- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Surendra Kumar Chaturvedi v. State Of M.P And Others
Factual and Procedural Background
This petition was originally filed before the State Administrative Tribunal, Jabalpur on 10-12-2001. On account of the abolition of that Tribunal, the petition was received by this Court for adjudication.
The petitioner worked as a Pump Operator in the Water Resources Department, posted in Water Resources Sub Division No. 3 at Shahdol. The petition states that the petitioner was appointed on 1-10-1980 and worked continuously until superannuation. The petition contains a gradation list dated 1-1-1984 (Annexure-A/1) showing the petitioner's date of appointment as 1-10-1980.
The petitioner was superannuated at the age of 60. The petition records a superannuation date "w.e.f. 31-8-2001" (paragraph 3). At a later point in the opinion the Court records that the petitioner retired on 27-8-2001 (paragraph 16). The petitioner sought quashment of an order dated 23-8-2001 (Annexure-A/12) which had informed him that he was not entitled to pension, and the petitioner sought a direction to respondents to pay full pension, gratuity and other retiral benefits with interest at 18% per annum.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the petitioner, having been appointed on 1-10-1980 and paid from "office contingency" on a monthly basis, acquired the status of a permanent work charged contingency paid employee under Rule 6(2)(c) of the M.P. Irrigation Department Work Charged and Contingency Paid Employees Recruitment and Conditions of Service Rules, 1977 (the "Rules of 1977"), upon completion of ten years of contingency service.
- Whether, having acquired permanent status under the Rules of 1977 and having completed the qualifying service, the petitioner is entitled to pension under the M.P. (Work Charged and Contingency Paid Employees) Pension Rules, 1979 (the "Pension Rules of 1979"), particularly with reference to Rule 2(c) and related government circulars and notifications.
- Whether the fact that a formal order regularising the petitioner was issued with an effective date later than other similarly situated employees (specifically, regularisation stated as w.e.f. 8-4-1997 by the respondents) prevents the petitioner from claiming pension for earlier qualifying service.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioner's Arguments
- The petitioner was appointed as Pump Operator on 1-10-1980 and worked continuously until superannuation, thereby completing approximately 20 years and 11 months of service.
- The post of Pump Operator is a work charged establishment post and the petitioner was paid monthly from contingency funds; therefore his service conditions are governed by the Rules of 1977 (including Rule 2(b)'s definition of contingency paid employee).
- Under Rule 6(2)(c) of the Rules of 1977, an employee appointed after 1-1-1974 becomes eligible for permanent work charged contingency paid employee status on completion of ten years of contingency service; thus the petitioner became permanent in October 1990.
- The petitioner met the requisite educational/training qualifications for the Pump Operator post (Schedule II of Revision of Pay Rules, 1984 — 8th class pass plus one year I.T.I. training), having 9th class pass and I.T.I. Rewa training.
- Government circulars (15-1-1985, Annexure-A/7, and related orders) required regularisation of long-serving daily wagers with an effective date such as 31-12-1987; similarly situated Pump Operators were regularised effective 31-12-1987 (Annexure-A/11). If respondents delayed issuing regularisation orders (e.g. Annexure-A/10 dated 8-4-1997), the petitioner should not be penalised for such delay.
- Under the Pension Rules of 1979, and notifications/circulars referred to in Annexure-A/12 (notification 8-1-1980 and Finance Department circular 13-9-1982), qualifying service for pension is ten years after 1-1-1974; thus petitioner is entitled to pension.
- The petition alleged specific facts in paragraph 6.2 demonstrating the petitioner's right to pension; those pleadings were not specifically denied in the respondents' return and therefore should be deemed admitted. To support these contentions counsel relied on decisions including Smt. Naseem Bano vs. State of U.P. (AIR 1993 SC 2592), Bharat Singh vs. State of Haryana (AIR 1988 SC 2181) and Ram Kumar Agrawal vs. State of M.P. (1995 Supp (3) SCC 67).
Respondents' Arguments
- The regularisation order Annexure-A/10 regularised the petitioner w.e.f. 8-4-1997; the petitioner never challenged that order asking that it be given effect from an earlier date, and he cannot now raise those grounds.
- The petitioner was employed as a daily wager in 1980 and the vouchers for the period 1980–1985 are not traceable because Division No. 1 had been closed.
