiffs for the purchase of the suit plots and that d. W. 2 arranged for purchase of those plots, that himself and d. W. 2 went to hyderabad and paid the consideration to p. W. 4 and that p. W. 4 and d. W. 2 came to hanumakonda and executed the registered sale deeds, exs. A - 1 and a - 2 in favour of the plaintiffs and that d. W. 2 also attested exs. A - 1 and a - 2 along with him. P. W. S - ramachandram is another purchaser of a house plot from p. W. 4 through d. W. 2. It is in the evidence of p. W. 5 that he purchased about 199 sq. Yards from p. W. 4 through d. W. 2 and that he paid the advance amount to d. W. 2 and he obtained the agreement of sale, ex. X - 2 when he paid the advance of rs. 1,560/ - and that it bears the signature of d. W. 2. He further deposed that subsequently he obtained the registered sale deed and constructed a house on the site purchased by him and that his daughter is residing in that house. The plaintiffs examined as p. Ws. 1 and 2 have also deposed that they purchased the suit lands from rukminibai that they negotiated with d. W. 2 for the settlement of price through p. W. S - malla reddy and that d. W. 2 was also present at the time of execution of sale deeds, exs. A - 1 and a - 2 and identified the parties before the sub - registrar at the time of registration and also attested the documents, exs. A - 1 and a - 2. Thus, according to them, d. W. 2 is fully aware of the suit transaction and it was he who prompted them to purchase the suit land from p. W. 4 giving an impression that rukminibai had saleable interest in the suit properly.
(10) As against this evidence adduced on behalf of the plaintiffs, d. Ws. 1and 2 were examined on behalf of the defendant. The defendant got himself examined as d. W. 1 and he deposed that he purchased 300 sq. Yards of open site from d. W. 2 under the original of ex. B - 1, that he had no knowledge about the alleged oral gift of the suit land by d. W. 2 in favour of p. W. 4. He denied the suggestion about the said oral gift. Moreover, it is an admitted fact that the defendant's mother is the sister of the wife of d. W. 2. Thus, both of them are closely related. Now, i will refer to the evidence of d. W. 2. He deposed that the municipal number 13/775 relates to his house and municipal number 13/776 relates to open site; that he purchased open site about 50 years ago from housala brahmayya and later on he constructed the house bearing number 13/775; that he gifted some portion of his house and house - site to his brother - muralidhar; that brother - muralidhar is no more and that the sons of his brother are alive. The crucial admissions made by d. W. 2 in his cross - examination are that ramachandra (p. W. 5) , malla reddy (p. W. 3) and one venu have purchased house - sites from out of the vacant land bearing number 13/776 and that p. W. 5 and venu constructed houses over those sites and he claims that he did not know from whom they purchased those house plots. But he admits that he gave open sites which were purchased by p. Ws. 3, 5 and venu to his brother - muralidhar and that he does not know who had sold those plots to them. D. W. 2 also denied the suggestion made to him that this vacant site bearing number 13/776 was orally gifted by him to p. W. 4 and that he sold the said sites to the plaintiffs, p. Ws. 3,5 and venu. He also denied the suggestion that he attested exs. A - 1, a - 2, x - l and x - 2. He claims that he cannot sign in english and that only he signs in telugu as 'k. V. Damodar'. He also admits that he signed in the original of ex. B - 1 as 'k. V. Damodar rao' and not as 'k. V. Damodar'. It is common knowledge that men may lie to suit their convenience but the established facts and circumstances when and properly analysed will never lie. In the instant case, to suit his convenience d. W. 2 is disputing his own signature as attestor in exs. A - 1, a - 2, x - 1 and x - 2. The attestation of these documents by d. W. 2 has been spoken to by the plaintiffs (p. Ws. 1 and 2) , p. Ws. 3 and 5. P. Ws. 3 and 5 are independent witnesses and there is no reason for them to speak falsehood against d. W. 2. P. W. 4 is his own sister and there is no reason for her to depose falsely against d. W. 2. It is in the positive evidence of p. Ws. 3, 4 and 5 that d. W. 2 attested these documents at the time of execution by p. W. 4. He also figured as identifying witness at the time of execution of the documents, exs. A - 1, a - 2, x - l and x - 2 before the registering authorities. Further, if the contention of d. W. 2 that he gave the open site bearing number 13/776 to his brother - muralidhar, it is not known how p. W. 4 could sell the said open site in favour of p. Ws. 3,5 and one venu. D. W. 2 admits that p. W. 5 and venu have already constructed their houses over the said site. It is obvious that to suit his convenience d. W. 2 is exhibiting ignorance with regard to the person who executed those sale deeds in favour of p. Ws. 3, 5 and venu and he also deliberately telling a lie that he did not attest the documents exs. A - 1, a - 2,x - 1 and x - 2.
