Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Jagdishchandra Chandulal Shah v. State Of Gujarat And Others

Gujarat High Court
Aug 26, 1988
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Judicial Opinion Summary — B.S. Kapadia, J.

Factual and Procedural Background

The petition challenges an order dated 4-9-1986 of the learned Metropolitan Magistrate, Court No. 5, Ahmedabad, made on an application in Criminal Case No. 1793/83. The petitioner is the original complainant who filed a criminal complaint against opponents Nos. 2 and 3 (originally the accused) under Section 420 read with Section 34 and/or Section 109 of the Indian Penal Code, alleging that the accused had previously sold disputed land to one Mahobatsing Mansing Jadeja and had suppressed that fact while inducing the complainant to part with Rs. 72,500.

During the criminal proceedings the complainant sought to produce 14 documents; the Magistrate allowed production generally but dismissed the application as to documents at serial numbers 4, 6, 9 and 12 on the ground that they were not public documents and their contents therefore could not be proved by certified copies. On the present petition counsel for the complainant (Mr. A.D. Shah) pressed only for the admission of documents at Sr. Nos. 6 and 9. Document No. 6 is a certified copy of a sale-deed dated 19-12-1970 in favour of Mahobatsing Mansing Jadeja. Document No. 9 is a certified copy of the plaint in Civil Suit No. 22/82 filed by the complainant dated 6-1-1982.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the certified copies of the sale-deed (document at Sr. No. 6) and the plaint (document at Sr. No. 9) are "public documents" within the meaning of Section 74 of the Evidence Act and thus admissible in evidence by certified copy under Section 77 of the Evidence Act.
  2. Whether certified copies of such documents can be produced as secondary evidence of their contents under Sections 61–65 and Section 77 of the Evidence Act, and what limitations apply (in particular regarding proof of execution/signature).
  3. Whether the Magistrate erred in dismissing the application to exhibit documents at Sr. Nos. 6 and 9 on the ground that they were not public documents.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments (as presented in the opinion)

  • Only documents at Sr. Nos. 6 and 9 were pressed before the High Court for admission.
  • Counsel for the petitioner contended that the certified copies of documents 6 and 9 fall within the category of public documents and their contents can therefore be proved by producing certified copies under Section 77 of the Evidence Act.
  • The submission invoked provisions of the Evidence Act (Sections 61–65, 74 and 77) to show that where public records of private documents are kept by the State those records become public documents and certified copies are admissible to prove contents.
  • Reliance was placed on authorities (discussed below) that returns filed with public officers and registration records become public records for these purposes; specific reliance was placed on a Calcutta High Court decision (Tarit Kanti Biswas) supporting that position.
  • With respect to the sale-deed (Sr. No. 6), reliance was also placed on statutes under the Registration Act (Sections 17, 51, 52 and 57) showing that registration books and certified copies kept by the registering officer are admissible to prove contents.

The opinion does not set out any detailed contrary arguments by the respondents/opponents.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Tarit Kanti Biswas, Printer and Publisher of the "Amrita Bazar Patrika" and others (Calcutta High Court), 19 Criminal Law Journal 530 That returns lodged with a public officer (e.g., under Companies legislation) when filed by that officer constitute public records of private documents within subsection (2) of Section 74 of the Evidence Act; discussion of the meaning of "record" and the consequence that such filings are intended for public reference. The court relied on the case to support the proposition that documents which are private in origin can, by being kept as public records by a public officer, become public documents admissible by certified copy; used to support admissibility of documents kept in official records.
Vithoba Savlaram v. Shrihari Narayan, A.I.R. 1945 Bombay 319 That mortgage deeds are public documents under Section 74 where public records of mortgages are kept; Section 65 permits secondary evidence when the original is a public document; Section 77 permits certified copies to be produced to prove contents. Also, certified copies authenticate the copy but do not prove the actual execution of the original document; statutory presumption under Section 90 applies only when the actual original is produced. The court relied on these observations to emphasise that certified copies of registered documents can prove contents but cannot by themselves prove execution/signature; the principle limited the effect of admitting certified copies to proof of contents only.
Mohmed Sahabudin v. Vadgeberry, reported in 10 B.L.R. (appeal) 31 That a plaint forming part of court record is a public document for the purposes of the Evidence Act. The court relied on this authority to treat the certified copy of the plaint (document at Sr. No. 9) as a public document admissible to prove its contents.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court undertook a statutory and textual analysis of the relevant provisions of the Evidence Act and the Registration Act to determine whether the certified copies at issue were admissible.

