Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Smt. Sudha Chhipa And Ors. v. State Of M.P & Ors.

Madhya Pradesh High Court
Jan 13, 2014
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioners initially filed WP No. 1650/2000 seeking a direction to the respondents to extend the benefits of pay scale as per the 5th Pay Commission. This petition was disposed of on 1.12.2004 with a direction that the respondents extend the benefits within six months. However, the benefits were granted belatedly on 27.8.2012. The petitioners now seek interest on the delayed payment beyond the stipulated six-month period.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the petitioners are entitled to interest on the delayed payment of pay scale benefits beyond the six months period prescribed by the Court's earlier order.
  2. Whether the principle of constructive res judicata bars the petitioners from claiming interest in the present petition when it was not claimed in the original writ petition.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' Arguments

  • The earlier writ petition directed the respondents to extend pay scale benefits within six months, but the benefits were granted only after a delay of nearly eight years.
  • The delayed payment should attract interest for the period beyond the six months from the date of the original order.

Respondents' Arguments

  • The petitioners could have claimed interest in the original writ petition but did not do so.
  • Claiming interest now is barred by the principle of constructive res judicata.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Suresh Kumar Dwivedi v. State of M.P., 1994 JLJ 73 Employees of non-government colleges are entitled to the same pay scale as corresponding government college employees; judgment in rem. The Court applied this ratio to direct extension of pay scale benefits and held the respondents liable to implement within six months.
Ashok Kumar Gupta v. State of M.P. Confirmed the principle of entitlement to pay scale benefits as per Suresh Kumar Dwivedi judgment. Reinforced the basis for the relief granted in the original writ petition.
Union of India v. Justice S.S. Sandhawala (Retd.), (1994) 2 SCC 240 Belated payment of amounts illegally withheld should carry interest. Supported the principle that delayed payments must attract interest when illegally withheld.
Union of India and Anr. v. M.S. Abdulla, (2006) 6 SCC 455 Reiterated the principle that illegally withheld dues must carry interest. Applied to affirm entitlement to interest on delayed payments.
S.K. Dua v. State of Haryana and Another, (2008) 3 SCC 40 Held that delayed payments due to illegal withholding must carry interest. Further confirmed the principle supporting interest on delayed payments.
State of M.P. v. Ramji Das Agrawal, 2013 (1) MPLJ 53 Division Bench endorsed the principle of interest on delayed payments. Used to support the Court's conclusion on entitlement to interest.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court noted that the original writ petition was disposed of with a clear direction to the respondents to extend pay scale benefits within six months, based on a judgment in rem (Suresh Kumar Dwivedi). The respondents failed to comply within the stipulated period, resulting in illegal withholding of benefits. The Court rejected the respondents' objection based on constructive res judicata, reasoning that the delay was not anticipated and there was no reason to presume non-implementation within six months. The Court relied on a series of Supreme Court judgments establishing that illegally withheld amounts due to employees must carry interest when paid belatedly. It emphasized that such payments are due to similarly situated employees without each having to approach the Court individually, and failure to pay interest would reward respondent lethargy. Consequently, the Court held that the petitioners are entitled to interest on the delayed payment from the expiry of six months after the original order until actual payment.

Holding and Implications

The Court allowed the petition to the extent of granting interest on delayed payment from six months after the order dated 1.12.2004 until actual payment. The respondents were directed to calculate and pay the interest within four months.

The direct effect is that the petitioners will receive interest for the delay in payment of pay scale benefits. No new precedent was set; rather, the Court applied established principles to enforce timely compliance and penalize undue delay in implementing pay scale benefits.

Show all summary ...

1. This is second visit of the petitioners to this Court. It is contended by Shri Prashant Sharma, learned counsel for the petitioner, that earlier petitioners filed WP No. 1650/2000, which was disposed of on 1. 12.2004 (AnnexureP/1). In the said case the petitioners prayed for a direction to the respondents for extending the benefits of pay scale as per 5th Pay Commission. It is contended that said petition was disposed of on 1.12.2004 and the respondents were required to extend the benefits within six months there from. Benefits were granted belatedly on 27.8.2012 and, therefore, it is prayed that the delayed payment beyond six months from the date of original order should carry interest.

2. Prayer is opposed by Mrs. Patankar on the ground that petitioners could have prayed for interest in the first round itself. If interest is not granted by this Court in WP No. 1650/2000, said prayer for grant of interest is hit by principle of constructive res judicata and cannot be granted in this petition.

3. 1 have heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the record.

4. This Court while deciding WP No. 1650/2000 directed as under :-

" ..... In all these cases after considering the earlier judgment rendered by this Court in the case of Suresh Kumar it has been held that employees of non-government college are entitled to the same pay scale as. is being extended to corresponding category of employee in the Govt. College. Considering the aforesaid this petition is allowed. For the grounds and reasons already indicated and discussed in the judgment referred to hereinabove, respondents are directed to extend the benefit of pay scale as has been granted to the corresponding category of employee in the Govt. College. Let action be taken for extending the aforesaid benefit as per prevailing liability of State Government within a period of six months from the date of receipt of certified copy of this order.

Accordingly, petition stands disposed of ."(Emphasis supplied)

5. A careful reading of this judgment shows that this Court applied ratio decidendi of earlier judgment of this Court in the case of Suresh Kumar Dwivedi v. State of M.P., reported in 1994 JLJ 73. The judgment of Suresh Kumar (supra) got a stamp of approval from the Supreme Court. The same view was followed in Ashok Kumar Gupta v. State of M.P. by this Court, referred in the said order. Thus, relief granted by this Court was based on a judgment in rem. Respondents were required to implement the judgment within six months. If they have not done it within six months, it is to be presumed that they have illegally withheld said benefits beyond six months till actual payment. If the respondents would have paid arrears of 5th Pay Commission within six months, as directed in WP No. 1650/2000, there would have been no question of claiming interest. There was no occasion for this Court to presume that respondents will not implement the order within six months. Hence, objection of other side cannot be upheld.

6. In catena of judgments the apex Court held that if an amount is due to an employee and it is illegally withheld by the other side, belated payment should carry interest. This view is taken in (1994) 2 SCC 240 (Union of India v. Justice S.S. Sandhawala (Retc.) and Ors.), (2006) 6 SCC 455 (Union of India andAnr. v. M.S. Abdulla) and (2008) 3 SCC 40 (S.K. Dua v. State ofHaryana and Another). The Division Bench in 2013 (1) MPLJ53 (State of M.P. v. Ramji Das Agrawal) has also taken the same view.

7. In the considered opinion of this Court, whether it is retiral dues or other financial benefits, if it is shown that delay in payment is solely attributable to the respondents, the delayed amount must carry interest. I am not impressed with the argument of the respondents. In cases where entitlement of the employee is covered in principle and judgment delivered on the point is judgment in rem, every person need not be compelled to knock the door of the Court. Model employer should implement the order in favour of all similarly situated persons. If the order is not implemented in time and still employees are deprived from the interest on delayed payment, it will be a premium to lethargy and inaction on the part of the respondents.

8. On the basis of aforesaid analysis, in my opinion, petitioners are entitled to get interest on delayed payment after six months from the order dated 1.12.2004 till actual payment. The respondents shall calculate the interest and make necessary payment within four months.

9. Petition is allowed to the extent indicated above.