- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Manish Nema v. Sandhya Nema
Factual and Procedural Background
The appellant and respondent were married on 16 May 2003. Their marriage was later declared null and void under section 12(1)(c) of the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955, following divorce proceedings initiated by the respondent, culminating in a decree dated 12 January 2005. Subsequently, the respondent filed a suit under section 27 of the Hindu Marriage Act read with Order 7, Rule 7 of the Code of Civil Procedure (CPC) and section 151 CPC, seeking the return of gold and silver ornaments and other articles given as gifts at the time of marriage or alternatively, monetary compensation for these items. The trial court allowed the respondent’s application and decreed that the appellant return specified ornaments and articles or pay their market value after deducting 'batta'. The appellant challenged this judgment and decree dated 24 September 2007 in the present appeal under section 28 of the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the trial court exceeded its jurisdiction under section 27 of the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955, by entertaining the respondent's application for return of ornaments and articles post-divorce.
- Whether the property in question should be considered joint property of the husband and wife or stridhan belonging exclusively to the wife, affecting entitlement and relief under section 27.
- Whether section 27 of the Hindu Marriage Act read with Order 7, Rule 7 and section 151 CPC can be invoked in a proceeding subsequent to matrimonial dispute resolution for recovery of such property.
Arguments of the Parties
Appellant's Arguments
- The trial court exceeded its jurisdiction under section 27 of the Hindu Marriage Act by entertaining the suit, as the property should have been treated as joint property.
- The court ought not to have allowed the application under section 27 read with Order 7, Rule 7 CPC and section 151 CPC in a proceeding subsequent to the matrimonial dispute.
Respondent's Arguments
- The trial court correctly decreed the suit in her favour, recognizing her right over the ornaments and articles as stridhan.
- The application under section 27 and relevant provisions of the CPC was valid and properly entertained by the trial court.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Nirmala Gupta v. Revendra Kumar, AIR 1996 MP 227 | Section 151 CPC read with Order 7, Rule 7 CPC permits courts to pass decrees for return of property belonging exclusively to either spouse. | Supported the validity of entertaining the respondent’s suit for return of ornaments under section 27 read with CPC provisions. |
| Prathibha Rani v. Suraj Kumar, AIR 1985 SC 628 | Clarified scope of reliefs available under matrimonial laws and CPC provisions. | Reinforced the principle that courts can grant relief for return of property under CPC provisions in matrimonial matters. |
| Manohar Lal Chopra v. Rai Bahadur Rao Raja Seth Hiralal, AIR 1962 SC 527 | Application of procedural powers under CPC in matrimonial disputes. | Supported the procedural basis for entertaining claims under section 27 read with CPC. |
| Kamta Prasad v. Smt. Om Wati, AIR 1972 All 153 | Use of CPC provisions in matrimonial proceedings. | Supported the court’s jurisdiction to grant relief for return of property in matrimonial cases. |
| Sangeeta Balkrishna Kadam v. Balkrishna Ramchandra Kadam, AIR 1994 Bombay 1 | Recognition of relief under CPC in matrimonial disputes. | Further supported the trial court’s exercise of jurisdiction under section 27 and CPC provisions. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court examined section 27 of the Hindu Marriage Act, which empowers courts to make just and proper provisions regarding property presented at or about the time of marriage that may belong jointly to both spouses. The court clarified that this provision applies to property given at or about the time of marriage and allows the court to pass decrees concerning such property in matrimonial disputes. The appellant’s contention that such powers cannot be exercised in a proceeding initiated under section 27 read with Order 7, Rule 7 CPC and section 151 CPC was found untenable. The court relied on binding precedents, including the division bench judgment in Nirmala Gupta v. Revendra Kumar and Supreme Court decisions, which establish that the inherent powers under section 151 CPC and Order 7, Rule 7 CPC enable the court to grant relief for return of property exclusively belonging to one spouse. The court also referred to section 4(1) of the CPC, which preserves special laws and their procedures, noting that the Hindu Marriage Act incorporates the CPC insofar as applicable. Consequently, the trial court did not exceed its jurisdiction in allowing the respondent’s application for return of ornaments and articles as stridhan, and the decree was legally sound.
Holding and Implications
The appeal is dismissed.
The trial court’s judgment and decree allowing the respondent’s claim for return of ornaments and articles or payment of their value is upheld. The parties are directed to bear their own costs. This decision confirms the applicability of section 27 of the Hindu Marriage Act read with relevant provisions of the CPC in matrimonial property disputes and affirms the trial court’s jurisdiction to grant relief for return of stridhan property. No new precedent was set beyond reinforcing established principles.
Sanjay Yadav, J.:-
(1) In the present appeal preferred under section 28 of the hindu marriage act, 1955 the appellant seeks quashment of judgment and decree dated 24 - 9 - 2007 passed in civil suit no. 55/ 2007, whereby the trial court allowed the application preferred under section 27 of the act of 1955 read with order 7, rule 7 of the code of civil procedure and section 151 of cpc preferred by the respondent/plaintiff.