  1. The court began with Chapter V of the Evidence Act (Sections 61–65) explaining the distinction between primary evidence (the original document: Section 62) and secondary evidence (including certified copies: Sections 63 and 65). Section 77 permits certified copies to be produced in proof of the contents of public documents.
  2. The court analysed Section 74 (and subsection (2)) of the Evidence Act: a document originally private in character may nonetheless be a “public document” if public records thereof are kept by the State. The court clarified that the public-record character derives from the fact of official custody and the function of the records, not from any change in the intrinsic private nature of the original document.
  3. Applying that principle, the court explained that where public records of private documents are kept (for example, registration entries made under the Registration Act), certified copies of those records are public documents admissible under Section 77 to prove contents.
  4. Turning to the Registration Act, the court examined Sections 17, 51, 52 and 57. Section 17 requires registration of sale of immovable property over Rs. 100. Section 51 prescribes the registers to be kept in registration offices; Section 52 requires entries to be copied in the appropriate book; and Section 57(5) provides that copies given under that section shall be signed and sealed by the registering officer and shall be admissible to prove contents of the original documents. The court concluded that a certified copy of the sale-deed kept pursuant to these provisions is a public document for the purpose of proving contents.
  5. On the law of authorities, the court relied on the Calcutta High Court decision in Tarit Kanti Biswas to support the interpretation that statutory filings/returns or registers kept by public officers may amount to public records of private documents. The Bombay High Court decision in Vithoba Savlaram was used to emphasise the scope and limits of admitting certified copies: while certified copies authenticate the copy and allow proof of contents, they do not in themselves prove the actual execution of the original document; statutory presumptions (e.g., under Section 90) apply only when the actual original is produced.
  6. For the plaint (Sr. No. 9), the court applied Mohmed Sahabudin v. Vadgeberry to hold that a plaint forming part of court records is a public document; consequently a certified copy of the plaint is admissible to prove its contents.
  7. The court therefore concluded that the learned Metropolitan Magistrate erred in holding that documents at Sr. Nos. 6 and 9 were not public documents and in dismissing the application to exhibit them. However, the court qualified its conclusion by noting that admissibility as public documents relates to proving contents; whenever the question of execution or signature arises, those aspects must be proved according to law (i.e., certified copy does not replace proof of execution).

Holding and Implications

Core Ruling: The order of the learned Metropolitan Magistrate dated 4-9-1986 in Criminal Case No. 1793 of 1983 is quashed and set aside insofar as it refused to admit the documents at Sr. Nos. 6 and 9; the learned Magistrate is directed to treat those documents as admissible for the purpose of proving their contents. The Rule is made absolute to that extent.

Implications:

  • The immediate practical consequence is that the certified copy of the sale-deed (Sr. No. 6) and the certified copy of the plaint (Sr. No. 9) must be treated as admissible evidence of their contents in the criminal proceedings before the Magistrate.
  • The court expressly limited the admissibility to proof of contents: any question of the actual execution or signature on the original documents remains subject to the ordinary rules of proof and must be established independently (the certified copy does not prove execution).
  • The opinion applies established statutory interpretation of the Evidence Act and the Registration Act and relies on existing precedents to resolve the admissibility issue; the decision remedies the Magistrate's refusal but does not announce a novel or broader precedent beyond applying those principles to the documents in issue.

Rule made absolute to the extent indicated in the decision.

Show all summary ...

B.S Kapadia, J.:— The present petition is directed against the order passed by the learned Metropolition Magistrate, Court No. 5 at Ahmedabad on 4-9-86 on application filed in Criminal Case No. 1793/83.