- Photocopies of payment vouchers show payment in November 1985 (Annexure-R/2) and for the period 1-7-1997 to 23-7-1997 (Annexure-R/3). The respondents contend that the petitioner continued as a daily wager until conversion to work charged contingency establishment on/around 23-7-1997 (Annexure-R/4) and thus had not completed ten years of service as a contingency-paid employee to qualify for pension; therefore the petition should be dismissed.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Smt. Naseem Bano vs. State of U. P. and others, AIR 1993 SC 2592 | Cited by petitioner (through counsel) to support the contention regarding facts/pleadings and entitlement arguments. | The opinion records that the petitioner relied on this decision, but in the Court's analysis it states: "In that context it would be opposite to rely the decisions of Smt. Naseem Bano and Bharat Singh (supra)." The Court did not apply this precedent in favour of the respondents. |
| Bharat Singh vs. State of Haryana, AIR 1988 SC 2181 | Cited by petitioner (through counsel) to support the contention regarding pleadings and entitlement. | As with Naseem Bano, the Court records the citation but states it would be "opposite to rely" on these decisions in the context; the Court did not apply them against the petitioner. |
| Ram Kumar Agrawal vs. State of M.P. and others, 1995 Supp (3) SCC 67 | Cited by petitioner to bolster the contention concerning the consequences of respondents' failure to controvert specific pleadings or to demonstrate employment categorisation. | The opinion records that counsel placed reliance on this decision. The Court's reasoning subsequently discusses deemed admissions where pleadings are not specifically denied and relies on documentary record and procedural defaults; the opinion does not state an explicit holding that turns solely on this precedent. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court undertook a fact- and document-based analysis guided by the Rules of 1977 and the Pension Rules of 1979.
- The Court noted there was no denial in the respondents' return that the petitioner was employed as a daily rated employee on 1-10-1980; the gradation list of 1-1-1984 (Annexure-A/1 or A/8 referenced) specifically records the appointment date as 1-10-1980.
- The post of Pump Operator was established as a work charged establishment post (Annexure-A/2). The Court quoted Rule 2(b) of the Rules of 1977 which defines a "contingency paid employee" as a person employed full time, paid on monthly basis and whose pay is charged to "Office Contingency".
- The Court examined payment vouchers: Annexure-R/2 showed payment to the petitioner from 1-11-1985 to 30-11-1985 on a monthly basis; Annexure-R/3 showed payment for a period in 1997 in the same manner. The Court treated these documentary payments as significant evidence that the petitioner was paid monthly and thus fell within the Rule 2(b) definition.
- The Court observed that it had directed the respondents on 9-3-2004 to file an affidavit of a competent officer with supporting documents to demonstrate in what category the petitioner was employed and how his claim fit into the compartments of contingency paid employees. The respondents failed to file such an affidavit and supporting documents. Because of this failure, the Court held that "for all practical purposes" it would be deemed that payments were made on a monthly basis and that the petitioner therefore acquired permanent status after completing ten years of service under Rule 6(2)(c) of the Rules of 1977.
- The Court emphasised that paragraph 6.2 of the petition contained specific pleadings demonstrating the petitioner's right to obtain pension and these were not specifically denied in the respondents' return; therefore under the law such pleadings would be deemed admitted. The Court linked this finding to the inability of the respondents to rely on the two Supreme Court decisions cited by them in the specific context (stating it would be "opposite to rely" on Smt. Naseem Bano and Bharat Singh in that context).
- The Court addressed the respondents' submission that the petitioner should not now challenge the regularisation order dated 8-4-1997. The Court rejected that submission as having "no substance", reasoning that respondents ought to have issued orders similar to those they issued in favour of other similarly situated employees (for example Annexure-A/11 dated 31-12-1987 which regularised some Pump Operators w.e.f. 1-1-1988). The Court held that the petitioner could not be made to suffer for the respondents' inaction or delay.
- The Court interpreted the Pension Rules of 1979 (Rule 2(c) as quoted/discussed in the opinion) and government instructions/notifications (notification dated 8-1-1980 and Finance Department circular dated 13-9-1982) as establishing that the qualifying service to obtain pension could be ten years after 1-1-1974 and that no further written order was necessary for completing the qualifying service. On that basis, having found that the petitioner acquired permanent status and had completed the requisite ten years of service under the work charged establishment, the Court concluded he was entitled to pension.
- Taking these conclusions together, the Court held that the impugned order Annexure-A/12 dated 23-8-2001 (which informed the petitioner he was not entitled to pension) was contrary to the law and facts as found, and therefore it should be quashed.