(11) Further, it is also in the evidence of p. Ws. 1 to 5 that it was throughd. W. 2 they negotiated for the purchase of the sites under exs. A - 1, a - 2, x - 1 and x - 2 from p. W. 4. Admittedly, d. W. 2 resides at warangal while his sister - p. W. 4 resides at hyderabad. It is in the evidence of p. W. 3 that himself and d. W. 2 came over to hyderabad and negotiated with p. W. 4 in her house for the purchase of the suit site and also the site under ex. X - 1. P. W. 5 also stated that he negotiated for the purchase of these sites under ex. X - 2 through d. W. 2 and he paid the advance amount also to d. W. 2 after obtaining his signature under ex. X - 2. It is clear from the evidence of these witnesses that d. W. 2 projected p. W. 4 as ostensible owner having saleable interest in the suit property and made the plaintiffs and others to purchase the open site for valid consideration from p. W. 4. It is only with the consent of d. W. 2 the plaintiffs have purchased the suit sites for valid consideration. Thus, the conduct and acts of d. W. 2 in finalising the suit transaction by negotiating with p. W. 4 in favour of the plaintiffs attracts the provisions under section 41 of the transfer of property act. As such, it is not open for him now to contend that the transferor i. E. , p. W. 4 is not the owner and he himself is the owner of the suit property. All the ingredients of section 41 of the transfer of property act have been satisfied in this case. D. W. 2 himself had created an impression in the minds of the purchasers including the plaintiffs, p. Ws. 3 and 5 that the transferor - p. W. 4 is the ostensible owner of the site by giving his consent for the said transfers. Therefore, it is not open for d. W. 2 now to contend that p. W. 4 was not the ostensible owner and that she was not entitled to sell the same to the plaintiffs. P. W. 4 had exercised the rights of ownership over the disputed site by alienating the same and that she became such a owner by virtue of the oral gift effected by d. W. 2 in her favour towards pasupu kumkuma. Thus, d. W. 2 had no existing rights over the site sold in favour of the defendant under the original of ex. B - 1 on 7 - 1 - 1977 as he had already gifted the same to p. W. 4 in the year 1960 - 1961 and the plaintiffs got the title by virtue of the sale in their favour under exs. A - 1 and a - 2 from p. W. 4 who was the ostensible owner of the same. Thus, the defendant has no better title than the plaintiffs over the suit property.