(2) Bonding of nuptial rights to which the appellant and respondent were knotted on 16 - 5 - 2003 got separated when the marriage was declared a nullity under section 12 (l) (c) of the act in the proceedings initiated by the respondent when a divorce decree was passed on 12 - 1 - 2005.
(3) Prompted by the provisions under section 27 of the act and order 7. Rule 7 of the code of civil procedure read with section 151, cpc the respondent instituted a suit in the court of 1st additional district judge narsinghpur; claiming return of gold and silver ornaments and other articles given as gifts by her parents and relatives at the time of marriage or in alternative recovery of rs. 1,36,875/ - in lieu of 18. 25 tola gold ornaments, rs. 11,220/ - in lieu of silver ornaments and rs. 58. 569 in lieu of articles like almirah, dressing table, cooler, television set etc. The total amount for which the suit was preferred was rs. 2,06,664/ -.
(4) Evidence and counter evidence were led and trial court after appreciating the same came to uphold the respondent's entitlement for the articles and one gold necklace (3 tola) , four gold bangles (1 tola) , one set earnings (0. 25 tola) , three gold finger rings (0. 50) , mangalsutra (1 tola) and two pairs of silver anklets (payals) (20 tola each). The suit was decreed in the terms that the appellant shall return to respondent the aforesaid ornaments and articles or in lieu there of should pay the amount in terms of money at the market rate prevalent at the relevant time after deducting the 'batta'.
(5) Appellant criticises the order on the anvil that the trial court exceeded its jurisdiction inherent under section 27. The trial court, it is urged, ought to have held the property in question to be a joint property and ought not to have entertained the petitioner under section 27 of the act of 1955.
(6) The respondent on its turn supports the impugned order and claims that the trial court did not err in decreeing the suit in her favour, rightly holding her right there over being the stridhan.
(7) Section 27 of the hindu marriage act of 1955 provides for that
"in any proceeding under this act, the court may make such provisions in the decree as it deems just and proper with respect to any property presented, at or about the time of marriage, which, may belong jointly to both the husband and the wife".
(8) Fair reading of the aforesaid provision reveals that it is applicable in respect of the property received at or about time to marriage, which may belong jointly to both husband and wife. It empowers the court while deciding the matrimonial dispute to also pass decree in respect of property which may jointly belong to both husband and wife. It provides the civil remedy to an aggrieved wife or husband as the case may be.
(9) The submissions put forth by learned counsel for the appellant that such powers can be exercised by the matrimonial court in a matrimonial dispute and not in a proceeding subsequently initiated under section 27 under order 7, rule 7 of the code of civil procedure read with section 151 of the cpc.
(10) The submissions of the learned counsel for the appellant looses its hold in wake of judgments rendered by the division bench of this court in nirmala gupta v. Revendra kumar, air 1996 mp 227. Wherein placing reliance on judgments rendered by the supreme court in prathibha rani v. Suraj kumar, air 1985 sc 628 and manohar lal chopra v. Rai bahadur rao raja seth hiralal, air 1962 sc 527, and the judgment rendered by the high court of allahabad and bombay kamta prasad v. Smt. Om wati. Air 1972 all 153 and sangeeta balkrishna kadam v. Balkrishna ramchandra kadam, air 1994 bombay 1 it was observed that provision under section 151 read with order 7, rule 7 of cpc permits a court in passing a decree in favour of wife or husband as the case may be for return of the property, which may exclusively belong to either of them.
(11) For the sake of completeness we note with profit paragraph 12 of the judgment referred in nirmala gupta (supra) "it may be noted that the act is a special enactment governing the matrimonial proceedings between the parties. Section 4 (1) of the code of civil procedure reads as under : -
"4. Saving. - (1) in the absence of any specific provision to the contrary, nothing in this code shall be deemed to limit or. Otherwise affect any, special or local law. Not in force or any special jurisdiction or power conferred, or any special form of procedure prescribed, by or under any other law far the time being in force."
From this provisions, it is clear that the procedure prescribed by the special law will not be limited by the code of civil procedure. However, the act itself adopts the gpc so far as it is applicable in the matrimonial proceedings under the act and, therefore, all the provisions of the cpc will be applicable to the matrimonial proceedings under the act. section 151 read with order 7, rule 7 of the code of civil procedure will also be made applicable because there is no provision under the act which bars the application of these provisions of the cpc. Order vii, rule 7 of the code permits the court to grant such relief not prayed for as would be just under the circumstances of the case".
(12) Having thus considered we do not find any substance in the submission put forth on behalf of the appellant that trial court acceded its jurisdiction inherent under section 27 of the act of 1955 or that it committed any error in allowing the application for return of ornament and furniture.
(13) In the result, the appeal is dismissed. Parties to bear their own costs. Appeal dismissed.
Alert