Holding and Implications
Core Ruling: The petition is allowed and the impugned order Annexure-A/12 dated 23-8-2001 (which denied the petitioner pension) is quashed; the petitioner is held to be entitled to pension.
Consequences and directives given by the Court (direct effects on the parties):
- The petitioner is entitled to pension under the applicable Rules and the impugned denial order is quashed.
- The respondents shall bear the costs of the petitioner; counsel fee of Rs. 2,000/- is awarded if pre-certified.
The opinion does not discuss any broader precedential effect beyond the direct relief and costs awarded to the petitioner.
This petition was originally filed before the State Administrative Tribunal, Jabalpur on 10-12-2001, however, on account of abolition of the Tribunal, this petition has been received by this Court for its adjudication.
2. By this petition, the petitioner is seeking relief for quashment of order dated 23-8-2001 (Annexure-A/12) with a further direction to the respondents to pay full pension, gratuity and other retiral benefits to the petitioner with interest at the rate of 18% per annum.
3. In brief, the case of the petitioner is that he was working as Pump Operator in the Water Resources Department of the State of Madhya Pradesh and was posted in Water Resources Sub Division No. 3 at Shahdol under respondent No. 3. He was superannuated at the age of 60 years w.e.f. 31-8-2001. It has been putforth in the petition that the petitioner was initially appointed as Pump Operator on 1-10-1980 and he worked continuously till his superannuation i.e. 31-8-2001. Thus, the petitioner has put nearby 20 years and 11 months of his service. The petitioner has filed Annexure-P/1 which is a gradation list dated 1-1-1984 in which the name of petitioner has been shown at serial No. 25 and in column No. 6 which is a column of date of appointment, 1-10-1980 his date of appointment has been mentioned.
4. The post of Pump Operator in Water Resources Department is work charged establishment post. In that regard the petitioner has filed Annexure-A/2. According to the petitioner, his service conditions are governed by M. P. Irrigation Department Work Charged and Contingency Paid Employees Recruitment and Conditions of Service Rules, 1977 (in short 'the Rules of 1977'). The contingency paid employee has been defined under Rule 2(b) of the Rules and according to which a contingency paid employee would mean a person employed for full time in an office or establishment and who is paid on monthly basis and whose pay is charged to office contingency excluding employees who are employed for certain period only in the year.
5. According to the petitioner, his appointment on the post of Pump Operator was on full time basis and he was being paid wages on monthly basis which was from contingency funds of the department and, therefore, his services were governed by the Rules of 1977.
6. Learned counsel for the petitioner by inviting my attention to Rule 6(2)(c) of the Rules of 1977, has submitted that employees who are appointed after 1st January, 1974 on completion of 10 years of contingency service by them becomes eligible for the status of permanent work charged contingency paid employee. Since the petitioner had worked for more than 20 years, in terms of Rule 6(2)(c) of the Rules of 1977, he had become permanent work charged contingency paid employee in October, 1990. It has also been putforth by learned counsel for the petitioner that the petitioner does qualify the requisite qualifications for the appointment on the post of Pump Operator as given in Schedule II of the Revision of Pay Rules, 1984. Since he was possessing qualification of High School fail i.e. 9th class pass and he had trained from I.T.I., Rewa. The requisite qualification for Pump Operator is 8th class pass and one year training certificate from I.T.I. In this regard my attention has been drawn to Annexure-P/6 which is a Schedule attached to the Rules of 1977.
7. It has been further contended by learned counsel for the petitioner that General Administration Department of the State Government issued a circular dated 15-1-1985 (Annexure-A/7) for regularisation of daily wages employees. The contention of learned counsel is that in consequence to Annexure-P/7 vide order dated 7-3-1986 (Annexure-A/8) 5879 additional posts were created out of which 67 posts were of pump operator the State Government issued another circular dated 9-10-1990 (Annexure-P/9) whereby the entire process of regularisation was to be completed latest by 31-12-1987. The contention of Shri Pathak, learned counsel is that if the respondents wasted time in correspondence and issued regularisation order of the petitioner on 8-4-1997 (Annexure-A/10) the petitioner cannot be made responsible for it. Indeed as per circular Annexure-A/9, order for regularisation ought to have been issued giving benefit to the petitioner w.e.f. 31-12-1987 and if the order was issued on 8-4-1997 vide Annexure-A/10, the petitioner cannot be penalised for it. Shri Pathak, learned counsel for the petitioner by inviting my attention to Annexure-A/11 which is an order regularising the services of similarly situated co-employees (Pump Operators), has submitted that they were regularised on the posts of Pump Operator w.e.f. 31-12-1987.