2. In nutshell it may be stated that the petitioner, who is the original complainant has filed the complaint in the court of learned Metropolitan Magistrate, Court No. 5, Ahmedabad, against the opponents No. 2 and 3 (original accused) for the offences under Section 420 read with Section 34 and/or Section 109 of the I.P.C and the said complaint was registered as Criminal Case No. 1793/83. It is alleged that the accused. Nos. 1 and 2 who are present opponents Nos. 2 and 3 had previously sold land to one Mahobatsing Mansing Jadeja by a registered sale-deed and they suppressed this material fact from the present petitioner original complainant had induced the eomplainant to part with the amount of Rs. 72,500/-. During the course of the proceedings an application was preferred for producing certain documents and for exhibiting the same if the other side, i.e the accused have no objection. The said application was filed by the original complainant. Along with the said application he has produced 14 documents as described therein. Before the learned Magistrate the dispute was with regard to exhibiting of documents at Sr. Nos. 4, 6, 9 and 12. The learned Magistrate by his ordered dated 4-9-86 dismissed the said application in respect of the aforesaid four documents on the ground that they are not public documents and therefore, the contents thereof cannot be proved by the certified copies thereof.

3. At the time of hearing Mr. A.D Shah, learned Advocate for the petitioner has pressed his application only for the documents at Sr. Nos. 6 and 9. So for as the document at Sr. No. 6 is concerned, it is the certified copy of the sale-deed of the disputed land executed in favour of Mahobatsing Mansing Jadeja on 19-12-1970. The document at Sr. No. 9 is the certified copy of the plaint in Civil Suit No. 22/82 filed by the complainant against said Mahobatsing Mansing Jadeja and it is dated 6-1-1982.

4. Mr. A.D Shah further submits that the certified copies of the said two documents, i.e documents at Sr. Nos. 6 and 9 are admissible in evidence as they foil within the categary of public documents and contents thereof can be proved under Section 77 of the Evidence Act by producing certified copies thereof.

5. It may be stated that so far as the proving of the contents of the documents is concerned, it is provided in Chapter-V of the Evidence Act. Section 61 of the Evidence Act provides that contents of the documents may be proved either by primary or secondary evidence. Section 62 of the Evidence Act defines what is ‘primary evidence’. Primary Evidence means the document itself produced for the inspection of the court. The definition of ‘secondary evidence’ inter alia includes the certified copies given under the provisions contained in the said Act. Section 63 of the said Act also provides that secondary evidence may be given of the existing condition or contents of document in the cases enumerated therein inter alia when the original document is a public document within the meaning of Section 74 of the said Act and when the original is a document of which a certified copy is permitted by this Act or by any other law in force in India to be given in evidence. So, secondary evidence in respect of a document can be given by certified copy of the document inter alia in cases enumerated in clauses (e) and (f) of Section 65 of the said Act, and in cases falling under clauses (e) and (f) of Section 65 of the Aet the certified copy of the document and no other kind of secondary evidence is permissible. Section 74 of the said Act specifies the documents which are ‘public documents’ and sub-section (2) of Section 74 provides that public records kept in State of private documents are public documents. Private documents are defined as those documents which are not felling within the category of public documents. Section 77 of the said Act provides that such certified copies may be produced in proof of the contents of the public document or parts of public documents or which they purport to be copies.

6. From the above provisions of the Evidence Act it is dear that there might be private documents but if public records thereof are kept in any State then such public records of the private documents would be public documents and, therefore, certified copies of such documents can also be produced in proof of the contents of the private documents of which public records are kept. Initially such documents might be private documents and such private documents never change the character as private documents, but if public records thereof are kept then such public records of such private documents kept by the State would be public documents and therefore, though they might be copies of private documents kept in the public record, they would be public documents and hence the contents thereof can be proved by producing certified copies thereof.

7. In support of his submission Mr. A.D Shah has relied on the judgment of the Calcutta High Court in the case of Tarit Kanti Biswas, Printer and Publisher of the “Amrita Bazar Patrika” and others, reported in 19-Criminal Law Journal 530. In the said case it was contended that as regards Mrinal Ghose and Golap Lal Ghose there is no proof that they are directors, notwithstanding that their co-director and secretary have sworn that they are, and they have themselves declined to give any information on any point to the Court. The said argument was based on the contention that certified copy of the summary filed on the 9th May 1917 of share capital and shares, etc as they stood on 5th March 1917 purporting to be signed by Golap Lal Ghose as financial manager, was not admissible. Thereafter there is discussion about the word “record” occurring in sub-section (2) of Section 74. Similar observations are also made on page 584 of the said judgment. After referring to the Oxford Dictionary meaning of the word “record” which includes collection of documents it is observed that when as in the case of the Indian Companies Act, the Legislature has provided that returns are to be lodged with a public officer, these returns, when transmitted to and filed by him, do constitute public records of private documents within the meaning of sub-section 2 of Section 74 although they are not copied out by the Registrar of Joint Stock Companies into a volume kept for the purpose; they are undoubtedly intended for reference and use by the public.