(12) Admittedly, the suit plots are vacant. It is in the evidence of p. Ws. 1and 2 that those plots have been mutated in their names in the municipal records by virtue of the sales in their favour under exs. A - 1 and a - 2. They have also paid property tax with respect to those house plots. Exs. A - 3 to a - ll are the property tax receipts standing in the name of the plaintiffs. It is no doubt true that they are of the year 1978 subsequent to the execution of ex. B - 1 in favour of the defendant. On behalf of the defendant also exs. B - 2 to b - ll were marked. Under ex. B - 2 the defendant seems to have mortgaged the suit land in favour of the government when he obtained loan for construction of a house. Under exs. B - 3 he obtained permission from municipality for construction of the house and ex. B - 4 is the plan attached to ex. B - 3. The defendant also relied on exs. B - 6 to b - ll the receipts for payment of property - tax issued in the name of d. W. 2. They have been issued with respect to municipal numbers 13/775 and 13/776. It is not in dispute that d. W. 2 is the owner of house bearing municipal number 13/775 and he also possesses some vacant site in municipal number 13/776. Therefore, these documents, exs. B - 6 to b - ll do not in any way help to establish possession of d. W. 2 with respect to the suit sites. Admittedly, as earlier stated, the suit sites are vacant plots and the plaintiffs purchased the same from the rightful owner p. W. 4 and as such they get a valid title. When the plaintiffs have established their title for the vacant site, possession is presumed with them on the principle that possession follows title. Therefore, it follows that the plaintiffs were in possession of the suit property on the date of filing of the suit by virtue of the title deeds, exs. A - 1 and a - 2. As such, the plaintiffs are entitled for the relief of injunction as prayed for in their suit.
(13) There is also no substance in the contention raised by the learnedcounsel for the respondent that the plaintiffs' suit is not maintainable without seeking for declaration of title. The learned counsel for the respondent also contends that the defendant disputed the title of the plaintiffs with respect to the suit land and in spite of such denial of title, the plaintifs did not choose to get the plaint amended seeking declaration of title. It is not the law that the plaintiff should get his plaint amended as soon as the plaintiff's title is disputed in the written statement filed on behalf of the defendant in a suit for injunction filed under section 38 of the specific relief act. It is well settled that in a suit for injunction the primary question to be considered is one of possession on the date of filing of the suit. Of course, the question of title also may be gone into incidentally. It is also well settled that a person in possession, though without title, can resist interference from another who has no better title than himself and get injunction. Section 38 of the specific relief act, 1963 deals with the grant of perpetual injunction. Under sub - section (3) of section 38 a perpetual injunction may be granted to the plaintiff when the defendant invades or threatens to invade the plaintiff's right to or enjoyment of property where the invasion is such that compensation in money would not afford adequate relief and where the injunction is necessary to prevent multiplicity of judicial proceedings. In swaminatha vs. Narayana swamy it is held that where the allegations of the plaintiff are that he is in lawful possession of the properties and that his possession is threatened to be interfered by the defendant, plaintiff is entitled to sue for a mere injunction without adding prayer for declaration of his rights. A division bench of bombay high court in fakir bai vs. Nagan lal held that it is not necessary for the person claiming injunction to prove his title to the suit land and that it would suffice if he proves that he was in lawful possession of the same and his possession was invaded or threatened to be invaded by a person who had no title whatsoever. In m. Kallappa chetty vs. M. V. Lakshminarayana rao the apex court also held that the plaintiff can on the strength of his possession resist interference from the persons who had no better title than himself to the suit property. In that case, the apex court having found that the plaintiff failed to establish his title to the suit property but the plaintiff was found to be in possession on the date of filing of the suit granted injunction in favour of the plaintiff. In chepana peda appalaswamy vs. Chepana appala naidu and others my learned brother c. V. N. Sastri, j. Also took the same view that a suit for bare injunction without a prayer for declaration of title is maintainable.
(14) In this context, it may be necessary to refer to the provisions undersection 38 of the specific relief act, 1963, which deals with declaratory decrees. Under section 34 of the said act a mere suit for declaration does not lie when the consequential relief like injunction is available. But under section 38 the relief of injunction can be granted even if no declaratory relief is expressly prayed for. Therefore, on a reading of these two sections it is clear that a suit for bare injunction is maintainable without a prayer for declaration of title.
(15) In the light of my above discussion, the impugned judgment of thelower appellate court in a. S. No. 14 of 1986 is liable to be set aside and the appeal has to be allowed.
(16) In the result, the appeal is allowed with costs. The judgment and decreein a. S. No. 14 of 1986 under appeal are set aside. The judgment and decree of the trial court in o. S. No. 279 of 1978 are restored.
Alert