8. Learned counsel for the petitioner has further placed emphasis to Rule 2(c) M. P. (Work Charged and Contingency Paid Employees) Pension Rules, 1979 (in short 'the Rules of 1979') which defines permanent employee and, according to the said Rules, a permanent employee means a contingency paid employee or work charged employee who has completed 15 years of service on or after 1974. Learned counsel by inviting my attention to impugned order Annexure-A/12 mentioning notification of the State Government dated 8th January, 1980 and further mentioning the circular of Finance Department dated 13-9-1982, has submitted that the qualifying service to obtain the pension is 10 years after 1-1-1974. According to learned counsel even if the qualifying service is 15 years as envisaged under Rule 2(c) of the Rules of 1979 is made applicable then also petitioner has become entitled for the pension, since he was appointed on 1-10-1980 as it appears from the gradation list dated 1-1-1984 (Annexure-A/1). On these premised submissions it has been contended by learned counsel for the petitioner that the impugned order Annexure-A/12 dated 23-8-2001 informing the petitioner that he is not entitled for the pension is contrary to the law and respondents be directed to give benefit of pension to the petitioner.
9. On the other hand, it has been submitted by Shri Ashok Agrawal, learned Govt. Advocate, that the order of regularisation Annexure-A/10 regularising the petitioner w.e.f-8-4-1997 was never challenged by him saying that it should be given effect to from an earlier date and, therefore, now the petitioner cannot be allowed to raise all these grounds. It has also been putforth by him that the petitioner was employed as a daily wager in the year 1980. The vouchers relating to the year 1980 to 1985 are not traceable as the Division No. 1 has been closed. Photocopy of payment of voucher for the month of November, 1985 has been annexed as Annexure-R/2 whereas another voucher for the period w.e.f. 1-7-1997 to 23-7-1997 is Annexure-R/3. Thereafter the service of the petitioner were converted into work charged contingency employee and the copy of payment of voucher is Annexure-R/4 and, therefore, the petitioner continued from work charged contingency w.e.f. 23-7-1997 till he was superannuated on 31-8-2001 (Annexure-R/5). The contention of learned Govt. Advocate is that since the petitioner continued as daily wager from 1982 to 23-4-1997 and he was only on 23-4-1997 assigned as work charged contingency establishment, therefore, since the petitioner had not completed 10 years of service, he is not entitled for the pension and, hence, this petition be dismissed.
10. In reply, it has been contended by Shri Pathak, learned counsel for the petitioner, that Annexure-A/10 dated 8-4-1997 regularising the services of the petitioner as work charged establishment would not come in his way because in this order nowhere it has been mentioned that he would not be entitled for any pension and, therefore, there was no necessity for the petitioner to challenge that order. It has also been putforth by him that in para 6.2 of the petition necessary specific pleadings demonstrating the right of the petitioner to obtain pension has been pleaded and these pleadings of petitioner are not specifically denied in the return and, therefore, under the law, they should be deemed to be admitted. To bolster his contention, learned counsel has placed reliance on two decisions of the Supreme Court, they are Smt. Naseem Bano vs. State of U. P. and others, AIR 1993 SC 2592 and Bharat Singh vs. State of Haryana, AIR 1988 SC 2181. Learned counsel has also invited my attention to order sheet dated 9-3-2004 and has submitted that this Court directed the respondents to file the affidavit of competent officer in order to demonstrate that in what category the petitioner was employed and how his claim would be fit into the compartments of contingent paid employees. It was directed to file necessary documents in support of the affidavit but the respondents did not care to file affidavit of any of the officer with supporting documents and, therefore, it would be deemed that the petitioner was not a daily wager but the payment was being made to him from regular establishment. Learned counsel has also placed reliance on the decision of the Supreme Court in Ram Kumar Agrawal vs. State of M.P. and others, 1995 Supp (3) SCC 67.
