- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Bapu And Others v. State
This revision is directed against the conviction and sentence of the applicants under section 147, Indian Penal Code.
2. Initially the quarrel started between the applicants Kisan and Raja ram on the one hand and the opposite party on the other. As the quarrel began others also joined the parties according to their affiliation. There is nothing to indicate that other applicants joined the quarrel on the persuation or instigation of Kisan and Rajaram. In fact, it appears that they were initially only spectators and went home to bring sticks and then joined the quarrel. [Ganpat (P. W. 4)1. The question is whether they formed an unlawful assembly within the meaning of section 141, Indian Penal Code.
3. There can be no doubt that the expression "common object in section 141, Indian Penal Code, presupposes a preconcerted plan. This was the refining that was given by their Lordships of the Supreme Court to the expiration "common intention occurring in section 34 Hid. (fee Pandurar v. State of Hyderabad) AIR 1955 S. C. 216. The same significance, by parity of reasoning, would tithe to the expression "common object". It is true that cordon object, which denotes a privities of minds, may be formed instantaneously. But there must be some facts to denote a preconcerted plan. Otherwise, each one of the participants in the quarrel would be deemed to be acting independently without any united mind. In such a case, even if they may individually have the same object, it would not be a case of a common object.
4. In this connection, the word "assembly” in the Explanation to section 141 ibid appears to be an assembly as contemplated by the first part of the section, that is an assembly of five or more persons. If there are not 5 or more persons initially, and others join later, it would not form an unlawful assembly unless they had a preconcerted plan for prosecution of a common object. Since there is want of proof of a common object in the instant case, the applicants must be acquitted of the charge.
5. The facts of the case, however, clearly disclose the commission of an offence punishable under section 160, Indian Penal Code, The parties were fighting on the open space between the houses of the locality, which evidently formed a public place. This is a minor offence within the meaning of section 238, Criminal Procedure Code. The applicants are, therefore, liable to be convicted under section 160, Indian Penal Code.
6. The re vision is partly allowed. The applicants' conviction and sentence under section 147, Indian Penal Code, are set aside and they are convicted under section 160, Indian Penal Code. The facts of the case do not warrant a serious view in respect of punishment. Rajaram and Kisan are accordingly sentenced to pay a fine of Rs.10 each, and the rest of the applicants, Rs.5 each. In default of payment of fine, they shall undergo rigorous imprisonment for a period of one week each. Excess amount of fine, if paid, shall be refunded to them.
Application partly allowed.
Alert