8. In the said case it was further observed that the second exception is well-founded; for although secondary evidence may be admissible, the party who produces the evidence is not relieved of his obligation to prove the execution of the document just as if the original had been produced, unless the case is covered by Section 90 of the Indian Evidence Act.

9. Similar observations are made in respect of mortgage documents by the Bombay High Court in the case of Vithoba Savlaram v. Shrihari Narayan, A.I.R (32) 1945 Bombay 319. In the said case it is observed that mortgage deed is, under Section 74 of the Evidence Act, a public document because public records of mortgages are kept in British India, and under Section 65 secondary evidence can be given when the original is a public document; and under Section 77 certified copies may be produced in proof of the contents of public documents. Therefore, by producing a certified copy the contents of the mortgage deed can be proved. As the original document was more than thirty years old the question of statutory presumption under Section 90 arose and it was observed in the said case by Chagla, J. (as he then was) that the statutory presumption under Section 90 can be raised only with regard to the actual document produced in the Court. No presumption under Section 90 can be raised with regard to the original document by the production of a certified copy of the same when the original document is not before the court. In the said case it is further observed that all that the Evidence Act does is that it permits secondary evidence to be given of a registered document because it is a public document within the meaning of Section 74, and under Section 74 it provides that certified copies may be produced in proof of the contents of the public documents. All that a certified copy does is that it authenticates the genuineness of the copy. The Court presumes that the original document had the same contents as the copy. It certainly does not prove the actual execution of the original document. It is, therefore, held that the actual execution of the mortgage deed was not proved by the secondary evidence that was tendered by the plaintiff in the courts below.

10. Further, it may be mentioned that Section 17 of the Registration Act inter alia provides that when there is any document of sale of immoveable property for the value of more than Rs. 100/- it requires compulsory registration. Section 51 of the Registration Act provides that the following books shall be kept in the several offices:

A-in all registration offices:—

Book 1 “Register of non-testamentary documents relating to immovable property”:

Book 2 “Record of reasons for refusal to register”

Book 3 “Register of wills and authorities to adopt”, and

Book 4 “Miscellaneous Register”

Section 52 of the Registration Act provides for duties of the registering officer when the document is presented for registration. Section 52 also inter alia provides that subject to the provisions of Section 62 every document admitted to registration shall without unnecessary delay be copies in the book appropriated therefor according to the order of its admission. Section 57 of the Registration Act provides that the books No. 1 and 2 and the index relating thereto relating to Book No. 1 shall be not at all times open to inspection by any person applying to inspect the same and subject to provisions of Section 62 copies of entries in such books shall be given to all persons applying for such copies. Sub-section (5) of Section 57 provides that all copies given under this section shall be signed and sealed by the registering officer, and shall be admissible for the purpose of proving the contents of the original documents. When that is the legal position the document at Sr. No. 6 which is the certified copy of the sale-deed in inspect of the disputed and would be a “public document” and therefore, admissible for the purpose of proving the contents of the original document. However, it is clarified that whenever the question of execution of same arises it will be required to be proved according to law.

11. So far as the document at Sr. No. 9 is concerned, it is the certified copy of the plaint filed against Mahobatsing Mansingh Jadeja by the complainant and it is a public document as it forms part of the record, as held by the High Court in the case of Mohmed Sahabudin v. Vadgeberry reported in 10 B.L.R (appeal) and 31 and therefore, that is also admissible in evidence for the purpose of proving the contents thereof. However, when the question arises with regard to the signature thereon, it will be required to be proved in the same manner in which execution of the document is to be proved. In view of the aforesaid reasons the order passed by the learned Metropolitan Magistrate, Court No. 5 at Ahmedabad on 4-9-1986 in Criminal Case No. 1793 of 1983 in respect of the documents at Sr. Nos. 6 and 9 deserves to be quashed and set aside and is hereby quashed and set aside. The learned Magistrate is directed to treat the said documents as admissible for the purpose of proving the contents thereof. Rule is accordingly made absolute to the aforesaid extent only.

12. Rule made absolute to the extent indicated.