11. After having heard learned counsel for the parties, I am of the view that this petition deserves to be allowed.
12. There is no denial in the return that the petitioner was employed as daily rated employee on 1-10-1980. In this regard Annexure-A/8 which is a gradation list dated 1-1-1984 is quite clear in which 1-10-1980 the date of appointment of the petitioner has been mentioned. Annexure-A/2 is another document demonstrating that the post of Pump Operator in Water Resources Department is a work charged establishment post. Rule 2(b) of the Rules of 1977 contemplates about the contingency paid employees which reads thus :
"2(b) 'CONTINGENCY PAID EMPLOYEE' means a person employed for full time in an office or establishment and who is paid on monthly basis and whose pay is charged to "Office Contingency", excluding the employees who are employed for certain period only in the year."
On bare perusal of Annexure-R/2, it is gathered that the payment made to the petitioner from 1-11-1985 to 30-11-1985 was paid to him on monthly basis. Similarly in Annexure-R/3 also the payment has been made from 1-4-1997 to 23-7-1997 in the same manner. Apart from this, there is no specific denial of the specific averments made by the petitioner in para 6.2 of his petition, in the return filed by the respondents. This Court on 9-3-2004 also directed the respondents to submit affidavit of competent officer along with documents in order to show that in what category the petitioner was employed and how his claim would be fit into the compartments on contingent paid employees. Since no affidavit along with documents has been filed, for all practical purposes, it would be deemed that the payment was made to the petitioner on monthly basis and thus, the petitioner became permanent employee after completion of 10 years of his service and, therefore, under Rule 6(2)(c) of the Rules of 1977 the status of petitioner became permanent work charged contingency paid employee. Since permanent status, as pleaded by the petitioner in para 6.2 of his petition, has not been specifically denied by the respondents, they would be deemed to be admitted. In that context it would be opposite to rely the decisions of Smt. Naseem Bano and Bharat Singh (supra).
13. The State Government issued circular dated 15-1-1985 (Annexure-A/7) by giving specific direction to regularise the services of the daily wages employees and thereafter again the instructions were issued vide Annexure-A/9 that since the daily wages employees are serving for a long duration, it would be deemed that their services are satisfactory and there is no necessity to take any written examination or interview in that regard. As no confidential report of these employees are kept in order to ascertain their work, therefore, list was prepared treating that their work is satisfactory. It would be appropriate to quote clause (3) of the said instructions which reads thus :
Accordingly it was directed by the State Government to scrutinise the matter and the list be prepared and appointment order be issued latest by 31-12-1987. It would be condign to re-write the said clause-2 as under :
14. Thereafter some orders were passed directing appointment in accordance to the instructions given in Annexure-A/9. One order has been placed on record as Annexure-A/11 dated 31-12-1987 giving appointment to some of the Pump Operators whose names are referred in this document under work charged establishment, they were appointed w.e.f. 1-1-1988. Indeed, the petitioner ought to have been appointed accordingly from this date. But, if no such order has been issued in favour of the petitioner, he is not at fault and he cannot be allowed to suffer for the inaction of the respondents. The submission of learned Govt. Advocate is that the petitioner never challenged his order of regularisation Annexure-A/10 regularising him w.e.f. 8-4-1997. This argument is devoid of any substance, since it was for the respondents to have issued similar type of order in favour of petitioner as they have issued in favour of similarly situated other employees and one of the order is Annexure-A/11 dated 31-12-1987 by which certain Pump Operators were given appointment w.e.f. 1/1/1988. Who prevented the respondents to pass suitable order in favour of the petitioner in the year 1987 as mentioned in Annexure-A/9 which clearly directed to issue orders latest by 31-12-1987. Judging from all the angles, the petitioner was also entitled to be given appointment as certain similarly situated other Pump Operators were appointed.
15. It be seen that for completing qualifying service of 10 years for obtaining pension, no written order is necessary and after completing the requisite ten years of service, an employee automatically becomes a member as envisaged in Rule 2(c.) of Pension Rules of 1979 and becomes entitled for the pension.
16. Since the petitioner acquired the status of permanent work charged contingency paid employee and was a permanent employee in terms of Rule 6(1) and 2(c) of the Rules of 1977 and he had already completed more than 10 years of his service under the work charged establishment, therefore, under the Pension Rules of 1979 he is entitled for the pension, as he retired on 27-8-2001. The order of respondent No. 3 directing and intimating the petitioner that he is not entitled for the pension vide Annexure-A/12 dated 23-8-2001 is, accordingly, quashed and it is held that the petitioner is entitled for the pension.
17. Resultantly, this petition is allowed. The respondents shall bear the costs of the petitioner. Counsel fee Rs. 2,000/- if pre-certified.
Petition allowed.
…………………………
Alert